Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beer & Bread Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:04

hey everyone today I'm taking a look at beer and bread now this is a two player only multi-use card and most Resource Management game designed by Scott arms and published by Deep print games and Pegasus Spiel this game takes around 30 to 45 minutes to play on average now before I get started on my review of beer and bread I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor and place where I purchased beer and bread this is keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so beer and bread is gonna look like this once it's set up where you have the mayboard here which is essentially a placeholder for the different components of the game such as the cards You'll Play and the resources that are readily available so you've got five different types of resources you also have a round tracker here so you're going to play out over six rounds and alternating you're going to have two kind of phases um off the game so in rounds one three and five you're gonna have fruitful seasons and in rounds two four and six you're gonna have what we call dry seasons and what that essentially means is that there are going to be fewer resources available in those dry seasons but there are also some other changes too which we'll touch on and it's going to be a big deck of cards here where you're going to have the two types of cards the beer and the bread mixed in together randomly each player is going to draw five cards at random to

create their hand of cards um and then the game will begin so the objective of the game is to utilize these cards as best as possible to physically fulfill these contracts so you can see here that each of these cards is broken down into three parts the top strip here is essentially your way to gain resources the middle part here is the resources you need to cash in to get this many points and the bottom part of the card is kind of an engine building benefits which we'll use to tuck in to the main board here and give you ongoing rewards as the game progresses Now The Twist on this game is that when it comes to the final scoring you are going to calculate how many points you've got in the beer category and how many points you've got in the bread category but only your lowest of the two is going to be your final score so it's a good idea to keep both of those categories as balanced as possible so the first thing you're going to do in a fruitful round is you're going to seed the board here equal to the numbers here so you can see here that um you know this particular resources wants seven on the um on the little farm space this one wants eight and so on and once that's done you are going to draw your five cards and you're going to have a bit of a draft by selecting one of your cards I'm choosing which way you want to use it and then passing the remainder remaining cards in your hand to your opponent and your opponent will do the same thing back and forth until you have no cards left and that'll be the end of the first round of the game so let's talk about what your three choices of actions are so we've already touched about

um would basically touched on them but the first one is to again gain resources so let's just say I wanted to play this card here without any Rhyme or Reason to gain these two particular resources now when you gain them you are going to take them from the board here and if they run out you can't have them anymore so it's quite careful you've got to be quite careful about the availability of each resource so you know in this example I would gain one of these and also one of these now when I take these resources I'm going to put them on my storage area here now this is important because you do have a very strict capacity of only nine resources to begin with there are ways to increase your capacity and that's going to be the end of your turn basically but in the future let's say I played another card in this method like so I am going to have a look at any of the matching symbols that I've played and also get those resources so in this example I'll get a water from the supply here but I'd get two of these resources and then two of these resources as well so they do start to compound together but that only happens when they match so if I wanted to play it's a third time I would not actually get any duplicates because these are two fresh symbols that have not been seen in that row yet now another thing to be aware of is that if you take resources from the supply and you do not have the space to store it in your kind of storage area here than any over spill will be given to your opponent if they have the space to store it so you've got to be quite careful about what you take and not to kind of

give things to your opponent my second option is to complete one of these contracts so if I had all the resources list here so I've got the the water I've got one of these one of these and one of these I'm going to remove them from my storage like so and then I am going to put them back in the General Supply so they're not going to go back into the fields and that is going to be essentially a completed contract for endgame scoring now once you've played them you are going to put them face down on the matching spots here so you have again the beer spots the brewery and you also have the bakery for your completed Bread cards but something that's important is that you can only as a as a base rule you can only ever complete one contract at a time and if that space is complete then you are not going to complete another one of that type so if I had another beer contract ready for I'm completing I'm not going to put it on here until this card has been moved out of the way and that will link to the next action which is to play a card as an engine building benefit so what you're going to do is you're gonna have a look at the bottom benefit here like for example if I wanted to play this one it will say at the end of the seeding phase which is when you fill up all the resources you are going to collect one of these resources so let's say I wanted to do that because it's going to benefit me in the long term what I'm going to do without any prerequisites or any kind of requirements I'm going to tuck that under the matching spot on the board here to remind me that whenever it comes to this part of the game I'm also going to get this nice little benefit here and

there are a ton of different things that these um cards do each relating to a different aspect of the game like some of them might say you know um your beer your Brewery or break or Bakery you might be able to store another card before you wipe them off or something might give you end game scoring such as you know for every two beer cars that you sold you gain an extra coin for beer and so on or talk about some more of these cards a bit later but another thing that's important is that when you do tuck a card under your player board as an engine building benefit you get to wipe off these two slots here ready for more contracts to be completed so the fruitful round is going to end once each player has drafted and resolved their five cards and you'll progress on to the first dry phase now as mentioned earlier this will mean that there are fewer resources available here so you can see in this example the eight drops all the way down to A4 making resources a lot harder to get but it'll also modify the way the game is played because the dry phases don't get resolved in a draft you are going to pick up the cards that you've played as resources back into your hand ready to be used again and then you're going to draw additional cards to make your hand back up to five now what this means is that if you wanted to maybe hold on to a card because of the contract on it you can potentially play it as a resource gatherer drop back into your hand in order to play it as a um as a contract later however when it comes to the end of a dry phase any cars that you play as resources will be discarded for

good so you're not going to be able to keep rinsing and repeating for that you're only going to have one rounds Grace and you know in order to do it now a change another change made between the fruitful and dry phases of the game is that instead of drafting back and forth um you actually only keep the cards in your hand and play them um one by one so again you don't have that worry of giving cards away to your opponent another change that happens during the dry phases of the game is that three cards are going to go into this public display here meaning that you can swap cards from your hand with ones on public here and if you do that you're gonna have to resolve this card instantly but it does mean that you might be giving a card that your opponent wants it to them as an option so you've got to be quite careful of that and that's essentially how the game is going to progress over over these six rounds you're going to add up your score in each category again the lowest one of the two is going to be your final score added any bonus points you'll get by um putting cards under this coin slot here but let's take a look at some more of the engine building benefit cards so we have some examples of the end game scoring cards here you know this one here where it says if you have at least two more resources in your storage than your opponent does at the end of the game you're going to get an extra two coins this one here you have every two beer cars that you sell you get an extra coin this one here you'll get an extra um coin for every car that is worth four or five coins this one here when it comes to the cleanup phase if you remove both your beer and bread in a single movement

you'll get two water uh this one here because you may hold an additional bread card in your bakery to stop you having to refresh so frequently this one here simply gives you more storage so you don't have to worry about being at capacity so soon and these ones here will mean that you get resources when it comes to the seeding phase and you even have ones that will rely on the kind of turning of a phase where this card says that during the fruitful years are before the first card swap with the other player you can turn one of the cards in your hand upside down protecting it from being stolen from the other player okay so let's share some thoughts on beer and bread so generally speaking I'm not a huge fan of almost like contract fulfillment games where you're collecting resources in order to complete cards now this game does have that but I do like the way that is merged with a few additional sometimes minor mechanisms to start with the um the actual choice of how to utilize the cards is an interesting one especially when it comes to the drafting or the fruitful years because you know you do have to bear in mind the risk of giving cards away to your opponent because you might think you know I don't quite have these resources yet but if I play them now and get the resources hopefully the card will make it back to me and then I'll have the resources in order to cash it in but you also do have that almost kind of um you know like one round's Grace that's strategic planning of yes I'm gonna play these cards in front of me to gain resources and I can really compound if you start matching the symbols but it does mean that when

