Skip to main content
Loading video...

Aron West takes me through the Catacombs Monster Pit - TCbH Interview

Transcript 24:35

aaron west welcome back to the cardboard herald we're talking on the precipice of the catacombs monster pit kickstarter you have got to be excited man this represents a lot this is what the 10th anniversary of catacombs that's happening now yeah that's right yep 10 years that uh i've been publishing board games so yeah it's uh it's an event 10 years on this unexpected journey like what was your life trajectory beforehand before you got together with your friends you came out with this surprise hit beast this dexterity dungeon delve catacombs i mean i gotta imagine in some ways it kind of took your life in a different direction than you may have expected oh yeah it sure did i mean i was doing software development and we still treat a lot of our development process you know i mean having techniques being influenced by that background but uh yeah eventually the the board game and the various kickstarter campaigns crowded out that part of my life you got all these catacombs games coming out you've just released catacombs cubes which was still within the same universe but quite the divergence kind of opening up the the dimension of what catacombs represents and kind of the possibility space going forward but we're here to talk about monster pit so what is this game this is like a standalone game it's got two different modes and it's also compatible with catacombs third edition proper so why don't you give me kind of the the like overview pitch of what this is

so a monster pit you're defending a town first of all okay and that's a fully cooperative game and you can play that solo and then you flip the play mat over the kickstarter version includes a play mat and then you go underground into the monster pit itself to continue the confrontation with that catacomb lord and hopefully emerge victorious first off i love the concept of like bisecting a game and having two halves and they can be played independently right like if you wanted to you could just have an evening where you're playing the dice game and then an evening where you're playing the the 1v all monster pit arena whatever madness that is yeah that's right you could do that i mean the games are probably compact enough that you could play them as intended you know from one half uh to the other i mean really the the town defense game if you want to call it that um it really mirrors the um the part in catacombs three where you're track trekking through the various rooms to ultimately reach the catacomb lord's lair and then the the dexterity mode on the other side of the playmat is a full-on competitive experience we're using our dexterity game system of course and some of the mechanics that we're introducing there are different from uh 3e but the heroes that

you're playing as are fully compatible and are there persistent elements i carry over from one side to another like i'm thinking of actually one of my favorite games that doesn't get enough love is hunt for the ring which was a hidden movement game that's kind of like a spin-off of war of the ring but it was one of the first games i played where it kind of bisects into these two different modes there's familiarity between them but the the kind of cool element is the outcome of the initial mode will affect the standing of both sides when you go into the second mode so is there some of that here is it just you know if the heroes lose then you start all over again or no matter what is there going to be continuity and it just kind of affects some of the statuses or maybe certain metrics as you proceed into the second mode yeah that's right i mean obviously people are free to role play a bit as to how they want um it to proceed but there will be rules that are that affect the continuity uh between the uh the the two modes you know like you said like you know affecting some of the stats and things like that and certainly there is continuity with respect to the catacomb lord that first initially menaced the town you're gonna be fighting that same catacomb lord again but of course this time instead of it being on your turf for the town it's on his turf underground so as far as dexterity games go at this point you have going parallel catacomb start

edition you have catacombs and castles you have catacombs conquest the real small box game that's driven by a card based system and at this point you are now introducing yet another catacombs dexterity game that's being played independently of third edition the the core thing and while these have ways of integrating with that kind of core master set these really are independent and parallel games do you ever worry about brand confusion as you're coming out with yet another catacombs release well i think that's always a risk but you know at the same time this uh i'm confident that this version is is is different enough from what we've done uh before it really allows us to go back and examine some of the early choices that we made that it that still informed a number of the decisions in catacombs 3e and we don't necessarily have those same constraints in monster pit but at the same time we kind of go full circle because the catacomb lords that you play in monster pit with the dexterity game and also in the town defense game as well they have those nice big player boards that uh we used to use right in fact i've got one right here you can see this is uh you know a first edition player board i love it and you've got all your rules on it and all that sort of thing

and then in we kept that um in catacombs 3e but of course a lot of that information translated onto cards for maximum reuse but the the catacomb lords in monster pit have their own dedicated player board just like uh first and second edition and the the the tracking board is separate so you actually have like a pretty big dashboard in front of you when you're playing as the overseer and of course the heroes have their player boards as well because they will have one player board on one side for the town defense game if you like and then you flip that over and they have their cards slots for you know for their heroes and upgrades and things of that nature for the dexterity game well you just showed off some of the the first edition catacombs playmats and that had that original to me iconic artwork like what i love about it is it has this really gothic semi-realistic presence especially compared to what catacombs is looking like these days which of course having quanchi amoria do the the the artwork for third edition that was a big part of the the breakthrough into the mainstream with catacombs and i wouldn't have it any other way i love how catacombs looks but that old art

