Finca Review
Transcript
welcome to John gits games as selected by the voting level supporters of my patreon page today I'll be reviewing FAA in this game players play farmers who are harvesting a variety of different foods which in the game turn out to be wonderfully shaped and vibrantly colored little wooden bits the farmers are going to be taking the food to various towns that want them in order to get victory points there is also a wonderful windmill rondle mechanic first I'm going to go through some gameplay examples of turns to show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here we have the starting setup for a three-player game of FAA this board here has a whole bunch of these little tiles with different fruit numbers on them this is all randomly Associated and then this windmill has all of these different fruits on these little windmill tiles and this was also randomly distributed on the board the last thing that has to happen before we can actually play the game is each player in turn order starting with red is going to take one of their farmers and put it down on one of these windmill blades and they'll take a single uh piece of fruit that's associated with that blade into their stock and they will keep doing this around and round until all three players have put all four of their farmers down onto the windmill all right so now we can begin the game on each player's turn they can take a single action from a selection of three the first of these is simply moving your Farmers around this windmill over here and I think that's what our red player is going to do the first thing you do is decide which of your Farmers you want to move in this case our red player is going to choose this one here then you look to see how many farmers are on that windmill T we see there's only a single farmer here which means you're only going to move this farmer one spot so we take this here we
move it once onto this spot here now you look to see how many farmers are on that windmill blade after you move and that is the number of that fruit that you get from the supply so in this case there are four Farmers on this spot right here so they're going to take four of these figs from the supply and put it into their player area because there are so many farmers on the spot it actually incentivizes people to keep going there in this case the green player has this farmer here and since there are two farmers on that spot they get to move two spots so in this case the green farmer would probably move twice get onto this really big tile here and take five of these figs from the supply and put it into their area it's important to note that if a player ever tries to take resources from the supply and there is not enough to fulfill what they need to grab then instantly everybody loses all of that type of resource back to the supply and then that player takes the required amount so this is a good balancing mechanic to get around people hoarding different types of goods it's now our blue players turn so they could take one of these guys here and since are five Farmers on the spot they can move five spots on the board so 1 2 3 4 five puts them onto this towel here which is lemons and they get to take four from the supply because there are now four Farmers there at this point I'm sure you've noticed all these tiles that are face up on the main board and they have a value on them which is the number of resources on those tiles and it's pretty obvious that what we're trying to do is get these resources to match these tiles but you can't cash in that set collection until you get mules mules are here in
the middle of the windmill and you only grab those when you go past this uh equator line of the windmill with one of your Farmers so because a red player now has all these goods and they want to start cashing it in they are going to specifically move their Farmers to cross this line right here in order to grab a mule he'll grab this guy since there are four people on the blade he moves 1 two 3 four he gets a lemon from the supply but more importantly he crossed the mule line so he takes one of these and puts it into his area at this point let's fast forward through a couple turns till we get to the next thing that I'd like to show you so now it's a red player's turn and they have a mule now which unlocks the ability to do the second type of action on your turn which is deliver Goods to these different towns each mule can deliver up to six Goods at once and that means players can grab multiple tiles from the board when they're going to the market as long as the numbers on them don't sum to more than six at this point however a red player does not have any options like that so they're going to go ahead and grab this tile here put it into their player area they discard their mule in order to do this and then they need to get rid of two lemons and two figs back to the bank the number on these tiles indicates the number of victory points that tile gives you at the end of the game there is one other reason why this number is important but I'll get to that in just a minute the last thing before the next player's turn is you flip the next tile up on a spot to make it available to other players it's now our green players turn and they're also going to go to town and sell some of their goods looking at the board we see there are tiles like this and this indicates that you need to have five of the same type of good in order to take this tile well fortunately our green player has five figs right here
