Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ginkopolis: Experts Review - Beyond The Base Game - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 19:28

hmm yeah hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken meepo beyond the base game if this is your first time checking out the channel then consider thumbing it up commenting subscribing maybe look at the patreon and of course checking out my new sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.com.uk stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5 discounts on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kianda and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get done with it so for today we are looking at the ginkopoulos i hate that name kinkopolis expansion the experts this was donated to me by asmoday so thank you for them for helping out with a review copy and this is an expansion for a very underrated game do i think the game is like the best game ever no but i've been playing it a little bit more often and it hasn't appeared in my top 100 yet although it could potentially next time we'll have to see it it's starting to rise up in my appreciation for it but ginkopoulos is one of those games from pro games that's not talked about much but those who do

talk about it really like it and it is a pretty cool game but you don't hear about it much it came out in 2013 on time maybe even slightly earlier than that and it went out of print and then nobody spoke about it for ages until recently it's had a reprint along with the expansion and now of course people are starting to think oh maybe i should check it out anymore i've not actually reviewed gingo bliss on the channel maybe i should do that at some point maybe on the podcast but i want to talk about the expansion because after playing this game a few times i'm like okay cool what could the expansion add is there a way that they could augment the game to make it even better well uh yeah we'll get onto the overall verdict later but basically what this game this expansion does is it adds six new modules and you can basically decide which of the modules that you want to throw in the game although six modules is a little bit of a lie it's mainly five five and a half maybe five and a quarter modules we'll get onto that a bit later but essentially you just choose which modules you like they've got different levels of complexity and you can decide which ones you want to throw in if you're not familiar with ginkopoulos it's essentially a city building game where you are building tiles of red blue and yellow in differing heights some tiles start in play and they're surrounded by letter markers that show where new tiles can be placed on your turn you choose a card from your hand simultaneously players reveal the cards and add new tiles to the border of the city in the appropriate location or place tiles on top of existing tiles each card that you don't play from your hand though is passed on to your left

hand neighbor so you have to keep in mind how their your play will set up theirs and when you add new tiles to the city you take another card of the same color and these cards as they get more powerful as the game progresses provide you with additional abilities and potential point scoring effects it's a quirky little game and like i say definitely underrated it's definitely worth checking out but maybe i'll have to do a proper review on it sometimes i can give it a bit more detail so how do these different modules work then i'm just going to go through each one in turn and say what my general thoughts are before i get to a verdict on the whole expansion itself first up you've got new buildings yes i said it goes from 1 to 20. well now you've got buildings in each color that go 21 22 and 23. yay i mean that's pretty much all it is you know normally you can choose to take a couple of level one buildings at some stage now you have a choice of taking a single one of these they're higher in value they allow you to build on top of them and the cards associated with them get you points at the end of the game for collecting other types of point scoring cards they're fine but i don't think they really add that much to the game and honestly the idea of collecting other types of point scoring cards to score points for this particular set is kind of weird it's an unusual type of scoring mechanic however it's a pretty easy include to throw in the game it doesn't add too much in the way of complexity but it also doesn't add that much interesting stuff to the game either it's just kind of there well i like war but i wouldn't say i love it next up

you've got very simply prestige buildings i already mentioned 21 22 and 23 well you can also go as high as 24 and 25 if you throw in these prestige buildings now they don't have an associated card with them so there's no other point scoring opportunity it's mainly just a way to secure yourself against them being taken over by other players again relatively simple it adds to no another option for drawing tiles which can elongate the length of the game because there's a bit more to consider but again and they they're there it's just like the other new buildings i don't feel that they add that much to them i would maybe be more interested if you've just given me like alternate versions of the other buildings with some similar but differing effects so that you could chop and change each game these you kind of just bolt on and forget about it and like i say you can bolt this on with the other buildings and give yourself a little bit of extra choice but for the price of the expansion i don't see it being that worth it well that was pointless now we get on to probably the most complex but also the best expansion out of this entire expansion that's the one way of putting it the green spaces it essentially allows you to create parks these do not have buildings on them or numbers or anything like that you can only play these with the urbanization action which is essentially what you use to create more land but what these do is they add a nice little strategic element to the area control aspect of the game so when you play the urbanization card if you when you place the green space first up you get to

utilize the buildings that are adjacent to it as if you had played them already so knowing where to place these is already a cool thing but on top of that if you urbanize next to a park already you get bonus victory points depending on how big the park is now that's all well and good you know that's on its own that's already pretty cool but then when you get to the end game scoring part of the game essentially when you're deciding like oh the resources are in this particular district or that for area control resources that are in a park also count as being included in adjacent districts providing that you've got one resource in both so as long as i've got one in the park and one in the district that's relevant i get to add the resources on the park to the district that i'm in already for the purposes of scoring majorities and at the end of the game it's a cool addition and it really does add another cool strategic element to the area control part this is one that i would actually like to throw into most of my games however it does add to the complexity of the game i mean it's a simple inclusion in terms of the tiles it's literally just these and certainly you have a choice of whether to draw these or the normal tiles so it's again it's another different choice to make but the complexity of using these takes the game out of newbie player friendliness i mean the game is not new player friendly anyway it's not a gateway level game but if i'm teaching this to players for the first time the last thing i want to do is throw these in so this is definitely one to play with well no pun intended

