Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hamlet - Board Game Review - Tiny Epic Hamlet

Transcript 13:27

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so by popular demand I'm taking a look at Hamlet The Village building game yes sir man has this one been requested ever since I got the Essen last year I've been trying to get it played played it a bit and then got you know tied up with a bunch of other reviews because this one I just bought out of my own pocket and then everybody was saying when you get a review Hamlet where's the review of Hamilton it's like okay okay I'll get it done all right so you know finally I can do a quick draw review on it so in Hamlet you're basically building a cathedral which is the common theme for pretty much any building game these days but it's done on a communal map in the middle of the table which is made up of various tiles of all sorts of weird shapes from hexagons to rhombuses to Diamonds to multi-hexes to some shapes I'm not even sure what on Earth that's supposed to be it's kind of a mixture of the two but essentially what happens is you have several of these at the start of the game and then you will be able to are more tiles and build the map as you go along but what players are doing is that some of these places like quarries and do wood cutters are being populated with resources that players can move their meeple workers along in order to trigger actions based on the tile the idea being that in order to build more tiles you're going to need some resources but in order to sell to the market you're going to want some resources as well for more points but the main goal is to supply the cathedral with various components in the middle

which effectively allows you to you know contribute towards the cathedral endgame timer as well as gain more points but in order to build anything in this game the resources have to be able to get from point A to point B so it's kind of like almost a bit like a pickup and deliver Logistics game where you require these donkey meeples dong equals Depots I don't know what you would call them do and you use those donkeys to get a kind of like a conga line from point A to point B so that if I want to say use a couple of flour to give to the market if the flower is over here on this tile then as long as I've got enough donkeys to get from Woodland to the town hall to the flower Mill it's okay I can use those resources now I should stress that this is the founders deluxe edition this came out to Essen the retail version isn't even out yet until like mid 2023 but the only difference on as far as I'm on aware is going to be that you will get normal cardboard coins and not these really cool metal coins uh your meeples and donkeys won't be screen printed but they'll still be one Meep or so big whoop and I believe that's it oh yeah no you get this 3D cathedral which is already falling apart uh we'll get on to components and stuff a little bit later but that's pretty much the main difference you're gonna get the same gameplay content in retail as you do Kickstarter probably my favorite aspect is the fact that you do have a communal map because a lot of games will typically have your own your own little board and even if they do sometimes have a communal map you know like our terrify marzers and other games the map doesn't really equate to a lot so it tends to be the same thing every time here though it's a lot more different because of these weird shapes and everything that

you can create I mean this is just a selection of tiles from the box and there's all sorts of weird combinations that you've got and different ways to make Goods like dairy farm and you know you've got mountain ranges shrines flower oil ponds you know quarries wood cutters Sawmills you know all sorts of different things and the tiles will come out at different times in each game depending on what players build and of course the map is going to start off as you know this one tile to begin with but then eventually it's going to have you know this on top of there this on top of there you know this one next to it and it's it's going to create a nice unique map every time even the idea of the logistics of moving from point A to point B can be quite fun I mean you're having to kind of plan out how you're going to do this particular building task you know in the long run but of course you've got to factor in the fact that other opponents might decide oh he's gonna do that isn't it ah what am I supposed to do if he does that and so it does throw a little bit of a chaos factor into the mix and if you're the sort of person that likes to be able to meticulously plan right term one is this turn to assist tune free is this you might be put off by this game by the fact that somebody can very easily come along and Scupper your plans it tends to balance out for the most part but player scaling more is I find that this game is much better played with less players two players actually this game works at its best at its peak three and four it's diminishing returns and honestly I don't think I would ever want to play this before again not just because the game length is elongated because the fact that it's based on when a player wants to end the game and the only person who wants to win the game is the one who's in the lead he goes it kind of does make

the game pretty long but in four players you regularly end up with situations where two players or two or three players do the actions sorry do the actions that they want to do and the person who's left has nothing to do and I had one game where I swear four times in a row right one player goes right I'm gonna spend the resources and do this next player comes along and goes right I'm going to replenish the resources on this bit and I'll get money sweet your turn and because I can't replenish any more resources for money and I don't have enough money to money workers and I had nothing to spend resources on at the time I had nothing to do with four turns that's not fun that sucks that's just problematic design in my opinion and this can happen a lot with more players now in two players not so bad because usually there's at least one thing you can do with two players so you don't end up with that problem but with three and four there's usually one maybe two players that are getting hosed on a regular basis because things are happening and with four of you the chaos factor is ramped up to 10 because of the fact that three other players are messing around with this map at the same time you are so honestly at two players this works best but you can play it so low thanks to David turksey you essentially have a bunch of action tokens underneath this little board and some priority markers of red yellow and green color and a little cup nearby which you've got to provide yourself and the idea is that you draw the markers and depending on what color you pick it does the action so naturally the red one is going to get done more often than the yellow than the green and then the tokens move around and it's essentially a little priority thing now Kudos especially for turkey designs this