they can sell to the bank but since their mules can allow them to carry up to six things they can also take this tile down here which is just a single Olive return that to the bank and now they've taken two tiles for that single mule action okay let's fast forward through another couple turns until we get to the next thing I'd like to explain all right so now we're at the blue player turn and let's show what that third action type you can do on your turn is and that involves using one of your special action tiles that each player has in front of them now these are one time per game used tiles as soon as you use them you get rid of them and it's important to note that each tile that you still have in front of you at the end of the game is worth two points but let's talk about what these things do this first one allows a player to move any farmer from anywhere on the windmill to any other spot and take the goods as normal however if you cross over any mule lines you don't actually get any mules for doing it this second one allows you to send Goods to the market with a maximum of 10 Goods instead of the normal six this is essentially a super mule next up we have the double move tile this lets you move two farmers on your windmill either the First Farmer twice or spread between two different Farmers to get a whole bunch of goods and lastly a player can use this when they are sending Goods to the market in order to pay one less good our blue player has decided to use their super mule which lets them take 10 Goods to the market the first one they take is this tile right here which is five of the same type of good so they get rid of
these five lemons to the bank the next tile is these three figs here so they were able to get three tiles for that action however they did need to get rid of this tile which cost them two points at the end of the game all right let's fast forward a bit more okay so the red player took the last tile from this region here and when that happens you take this bonus chit which was also randomly arranged at beginning of the game and you look to see who has the most of this particular good amongst the tiles that they've already purchased in this case it's an olive and we see that the red player has five the green player has two and the blue player has none and that means that the red player immediately gets this fivepoint bonus and that's going to stay with them until the end of the game the last thing that happens is we take one of these fet tokens from the top here and we put it down onto the board you'll notice there are only five of these and this is the endgame clock as soon as all five of these been placed onto the board then the game will end I've got one more important thing to show you so let's fast forward until it becomes relevant all right it's the blue player turn they're going to use one of their donkey tiles and they're going to go ahead and grab this tile here now if you look down here you'll notice they only have five grapes so in order to do this they have to get rid of this special token right here which is going to give them a minus one discount as soon as the blue player puts this six down here you'll notice they have one of each kind they have a 1 2 3 4 5 six and what what players are looking to do is make these sets of numbers because we have these bonus tiles right here you'll notice on
it it's got one of every number and then in the middle there is a seven this means since the blue player was the first person to get one tile of each they take this seveno bonus tile and put it into their area you'll notice here the second person to do that is going to get six bonus points instead of seven so it's not the end of the world to not be first but there is obviously an incentivization to get there first it's also important to notice that players have the potential to take multiple of these tiles because you can make multiple sets of one to six and you can work on them at the same time as you're going you don't need to necessarily get all of the different types of tiles before you can get duplicates all right I think I've shown you pretty much everything I need to so let's fast forward to the end of the game it's important to note that as you are trying to assign this bonus tile if two players tie for it so we see that the red player has four of oranges and so does the green player then nobody gets the bonus all right so it's the green players turn and they are going to end the game they put this mule back over here and they're going to purchase this tile here with they have a lot of five tiles since you can see that cost them the two brown and three green to the bank and now let's go ahead and assign this to here you'll notice there are two different uh Goods on there you just sum up all the lemons and all of the olives and see who gets the bonus and with 14 of those this definitely goes to the green player and now we put the last wooden FAA down and the game is officially over so let's take take a look at how the points rack up in order to count your points you
simply add up all the numbers on all these tiles you add up your bonuses from the set collection or the FAA locations and then finally you get an extra two points each if you have any of these bonus chits remaining in this case the red player has 56 points the green player has 53 points and lastly the blue player has 47 points so for this game the red player one if there had been a tie then you would simp simply see who has the most remaining fruit left so let's start off the review by covering the first positive point which has to do with that wonderful windmill mechanic uh first of all I love that the tiles are all randomized each game so that pretty much every game you're going to play at least one of the food stuffs is going to be right next to each other with the different um tiles for it so if you Clump your Farmers up which can tend to happen you might get a whole bunch of that item and then there'll be a bit of a drown as you try to get back around the windmill and I just like that every game is going to play differently with those different food stuffs because they're random I also love the mechanic of moving your Farmers around and I know that FAA did not invent that the idea that when you move a piece it moves X spaces and X is equal to the number of pieces on that spot but think does it very well in fact they kind of double that effect by also having you get X number of food based on the number of Farmers on the spot that you land on so that creates a bunch of interesting decisions because well you can pretty quickly look at the Windmill and realize what maybe two or three different type of food stuffs you have available on a specific turn but you might be thinking a few steps ahead and jump onto a windmill spot to get some food you don't
