Skip to main content
Loading video...

Barrage Review - Let's HATE water.

Transcript 14:27

delicious delicious water nothing could ever ruin this string oh yeah it's you barrage is an incompetent simulator where one to four players will attempt to milk water for electricity until they realize that water just doesn't work that way how do you even begin to milk water well turns out you need three things first you'll need to build a dam as the water flows down the river from the mountains it will stop at every dam and wait to be milked then you need to build a conductor this is the person that actually milks the water and sends it down the pipe and finally as the water flows all the way down the pipe it reaches the power plant where a bunch of people sit and wait for the water to come and when they see it they go hooray the water is coming hooray the water is coming and then everybody sorry got carried away there a little bit you might be saying to me though efka this sounds like a delightful euro game where you'll build this cool combo free buildings and that will make the water flow and then you'll produce energy and then you'll score points you're wrong you are so wrong barrage is a game that will break you every move you make every breath you take barrage will be

watching and when you slip up it will gut you like a fish out of water i already mentioned that barrage is a worker placement game and at first glance it might seem like a generous one in each of the game's five rounds you will get a whopping 12 workers and you can spend them however you like on various actions you can build buildings you can gain resources you can hit contracts that will provide you with various bonuses and you can make the water flow through your pipes naughty euphemism each action space you place workers on is blocked off for the other players for the rest of the round and therein lies the run because each player has a whopping 12 workers this spartan action board will get clogged up quicker than bad plumbing for example let's look at the action spaces that actually let you produce energy in a full player game there's like 10 of them until voila the other three players have all decided that they too would like to power their plants now the only action spaces you have left are ones that impose a penalty on how much energy you produce in total with that action or ones that not only cost extra money but also cost an extra worker to take and if you don't think that's a big deal then consider the difference between two and three workers is also the difference between a sixth and a whole quarter of your worker allotment for the round notice how i said will allow you to score points which isn't the same as

will score your points this is the energy track which you will very quickly come to love each time you produce energy your total will be marked and recorded as a display of prominence or outright shame whoever produces the most energy in a given round will be awarded a bonus of six points and this makes sense in barrage you are playing a real world fictional country and energy production is framed as a yardstick competition i say real world fictional because you are playing countries like italy or germany but then there's mex and steampunk you have to have mechs and board games because otherwise it's just zombie water or cthulhu water and that doesn't sound so good but on top of that each round there is a bonus scoring marker if you have built dams you can score four points for each dam you have built the problem is that you'll only score all of those points if you reach the requisite space on the energy track which each round slides further and further away and because this is obviously a race spaces that let you actually produce energy will disappear faster than water disappears in a box of sand which according to scientists is very very fast and if you think that sounds tight you haven't yet considered this map salty welcome to the battlefield of the best water fight since everyone at my college got themselves a super soaker let's examine

what happens when i attempt to harness the power of flow which is about as easy as capturing water with your bare hands during each round there will be water at the top of this board at the end of the round these will start falling down and unless something barricades it it will tiddle all the way down this river let's capture it you say that water will do a lot of work for us because that's how water works in the waterworks there's a few things we need to consider here the cost of building a dam is more expensive above than it is below and that makes sense because it's harder to build in the mountains we could afford it but then we wouldn't have enough resources left to build a conductor and not to mention that conductors generally tend to be more expensive the higher you go as well but let's say we managed to build a dam an elevation for the dam a connected conductor and a connected power plant great now all we need is for that water to fall down okay but look at this this scallywag came and built a dam right above mine that's not the end of the world each town can hold a droplet of water each elevation above it can hold another one which means that when water flows each droplet in excess of these two will simply skip over their dam and come straight to me unless of course said scallywag also builds their own conduit and power plant siphons all the water out and you want to know

what's the best part that water won't even keep flowing down the river towards my dam instead it will follow this pipe and land here in front of their other dam where they can keep leeching it i think i'm beginning to paint a picture of how ruthless and unforgiving barrage can be but trust me there's layers to the meanness instead of blocking a person from above and outright stealing the water you can do something a little bit more subtle and build a dam to where my water would flow out so anytime i actually want to run and power my power plants i'm directly feeding into another player's success making me not want to succeed piranhas reminding me what i like most about euro games instead of creating complex systems around action selection it focuses on what's interesting and that is what i do with those actions it doesn't make me spend five minutes trying to figure out whether i can actually place a worker i just do it but barrage isn't exactly clean either if you're unfamiliar with this landscape then you'll probably spend a good five minutes just looking at the resources you have available looking at how many workers you have left and figuring out where is it exactly that i want to place this conduit further complicating matters is that at the start of the game there's only a mere free droplets of water and they are sitting in front of neutral