doesn't have a two page long flow chart to understand what the various actions are and things like that this is the solo rule book and it's literally just three pages it's not a lot of rules and some of that is just about the adjustment of the difficulty and overview and setup so there's not a huge amount of overhead to learn and that makes for a good fun solo game I would say that the solo mode is probably second best to play this player two player then solo then freed and four but there is one critical problem I do have with the solo mode in order to keep this thing going you have to basically keep adjusting these priority tokens every time the opponent takes a turn and you do a lot of turns back and forth so this is going to happen a lot you're going to be adjusting these a lot and by the time you've done it for the 64 trillionth time I hate you now it really does become a bit of a chore if this becomes an app integration if someone does a third-party app for this uh solo mode I think this would be brilliant past the victory are pretty plentiful I mean you've got some Milestones that you can aim for where you have like more sale most sales in the market and being the first to be able to you know generate wood or bricks or milk and therefore you make high quality resources which can generate more points but then there's a bunch of these little tiles like ponds more points if they're connected by a path you know mountain ranges points for connecting the mountains and forests do the same thing so there's quite a few different ways that you can score in a game it's not just about completing the cathedral that is certainly one way of going about it if you've managed to collect a bunch of these scoring tiles and make good use of them with your flags then you can score a decent amount

of points by various means in this game and I like the fact that it does have that variety however one issue I do have is that there is such a critical need for workers I mean you're going to need some donkeys but you could get away without needing every single donkey you have in the game if you try to do this with your bare bones amount of workers you will lose outright because each one of these is an action each term which means that if you have two actions and somebody else is getting four all the time they will win full stop they will win they're just far out doing more than you and you need a certain amount of workers to be able to do the kind of combination of right I'm going to spend a bunch of resources and then spend them on the resources and then I'm going to use the last worker to replenish them for money or the other way around if you don't have enough workers to do that kind of little combo that Loop then it puts you in a really difficult position and it forces you to get a bunch of workers and then rewind back to what I said about three and four players where you can be stuck in a situation where you can't physically get any money because there's no action available that lets you get money you're slower to get the workers which means you get a slower start and so there is very much a you know a runaway leader problem here but as much as there's good and bad stuff with this game we haven't got to the critical elephant in the room here the components for the founders Edition the components are cool you know you know screen printed meeples and coins and that but that's not the component I'm concerned about okay if you're struggling to see what's on the table here then you're getting the gist because I have a problem with games like tiny epic series and all that lot for similar reasons when you take a game that should be bigger and you're trying to make it too small this box is not

particularly big compared to a lot of other games and there's a lot of tiles that you're building on the board here I mean you're building a pretty big map the problem is is that everything is too damn small it you know you could play this on a small table great it doesn't matter though if I've got to constantly squint this close in order to be able to see what I'm doing and you know if there wasn't a huge amount of detail on the tiles it wouldn't be too bad but there is artwork Galore which is nice it's very nice artwork but I've got to see you know the costs I've got to see the um the rewards I've got to tell of its victory points or money I've got to be able to see path connectors and get this right you join up these tiles by these various connectors right there's like spots on the edge of the tile in order to do it they are represented by literally a very tiny green patch like a tiny little green circle that's basically built into the terrain right yeah have fun spotting those on a tiny diamond tile that is entirely Forest they blend in like crazy and even on my other towels they just blend in too much there's too much green everywhere for you to be able to spot small green notches on the edge of a tail but in even on that front everything is too small because you're trying to obviously see right hang on if I've got to get from this one to this one over here so I need to go through there there oh that doesn't join that's a mountain ah where's the path so the path goes there when I need to go there hang on oh wait a minute ah I can't tell no sorry that's a mountain uh I know do I need to build a towel first where's that going to go trying to plan the route in this game

causes a chronic amount of AP and a chronic amount of turn callbacks what was the word Kickbacks or whatever you know where you have to basically go oh hang on I can't actually do that can I retract my term please all because it's too tiny Hamlet overall is a decent game but It suffers greatly from some bizarre choices with regards to its graphic design and components I like the logistics part of this game I like the fact that it's a communal map and the fact that it builds differently every game that is cool what I don't like you know with the solo mode is the whole reorganizing the priority tiles about 50 trillion times every game but I also just don't like the fact that everything is condensed down so small that this might as well be called tiny epic Hamlet that's essentially I swear the nickname that's going to be given to this the fact that you really are only going to play this for two players and you are going to have to really look down closely and focus on very small artwork and green notches it just hurts it for me but I do see that there's a market for this game if you if you are I mean I've got 20 20 Vision if you've got Sumo Vision then fantastic and you've got a small table and you just want a two-player head-to-head experience like that with the solo mode I suppose bolted on top as well you'll get a decent amount for your money don't worry about getting a Founder's deluxe edition though I mean you don't need metal coins you don't need screen printed meeples just wait for it to come out and Retail and it'll be cheaper you know don't try to find inflated eBay prices for this all right but for me it just doesn't it won't work for the setting that I'm in and so Hamlet For Me overall is getting

it's getting a six out of ten for me it's an above average game but for me especially with three and four players it's hurt by these choices that are made for how the game looks now I dare say you could actually give this a 7 out of 10 with a seal of endorsement for two players and I will stress that as a two-player game I think this game can work for people but if it's three and four players you're after and a big table that you're playing on you're gonna have problems trust me on this so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see please thumb it up on YouTube and on Board Game Geek leave some comments down below what are your thoughts on this game what are your thoughts on the founders Edition the normal Edition what your thoughts on the whole graphic design and the Zumo tiny epic Hamlet feel I'd be interested to know what you have to say until next time check out more content on the channel including the recent top 10 list I did for two player casual games that you can play both as a couple or otherwise take care and remember as always it's only a game regardless of whether you can see it or not bye for now

Progress saved