style i i feel like somehow that that's indicative to the the original heart and intent and tone of catacombs and as you reflect on the last 10 years and kind of thinking about the future 10 years you know do you see space for elsa to kind of explore kind of different tones than what established catacombs colorful cartoony fun cutesy look represents right now well actually that's a great point because monster pit does attempt to go back to some of that dark gothic type style the kickstarter version of the box is very much this color theme of black and red which harks back to the original box cover of first and second edition which had a very black brick like texture with this red ring and the catacombs logo and that is you know like a coming full circle um on the the monster pit box and it the tone of monster pit is uh is is definitely darker um the the characters are darker the overall presentation is darker because i really want to convey that this adventure into the monster pit is not necessarily gonna be easy for the heroes um you know this isn't your bright pastel dungeon crawl necessarily it's uh

you know you're you're going into this uh environment um it's uh it's dark it's cold it probably doesn't smell very good and you've got a you've got to deal with that and you've got to try and emerge victorious um from some of the toughest care against some of the toughest characters in the in the catacombs universe so there there is that uh desire to have that black red gothic tone uh reassert itself again even right here in the present in monster pit so if you're expecting um you know the the sort of cotton candy trees or whatever uh this this game will not necessarily have as much of that it's definitely going to have a more serious dark tone to it but of course rendered in that uh you know lovely quantity moria art style one of the things that you mentioned earlier is that the dice portion of monster pit is going to be solo which is great to hear or it can be played solo and that was one of the things that really excited me about uh catacombs cubes is that it makes for a really good solo game like i love playing multiplayer but if you got it play it solo like it's got a pretty interesting solo mode in there but as we're thinking about quarantine right now and the kind of explosion of interest in solo games

have you given a lot of thought to developing a catacombs dexterity game like true to third edition dexterity game that kind of cracks that nut of how do you make a solo dexterity joint well i think uh part of that experiment will be informed by our work on phantom division okay of course yeah venom division you will be able to play it solo and once we've put that system into a market tested product you know i've already discussed this with the designers there's very much the potential to take elements of the phantom division system and bring it over to a catacombs 3e solo implementation so that's that uh i will be working on because i think it's important to have that solo story especially during these times yeah i think a lot of people are going to be excited about that and it's a hard thing to address but if you are able to to create that system where it feels compelling to play even if there's like static obstacles that you're fighting against i i think that it could be really something special now with with monster pit you know i know that you've been kicking around some ideas for a long time for this project and you're

someone who takes a ton of feedback from users like i see you addressing stuff all the time on bgg i see you at conventions taking questions and you know consulting people about what they think about various aspects of uh the the games that you already have out what they'd like to see in the future and i'm wondering like what what is the story for catacombs monster pit and its current incarnation like is this something that was entirely developed in-house how did this come about it developed in-house in what sense in terms of the mechanics of the story well i i'm thinking about like the the mechanics of the game the game design is this something that uh was originally born out of you as the designer of catacombs third edition and many of your games since is this something where you reached out to someone else are the two halves of the game designed independently like what's the evolution of this up until this point well it has obviously gone through some evolutionary iterations and there has been some design input from some other uh actors as well let's say um but the the holistic uh result that we have um you know was curated by myself and i'm very pleased with how it's it's turned out and i'm hoping that

uh you know people enjoy getting it to the table what is like the killer moment for you like the thing that's most satisfying in playing that because i know you're a gamer i know you have a huge history of just like playing and observing different games you and i have talked about various uh games that you've really latched on to and also seen as like you know springboard points where you might even attempt to to iterate on in the the future but like when you were playing monster pit what's the moment where you're like yeah this is so damn cool that i'm doing this right now well i think it's uh you know really the opportunity to take the the exploration of our catacombs world to a whole new location this is a new a new city a new environment it's actually a walled citadel and then of course there's this um cavernous environment below it where all kinds of uh nefarious belligerent creatures are you know waiting to emerge so just even the the simple elaboration of that story and seeing that theme come out in the in the play mechanics is uh very exciting because you do get the sense in the game that you are protecting the citadel um it's not a traditional tower defense game or anything like that

but you're that you're first charged with protect the citadel and then um you're into the the the dexterity side and you know to really feel like it the game is building towards that that crescendo of that you know let's go and finish this thing and and get it uh and get it done that almost sounds like the story arc of the game development and the ultimate kickstarter and you know resulting delivery of it too that crescendo there which is actually something i wanted to ask you about and maybe that's a good way to kind of end this is i i've known you several years at this point you know we've met at conventions i've witnessed kind of the the evolution to some of your approaches for your kickstarters i've seen you lead several successful kickstarters and you know make sure that those products get delivered you're very customer focused but i know one thing that gets talked about a lot within the hobby is you know what are the these established companies utilizing kickstarter for like you know leave that for the the people who are you know just dreaming of making a game what is eldra doing kickstarting this next game because surely at this point you've had enough kickstarters that you could totally fund this yourself and this is just a pre-order service right you know that that may be the perception of people so like from your perspective

