Arcs is it Right for you or Wrong For you? | Full Review
Transcript
hello welcome to wob thank you for being here today I'm bringing you a right for you wrong for you review on arcs by leader games a game that's been out for the better part of half a year now I I think time has disappeared over the last I have a four-month-old now and I was playing it like a month before he came into existence as if time actually existed before my my my child ever did it it's it's been about five or six months since ARS hit the scene and hit the scene to great a claim and regard first off coming from a publisher that has released a number of games that have been wild and wildly praised and successful and a number of games that have been controversial around which type of gaming group they're successful for root being the preeminent example vast coming before that is one of the first asymmetric style board games representing or replicating a Dungeon Crawl Experience where you take each little subcategory and Venture forth trying to succeed at whatever your mission is and then of course with games like oath Cole whle has set the standard for designing games that some people love and many people are mixed on and a few people hate I mean his games are brilliant and I think across the board most people in the board game Community recognize them as such but it doesn't mean they're right for you that's what this review is des designed to answer
throughout this review I'm going to go through seven categories that I think are very important when determining whether to add a game to your collection onto your shelf and onto your table cuz eventually that's hopefully what you're going to end up doing with it how many of you have purchased a copy of this and have yet to get it to the table I know I have the number of games that I'm guilty of doing that exact thing with I'm going to give you a quick overview of the game so you understand what we're talking about dive into the theme discuss the accessibility how easy it is to get to the table take a swing through gameplay what makes it unique not how to play discuss the modes of play I want to analyze and break down what does it play best at what type of player counts are available and what are the other versions of arcs that exist out there in The Ether then we're going to talk about Innovation whether or not it is or is not Innovative and if that matters either way I'm going to break down the general price and then give you my personal opinion my verdict on arcs at least as it stands now about 10 games in or so and still needing to go through the blighted reach expansion I've experienced this game at all player counts 4 3 and two and I have played with leaders and lore included which is not the recommended way to start playing arcs in the first place we didn't start that way but we did end up getting there along with that I've played with I think six or seven different individuals so I've got a vast array of opinions and
the majority of people I've played arcs with so far have not found it to be a game that was right for them but I am actually still compelled I'm not in love with it but I'm very drawn to it and I probably need to watch this video to determine whether or not it's right or wrong for me so uh we'll do a circle back soon let's start with an overview let's break down what arcs is what it's trying to accomplish AR at its core is a trick-taking esque or hand management es area control style board game with the main way of winning the main objective of the game is to score victory points or power points through this Ambition track you'll be declaring as a chapter passes by and the game could last as many as five chapters or end as quickly as two depending on how scoring happens typically a game will last three or four chapters and run about 90 minutes or so depending on player count of course these Ambitions will relate to different objectives that you might have in the game and so your main goal is to identify what you're going to be able to score for and then accomplish that on the board by taking actions through the cards that you have now you're not going to be able to control the cards that you've drawn up into your hand instead you have to be Innovative with the way you use them cuz you're going to be responding or reacting to other players as they play their card cards you can see there's four different colors or four different types of cards here on my board we have construction
cards mobilization cards aggression cards and administration cards the orange blue red and gray and whoever is the first player of the round will set the standard or set the uh Target card the lead card and that'll be how you're responding that'll be the actions that you're trying to maximize during that round of that chapter rounds will last as long as there's a first player who has a card they're willing to play and so you could have a number of rounds in every chapter and each one could be filled with a lot of actions or a tiny little segment of actions depending on the lead card that was played you have a few options you can play a card that is of higher value getting all of the actions related both to that card and the Pips on it so this to would have given him four actions in the mobilization category this six would have been a legal play giving him two actions in the mobilization category again because there's two Pips and it's a blue card you also alternatively could play a single card that doesn't match giving you a single action no matter how many Pips are on that card of that action type if you needed to desperately do something or you could play a card face down restricting the amount of information other players are going to be getting at the table and copying the lead card giving you one of whatever that type of action is a great way to get that extra battle move or recruit uh or influence if you happen to not have that card type in your hand but you need to take that action so you're going to be gauging