really care about but because it means you're probably going to be able to jump ahead and get that one food you really need and you're going to hope that no players come around and screw up those plans so in general I think it's a really elegant and beautiful mechanism and I love it in this game positive Point number two has to do with the variety of things that you are shooting for in this game at First Look it looks really simple you're getting fruit and you're cashing them in for those tiles okay that's the whole game but it isn't you are first of all thinking about the um set collection of the numbers where you're trying to get a one a two a three four all the way up to six because you want to get those bonus tiles those are very real amounts of points and you want to do it sooner rather than later because the points only get worse as the game goes on and other players grab those so it incentivizes you to get a variety of different tiles instead of maybe just shooting for threes the whole game long because maybe three is an easier number to get to uh I also love those little think of bonus chits that get put out into play as soon as the last tile from a stack gets taken because it doesn't just reward the person who took that tile no it reward rewards the person who has the most of that particular good in their area so you are also planning ahead for that you can look around and see which Stacks are getting low and what is the bonus on that and that will also influence which of the tiles you take you might see that the lemon bonus is getting low and you and another player are tied with the number lemons in your area well you might gun to try and get more lemons to get those tiles in place so that when that last tile is taken you get that bonus five points instead of the other person because Five Points is also a
very real amount of point to consider and then lastly of course you are constantly thinking about maximizing the amount of fruit that you can get from the windmill in order to get all these tiles into area I think all of these different decisions mesh well together and create a lot of cool things to think about as you're playing for positive number three I'd like to highlight the Great player interactions that exist in a game of FAA I've already talked about a couple of those you know one with the one through six set to grab those bonus tiles earlier to get more points and also with those little bonus chits that go to the person who has the most of those specific types of foods those are both great indirect player interactions but you also have that rondle with the windmill and you can see what players are potentially trying to set up you can see oh they really need that four and the only four on the board needs oranges and they just put their piece on there to jump over and get oranges well I'm going to jump onto that piece myself and I'm going to get whatever it is figs I could use figs somewhere but more importantly now they have to jump three instead of two they're going to miss that orange and I am kind of messing with their plans this is kind of indirect and kind of direct because you are also getting something for that but you are directly messing with their plans to jump ahead and then also there is the fact that you can force everybody to lose their goods by taking the last of the resources in that pile and that can happen once the farmers start to stack up a couple people can jump on and take four oranges and then five oranges then six oranges and suddenly there aren't any oranges left and everybody puts them back on the board and this kind of feels much more direct this also
comes into play with those mules somebody uh takes the last mule suddenly all the mules go back and that can definitely set people back and it's a bit more of a direct interaction than you're maybe used to seeing in a euro but it doesn't happen that often and it's somewhat easy to avoid you just start seeing a run on oranges well try to cash out your oranges if you notice that the mule C are getting really low well maybe do one or two really inefficient selling actions to the market to just get use out of those tokens before they potentially disappear so altogether all four of these uh great player interactions come together in a great way for the game and the fourth and last positive point is the component quality in this game I cannot avoid the fact that these bits are wonderful when you walk by somebody playing this game you cannot help but notice the little grape bits and the orange bits and the lemon bits and they all look like the thing they're supposed to be they're vibrantly colored they just feel great in your hands they could have been different colored Cubes but no they went out of the way to make custom food tokens which is also going to help with color blindness because all the tokens look different on the board and oh the board itself is gorgeous that windmill is huge and all those wonderful little tiles on it it's just a vibrant wonderful package every single aspect to it comes together so well and I just love seeing the game on the table so now let's jump into my one neutral point which has to do with those four one-time use bonus tokens that each player gets now as a general rule I don't really like onetime use bonus actions in any game and the same goes for FAA I feel
