Cascadia Review - I Was Wrong
Transcript
today i want to tell you about a game that i was expecting to hate i thought it would be a culmination of all the things about modern gaming that drive me crazy but it turned out i was wrong it's called cascadia the last few months i've been making better videos more often and a lot of you have noticed and the reason for that is because i've been working with a talented guy called bart to help me make my videos and i'm currently raising funds so that i can pay for his work on a regular basis if you want to see more videos like this one please guarantee that by becoming a patron of the channel at patreon.com forward slash actually the trend that i hate the most in modern board games is the growth of the personal area it used to be that a game was played here but now most new games are played here here is shared it's the landscape we're all building together in carcassonne here is mine it's the landscape i'm building on my own here i'm competing against my friends i care what they're doing because it affects me here i'm alone i compete against the game my friends are in the room but i won't need them until we compare points in an hour if i was feeling glib i would call this multiplayer solitaire this is multiplayer solitaire so cool because it
feels like you're all playing your own game at the same table and no it's never 100 true most games try to give you a reason to care about what the other players are doing if they're taking the tiles you want or completing a goal faster than you but the majority of the time you're looking here not here you're thinking about you not them i play board games because it has a social hobby if i wanted to complete a personal puzzle i could play one on my phone in bed i've invited my friends over slaved over a hot pizza order and finally got dressed to play with them not alongside them in this last year and a half has taught me the deep need for social activity so if a game dares to put me back here on my own in lockdown at my gaming table i will lose my that's the bias i was going into cascadia with but i might have gotten my high horse a little too soon let me tell you about this wonderful game in cascadia you each build your own personal area of the pacific northwest by adding habitat tiles to expand your lands and putting animals in those habitats to live there it has all these magnificent wild creatures like elk and hawks and bears and then it has foxes which are about as exotic as rats and they're shy when you try and take a photo of them on the street but they're not so shy when they're waking up your
neighborhood with their sex noises at 4am on your turn you always take one of the pairs one tile and one animal and the habitat tile can go wherever you want but ideally you want to expand regions of matching terrain because you'll score points for your biggest habitat of each type at the end of the game whereas the animal token can only be placed on a habitat tile that has its icon the main goal of cascadia is to place animals in certain patterns to score points in each game you have a card for each animal telling you how it will score so in this game you'll get 10 points for clusters of three bears the next game you'll need the bears in pairs instead it means that every time you decide where to put a habitat tile you're actually planning ahead by putting it somewhere where it might help you create a long salmon run for example there's something satisfying about that every turn you not only get to build for the future but you can also finish off something you planned earlier satisfying that's the word that best describes cascadia and all my favorite puzzle games when you slot something in that fits perfectly you feel so pleased with yourself it's like drawing something exactly how it looked in your head i imagine i've never actually done that and it's a strategy that's easy to keep track of because those habitat tiles are the outline of the drawing you've already made and you're now just
following on tracing paper but that doesn't mean it isn't tough every turn you've got to decide which pair to take and you always have to compromise your plans somehow do you take the habitat tile that perfectly extends your huge forest sure but it doesn't have an elk icon on it so it ruins your perfect elk ring that you were planning or do you take the salmon token because it will get you so many points to finish that run but that comes with an annoying fox habitat tyre which you don't have a use for it's a brilliant system because you always get one thing you want and then you're lumbered with something annoying it's like inviting your friend out to play and they bring their little brother with them but if you're clever you can find a way to use the annoying thing to your advantage the key to cascadia is to not get your heart set on anything it will come to your turn and there won't be any salmon again that's your cue to pivot most habitats can take more than one type of animal so you ditch your plans for a salmon run and stick bears down there instead and i love that about this game you never feel out of option there's always something new to try it helps that you're not constricted by a board or a fixed shape so you can expand in any direction one of the reasons i was so apprehensive of cascadia was because i've played calico a puzzle game from the same design collaborative and publisher as cascadia and they look and sound a lot alike i found calico infuriating because
you're playing on a fixed board and if you can't get the tiles you want you feel like the game is ruined puzzle games like that can make you feel stupid like everything you do is a mistake and then there are others that make you feel like you can achieve anything you won't of course but there's a feeling of possibility cascadia is on that end of the spectrum and that comes from that ability to pivot and change plans nine times out of ten if i put a token down it won't ruin everything i can work around it later and knowing that is freeing it means you don't have to stress out over every turn which makes the game go quicker and makes it more social despite my rant earlier this isn't the first multiplayer solitaire game i like role and right games like on tour and avenue have no player interaction and tetris puzzle games like spring meadow are very focused on your personal area and all of those share something with cascadia the puzzle is really satisfying and addictive but they're not so brain burning that it requires all of my attention there will be many people watching this thinking multiplayer solitaire games can be social because you can just chat between your turns but in my experience when a puzzle is so demanding that i get analysis paralysis i have to focus if i want to succeed so with a game like calico i have to decide between being social or doing well in
the game it's the same reason i don't play heavy euro games i'd rather fully commit to a light game then half commit to a heavy one thankfully cascadia doesn't force me to make that choice but it's not the only reason to like it at a time when the average new game has too many bits rules and faff there's a refreshing simplicity to cascadia setting up the game is a dream get this you have to take the tiles out of the box and pick a scoring card for each animal that's it it's details like that which make you more likely to play a game because you don't dread taking off the shelf and it's a dream to teach because it's also bleedingly obvious to understand there's a minimalism to the rules every rule has a meaningful impact on the game every component too there is only one other component you don't know about yet these nature tokens you can spend one to break the rule of having to pick a pair instead you can now take any tile in any animal it's so useful and so potent it gives you the same buzz you'd get on non-uniform day at school yes you're a punk but you've had to pay 50p to be a pun the way you get a nature token is by placing an animal onto a tile where only it can go which is a really nice reward because by taking that tile you were closing off your options you can also use a nature token to clear out the animals and redraw if you're desperately waiting for a specific one
but don't do it too often because they're worth a point per token and the last perfectly judged rule is overpopulation if there are ever four animals of the same type in the display you must get rid of them and redraw and if there are three of the same type on your turn you can choose to call them which makes you feel very powerful and is especially good if your rivals wanted that animal because like any good or should that be bad multiplayer solitaire game there is a reason to care about what's happening over there in their personal areas you will be annoyed when they take the salmon you wanted you will be jealous when they complete their elk ring and the game incentivizes you to keep an eye on their boards because there's a bonus for whoever has the biggest terrain of each type and that can easily clinch the game the magic of cascadia is in the little details they might not sound like much when you read it in a rule book or hear me talk about it but when you play it they work together to deliver a game that is way more than the sum of its parts i've heard other reviewers say that it's just a collection of ideas taken from existing games yes it is and the beef berganyon that gordon ramsay makes is just a collection of ingredients taken from existing recipes but he's taken just the right ones and pulled it together in just the right way cascadia is so good it made me reassess why i don't like these types of games and the truth is i do i just hadn't
played a great one yet if you want to buy cascadia there's a link in the description below and if you're new to actual old please subscribe to get more board game recommendations if you're old to actual and you like these types of videos that we've been making these last few months please support us on patreon so we can keep making them that's at patreon.com forward slash actual i'm john perkis thanks for watching you