why why should you still use crowdfunding as an established veteran company that has been making products for 10 years well i think there's a couple of answers to that you know one is is that we may be a veteran company but we have a very very niche type of game dexterity games which we primarily publish at the moment are a niche and that's what we're trying to do with monster pit like what we did with cubes is diversify that audience if you're if you don't like dexterity games you would be able to buy the standard version of monster pit and enjoy the citadel defense the town defense element of the game and have some fun with it and not even necessarily worry about the dexterity part if you really viscerally didn't even want to get into that and of course that also implies that you can play and just back for that standard version just um you know as a solo player and you're not playing paying for all those extra elements and so but to answer your question further about the the crowdfunding situation this is not a pre-order uh we do need your help to make this uh this is an ambitious project because we would also like to reprint the second edition of catacombs and castles

okay so that is going to be available as part of this campaign okay and it's always easier when you can push everything through at one time at least we find it easier so we're looking to get um catacombs and castles back into print and also as a complimentary product reissue um or you know well i shouldn't say reissue but we're going to issue monster bit too so it's uh it we really do need people's help and support the retail market right now has been heavily impacted by the economic lockdowns and the global pandemic situation so retail stores are not necessarily able to operate according uh you know maybe how they would like because they're subject to these public health regulations and as a result they may be less inclined to take a risk on product or inventory that may sit there okay so you know if you think about it if you're a retail store might just be easier to order another few cartons of wingspan um than bother with trying to research and stay on top of all the new product coming out in the hobby

and the same goes for license games it's just easier to bring in a licensed title um that's maybe gotten some good press and sell that rather than trying to bring in and keep up with all the the new product that's it's being released so the direct sales model is very important and kickstarter is one of those channels like of course we have shop.elsewhere.com for uh us and international customers we have shop.elsewhere.ca for canadian customers specifically but kickstarter does have that interactive platform and that place where we can set up our temporary catacomb if you like have the community there host the community and get their opinion about what they like what they don't like we can't make necessarily wholesale changes but to your point earlier i do listen to what people say and if there's something a good idea for example that emerges and we can implement it without uh detrimentally affecting the the the budget and the timelines and things of that nature then i would look to do it and certainly this time around with the stretch goals i'm i'm looking forward to hearing uh some more feedback from our players because a lot of what was in our icebox expansion for catacombs 3e came from the community

people submitted suggestions i vetted and curated those suggestions and where we could implement them we did it and i'm happy to say it was easily 50 to 60 of the stretch goals that we put out were community driven and i'm planning to do the same thing here with monster pit in fact instead of it being the ice box we're already planning for a black box going back to that whole gothic theme again that we were talking about earlier so i'm i'm interested to see what suggestions people have so as to what we can put in the black box and that'll be the stretch goals box for monster pit so i don't even know what's in it yet because i'm i'm inviting our backers to tell us what they would like to see and we will do our best to implement those suggestions that they have and of course we've got some broad ideas too that we can we can of course add some additional flavor to it etc we always have things that we can add to it but um i'm interested to see what people come up with so that's the reason so for us even though we're established we've been around the kickstarter uh block kickstarter always has new things to teach you we never take backers support for granted we always know that people can always take their virtual pledge and go just two clicks away to somebody else's campaign but we hope that you stick with us and there'll be a lot of options in this campaign to either um you know get what you may

have missed order what you've already missed or upgrade during our custom elsewhere pledge manager adding on other things that may not be of the focus of the campaign but you will be able to buy them so in cube we didn't really do that we didn't have a lot of um extra material available in the pledge manager but this one we are planning to open it up there'll be some different uh things that of course you can that you can add in the in the in the pledge manager so that's uh you know we're not we're not seamon we're just a couple of guys working hard uh trying to pay the grocery bills um you know and we we appreciate your support as we uh keep moving forward and hopefully keep making games that uh the community enjoys all right well thank you so much for coming on to the show everyone go out and check out monster pit i'm going to have links in the video description in the podcast description in order to find the kickstarter for that we'll have all the dates and information if you are watching or listening to this after the kickstarter has already happened then i'm sure there's a whole host of information uh about possible late pledges or any way that you can kind of find out more information about what is kicking around at elsewhere games aaron thanks again for coming on to the show yeah thanks jack and there will be late pledges if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if

you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved