Russian Railroads Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'll be taking a look at russian railroads now you can see here this is the ultimate railroad box which is essentially russian railroads with all the expansion content but for this video i'll only be looking at the original russian railroads which came out back in 2013 it accommodates two to four players and takes around 90 to 120 minutes to play before i get into my video i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor and the place where i actually bought ultimate railroads from dot co dot uk you're a great online retailer here in the uk and if you um check out my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but let's get started on the video okay so russian railroads is a very high scoring worker placement game um and this is what the main board is going to look like and as you'd expect you have a bunch of different worker placement spots you can go to so you can see here if i place two workers on this spot then i get to move this piece um three times up my personal board which we'll touch on shortly and now most of these spots here are fixed however you do have these kind of modular tiles here which act as a countdown timer to the end of the game and depending on the player count that is going to change so you can see here in a three player game you're gonna start with six workers but you play six rounds in a four player game you start with five workers but you play seven rounds you're also going to have these bonus cards which you can potentially unlock as the game goes on and you're also going to have a ton of these train tiles and which are going to get added onto your personal player board and are a big part of the game and these actually have two functions so you've got the train
function on one side and you have this kind of factory function on the other side which again is a pivotal part of the experience and you also have some end game scoring cards here that you could unlock as the game develops and also these ideas tokens where every player is going to have the same formation and again these can potentially be unlocked as the game goes on to give you some pretty strong boons but more importantly each player is going to have their own personal player board that look like this and these player balls are made up of three different railways the first one being the trans siberian then you've got the moscow to st petersburg and then you've got the moscow to kiev line and the general premise of this game is you want to be sliding up these railway tracks as far as you can up these to get more and more points as the game goes on but i'll touch a bit more on this later because it's quite a unique mechanism the way this works and at the bottom of this play board you're gonna have this little industry track you can climb up as well to generate more points and bonuses so let's talk in more detail how the scoring actually works in relation to these railways so you can see here that a bunch of the worker placement spots are simply to move up those train pieces up a track so you can see here if i place one worker i can move two um of these wooden pieces up the track in any form i want so i can move say two up the same one like this or i could split them one on one uh like so it's absolutely your choice and the way this works is quite interesting because you can see here that the first piece is worth zero points for each one i climb up um and as the game goes on and i reach these different checkpoints like i've reached this green one here
then i will unlock my next piece and kind of start them at the beginning of the row meaning that when i go to this worker placement spot then i can start moving my green one up and then for each green spot i move up i'm going to start gaining one point each and the same applies to all the different ones so just as an example here you can see that this place is going to score nothing then this one and this one is going to score one point because these points stop when it hits the next type of train track so it's gonna be one point one point and it's gonna be two points and two points because you can see here that the red piece or the bronzy piece gets two points and per spot you've moved up and again they stop where the next one begins however you do not score anything until you have a train covering those spots so you're always going to start with a basic one train here on the trans-siberian line which means that your first spot is going to be covered but as the game goes on you can end up acquiring these additional trains which you're going to need in order to score things in the first place you can see here i've got the 5 plus this one piece then i'm actually covered up to six meaning that anything six or below is eligible for scoring so you really need to balance the two you know climbing up the tracks as well as as well as having these trains to cover each spot on those tracks now the trans siberian line is the only one that can cater to two different trains and the other two lines can only have one and you can also see here that some of these unlock spots require certain prerequisites so you can see here that this one needs to have this um this train track to this spot as well as being covered by a train which
it is at the moment it's got five plus one again i'm going to be covered all the way up to here and i've got my red piece here which means i can unlock my next worker and some of these spots do require um have been covered by trains and some of them don't like to unlock your next train pieces you do not need the little train symbol there so again you can unlock them without having to worry about it being covered by a train and however most of them do so we've talked about these ones here getting you the train tracks you can get your new worker these ones here let you take one of these bonus tiles which are great um and we'll talk about what they do a bit later and you can even get ones here where if you get this piece up here you could double your points from the train track or this one here lets you get these little kind of accumulating points as you climb so let's talk about all the different worker placement spots on the main board so all these pretty much work in the same way and again when you place a worker on that spot you can move the corresponding track um up your personal playbook however you've got to bear in mind that say you're um it's kind of stuck or trapped in between or behind another one you cannot move that color further so you need to kind of make way to move your better tracks up so you can't just again overlap another one so again these are all the different ones either move three spaces by placing two workers or two spaces by placing one worker and these cannot be shared by other people however there is a spot down here where anybody can go to any amount of times where you can move your wooden piece or your green piece you've also got one here where if you place a worker and a coin you can move up any two um pieces of train or train track and something i should