you're going to be judging you're going to be trying to determine what other players around the table have left in their hand what is left to come out into the field of play and what you might be able to maximize or what actions you need to take now to set yourself up for later there's an argument that's been going or floating over the interwebs as to whether or not you can get a bad hand in arcs and I kind of fall on the sidelines that you can't every hand is compelling every hand is intriguing but it doesn't mean that every that any hand is in an itself bad it's all about your adaptability your ability to read the table to judge the room and take risky plays when and where necessary do I think you can lose because of the hands that you got dealt I think it's possible but I think it has more to do with the experience of the players of the table and less to actually do with the hands or the cards that you had to utilize let's go ahead and break this down on the board you can see this giant map this Arc logo in the center is just a graphical overhaul you have locations you have planets with their regions with their own little sub regions here and you're going to be spawning out into spaceports you're going to be building and defending cities so you can gain resources that give you extra bonus actions to utilize you're going to be influencing and gaining cards whether those are recruitable cards you know people that are on your team that give you extra bonus actions or events that might might happen like the song of Freedom that you can take advantage of and have them impact the game State all of this is done in favor of
accomplishing one of these or as many of these five goals as you can but only three will score at the end of a chapter you will be declaring Ambitions you'll be making publicly known what you're trying to score as the game State moves forward so other players should be able to react and curtail your attempt at scoring a ton of victory points and there will usually be a first and second place alongside that so whatever is public here you might not Score first place in a number of them but you might score all of the second place positions still giving you a confident lead in the game as you score these points you're going to be hitting an end Target in a four-player game it's 27 points in a two player in a three player game it's 30 in a two-player game it's 33 just like root there's a bit of a race to win system here you don't have to have the most planets conquered you don't have to be the most powerful player you don't need to be the most strategic all the time sometimes you just have to score darn points and if you don't like redirecting your attention away from the battle map the area control portion of this game over to the scoring portion of this game this game might not match up with your style of play it's an area control game yes but it has a lot more to do with exactly how and when you're going to score your Ambitions Tycoon here is simple have the most Cube resources and the most oil resources Tyrant here is have the most captives which you get by collecting cards or uh harboring hovering over other planets and stealing
resources and people from them warlord is have dealt the most destruction and you accomplish that by well dealing the most destruction on the board and taking ships over to your trophies so that you can count them at the end of that chapter keeper is going to deal with the number of Canon resources or or U uh whatever these Blue Magic resources you have an empath I think that's the SC scok resources uh down here is going to deal with the number of them you have on your board resources can be stored on your board they can be collected from the different colored planets that you have here on the table they can also be stored from some of the different influences uh different people you'll be recruiting into your game state so depending on where you're strong depending on how you've been playing you will hopefully be able to secure a few of these Ambitions that's the core principle of arcs there's a lot of nuance a lot of depth a lot of rules to learn it's a tricky game it approaches itself presents itself as simple and straightforward but the depth and strategy in play and the necessity of you thinking constantly on your feet along with redirecting your attention away from all the shiny beautiful pieces away from the pictures and the story that's being told over to the very very gritty scoring system makes this game unique compelling and also a game that you're going to have to get to the table a few times before you and the people around the table feel like you have enough of a
grasp of it to be competitive to really be able to sink your teeth into the joy of playing as opposed to just the mechanics system or the engine that you're sitting in front of that's an overview of Arts let's talk about the theme and theme is very important for me I really like thematic board games in leader games does a beautiful job at presenting theme without a lot of flavor text in most of their games their theme comes through the wonderful artwork that they produce the Miniatures that they have on the board or or the little uh meatles that they have on the board and the mechanics of the game itself and here I think arcs actually does a fairly decent job at replicating that feeling of a colonizing space Empire of setting a you know leader who can Journey forth and dive into to uh you know the Opera that's being played out I don't think it's overly thematic I don't think it needs to be I think this stands as primarily a themeless board game however the mechanics seem to match up my ability to recall and remember and play the game in a thematic way does still exist and I do sometimes feel like I'm a powerful space warlord playing incredible cards taking very very sneaky actions and securing or tyrannizing the world around me now of course there is another option there is the uh base box
