Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Fellowship of the Ring Trick-Taking Game Review (Co-op Tolkien Card Play!)

Transcript 15:46

let's talk about a Cooperative trick-taking game set in Middle Earth welcome to brain on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we're going to talk about a game that was sent to me from the folks over at asmo day this is a game that was created by office dog games a Cooperative trick taker set in Middle Earth titled appropriately enough The Fellowship of the Ring trick-taking game you do feel like a fellow ship when you're cooperating to complete these missions this is a game for between one and four players there are Solo rules in the Box games take only about 20 minutes to play and it works with kids aged 10 and up let's take a deeper look at the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game now I'm going to try and keep this as spoiler-free as possible there are chapters and missions and things like that that you're playing in this game but we'll keep the spoilers to a minute minum of course this is a light trick-taking game a must follow trick-taking game we're going to talk about that but it is a light game and it's a game where what you're trying to do varies based on the chapter that you're playing typically what you're trying to do at least in the early chapters is just complete each character's Mission so you get before you start the game a a little chapter card that looks like a book uh one side has some flavor text from The Fellowship of the Ring and then the other side side

kind of tells you how to set things up and what your goals are for that mission so this is revealed at the beginning of the game and then you start dealing out cards each Mission has certain characters that are going to be available and some characters are mandatory for the mission Frodo is going to be around a lot of the time uh and I'll tell you about that I wound up playing froto in almost every we played six games in a row and I wound up with the froto mission card every single time it's a game where you've got five suits uh there are hills and mountains and forests and Mordor and then you've got the Rings there's no Trump suit so if you know about trick takers we're talking about a game where uh each player is playing a card into the center of the table the high card is going to win often in trick-taking games there's a trump suit a suit that's going to defeat all the others that's not the case in The Fellowship of the Ring instead the only trump card is the one ring so the One Ring definitely rules them all in this game you can choose when you play the One Ring whether you want to win that trick or lose it once players have their hand of cards there's always going to be one card that's left over as like a they call it a lost card sometimes something will happen with one of the missions that will affect you know be based on that card or it'll affect uh the card that's here in the center of the table uh but once you've got all your cards you choose your characters which is interesting so you know know what cards are in your hands

before you choose which Mission you're going to try to complete and each character has a different Mission the player who's been dealt the One Ring card has to choose Frodo that's the first choice that gets made Frodo gets chosen his mission is that he has to win at least four ring cards and there's only five in the entire deck so they're numbered from one to five he's going to have the one ring card because that's while you're choosing this uh card as your character you can't give it away to anyone unless he chooses to lose a trick but he needs to get four out to five of those cards which can be challenging to do after that you go clockwise around the table and players are going to choose which character they want to play now we played this game at three players it was always three players the two-player rules have like a a dummy hand sort of with some cards that are arranged in a pyramid um but we played it three players and a lot of the times uh in the missions that we were playing there were three characters that were needed so we didn't have as as much flexibility in terms of which missions we were trying to complete so there are going to be some mandatory characters you've got a little wooden uh token that indicates which characters are mandatory once you start playing the game that token will be placed on the card once your your character has completed his mission um and then you get to choose uh as I said those characters you might have missions like well like I said froto has to get four ring cards uh Pippen here wants to win the fewest number number of Tricks Bilbo he wants

to win three or more tricks so so you're cooperating to make sure everybody wins or loses the right number of tricks in the game but those goals do become more complicated as you go up into the later chapters because this is chapter based Mission based games you're going to add new characters and new cards to your deck and and that does change things up a lot so I have talked about trick takers in the past I do really like trick takers a lot and this one I I haven't played a lot of Cooperative trick takers uh the crew stands out as one that's it's kind of similar to this one and sale is another one um but this is a a must follow trick-taking game meaning that the first player is going to be froto in the first round of every game and then froto is going to play a card everyone if they have that card a card of that suit in their hand has to play a card in that suit it's a must follow trick taker you have to follow the the card that's LED if you don't have any cards in that suit then you can play any card the high card is going to win or the one ring is going to win the high card and the lead suit will take that and then that player is going to lead the next round of the game so you're trying really hard to make sure that you win or lose the right number of tricks or that you win a certain card or or there are a number of missions and it does get more and more complicated I would say as you get up to later chapters Things become much more specific like like I said at the beginning three or more tricks but you

might have to win only three or only two uh and that becomes quite a challenge uh to be able to do that when you don't know when anyone's cards are in their hand one special token the player who's got the one ring card well froto typically is going to have this special one ring token this big wooden token uh sure that tells you that he's the first player but really what this is for is that it tells you once it reminds you that rings have been played so it's a game where you cannot lead unless the only cards in your hand are rings you cannot lead a ring card until a ring card has been played in a round so you're not going it rings aren't going to be the first card that's played those are going to get played later on in the game once the player has dropped a ring card then you flip this token over to show that now you could lead Rings if you wanted to maybe froto wants to lead if he's got the Five Rings he's going to want to capture that if he plays that five is going to get a bunch of rings from the other players who have them in the game I'm I am going to share one minor minor spoiler the second chapter of the game introduces some new characters and Sam is one of them how how are you going to play The Fellowship of the Ring without Sam being around and Sam also introduces a special mechanic that does come into play in later chapter not in every chapter but in later chapters too there's a deck of cards called the threat deck and Sam needs to win a hill card that matches

