Nemesis Retaliation Review: Same Same. But Different. But Still Same.
Transcript
Hello everyone. I'm Tally. This is Barl and we're bored of it. And welcome to our review of Nemesis Retaliation, the third iteration in the Nemesis series. For one to five players, Nemesis Retaliation is less survival horror and more survival action. As now you play as heavily equipped Marines entering a facility that's infested with intruders, which are legally distinct aliens. So here in Nemesis Retaliation, the core is very similar to the previous Nemesis Nemesis where if you've played those, you can play this almost straight away.
Yeah.
But there are several gameplay changes which we think are basically all for the better. So before we get into how to play, what's changed, and what we think, please know that this was a review copy provided by the publisher.
On a high level, on your turn, you'll take two actions, which will either be moving around the facility, interacting with something, or shooting at intruders. Players spend cards in order to take these actions, either by discarding cards to take generic actions or spending cards and doing the action that's written on that card. Each player will start with two objectives, a mission objective and a personal objective. And eventually, they'll need to choose one to proceed with. And to win Nemesis, you need to complete your chosen objective and escape the facility or undergo hibernation, but also survive a final infection check. However, this is never easy as Nemesis is semi-ooperative, so some of the objectives might conflict with each other, not to mention the abundance of intruders you'll meet along the way.
Turning to what's new in Nemesis Retaliation, the big change is to combat. You now have two flavors of shooting, shooting and bursting. Now, shooting will be done when you're in a room with an intruder, and you will always do one damage, and then you'll roll a dieice to see if you've done enough damage total to kill that intruder. This doesn't cost any ammo, but when you burst, you do have to spend ammo. And here is when you're attacking intruders in an adjacent corridor to the room you're in. You'll roll a burst die, which will tell you how many hits you get. And then you will assign that to uh that many hits to the intruders in the corridor. Generally, you will do uh generally one hit will kill one intruder, but it depends on the intruder type. And it's done this way because when intruders spawn in corridors, you'll generally spawn loads at once.
Whereas when intruders spawn in a room or they move into a room, generally only one will move/spawn into a room. And it's seen that when they're in the room with you, it's a tight space. So you can't fire as wildly. Whereas in the corridor, you can go wild in terms of spending ammo and not spending ammo.
Another big update is the use of tactical tokens. These are tokens that your character holds and includes health, ammo, grenades, and oxygen. And these tokens can be spent to gain the resources printed on them. Oxygen is needed because now players must track their oxygen supply. As at the beginning of the game, the oxygen facility is contaminated, and players must find the life support rooms in each section and turn on the oxygen. If you run out of oxygen, you die. Running through some other updates, you can now secure rooms, which prevents an attack when an intruder would spawn in that room or move in. You can reinforce corridors, which essentially makes them so that they can't be rolled during a noise roll, making it safer to explore around. When you explore, you now draw an exploration card, which tells you how to set up that room, what room type, if there's any intruders, if you have to make a noise roll, what tokens are in there, and so on, and where the corridors will go. You also now have a robot that you can take advantage of where you uh will get a robot that has a different ability each game and you can utilize him if you wish. And finally, the queen now has an update to her combat where she has a unique combat system to her that you kind of need to mill through her deck to eventually beat her as the big boss. Due to the massive popularity of Nemesis and the fact that we've covered a lot of Nemesis content before, which we'll link below, we'll mainly focus on how retaliation sits in the Nemesis universe. That said, short version is that everything that was true about previous iterations of Nemesis is
also true here. It is a Marmite game. You'll either think that it's the greatest storytelling device in board gaming or a horrifically unfun board game nightmare of randomness designed to give players a miserable experience. Yeah. So, Nemesis uses randomness in every element of it to create emergent storytelling. And if you're with a group who wants to tell a story and have an experience, then very few games do it better than Nemesis. But on the flip side of that, if you are unable to get in that mindset, if you want to play Nemesis like a Euro game or a game to win to minmax, then you can easily set yourself up to have a terrible time because of all of the variables that go in to create this randomness and it's very easy for things to cascade very quickly and have sudden player elimination, things like that, which mean that you just need to be in the right mindset. The best way to describe the duality of Nemesis Retaliation is probably to just explain what happened in our second game versus our third game. So, our second game was brilliant.
We were playing cooperatively and we were kind of wandering around the facility trying to complete our mission and then there was a power surge. The auto destruct sequence started, meaning we had very limited time before the facility explodes. I ended up sacrificing myself because you can turn off the auto destruct sequence, but it also means there's no oxygen in the place and I was deep in the bowels, very far away from any oxygen. I died a horrible suffocating death, but that let Tally survive and it let me complete the mission objective for both of us. So then she sprints to go to the landing zone to escape this place. She's chased by intruders. She's firing off burst behind her. She rolls to get in the lander. Oh no. She rolls the one that makes an intruder spawn, but she draws a blank token and gets on the lander and flies away. And then she explodes cuz she was infected. And that kind of dramatic end and storytelling is what Nemesis is about. But then if you go to our third game, it was a complete opposite where it was just an exercise in frustration. So again, it was us. We essentially every single time we moved for the first five or six moves, we spawned an intruder either through exploration or just through moving, which is just really frustrating and tedious cuz then you just sit there and kind of fire shots until they die instead of doing anything interesting.
