Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arboretum is Best at 4 Players | Unpopular Opinions

Transcript 13:54

hello and welcome to another episode of unpopular opinions i'm carlo and this is our channel all you can board this series was initially started by dylan you can go check out his first episode where he talks about why he didn't really like tainted grail in today's video i'm going to be telling you why arboretum is best with four players now the reason why this falls into this unpopular opinion series is because if you look at the board game geek rankings and you check out what people recommend is the best player count it is unanimously recommended as a two-player game and if you go on reddit and you look at board game geek forums people seem to love love love this game at two players and other than dylan i don't really know anyone else or haven't come across a whole lot of people who seem to like this game at most with four but i think it by far shines best at four players it's not even comparable to the two player rank so just for context here before i get into it the board game rankings the way this works is if you vote on player count you can vote for multiple categories so these percentages are not going to add up but as of today filming this december 8th uh best with two has 52 of the votes best of three players has 40 percent of the votes and best with four players has only 33 of the votes so out of 265 total voters only 65 of those voters said it was best with four that means out of those 265 200 people do not think it's best with four players so i'm definitely in the minority here i'm going to start by breaking down and give you a very very brief overview of the game in case you haven't played it uh then i'm going to tell you what's different about it with two and four players then i'm going to tell you what are the best aspects of the game that help it shine best at the

four player count and then i will talk about a couple of minor drawbacks for things that some people could consider drawbacks at the four player account so first off what are you doing in arboretum well everyone has a hand of seven cards at the start of the game and the idea of the game is you're basically on your turn you have this common deck of cards you're drawing from you're gonna start by drawing two cards either from the deck or player's discard piles which are always face up to all players you're going to draw two cards to go up to nine then you're going to play one card in your tableau and you're going to discard a card to go back down to seven players are going to take turns going in a clockwise fashion that way drawing two cards playing one discarding one until the central deck is depleted at which point you'll go to final end game scoring so what's in the deck of cards well it's pretty basic honestly this game could have been designed years and years ago with a different theme or whatever there's nothing inherently special about it there's just a certain number of tree types i think there are 10 of them and then there's eight cards per type each ranging with a number from one through eight and you're basically going to be building out your tableau i'm not going to get into all the specifics of the rules but you're going to be building out your tableau in a way where your numbers and your tree types or colors are sort of connecting in a way that allows you to follow paths with the first and the last card in that path being the most important to be of the same type at the end of the game the way the scoring is gonna work is that you're gonna go through each type of tree for example the maples the blue spruces the willows one at a time and you're gonna for each category every player is going to reveal which cards of that type they still have in their hand so let's say we said blue spruce if this was my end of

the game i would show that i have the one and the two you're all going to compare and only the player with the total highest value like the added value of the card so in this case i would have three has the right to score for that type of tree i might not even have any blue spruce cards but by holding on to these if all the other blue spruce cards were played in front of my opponents i'm denying them so they would all score zero for blue spruce as would i so there's an element of holding on to cards until the end of the game to basically deny your opponent's points or to have the right to score points for your own tree types if you were going for that type but the more you hold on to the fewer points that are available to actually be scored in your tableaus there's a couple other things like if someone is holding an 8 in their hand and someone else is holding a one the one makes that eight a zero there's a couple other things but that's the basic idea of how you play arboretum so now i'm going to talk about what's different with it as a two player game compared to four players so depending on player count if you play with two players you're actually going to play with only a 48 card deck instead of an 80 card deck uh with three players i believe it is a 60 card deck so you're basically removing two types of trees per uh player counter sorry 64 with three players so you're going to be removing two types of trees for each player count that you reduce so with two players not only is it a smaller deck but because you only have one opponent it ends up being kind of this head to head dual type game and it just plays out a little bit differently so the game is also shorter because the smaller deck there's usually going to be fewer turns the game is usually going to be playing out a bit quicker there's