it comes to the dry phase you can pick it into your hand pick it back up into your hand you could use it again as more resources or for the engine building benefit but more importantly you can build towards something so again you do have that option of looking ahead and you know gaining resources in order to you know build towards a certain card to get those points and I also love the way that you have to be careful of not gaining too many resources because again that over spill is going to go to your opponent which can you know just lay there or basically get a foundation for your opponent to use that against you and complete their own contracts um quicker there is the potential to build some rather nice engines here you know if um at the start of each round you're getting a bunch of resources and things that can be really useful and can just give you that passive um income I also like the fact that there are limited resources available here meaning that that pressure to get your resource cards down might be Amplified because those resources might not be there by the time it gets back um to your turn the game also feels very fast now there's not much downtime at all and before you know it those six rounds are gonna be finished and you are calculating final scoring so yeah it definitely does not outstands welcome I'm considering there are some you know reasonably good decisions here in terms how to utilize those cards now my biggest criticism of this game is actually something I tend to enjoy um in board games and that is the scoring system so this game recycles that kinesian scoring system where you know you're competing in several fronts but only your worst one is your final score now because in this game you are only

competing in two different fields you know the beer and the bread what it means is that you know naturally you are going to keep those piles as balanced as possible so for every beer card you do you're going to do a bread card and for me that felt a bit scripted and I felt a bit on the rails and it kind of took a lot of choices out of your hand because sometimes you would think you know what I've got loads of resources here I'm obviously going to do the one that I've got the lowest pile of and yes there are ways to kind of Tinker with that with these extra cars but it didn't make a huge difference yeah it kind of felt a bit diluted and it felt like it was a bit predetermined and a bit pre-written on what your overall strategy was going to be I think the production of this game is pretty much perfect it looks fantastic on the table you know Michael Menzel is probably one of my favorite board game artists who makes the best looking actual boards I've ever seen and this is another example um of that I actually think it's a really cool idea that these engine building cards slide under the different aspects of the game which they're helping or boosting so it helps to remind you and not forget which cards you've invested in and the resources are nice um I like the way they fit in your storage areas and the cards are nicely and cleanly broken down into the three different areas to you know easily um digest the information on them so yeah I've got no criticisms at all about the production I think it's Top Notch actually and it fits into a nice little kind of two-player sized box there there's even a little scoring pad which is kind of not entirely necessary but it's nicely added it in there okay so let's share some final thoughts on beer and bread now this is a nice game

it's certainly Pleasant to play I mean it flows really nicely and to be honest some of the things I like the most about it are some minor touches I think there's some very clever little design choices here especially when it comes to gaining the resources and the Surplus resources going to your opponent that's a really interesting touch to add some again more play interaction there and I do like that degree of planning that you can use cars as resources in the fruitful phases and then pick them back up and complete them in the dry phases to get plan ahead and build towards something and there are some nice engine build and engine builder benefits you can contribute to as well some of them are more interesting than others but generally it all works nicely and it does feel that you have some more forward momentum here and again that play interaction is a it's a strong part of the game you know giving cars away to your opponent during the drafts and then swapping the cards over being the first to grab the resources it is all quite harmonious in the way you interact with your opponent now despite me not having much negative to say about this game in general I know I do feel like the um you know the balancing of the beer and the Bread cards is kind of overplayed it's not actually that important you're obviously going to keep them as balanced as possible it's a lot more interesting when you're competing over you know three or four or five different ways to score points and your lowest one scoring one is only two you're obviously going to keep them balanced but again despite me liking a lot about this game I think the biggest thing about it is that it does lack a certain X Factor there's no real standout mechanism about it and it does feel kind of pedestrian and that you've seen a lot of these things before now it is a

strong example of the multi-use card system I do like Resource Management games when there is a capacity so I do like the fact that you can't just hoard a bunch of resources it keeps a bit more Tighter and a bit more interesting um but yeah is this going to be one that I'm always going to kind of come back to considering how many great Tour player games out there I'm not quite sure that it's going to be the case with this one I think it's going to kind of come and go um through my collection but that being said I certainly don't regret my time with it I would even recommend it to the to the right people but yeah for me um I think I'd rather play something else um so it's a bit of a near Miss for me you know probably put it about a six and a half out of ten um which is certainly you know better than average but yeah is it going to keep me coming back um I don't think so so sadly um I can't overly recommend this one but I'm not going to discourage you from trying it either if you do like these more simple Resource Management games with some pretty interesting twists so that is beer and bread

Progress saved