expert players as the expansion suggests but honestly this is the best ex the best module in this expansion and definitely worth looking into if you want to add a little bit more game arenas to ginkopoulos dear god what is it like in your funny little brains it must be so boring now we got to get on to what is probably the worst it's it's hard to say whether this is the worst module in the set uh it's the worst from a mechanical perspective the event tiles which is annoying because the event tiles is probably the biggest set of components you get in this expansion i mean all of these are the event tiles but what essentially happens is that there's one for each of green blue red and yellow and at the start of the game players get to look at all four decide which two they like and when they play a turn during the game they can decide whether to play one of these event tiles with them and each one does something different here's two big problems with this though firstly the iconography on these event tiles is some of the most unintuitive stuff i've seen is it's confusing as all get out which means you're gonna need the rule book in order to figure out what they each do i guarantee you will not necessarily guess what any of these icons mean on these event tiles but the other problem is that half of them are pretty vindictive effects they actually involve things like stealing stuff from your opponents this is the game that doesn't warrant that level of vindictiveness i mean you're already vying for area control in the game okay so the idea that somebody might take a district of you that you were building

up is already a fairly vindictive part of gingkopolis but then everybody's aware of that it's area control it's kind of in the game but these event tiles just coming out and saying right i'm going to you know steal something off you it's like i'm not a fan of these at all they're it's an easy include if you want to throw them in but having to remind myself all the time what the iconography does and throwing in like vindictive elements i just think are against the spirit of the game i don't like using these at all and honestly after trying them i won't use them again it's it's a shame because it's a big part of this expansion but yeah i think there's better ways to do event tiles with these sort of games there'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return now this next one is probably the most insulting one of this set it's an easy mechanic to throw in and it's actually in a way a good mechanic to throw in but it's a bit insulting because it literally is this much of rules that's it just that much of rules is keep a card what the hell is that and the keeper card is literally just a rule variant that could have been printed on a website and never included in something that you paid money for the idea of even counting as one of the six modules is ridiculous i mean that's why i said this thing basically has five and a quarter modules in it it is a cool inclusion though i will say but again it elongates the time of the game it adds to the complexity level and it's

definitely not recommended for teaching this with new players basically what happens is when you play one of your four cards in a turn you play a card and that's the one you resolve and then you normally pass the other three to the player on your left when you're all done in this version you instead get to choose one of those three cards to keep face down in front of you and only pass two cards on so you think well i could really use this one or i really don't want the neighbor to get that now it's a cool addition but not one that i tend to use all the time because i think that decision of deciding look i know i want to play this card but ah those other three are gonna go to the opponent that's oh it hurts but i think i'm gonna have to do it is a cool tactical choice giving you the opportunity to basically just negate that is kind of i don't know it kind of goes against what i like from the whole passing the cards round not to mention that if you are new to this game you will not have the faintest clue which card you really should be keeping behind it can also add to the ap ness of the game because as well as having to decide which one you're going to play you've then also got to decide which one you're going to keep so it's another choice that can hold people up it's an easy inclusion if you want a bit more control over the game you know a little bit less like a bit it loses some fluidity in the game system because you're keeping cards at different times but if you want a little bit more control a little bit more game arenas then by all means you can throw it in i'm kind of a hit or miss on this one but the fact that it's literally just a paragraph of writing and it's supposedly one of the six modules is a little bit

insulting i gotta say dude you're embarrassing me from the wizards and the final module is essentially what the the expansion is called experts it's a set of cards that you throw in oh wait those are the building cars we don't need those it's basically player powers so you get to choose so many of these at the start of the game and they give you some other means of kind of augmenting the rules or breaking the rules for yourself so again it's basically just player powers now normally i love player powers like oh i get to have player powers in this game great uh this is a little bit problematic though for two reasons firstly and some others will debate this i'm not convinced these are all balanced there are some in here that i feel are like yeah they score you points for what you have and what opponents have they are a lot easier to deal with than some of these other ones that are very much more situational because some of these will just trigger like regardless of the fact and some of them you only get benefits of you go out and hunt down those benefits so the balance is already a bit off key but the other problem is that it adds just another level of complexity and i think this kind of is one aspect of this expansion which is kind of rooted in the whole thing that is a problem i have with it ginkopoulos is not the most complex game ever but it does have some complexities to it it's also not very intuitive even though there's not a huge amount of rules to learn in genopolis it's abstracted it's different from other games so it's a hard one to teach and obviously it's harder for people to learn to then throw