like they're kind of like a Band-Aid that gets stuck on to help people if they dig themselves into a hole you could teleport your farmer over to the other side of the board and grab that thing that you really need because you found yourself bogged down or you could do a really big mule card action maybe you'll do that after you lost your mule card or you want to get up to 10 Victory Point Val into your area and that's that's fine I get why those exist and when you do those actions it does feel kind of cool doing a really big mule action to get all those tiles down or the minus one discount to take a tile you really needed uh right before your opponent and that was the only six on the board and you could laugh and but in general it just feels like an inelegant Splinter stuck in the side of a perfectly smooth elegant ball and I I won't play the game without them I just kind of wish that it had been designed so that they weren't there and now for the one negative point I have for fa which I contemplated not putting in here at all but whatever I'm going to say it anyway this game is pretty out of print and it is quite expensive to acquire these days when it first came out you could grab it for $25 in a whole bunch of different locations but it has been out of print for several years now and you are going to be lucky to pick the game up for 45 or so dollars you are likely going to be spending more than that which is a bummer because this is a elegant wonderful game and it's a bit of a detractor if you have to spend an uncomfortable amount of money to get it down on your table but ultimately if you're going to do that then I think the odds are good you're going to really enjoy that experience but ultimately I just figured I'd mention this so now let's briefly talk about replayability
long story short there is so much Randomness to the setup of this game that I think the replayability is quite strong each game is going to feel much like the last game like you are still moving your dudes around the rondle you are still picking up those tiles in the area of the island but each game your path to Victory is going to be slightly different you're not going to do the exact same moves you're going to be constantly looking at those bonus chits and trying to maximize them and trying to get your sets before everybody else that's not going to be different but the way you're going to go at it is going to be different enough from each game that it doesn't necessarily feel syy and those interesting decisions that you're making from game to game just continue to be interesting as time goes on so in general I think that FAA has a decent amount of replayability all right so now let's discuss player count thinka plays two to four players and the long story short is thinka is very good with all of those different player counts uh if I was to nitpick I would say that the two-player game is probably best because there is only one person to really analyze what their situation is like uh on the rondle and also you're going to take an action and then they take an action then you take an action so there's less chaos uh specifically on that rondle but also with the tiles out on the board between turns uh four player games are totally fine in this game but late game there has the potential for a little bit of analysis paralysis especially if you're playing with players who are predisposed to that they might be kind of locking down and saying well what options do you have on the rondle well what does that
mean out on the board with all these tiles and what food do you have and which tiles can you get and can you get the tiles I want to get and wait how many lemons do you have for that one bonus tile versus how many lemons I have there is the potential to kind of spiral down a rabbit hole of analysis paralysis but I've really only seen that happen with people who kind of analysis Paralysis on every game so in general it's not too bad and I've definitely enjoyed playing this game four players three is also fine and two I think has the slight Edge in conclusion I think that FAA is a gem it is a wonderfully elegant little game that has gorgeous components that just grabs everybody's attention who are playing the game and who are not playing the game you have those components that just feel great in your hands when you grab them and put them in your area you really just feel like these are fruit and you're taking them to the market you also have all these great levels of player interaction uh often times in Euro games you're kind of just multiplayer solitire but you have to pay attention to what everybody else is doing on a short-term level with that uh rondle to think about well are they going to come in and kind of mess up my plan to grab that orange but also longterm and think you know I really want to make sure I have all the olives because that stack with the olive bonus chip is getting low and I want to be in a position where I'm unrivaled in that situation and I get those free Five Points without even spending any actions for it so there are so many things to think about that are just interesting and fun as you're playing the game and also I didn't mention it before but the game plays relatively quickly like you're going to play a four-player game of this in probably about an hour and the three and two-player games are going to be quite a bit less than that unless
you happen to be playing with somebody who is a very into analysis paralysis unfortunately so in general this is a wonderful game if you have an opportunity to play it I highly recommend it and if you have an opportunity to grab it for a not incredibly large amount of money I would also highly recommend you go ahead and do that if you'd like to become more involved with the channel you can directly support it at patreon.com jits games and I'd really like to thank all of the current patreon supporters of the page I really appreciate it uh if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching