Chichén Itzá Review | A Feld Like No Other
Transcript
Hey everybody, today I'm going to be sharing my thoughts on the newest design by my favorite board game designer, Stefan Feld. So, this is a uh rather beast of a game called uh Teotihuacan: City of Gods. Uh two to four players. Uh the box says, I think about 120 minutes to play. Um to be honest, I think that's under selling the length a little bit. I did play this one yesterday and it was more towards that 2 and 1/2 to 3 hour mark. So, you are looking at a longer game here. And um if you're familiar with Stefan Feld designs, uh this one is a bit unlike anything else that he has made before because of course, Stefan Feld is mostly known for his kind of mechanically sound Euro style games where you get points for pretty much everything under the sun. This has elements of that, but it is built on this foundation of more kind of Ameritrashy mechanisms, lots of roll to resolve, kind of dudes on a map feel to it. So, it's definitely a a step in a different direction for Stefan Feld. So, this is number 10 from the City Collection. I'm just just going to lay this down here.
And unlike a lot of the other games from the collection, this is a brand new design. So, this is uh the first time this game has been out there in in any iteration. So, as I said, this is a dudes on a map style game, but you'll not only be um kind of fighting for positions with your opponents. Um there is actually kind of a a PvE kind of player environment thing going on as well where you can attack these monsters that are seated on the board. Now, throughout the game, you will be developing your skills in different types of combat by upgrading these skill wheels and they will give you kind of magic abilities to play these magic cards, uh ranged attacks, uh your melee attacks, um and also your ability to defend yourself. And the way the actual actions are resolved in this game is actually a one of my favorite parts of the game, which is through this action selection grid system where every vertical and horizontal axis will have a price assigned to it. Um and if you are the first to go there, you'll get the lower of the two prices, but every person after that you or or you know, more than the second person or second player or more will um will pay the higher of the two fees. So, sometimes those discrepancies can be quite large.
It could cost you as little as one or as many as seven coins to take an action. So, of course, you want to prioritize things when you are going to get the best value for your actions. And as I said, these are all these actions are pretty straightforward and you'd be uh what you would expect them to be. They are again upgrade your skill wheels. They are to move your troops onto the board. They are to spawn new troops. Um you can uh do things such as like scout certain locations to see how strong the enemies are there. Uh you can do things such as um buying these new cards that will give you permanent abilities or deploy heroes onto the map to give you more game breaking abilities. Um everything has its use. You know, I think this game has done a good job of making all the actions worth having. There aren't really any secondary actions and there is a strategy and pathway to go down and explore for all of them. So, you always have a a good option uh to go for here.
Now, the okay, the big talking point in this game, especially if you are you know, down the Stefan Feld rabbit hole, is does the roll to resolve combat work for it? And um you know, that's normally a big kind of red flag for me. I don't really like roll to resolve games. I like I love dice driven games and Stefan Feld has made some of the the best ones, but I tend to like random input rather than random output. This game has a lot of random output. So, essentially the combat system is that you will uh when you encounter an enemy, whether that be again uh a bot on the board or another player, uh you're going to go go through this phase system where you go magic, ranged, and then three bouts of melee attacks. And the magic phase is pretty simple. You can play these magic cards that you can collect throughout the game to give you some initial hits. Uh the ranged is purely based on your action wheel to get you some extra attacks as well. And then you'll go into your standard just roll off when it comes to the uh the melee phase. Of course, you you can um you can get these like reroll tokens to make you you know, to mitigate your your luck. And you can even cash in two of those tokens to to do a guaranteed hit. And one of the most interesting things about this game actually is this It's a very minor detail, but I did like it, especially considering it is maybe slightly more tailored towards Euro gamers or at least has that hybrid feel, um is that in order to attack the other players, you do need to declare yourself ready for war in advance so that you do know when you are vulnerable to be attacked. Uh and every time you attack
another player, you'll flip one of your war tokens back over to the peace side uh peace side. Um and then once they're all flipped to the peace side, you'll have to get re-go to that action in order to attack again. So, you do have a little bit of a buffer to protect yourself from attacks. Um and of course, there's a loads of ways to get points in this game. Um a lot of it is going to be through controlling territory. You know, as a baseline, you do get a I think it's two points for every single hex you control on this big modular map. But some locations will have hidden points as well based on these ruins that you're trying to protect the most the most lucrative ones. Uh you're going to get points based on the monsters that you slay. You're going to get points based on these gems that you can collect. The more the merrier. Uh any blue cards that you've collected which will get you end game scoring points. Um and so on. So, there's lots of different things you can go for, lots of strategies um and pathways for you to try and win the game. Now, all the monsters seated on the board also have a a different kind of skill set. So, they do range in strength. The strength is obviously declares how many hits they can take as well as how much damage they dish out and which combat phases they actually compete in. So, you might have these really powerful dragons that hit you in the melee phase, but if you manage to destroy them before you get to that phase, then you can get off scot-free and survive and hopefully conquer that tile. So, there is a good degree of kind of mitigation. There's a good degree of a predictability.