one of the cards in this deck so this deck of Black Riders gets shuffled up he he draws one and puts it beside his character card to show this is the hill card that I'm after oh he needs to get the one of Hills but as you play through the game more threat cards are going to get added to this deck it it's um it's an interesting mechanism and it really is thematic when it comes to the fellowship play continues until all the players have played the cards in their hand and then you're just checking to see has everyone accomplished the goal that will allow you to move on to the next chapter most of the time in the early chapters like I said the goal is just accomplish all the character missions and if all the players do that well then you're good to go to the next chapter if that doesn't happen though then you have to do your chapter over again you can't move on to the next chapter until you've completed this one there are some once you've completed the whole game there's some rules to sort of continue the story um where you can kind of be flexible in the way that you play one thing that I like about the game is that the cards are numbered so you can reset everything if you want to and start the whole thing all over again maybe you want to try it out with some new players one other thing I should mention I mean that is the game in a nutshell the must follow trick taker but one other thing that's important here is that communication is super limited you're not telling the other players about the cards in your hand um how are you communicating what cards you want or what you need well you need to pay attention to which car characters each player chooses so that you know what their mission is because they're

choosing their mission based on what cards they have so you you sort of know okay well maybe this guy chose Pippen because he doesn't think he's going to be able to win very many tricks the other way that you're communicating is by what cards you're playing as you play through uh each round of the game so you're trying to remember what cards everyone's played you're trying to keep track of cards that have been played because once the tricks are one they're turned face down so you need to remember them uh and then you're you're doing some deduction in terms of well what is it that this player wants or needs in order to win the game sometimes you get down to a last card I remember there was one game where I had a choice I was going to lead a low card so that I knew who was going to win that hand I was going to lead a low card but I had a choice of one suit or the other and I picked the wrong one and we had to start the whole mission over again because the other player didn't have a card in the lead suit what skills though are you practicing when you play a game like The Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game um well like all Trick takers you are trying to count cards you're trying to remember the cards that have been played when you win a trick in the Fellowship of the Ring those cards go face down in front of you so you have to remember what's been played to keep track of what people have in order to play the right cards you can accomplish your mission you're either all winning or all losing this game so there is there's a memory component here and what we're talking about is really visual working memory

now working memory is the whiteboard in your mind where you keep information so that you can manipulate it somehow so that you can work with it it's literally working with information in memory and it's visual information I've seen lots of hills that are already played so if I play this low-numbered hill card I probably can still win the hand for example uh might be something that you're thinking about as you play so visual working memory meaning it's that whiteboard but you're remembering this visual information of the suits and the numbers on those cards that have already been played so far in the game there's also a a deduction component so you're doing some deductive reasoning you're not just remembering those cards you have to think about what those cards play mean like why did that player play that card at that time what is it that he's got in his hand what is he looking for what does he need me to play in order to accomplish the mission so that we can all win and we don't all lose this game so you've got this great combination of simple social deduction but really there's a lot of visual working memory involved here final thoughts about the Fellowship of the Ring trick-taking game um well it is a trick taker you know I love trick takers I that's a mechanism that I really like but what does this add because trick takers need to do something different in order to stand out um so The Fellowship of the Ring has a a few things that I that are really going for it here um first it's the theme you know Fellowship of the I I

like the Lord of the Rings what am I going to tell you I'm maybe not a Steven coar level fan but this is a a theme that I I quite like and the idea that it's cooperative and it's a fellowship really does shine through in the game you feel like you're working together and you're trying to help Frodo get that one ring uh where it needs to go to Mordor right so that he can destroy it um I love the artw work on these cards maybe it might be a bit divisive it is quite stylized I I I really like these character cards it's almost like a stained glass window style the colors really pop out the components are fantastic this big wooden chip that has a bit of weight to it that's black and white until uh until you're allowed to lead rings I mean this is a this is a gorgeous component to this game even the box is cleverly designed I'm I'm covering something up here so that I don't spoil anything but you've got separate boxes as you play through the different chapters and there's ribbons inside it's like a bookmark so that you can separate out the cards that you're using and you don't lose your place what chapter am I on when you're playing this game so I I think that's like it's very well thought out this game and I think you know like other trick takers you're doing these missions that become increasingly difficult I think in this game there's a lot of variability that I really liked it's got um it's it's personal in that you're playing as a character in a book or or a movie that you probably like if

you're playing The Fellowship of the Ring um you're you're playing a character so it is personal you're not just playing a color you're not just choosing okay I'll be blue uh I'll choose this Mission no you're choosing to be Pippen or Gandalf or Bilbo um I think that makes it more fun really than other Cooperative trick takers I've played and the missions become complex and and there's so many different things that you're going to be asked to do depending on the characters that you choose I really like that threat deck and how it interacts only with certain characters at On Any Given Mission so you're not always going to be pulling a card from this deck if Sam's around you have to do that and there are other characters that I'm not going to tell you about there are additional threats that are going to get shuffled into this deck as you play through the later chapters so what a what a great game uh you've you've got good flavor text on on the cards you've got a little blurb from a chapter of the book before you play we had a lot of fun and there were some tense hands in this game where you're really trying to think about what card do I need to play here in order to make sure that the team can continue moving forward we didn't finish every mission on the first try sometimes it took a few before we went but we kept trying because this is a good trick-taking game and and my group likes trick t Akers and myself in particular uh I'm a fan so I have to thank asod day for sending the Fellowship of the Ring my way if you have any questions or comments you can

of course leave them in the comment section below the video or you can email me at Brian brains on.cafe.com

can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time

Progress saved