mention as well is if you run out of workers or if you want to use them you can actually just spend gold coins or your your money in order to take worker placement spots so you can see here that this workplace has fought here requires one worker i could simply put a coin on it rather than placing a worker on it you can also choose to bid to take the first or second player marker and turn order is very um you know important in this game because you want to be making sure you're grabbing the best worker placement spots and you've also got these spots over here such as gaining new trains or the new factories now when you go to those spots you can have three different options you can play one worker and get either if that spots taken you can place two worker and get either or you can place three workers and get one of each now when you do that action you are going to take the lowest available train and um either place it on your board as a train like so again which is a big part of the scoring because now i'm going to be covered up to the second spot or you can flip it over and use it as a factory and plug it into the bottom of your board here which means that you can now climb up this track without any obstacles and potentially get this bonus when you cross it these next spots here correspond to that kind of industry track and where you can climb up once twice or once and move a train piece once again normally moving up this little spanner piece as you go and generating a points engine whenever you cross these spots here then you will get the reward on it like you can see here the first one is to gain a factory or a train and you've got the final few spots here such
as getting these multiplier markers these times twos where you're gonna take one you're gonna put it on your little trans-siberian line here which means that any um any time this spot scores as in you know at the moment being this red on the bronzy piece um it's gonna just called double so that's going to be worth four points you can put these as far as you want up all the way up to the end of the track to get those huge scoring multipliers um and additionally you can get two money by placing a worker all this one here lets you sacrifice a worker in order to get two more also every round there's going to be these temporary spots where you can place a worker and get these bonuses which are normally just an improved version of the existing ones such as gaining a times two marker and getting five victory points so just an improvement on that one there or this one here where you can you can climb up that industry track and gain three victory points and you can also see that there's one here that's always going to cost a coin to buy and when you go to this spot you're going to take this tile and it's going to be a new unique workplace spot that only you can use and these again are normally really good and they're just like these ones here however in the previous round they were available to everybody but once somebody buys them then they're only going to be available to you and additionally at the end of the game whoever's got the most of these tiles is going to get 40 points and second most 20 points and anyone else other than that is going to get nothing so once everybody has exhausted all their worker or spent the additional money and when it comes to your turn you are going to flip over your car depending on the player order you're in so let's say i was the first player i'll flip over my card and get no additional
points however as the um different player order goes on um if you're later in turn order and you pass you end up gaining more and more victory points so this is actually quite an advantage at some times to be later in the turn order and again once everybody's done you're going to go through the scoring method which is to calculate the score on each of your tracks and also score the points for your industry track um and obviously add that on to your score tally and at the end of six rounds and the play with the most victory points will be the winner so let's take a closer look at the personal player boards we've already covered unlocking the new track pieces but you can see here you can unlock new workers um to deploy and you can also see here that at some point you can reach these idea tokens which are extremely powerful which lets you use one of these um bonus markers and everyone's going to start with the same little formation here and where you can place a new spanner on your industry track there to basically score that track twice if you manage to push them both up and even get these bonuses twice if you hit that spot you can take these idea cards or end game scoring cards and these are all really powerful such as just getting you like uh the total value of all your your four highest trains to get this really good amount of points there if you build towards that or even taking these bonus cards and which will kind of give you like a level nine train or take a um take a factory and move twice on that track um you can get a special wooden worker where if you place that um on a spot that lets you move your wooden piece you can move it in additional space you can get your own little personal helper here which let you move move any two tracks which is a really powerful one or this one here