which we're technically covering here and then ARX happens to have an expansion called The blighted Reach expansion which is bigger than the base box itself now the blighted reach expansion is something that I have not experienced yet because the price you have to pay to get into that expansion I think is fairly steep it requires an experiened group of players preferably three or four of them but it does introduce a lot more opportunity and depth into the lore and the storytelling giving you a sequence or a series of games to explore through you know harboring from or or taking from some of the ideas that oath set forward a game that remembers itself well the blighted reach expansion does that over the course of three full games the board changes the cities and the developments you have the technology you've been able to equip all of that adapts and grows as you dive head first now there is a mini expansion in arcs which I mentioned earlier which is leaders and lore leaders are going to add unique specific setups and custom rules based on their powers and preferences similar to things like Cosmic Encounter or Twilight Imperium not as complex as some of those but similar in the essence that you're playing a character and that character has their own unique role and responsibility in the world and then your lore is going to introduce powerful abilities one-time effects sniper rifles that can hit other players and scoring conditions or things that impact the way
that you actually might be able to win the game this is like shuffling and creating your own root character off of all the mechanics that exist out there but sort of inventing it uh or coming up with it by randomizing and scattering them across the table it does add flavor it does add lore it does add artwork it does give me more depth when it comes to the storytelling portion of ARS however it also adds more Randomness more chaos and more things other players have to account for when determining how to strategically play and I think that's the trade-off if you want more of a storytelling game you're going to end up getting more of a randomized game if you want less of a storytelling game you're going to end up getting a little bit more of a straightforward strategic hand management game however if you want those two things combined a highly thematic highly lore driven game without too much chaos then you're not going to find it here in ARs and therefore arcs might not be right for you accessibility how easy is it to get arcs to the table it's hard to say I mean teaching the game from the get-go probably takes a good 15 maybe 20 minutes but the experience of play is going to have people snapping too about halfway through the course of the game being like oh I just realized this or this is something unique that I can do it's going to not be until chapter 2 or Chapter 3 of scoring that new players start redirecting their attention to the Ambitions track which is really the
heart and soul of the game they have pulled their attention away from the Pretty board sitting in front of them it's a hard answer I think ARS is fairly accessible I don't think it's as complex as a root when it comes to the initial teach I do think though strategically and mechanically it is more confusing than Ru Ark sits in this weird space between oath which I think is probably one of the more difficult games to understand and get to the table from the leader games lineup and Route which is very easy in some ways to get to the table after all the players understand it after they all know it you follow your hierarchy of order on the board and you play through the game it's not overly accessible but it isn't too hard either it's right in that middle ground I think the hardest part of this is that I don't feel like most players have enough understanding of the core strategy the flow of the game to be competitive until two or three plays and I do think that the table State needs to be as equal as possible if you're an experienced ARS player you're just GNA have a baseline advantage over everyone else out there even if it just comes down to what you're paying attention to and that means that other players are going to have to know when and how to control for the uh inequality that exists here just
like in root if the Vagabond starts getting away with all the items and everyone's trading with him he will probably Sprint to a victory or if the corvid end up spreading all of their tokens and they're about to flip four or five of them and score tons of victory points other players need to do something about that but they need to do something about that before it's too late before he's started taking his turn the same thing here with arcs experience will allow you to react before actions have been taken and that's really where the long-term longevity the the the long-term player enjoyment is going to come from so if you've played other games from leader games if you have a group that enjoys the heck out of root that has handled oath with ease and doesn't mind a few in-depth plays to really get their feet under them for a game they're going to continue playing for the rest of the year arcs just might be right for you and your gaming group but if you like hopping into a game once every other month and you were left fairly confused and intrigued but disjecta of asymmetry I don't think arcs is going to shine or is going to be as enjoyable as if you were playing it very often let's talk about the game playay what makes arcs unique well I think for me the central thing is this trick-taking system I mean it's an Airy control style board with a game system that requires you to think on your feet and respond to other players and I don't know of another game that quite does