sort of less downtime that kind of thing so but it ends up becoming more much more of like a mathematical exercise it becomes a game of card counting and calculations because you know what you need to have in your hand in order to score and more of the game is open information so i'm going to get to this now when i get into my phase here where i talk about why is it better as a four player game and the three player count just for reference i would definitely say is closer to the four player game in terms of my enjoyment it's still amazing at three i think there's just a huge gap between two and three and it definitely shines best at four so what makes it amazing at four so first off the most important thing here is the end game scoring so because this as i said is a game of hand management and despite the you know beautiful inviting artwork and the you know really nice trees here it's a really brutal cutthroat game sometimes you can score zero points in this game i've done it more than once i've seen other people get zero points because you might be building out a tableau going for three or four different tree types and everyone else is holding more of that type in their hand and you just don't even get the right to score so i love that and the reason why that works better at four players in my opinion that's that's the the biggest part is because when it comes down to the final scoring so because i have three opponents in a four player game and each of them has seven cards in their hand that's a total of 21 cards that are in players hands that i don't know how they're going to affect the tree types that i have in play not only that there are 10 tree types so not only are there 10 types of trees but there's 21 cards out there how do i know who's gonna be holding what

right so let's say i have the six of a certain color in my hand and let's say i know that i haven't seen you know let's say the four the three and the seven haven't come up now if i was playing a two-player game and that happened i would know long before it even gets me at the end of the game if all i have is the six and i haven't seen a bunch of the other ones i know that single one opponent of mine is holding those cards i know i'm not gonna score in a four player game let's say one of those players had a three another player had the four and let's say the seven was in the discard pile and i kind of forgot about it my six is gonna be good enough to win but one player could actually have the three and the four which would make a seven total which would beat my six and another player could actually be holding that seven which would also beat my six so there's a lot more that's kind of up in the air the game you know has this arc with two players where the longer the game goes on the tension kind of deflates out of the game a little bit because you know your card counting along the way you know what has been out there you can see the discard piles face up as the game goes and because the game ends when the deck is depleted the only mystery left is the seven cards in your opponent's hand but you have a pretty good idea of what they're holding so before the game ends you kind of have a pretty good idea of how it's going to end what you are or aren't going to you know have the right to score on and that sort of thing so it kind of takes all the tension out of it and it kind of feels like the game fizzles a bit near the end whereas in a four player game the big end game reveal of who has what cards left who's gonna score for what who's gonna deny other players it's like punctuated by the fact that all these cards are spread out across

different players you don't know who has what who's gonna win majority who's gonna be able to score for what and i think that is just what one of the best things that works well about this game at the four player count so also because i mentioned there's more tree types you also are spread a bit more thin so instead of like in a two-player game where there's only six types of trees it's easier to commit and pick which ones you want to go for you also as the hand management aspect comes into play you don't have as many different tree types in your hand so it's easier to kind of prioritize the decisions become easier what i love about this game the beauty of this game is in the agonizing decisions it's the fact that you're always acquiring new cards and having to wait are you going to play this card for yourself to try and score are you going to hold on to these to try and score for that type or you're going to try and deny your opponent and having more types of trees gives you a wider variety of trees in your hand and on the board to play with which just makes everything tougher because you don't know what to commit to um and similarly the discard piles of four players makes it a lot more interesting as well so let's say you know the the the worst thing to do on your turn or the thing that's like sort of least enjoyable that's so agonizing is discarding a card that you know someone else needs and in a two-player game you know that if you discard that your opponent's gonna pick it up right in a four-player game let's say this player on my right is going for a certain type of trees in this case the tulip poplars i can afford to discard a tulip poplar and you know these two opponents here might say what are you doing they're just going to pick it up on their turn but that's not my problem anymore now on this player's turn the pressure's kind of on them do they want to let that sit in my discard pile until it gets around to that player so now i'm kind of forcing this player here to maybe take