that gets you a times two token a placement up the um the industry track and to move one of your wooden pieces the other ones let you move any four train tracks um you can upgrade your scoring um tile here so that you can score more points for all the different varieties of train track that you move i get four four coins i've got two of these key actions and these key actions are really good and not only do you get them from these tiles but you can also get them by reaching the end of each of these tracks and they can either let you move a wooden piece and one of your choice or just get a 10 point swing there additionally you can place this this token here which is one of my favorite ones where you place it on your um kiev line down here and when you reach that spot you get an additional 20 points and so that's a really good strategy to go for you can get four times two markers or even just move five spaces up the industry track okay so let's get to my thoughts on russian railroads which i have to say is definitely one of those games that leave you feeling very satisfied because at the end of the first round you've not really done much you're getting a few points here and a few points there by the end of the second round you might be getting say 20 points then by the third round you're getting 50 points per turn so it really does have that really cool like crescendo and game arc which makes you feel like you're achieving things and getting better and better as the game develops additionally i really love the way that all the different factors of the game synergize with each other and you have to spin a lot of plates in order to get what you want done like for example you need to get the trains to make sure that you're covering up the train spots which you've actually moved up in the first place because you can invest all
the time in the world to um to push these things up but again if you're not covered by training they're going to be worth absolutely nothing at the same time you want to be spending time to get these double tokens because that's going to massively increase your output when it comes to scoring at that particular railway you need to invest time in basically a dud movement just to move this one up to get it out the way so you can create more space for the other ones you want to be unlocking the workers along the way you want to be hitting these ideas tokens because they are really powerful if used at the right time and you want to be making sure you're unlocking as many of those as possible and additionally you might want to sacrifice thing in order to do another one because if you get this spot up here then you can end up doubling this railway line or even this one here which just gives you a really easy way to generate a little points engine especially if you unlock one of these tokens beforehand so lots of different things you can do here and just a ton of different ways to gain points i also love the way these factories work with this industry board because you know they just offer a great amount of points just by pushing this along the track however i do like the way that you have these obstacles along the way and you have to go to that factory spot in order to get a new one onto your player board um because if you don't do so you're going to hit again i hit that dead end and not be able to go any further and however you're only able to take the lowest value train um as you go and that like that bonus there might not be the one that you're looking for the main board itself is also fantastically weighted because it might look initially like there's a ton of spots here to go to you're always going to have a contingency and be able to take a good alternative however they do very quickly get swallowed up by the other players particularly if you want
the same thing of course there's only one option here to move the three spots with the two workers and before you know it they're going to get gobbled up especially earlier in the game and because everyone wants to be moving their wooden pieces up and that's what makes town order so so important because you might want to sacrifice your turn of course there will be other people um here um in order to secure first place next round however there is that kind of double edged sword there where going first is great because you've got to secure the spot you want however if you go later in the game when it comes to passing you're going to get a lot more points i really appreciate how different the scoring mechanism in this game is you know the idea of climbing up these different tracks but the kind of tokens on those tracks vary in quality as the game goes on which will unlock you bigger and bigger scoring i think that's fantastic and i love seeing new things um yeah this game is nine years old but it's completely new to me um and this is kind of one of those things where you know this is like the selling point of the game there's a ton of work and placement games out there but this is what really does differentiate it from a lot of the other ones and it might take an extra minute or two to explain it to other players how it works not like it's complex but because it is so different to anything else but that does almost tie in to my maybe well i'll say criticism it's more of an observation that because of the nature of the scoring here of always building upon your previous engine i'm kind of getting bigger and bigger it's quite difficult to make ground up if you do end up falling behind another player earlier in the game especially if you know that player is not likely to make many mistakes now it is doable