hand management quite quite does trick- taking at this scale and to this level of enjoyment I think it's super fun I like the fact that I can sit there and look at my hand and react and think through and do my best to analyze the game State I have to be thinking a few turns ahead I have to be prepared for what other players are going to do the game play is really about the hand of cards you have and how you can make the most of everything else in response to that the ships you have the space ports and cities you have onto the board the scoring objectives you're going for the resources even the people that you've recruited they all speak they all have reference they all have deference to the tricks that you're taking if you like trick taking games then this should be capturing your attention if you like area control style games then this should be one that you're looking at the game play feels fresh feels quick feels unique feels like it has a lot of opportunity for you to get more and more skilled and deeper and deeper into the engine it does require a little bit of memorization it requires a little bit of uh card awareness as they come out into play you could play with an open pile of cards so you have all the information possible for all players but like most trick taking games that actually takes away a little bit from the fun of Discovery the fun of doing your best to use your mind
and have it surmount other players outside of that arcs is kind of themed and built and the gameplay flows similar to most other space-based games build ships collect resources spread throughout the Galaxy blow up your enemies and if you do all of that well enough and good enough you'll secure Victory so if you like Space Games you like building ships and you know colonizing planets and destroying your enemies at every turn and the Hand system the hand management the trick-taking in response to other players system sounds cool if you want an area control game that requires more Innovative creative thinking than straightforward logical deduction than dudes the map spreading over the board and trying to outmaneuver other players then this game does that this game brings it all into the person when I play arcs I I sit there and I feel like I'm just absorbed in the hand of cards I have right in front of me everything else is just answering to is just responding to those four five six cards that I'm using so if that sounds compelling then arcs might just be right for you in your gaming group let's talk about modes of play Arc works as a two three and four player game and the two-player game is highly compelling it's a head-to-head straightforward battle it has most information revealed and you're only really paying attention to what other players are doing which means when you're countering when you're reacting when you're preparing it's always in
deference of other players it also plays the quickest so in two-player I think arcs really sells a compelling board game which isn't always the case for games like oath or games like root other titles coming from leader games primarily operate at higher player counts that's where they Shine the best arcs I think might just be the inverse at three and four players you add levels of randomization levels of interaction between players and a lack of information when it comes to the cards that could be out or might be out on the table those player counts are a lot of fun they're very compelling they certainly have a reason to drop players in but if you're looking for something that's a little bit more of a tactical head to head space combat then two-player is actually where you're going to want to sit and play this game the most it does not have a solo mode and I don't know how you'd incorporate one although I'm sure people on BGG will answer that question within the year and the blighted reach expansion for me is prohibitively complex if you have a group that is dedicated enough to get a game like Twilight Imperium to the table twice a year then the blighted reach expansion might be another alternative for you to incorporate into that once every 3 years or six months gaming experience but the average player is not going to be running into the blighted reach the average player is only going to operate here and every now and then incorporate leaders and lore with an experienced gaming Group which means when we talk about modes of play you really have to tie it down to
this on the board in front of me a you know multi Hour 4 to 6 hour long three sequence three game campaign is compelling but that should never be the reason why you pick up arcs because it's unlikely that you're going to be able to get it to the table and if you do once it's unlikely that that experience will be worth the investment in both time and resources I think multiple plays is going to be necessary for you to get the full breadth of what the blighted reach offers again this is just from my knowledge of the game system not for me actually experiencing it because it's hard to get to the table so so highly compelling two-player game for a head-to-head combative space game a more randomized three-player and highly chaotic four-player and if any of those categories sound like the type of game you'd like to play then arcs just might be right to you our second to last category is innovation is ARS Innovative and if so why or is ARS innovative if so why and does it matter and I'd say ARS is innovative in the hand management system I like the way that it incorporates it in I like the trick taking at this larger scale and I don't know of another board game that presents a case quite like arcs does trick-taking
in a game that requires a high level of outside strategic thinking that allows you to be responsive and Innovative with every card that you play and as far as I'm concerned like I said earlier in this video doesn't actually give you a bad hand like most trick taking games don't it's just a matter of how you utilize it yeah it's has a very very strong argument on behalf of itself that was a bad sentence but I'm going to stick with it does it matter that ARS is innovative in this case I don't think so while it does add something unique to my shelf while it is presenting a case that I don't know of another board game doing well the experience of play is unique I kind of am putting it in a similar category with Oath a game that for me was highly unique highly thematic extremely compelling a game that I still want to pick up another copy of and try again at a higher player count because that's what most of the audience said I should do and yet a game that I don't think is right for my collection even though it is a game that remembers itself a game game that lived on the table a game that didn't do anything that any of my other games current or ever in my collection have done it didn't stay and arcs is right there for me if I had a gaming group that really loved this game I think it would stick around but at the moment the trajectory that's set for it despite it