Then we had a mission task of kill the queen and she didn't appear till round 10. And then when she finally did, there was no tokens left in the bag for her at that point. So, she sat in a room, not moving, which is makes it 10 times more difficult to kill her when she's in a room. And then we also had a player kind of instak-illed in round three. Uh, and it just goes on that it was very frustrating, unfun experience because everything that went wrong did. At one point, we we wanted to get some tactical tokens. We moved in there. Then after the end of round event, we ended up with three intruders in that room and it malfunctioning. So that is kind of what Nemesis can be in either sense. Now I say this as someone who did not follow the campaign very closely, but I was actually a bit disappointed in Nemesis Retaliation in terms of how little it differs from the previous games. I just had the impression, right or wrong, that because now the setting is you have these hardened marines going in the facility, it's more combat focused, that actually the gameplay would be more different and maybe they would kind of twist on the core system or develop it and make it feel a bit more different being the third game in the series. But actually, it's 95% the same. And in one sense, in terms of being different, I would actually say it does less to push forward the system than uh Lockdown did compared to Nemesis because at least
Lockdown was a novel setting and it kind of played with these elements of light and dark and elevators and levels, whereas here it's using the same setting that Lockdown did and taking some of those layers away. Importantly, that is not to say we are dunking on Nemesis Retaliation. Actually, what has changed here in terms of gameplay is all for the better. And we would argue that if you if you don't have a Nemesis product, if you're looking to get into it for the first time, or maybe you've played a Friends and you want to get your own, this is the one to get because it's the most updated. It's the most fun to play in a sense. Uh, and that is because of these rule changes. So, one example, a very common complaint and is something we've complained about in previous videos is in the old games when you would shoot an intruder, you would have to spend an ammo, which is a very limited resource. Then you would have to roll a dieice to see if you even hit, and then you would have to draw cards to see if you've done enough damage to kill that. There was kind of these multiple levels of randomness, and you could end up spending all your ammo and doing nothing. Uh, which was very frustrating.
And here, that's gone. you'll always do a damage when you shoot or you burst. And what it means is that the game is much more fun and it's much more swashbuckling. The fact that there are two different types of combat, it makes things more interesting. And it also does this without losing any of the tension because you have so many that spawn in adjacent corridors. And the fact that there's a one in five chance of every time you move, you're going to spawn an intruder in your room. Similarly, the ability to add secure tokens to rooms to prevent attacks and being able to reinforce corridors to make it safer to move are great mechanisms because it gives players more control over their environment and allows them to be a bit more preemptive rather than only reactive. However, that's not to say that retaliation is any easier considering the hordes that occupy the corridors, but at least it does give you the illusion of control and it does make it feel better to play.
Just to run through a few more small changes we really like. The robot is a really fun addition because each game it will be different in what it can do. So it just adds variety game to game and it can allow for kind of novel or interesting tactics. And similarly the tactic tokens are a great addition. It's fun to build your load out at the start of the game and go back for more. And they're just really useful and uh a very interesting addition in the same way that the oxygen system is. This just acts as a ticking clock that you have to worry about. But in a similar way to you had light and dark in Nemesis lockdown, it just is adding something else to think about. And we find it an interesting problem to get around. Then even the rule book in Nemesis Retaliation is the best it's ever been in the series. We've really called out the rule books before. Uh but here it's the most concise. It has the most clarity. It's the best organized. Uh so props there.
For us though, as a summary, one of the issues is hard to get past is that as great as all of these changes are, they're almost in a sense counteracted by how much is exactly the same. You know, the same intruder attacks, the same intruder types, the same infection system, basically the same ways of escaping, the same theme as lockdown, the same type of objectives, the same type of rooms, the same uh tokens that go on rooms. You have the nest still, you know, all of this stuff. so much is so similar that it just feels like a real missed opportunity given the change in tone to a more combative Nemesis. And it just feels weird that they rested so much on their laurels given that this is the third game in the series. Final thoughts for me, as I've said throughout, I'm a little disappointed in Push the Boat out more, but at the same time, it is, in my mind, the best version of Nemesis out so far because of the gameplay changes. What about you?
Yeah, I agree. It is fairly similar to the previous ones, but at the same time, I like the new mechanisms.
Yeah, exactly.
So, very much enjoyed it. It's just nothing super novel, but I'd probably prefer to play this one over the other ones. So, take that what you will. Yeah, it's really hard to kind of
describe because we very much enjoy it.
Yeah, I agree with you that it could have maybe been a little bit more different. Yeah, I think it is in a sense if you own Nemesis or Nemesis and Lockdown then I don't see much point in getting this unless
you would sell one of those to get this because of the updated stuff. I think it's the best one to have,
but there is no reason to get it if you already own one.
Yeah.
So, I think that's where it lists and if you don't have any, then get this one. But yeah, is anything else you want to say before we close up?
Uh, no, not necessarily. I think we've pretty much covered it. But yeah, for me as someone who
I'm not so into storytelling games, but I do really enjoy this one. Actually, I think even if that's not your viable genre, I don't know. For me, I can just really get into this one because there's still enough gameplay elements to make it interesting and then you can like layer the story on top. But like you said, it's not if if you only try to play it as a game without the story, then that's probably where you would get a bit frustrated. So, but no, just someone that's like not so narrative driven. Uh for me, I think this is a perfect balance.
Yes. So, with that, we'll end our review and we'll hopefully be back soon with a buyers guide comparing all three games. Uh if you enjoyed this video, if you want to see that video, please consider subscribing. Really thank you for watching and we'll see you in the future. Bye.
Bye.