through some very clever you know efficient play but again because everybody is always kind of compounding on their previous income then squeezing that um gap between you does become quite a difficult task to overcome i love the way that the game gives you a ton of options to mull over and that all of them feel good it's not like well i have to take this action otherwise i'm going to get stuck with a bad action it's like no i want to take this amazing action but if i don't i'll probably get this other good action um and i just love the way that feels you know you really want to climb this track i really need to move my my pieces up my own my own railways i want to get these new personal worker placement spots because they're fantastic and nobody else is going to be able to use them and so yes so many different things that you need to consider here but you don't want to spread yourself too thin and you probably want to go down one or two of these different pathways to get maximum points for doing so so from a standpoint of the mechanisms and the meaningful decisions you make throughout the game there really isn't anything i can criticize here it works like clockwork i'm just a very finely tuned designer and with the only observation that if you do fall behind somebody it is difficult to make up that ground and that also ties into the balancing of the game um i haven't played this a ton of times of course i know there's people who've played this probably hundreds of times but from my brief experience with the game it does feel like all the different paths you can take are viable paths to victory it doesn't feel like there's one that you should neglect and one that's you know overtly worse than the others which i think is a great i love it when i have confidence in design that you can try something different each time and still have a good chance of winning i think considering the depth of
gameplay here that the time it takes is actually really good i know you are looking around 90 minutes to play maybe slightly more than that with that fourth player count um but i think the game is actually very easy to teach apart from maybe again taking an extra minute or two of care to explain how this personal board works and but other than that everything is very intuitive i do feel like the replayability with russian railroads is decent um you've got different modular kind of characters that come out each time you can go for different bonuses and just the way that the trains come out and different things like that are going to change your experience game after game but i do love the fact that if you want to you can start injecting all that additional material into it which from my brief reading of the rules doesn't seem like it changes the gameplay too much but it does just kind of play with the order of these player balls each time just to give you some variation there to make sure you're not always going to do the same thing the game also appears to scale really well of course there are some minor rules here changes here when you do play that three or four player account but on the reverse side of the board you do have a two player map um which closes off some of the spaces to keep it tighter and i have only played this at two and three players at the moment and at both of those play accounts it plays exceptionally well and i don't even think i have a preference over the other and i'm also really happy with the production of of this version i've not played the original russian railroad again this is the ultimate railroad version but it does have this kind of simple euro feel to it um it's not overdone you've got your traditional meeples um the card quality is more than adequate nice and strong tiles there and
they're gonna hold up really well um all the cards and things are fine i mean they are linen and finished cards not like you need to handle them too much everything fits on the board nicely not too big not too small and just generally i know average pieces as you'd expect with a game of this type so yeah no issues at all with the production okay so let's get into my final thoughts on russian railroad so i'm certainly at a point now where worker placement games have to be something special for me to you know really get engaged with it and this one certainly is that i was completely enamored with this design which is strange because on the facebook this part of the game itself the worker placement part is very simple all the spots are very straightforward and what they do just move the pieces along get this or get that and however the kind of tenseness to grab these spots is absolutely huge um additionally i love the different scoring methods and things you can go down i know am i going to do this am i going to do that am i going to get my best pieces on here and get those huge multipliers do i need a train right now to make sure i'm doing that am i going to be pushing my industry board here maybe i'm going to get that bonus token to get two things on my industry board to get a whole bunch of points that way i want the best factories um something i didn't mention is that if you replace certain trains on your board here because you can't upgrade them they go back into the factory pool which leaves it open to other people to take and they might really want that type of factory so yeah everything here has a huge kind of ramifications to the choices you're making uh the satisfying turns you get is just huge gives you all those dopamine hits especially when it comes
to scoring at the end of the round where you can really see how you are building a foundation of getting more and more points as you go and every single turn just feels great um an immensely deep experience for only six rounds and you're looking at an hour and a half to play this one which i think is spot on for me and in fact i think i wouldn't even be surprised if this was say a two-hour game in length i would still feel very content to bring this one out to the table because the gameplay really does warrant it so yeah extremely impressed with russian railroads and for a rare exception i'm actually completely like excited to try the additional material for right now as of recent years i've kind of got turned off the whole expansion uh model you know always wanting to upgrade stuff or add new um material into your games but this one i think if it stays true to this simple mechanism which i think it does and just plays around with the boards a bit then i'm really excited to see what the game has to offer uh but in his own right know just the russian robots in in isolation is truly an outstanding um worker placement game i could not recommend enough so those are my final thoughts on ultimate railroads strong strong recommendation for me and a worthy earner of my elite shield which is my highest commendation a game can get just very happy to have this one in my collection