being Innovative is probably lasting until we get through the blighted reach expansion and then likely going away in favor of playing another game like root if we're introducing new players to the table I don't want to teach someone arcs I don't want to re-experience arcs with brand new players I want to play with people that already know how to play it and that's the problem with innovation in this context it requires a level of experience for all the players at the table to be competitive combative and enjoy it and it just doesn't match up for me finally let's talk about my personal opinion and the price point for Arc ARS is going to stand in that 50 to $80 price point range depending on the sale and the location that you purchase it from and I think the base game for what it does is competitive there it's a very in-depth game it's a game that could give your gaming group quite a number of enjoyable plays however I don't think purchasing the blighted reach expansion or the miniature upgrades is worth the price turning these wooden meeples into plastic pieces just doesn't do it for me and actually limits the readability of the board in front of me and the blighted reach expansion is something you should only purchase if you're picking this game up after you all have already fallen in love with the core but if you at this point in this video and you you think that Arc sounds like a game that might just be right for you
well I don't think spending 5060 $70 on a copy is a bad deal get it home get it to the table have fun with your friends and it'll probably hold its value if you decide that it's going to be moving on from your collection and if it sticks around the good news is you have great opportunities to continue exploring and expanding your journey with arcs and I'm under the impression that more expansions will be coming down the road because leader games always has something planned up their sleeve so if you're intrigued by the game and you have the spare cash to spend and if you've made it to this point in the video ticking a number of boxes saying that Ark sounds like a game you and your gaming group would enjoy go pick up a copy and let me know we're still going to be leaving coverage and doing coverage of this game over the next few months if not farther I still intend to get a full gameplay of the blighted reach expansion here to the channel and even if it takes six 12 18 months or I have to wait till my kids grown up and like 17 years old we do it eventually I hope he likes this game cuz so far like I said most of my gaming group hasn't found this to be the right game for them while a number of them have been compelled and continue playing it hoping that they're going to discover or figure out that switch that just makes it perfect my personal opinion on arcs is ARS right or wrong for me and if I had
to make a determination right now off of the number of plays that I have and the experiences that I've had so far on the table I would say that it's not I wouldn't have it in my permanent collection I I wouldn't keep it or try to get it off the shelf I never want to teach a new player how to play arcs again but it is intriguing it's extremely extremely compelling and the experience of play is different from any other game I currently have if I had a game group that matched up with games like Cosmic Encounter and Twilight Imperium and we're able to get those games to the table more often than my life currently allows arcs would probably be higher up in that conversation I could be convinced to continue playing this with someone that was really in love with it but I'm not going to be that person selling it to the rest of the people sitting down to play I'm going to go for something that they already love like age of steam like Dune Imperium like terraforming Mars and when you're thinking of that those two three four player game experiences that scratch some of the same itches Victory Point scoring hand management deck building you know area control arcs just doesn't seem to to to win to counter to live up to any of the pillars that those other games stand on could it maybe I think
the expansion has the most potential and I also think that it's the most prohibitive and that alone might make it eventually sit on my shelf similar to how Twilight Imperium does it's there cuz I love it because the experiences I've had have been worthwhile and also I've fully acknowledged that I'm unlikely to be the person that gets that game off the shelf and onto the table and the copy that I owned previously because now on my second copy of Twilight Imperium I actually gave to a friend because they hosted such a good gaming session of it ARS is likely to be there in the same category it's either going to leave the collection or it's going to convince me through experience alone that it should stay with the acknowledgement that it's unlikely to ever be played let me know what do you think does Ark sound like a game that's right or or wrong for you and let me know why whatever the case whatever you do remember to do the important thing invite a friend over for two-player experience that you're pretty confident you can crush them at that's what I just did he's sitting over in the other room we're going to get Arch to the table right now work on a two-player game play and uh based off his track record he's uh waving at me let's let's say that he's waving at me based off his track record I'm pretty sure I'm going to dominate but we'll see you didn't cuz
he's scared he's a chicken he's going to lose we've played three times he's going to lose he lost every three times I won once I won once he's gonna lose