it and they might think oh well it's not my problem either when it goes over to this player they're going to have to take it so there's this kind of common added pressure that goes around the table of as soon as someone discards a card everyone's kind of thinking who's going to pick that up to deny that player or are we all just going to let it go around to them so they can just pick up that card they need and again that's just completely robbed of the game in a two-player game because anything you discard that your opponent wants they're clearly just going to pick up why wouldn't they and with four players right from the very first turn of the game the tension just is ratcheted up from the very first card played let's say on the very first turn of the game i play this yellow 3 cassia card as soon as i have played it basically any other player who's holding a yellow card in their hand is not going to discard they're probably going to stubbornly hang on to that card for the rest of the game so immediately you place that card and you're looking over second guessing wondering who is trying to screw you over here who is trying to hold out and so it makes it like immediately you don't even know what to play off to start because players could be holding anything so from the very start of the game the hand management the tableau building aspect having ex these extra trees and more unknowns of what's going on out there i just love that the four player game makes you act a little bit more on your intuition and sort of looking across the table looking at people in the eyes and trying to think what do they have what are you holding this card i need are you holding this maybe maybe not kind of thing whereas in a two-player game it just becomes more of a mathematical series of calculations okay this came out this didn't come out and as the game

goes on it just feels like things get less and less interesting it does work well as a two-player game still i'm not saying it's a bad two-player game but for how amazing it is at four players i just don't see why anyone would prefer to play with two or think it's better with two um there's better two-player games out there i would highly recommend something like lost cities or battle line if you want something that has a little more of that mathematical edge a bit more of the card counting there's still some mystery and intrigue to those games um but and i think those are better two player only games i do think arboretum is better than lost cities hard to say where i rank it against battleline just in terms of the game in terms of this as four players versus battle line as a two player game but yeah as a two player game i would recommend those over arboretum any day just because of how much of the tension is removed from this when you play with two players so that's not to say that the game is perfect with four or that everything about the game is better at four with four players there's definitely more down time between turns right because after you take a turn you have to watch three other people go and so you're only taking one quarter of the turns instead of half the turns in the game fair enough the game also takes a bit longer you know there's more cards in the deck uh there's you know turns are maybe more difficult because people have more to consider so it does add to the game length i find that with four players it's usually in the 45 minute to an hour mark maybe with experienced players who aren't thinking too much about it you can get half a half an hour kind of thing and this last point isn't a fair drawback to say always applies but there is a higher chance of there being that analysis paralysis if you're playing with players who are really trying to maximize your score or calculate

everything it could really slow the game down but this also ties into the beauty of what i said about the scoring is being hidden and the calculations aren't always possible because once you've played the game enough whether it's your first play your second fifth play tenth play whatever eventually you start to realize playing with three or four players that it's just not possible to calculate everything and you start realizing i have to play sort of on my intuition i have to go off my gut feeling and just trust it and kind of go out on a whim and kind of hedge my bets on certain things and again that makes the game sing rather than falter the way it does with two players i could go on and on about why i love this game so much and especially why i love it at four but i've highlighted anything i can think of off the top my head that makes this game best at four players but i'm curious to hear if you're one of those people who likes the game best at two tell me why if you were going into this video that you liked it best at two if i've somehow changed your mind and you're willing to reconsider now or you think hey you make some good points also let me know i'm curious to hear you know if i convince anyone to change their mind or whatnot and if there's anything you think i've overlooked at why the game plays better at 2 also let me know i'm really curious to hear i often agree with the board game geek recommended player counts for most games and that's why i decided to do this video on arboretum it's a game i absolutely love one of my favorite card games small box card games of all time it's probably a 15 20 game kind of thing excellent game if you haven't played it i highly recommend you check it out and if you have tell me what player count you like it best at and why otherwise thank you so much for watching if you enjoyed this video please consider

giving it a like subscribe to our channel for more videos like this keep an eye out for our top 50 games of all time which dylan and i will be doing in the coming weeks otherwise thank you so much for watching and i'll see you next time

Progress saved