Um but of course, you are always going to be at the mercy of those dice rolls. But again, you do have that ability to constantly upgrade your your um combat potency in order to um guarantee yourself higher probabilities and you know, are much more likely to win those fights. Uh I really do like the upgrades in this game. You know, Stefan Feld tends to do a really good job of um adding in game breaking powers. Like in this one again, you can deploy these heroes onto the map. They'll give you really cool things such as being able to like teleport across the board or you know, whenever you lose troops, you get money for them. So, I do like these little touches and let you do things that the other players can't do. You can build up a bit of an engine as you acquire more and more of these cards. Uh and I do like that idea of you know, the actual action phase itself where you do have to really get into your opponent's head. You know, what are they going to do? Where do I need to go first? What order do I need to do my actions in? Each round, those values are going to be jumbled about so that each time the prices are going to be different meaning that you're going to have a different priority order to take these actions based on the money that you have. Uh guaranteeing yourself a steady income is important because you of course need to be able to do the actions that you want. Um and you can do that by conquering certain tiles. You know, some tiles will uh up your increase uh your income as the game develops.
And this is really nice kind of passive um passive catch-up mechanism if you want to put it that way where the more troops you have on the board, um you're going to be flipping these tiles over meaning that you'll get a fewer and fewer income uh at the start of each round. So, if you are if you've got like no presence on the board at all, you're going to have a lot more income meaning that you can start spawning troops at pretty more affordably. Um but to contrast that, the more troops you have on the board, the more points you get at the end of the game. So, it's got that really nice little push and pull there to try and make sure that nobody is left too far uh behind. Now, I think if you are really put off by the fact that there could be potential, you know, PvP pretty much take that style gameplay in this, I wouldn't be too deterred because to be honest, when we've played this, most of the focus is going to be on fighting those monsters. There's just more points to be had.
Um and maybe towards the last round or two, people might start to see some opportunities to try to declare war and maybe steal a location or two. But again, I think 80% of the game you're going to be fighting those um in game monsters rather than the other players uh themselves. And you just want to be spreading your influence and getting to all the best locations. So, get this is quite a difficult game to talk about because it's so unfeldian in the way that it's designed, but it hasn't really cut any corners. It does a really good job of what it's trying to be. I think it's super experimental. I love the player boards. Um and I love the different kind of pathways you can go down to tailor your own tribe. You do you want to be really strong in in melee combat and get loads of powers that will let you maybe reroll dice in melee in the melees or you know, make sure you hit on really low number or um on much higher probability when you do fight uh the monsters and just make yourself an absolute war tribal. Do you want to just go around and collecting these gems and get loads of points that way. Are you going to have to also somewhat tailor your strategy towards these objectives that come out and will trigger at certain points in the whole game arc. Uh so yeah, there's lots of different plates you need to be spinning here. Um my only issue is that I think it's it's kind of one of those games where yes, it's experimental, but once you've played it a couple of times, I think you've pretty much seen what the game has to offer. It's more of a an experience style game. So, do you want to make it an event maybe once or twice a year? I think this is maybe more suited to that rather than
being like a regular um you know um a game that hits the table regularly as your go-to area control game because again doesn't have that it doesn't have that kind of jockeying for position. I kick you out of here, you kick me back like games like you know like Wallenstein or El Grande have. It's much more Eurofied than that but at the same time that comes with the the caveat of a lot of dice rolling. So I think ultimately if you are 100% against road to resolve games you are probably going to bounce off this but if you are willing to try something different especially with that foundation of a designer to the pedigree of Feld then I think it's worth a look and just to give this one a try. Of course that comes based on the fact that this is quite an expensive game to acquire so maybe you want to try someone else's copy. And if it doesn't sound right for you or you have some hesitations thinking it's right for you, I don't think it probably will be right for you. So if everything I said sounds wonderful then then give it a go. If not I would say maybe try staying your lane if you want to complete Euro style game player Euro one of Feld's other amazing games but if you want that true area control game then there are so many good options out there that I would recommend over Teotihuacan but that being said I do I or I have really enjoyed my plays of this one. I did enjoy them but I feel like I am ready to move on from it. It's not going to be one that's going to stick around and in my collection but
it's memorable you know I think I'm going to remember this one in years to come because it does have a distinct feel and again as an experience and a big and epic event game this one does the job. So it's certainly not my favorite of his designs maybe more down to the fact that it's not my not my style but again objectively it's a good design and full props to Queen with this one although it's ludicrously expensive. The graphic design, the the components they are of a much nicer quality. It's quite easy to read kind of the phases and what everything does, the symbology etc. It's really well put together. A few minor issues on some extra little symbols that could have been dropped in in certain locations with no extra effort ready to make it a little bit more readable but that is a real nitpick. I think the game is actually really well put together and it has that nice blend of new school and old school visual aesthetic going on at the same time. Again be prepared for it to go a bit long and you know we played a three game three player game of this yesterday and it was like you know nearly three hours which I think is a is a bit too long for me. I want to play two hours maximum really.
So if you that doesn't bother you then then say la vie but if it does then you might want to shy away from it as well. So all in all I'd give it a six out of 10. It's not going to be one that stays around but I do see its merits. I do see its I do see its upside and I think some people are really going to gel with it. I think a lot of people are also going to bounce off of it. So that those are my thoughts really. So hopefully you have enjoyed the video. You know definitely unlike any other Feld game that I've played which is saying something. So if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on Chaman off the board. Bye-bye.