in stuff like this just adds a level of complexity that i just don't think you need in ginkopoulos uh it also dictates which event tiles that you use if you pick them so if i pick this particular expert i have to take two of the red event tiles and if i pick this one i get a green and a yellow but if you're not playing events then it doesn't matter but there's not that many different experts either i mean for a whole module of these things it's kind of limited in scope and i just don't feel i want to throw these in that much even if i am playing this with people who know what they're doing certainly i will never throw this in with new players and again that is another problem with this expansion is that nothing in here really feels like something i would want to throw in if i was teaching this game to new players which for me and i understand that this is kind of more of a me thing is something that i end up doing on a regular basis i'm usually teaching this to new players and that's kind of the way it goes i'm a doctor just accept it so yeah not exactly the best of uh praises for this expansion and it's just that's the way it is it's just not a particularly good expansion i can recommend honestly the most useful thing in here and this is actually kind of like almost slightly pathetic is that it comes with a reference card for each player that tells you the powers on all the different cards this was something that we asked for from the main game and it basically goes through all the numbers from 4 to 23 or whatever and summarizes for blue yellow and red what power is on those cards not something i want people to be

studying constantly throughout the game but it's a nice useful aid for those who are new to it this is the most useful thing out of this entire box and it's just a reference aid oh wait you're serious let me laugh even harder that's kind of sad really so you've got an expansion here which takes a really cool underrated game i stress enough gingkopo this is a really cool game and you should check it out but this expansion just felt very lackluster like this is almost stuff that i think was on the cutting room floor when people were designing the original ginkopoulos and so they thought well let's take all that stuff that we shoved on the cutting room floor and just basically shove it into this expansion box you when you hear people talk about ginkopolis you don't hear people talk about the expansion that much and this is kind of why the green spaces are cool they're the best thing in it but still i wouldn't want to throw this in with new players the experts themselves they're not particularly varied they're a bit too complex and not the most balanced either the new buildings and the prestige buildings yeah they're easy inclusions but they just don't really add that much to the game that's of interest and it's just more complexity that you've got to teach as well as deal with in the setup and take down which is already pretty lengthy when you deal with the normal game and then you've got these event tiles which honestly i will never want to use because i don't want the added evilness that these things include in my games and then you've got that keeper card one which is a cool little variant but again

adds to the complexity adds to the length and frankly could have literally just been a paragraph of text on a website it doesn't count for this game so honestly yeah this was a bit of a disappointment really but to be honest it's an expansion you can take it or leave it it's up to you maybe some of these modules took your fancy maybe you really like some of these modules in which case you know if you like the green spaces one i can understand but if you like some of these other modules i'd be interested to know your thoughts let me know in the comments but yeah this is not an expansion i recommend it's pretty meh pretty bad i'm not gonna give it plus points for giving you a reference card or having to keep a card rule so you're talking one out of what five odd modules really that's any good now this is pretty bad i'm giving this one overall i'm giving this one a three out of ten it's it's not like the most terrible thing i've ever played but it is bad i i just think that for the money you pay for this because it's not a cheap expansion i mean you're getting quality components yeah you're getting those thick tiles again and good artwork and that but yeah i wouldn't buy this expansion just for the green spaces no you're going to need to buy this hoping you're going to use most of these modules and honestly i just don't think there's very many people out there who will this is kind of a bit like the isle of skye journeyman expansion the other one that i really don't like it adds too much complexity and too much fiddliness to a game that didn't really need it in the first place this is what this kind of feels like nowhere near as fiddly and complicated as that expansion was but it's another example of an expansion that i just

cannot recommend i don't often end up doing a negative review for the beyond the base game but yeah this is probably one of my first i don't recommend it stick with the base game you'll be more than happy with it trust me it's designed by xavier was it xavier george's so the same guy did carson city and uh the was it the new one i think carnegie yeah that everyone's a lot of people are talking about same designer by all means underrated check it out but this expansion skip it so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see then consider thumbing up the video subscribing to the channel consider looking at the patreon to help me out or you can just comment on the video and let me know your thoughts on gingkopolis and the expansion are you the complete opposite of me do you think this expansion's great in which case let me know and all the others know why in the comments but if you agree with me on some of these thoughts i'd like to know your experiences with this expansion as well or you can just tell me what you think of gingkopolis the base game you know have you just discovered it or has it always been a favorite in your collection until next time you can check out more content on the channel i don't know which one specifically you can check out this and this not that i can explain i don't know what the timing of this video is gonna be until next time take care remember as always it's only a game bye for now

Progress saved