dams you can build your conductor and power plant connected to them but then once you've established your water flow system someone else can just as easily come and build their conductor in front of that same neutral dam and then they can start siphoning your water all of these factors are something you need to weigh up before you even make your first move because appropriately for a game about the flow of water those first moves will cascade either into a tense to and fro between the giants of industry or an embarrassing display of bumbling and buffoonery and even when you figured everything out and coagulated what you think is the perfect plan there is still that little matter of resources every time you build a building you need to spend machineries either brown frogs or starship enterprises then you need to take a technology tile that matches the building that you want to build and together with the required machineries slot them into this wheel and turn it it's not going to be smooth the good news the tile and the resources will come back the bad news it will take quite a while each time you build something you get to rotate this wheel but another problem that the game chucks at you as if you were some sort of a bin that recycles problems is that at the beginning of the game you don't have enough resources or

enough tiles to complete enough revolutions to even get them back you can visit an action that will turn things faster but those spaces are scarce and once again expensive the more i played barrage the more i realized that it's a very compelling puzzle that straddles the dichotomy of here's all the cool things i can do and total prohibition created by my own hubris yes it can be slow especially with more players as everyone stares at the board with glazed over eyes trying to figure out the most optimal placement of a wooden block but frankly that is simultaneously the part that is most enjoyable because your brain can't help itself but start drawing patterns and roots and trying to piece together this impossible enigma that will inevitably get ruined by your friends and then you set up the game again and realize wait a minute everyone's playing a different faction that's also randomly paired with another power that's exclusive to you which is just a lovely touch because unique player powers are already a boost to replayability but pairing two together that just means you're going to be playing a different puzzle every single time if you ask me right now whether barrage was a good game i would say 100 yes everyone i played barrage with had a good time but then when i asked my players whether they would rather play this or terra mystica everyone unanimously said terra mystica and it's an apt comparison

and a valid response both games feature a spatial expansion puzzle with constricting resources and ways to bounce off of each player and abuse their decisions i think i have to tread very carefully here not to give the wrong impression barrage is a mean mean game and to fully engage with it and appreciate all its systems you have to be ready to outright cut people off from their goals and potentially make them have a bad time some people will bounce off of that immediately if you like your euros with little interaction stay away from this as far as possible but that isn't really the issue that's just style and i do like my euro games cutthroat but i do wish that barrage handled meanness in a different way when someone cuts me off in terra mystica or if i make a mistake i have so many options to bounce back i might no longer be able to win the game but i'm still in the game when i make a mistake or get cut off in barrage i have nothing barrage is a vertical design you build buildings to run water to make energy to score points and there are different variables feeding into the system like contracts or special technology tiles but you're still climbing a single ladder and if you fall none of what i have just said makes barrage unenjoyable if you

like building connections and finding paths and messing with your opponents this is still a pretty great water slide just don't get stuck in the tube worth noting that barrage has an expansion i'll be really quick here because the lee water project on paper looks cool adding action spaces with prohibitive costs and rehearsive rewards where you can either permanently spend your resources which you never have enough of anyway to get immediate rewards or even build a new type of building that will give you a permanent new action slot that other players can't take unless they also build it there's even a new faction and new unique player abilities and so far this sounds like a treasure trove right except that the leewater project expands the decision space so wide the whole thing becomes wishy-washy and muddlesome and just a bit blah i imagine people who play this game day in and out will find a lot to appreciate in it but for me just took it in a weird direction and i think i prefer the purity of the base game on its own water funny how it works you turn it on and then it goes well it's the same way that no pun included works turn it on and then we really go okay but how you ask me how do you turn on no pun included good question our channel survives solely on the generosity of our backers on patreon being crowdfunded we can indulge in the luxury of being entirely

independent and are not required to do things like kickstarter previews we don't deal financially with publishers we simply review their games if you value that kind of work and can afford to support us please consider doing so one of our backers aaron quintanilla even backed us at a pledge level where they get their own personal shoutout thank you very much aaron without your support we couldn't keep going and we have these t-shirts you can buy them now but only for like a month after a month they'll be gone you won't be able to get them and if you're a patron you get a four pound discount but don't tell anyone i said that

Progress saved