Skip to main content
Loading video...

Earth Board Game Review

Transcript 18:31

this is a strange review for me because there are so many things about this game that I recognize I don't like that much and yet this game is so satisfying and enjoyable for me so this is a weird review because do I make it sound like the game is ruined because of these things I don't like or do I just you know over promise on the game just because I had so much fun with it I want to be really honest and and do this review just right foreign we're going to take a look at Earth a game that came out in 2023 by inside up games for one to five players and plays in about an hour Earth is a competitive game where the objective is to score the most victory points by building a tableau of cards that represents your Island an ecosystem with its own climate geographical features and Flora all of the characteristics of your Island are going to be working together to help you amass lots of victory points by the end of the game so how do you play this game well for people who have played a lot of games I describe this as a cross between wingspan and San Juan players are going to take turns being the active player and the active player will choose one of four actions now that choice will allow every other player to perform a minor action and then after the action is

completed based on the color of the action every player's Tableau will trigger the cards of the matching color so as the Tableau grows they're just going to have more and more things to do more choices to make more resources to collect as the game goes on this is a real engine builder but before we talk more about what these actions are let's take a look at the anatomy of a card in the top left corner you're going to see the card's cost and the number of points that it's worth at the end of the game every card costs soil in this game and every card has some base value but there are several other ways that this card can earn you points during the game one way is by collecting growth tokens which go in this corner here another way is by collecting Sprouts which go along the bottom over here and still another way is by composting the card which is another way of saying discard the card but in this game while there is a common discard pile when you come post a card it goes into your own personal discard pile and cards in your personal discard pile your compost pile are worth one point at the end of the game so you've got growth tokens that are worth one point at the end of the game Sprout tokens worth one point in the end of the game compost that's worth one point at the end of the game and then every card may or may not satisfy

objectives you're going to have public objectives available to everybody some of them are going to be achievements that you will claim when you satisfy the condition those are the fauna cards others are in-game scoring and still every player has their own private objectives and during the game they can play terrain cards which would possibly give them even more objectives so every card can be worth a lot of points in fact in a game where you're going to plant no more than 16 cards it is not uncommon to have scores that are above 200 points with that being said we can now take a closer look at these four actions so the first action the green action is the planting action and it allows the active player to plant two cards of course they pay the cost for that then they get to draw four cards and choose one to keep now for everybody else they get to plant one card and draw one card now the green cards that get triggered when you choose this action have a variety of effects but most of them are about receiving something for free so a free Sprout free growth get a card get a soil now the next action the red action is composting it allows the active player to get five soil and put two cards in the compost heap of their own player board and it allows every other player to choose between either composting or taking soil now generally speaking the red cards that get triggered when you choose this

action all have to do with composting as well either you're getting more soil or you are discarding more cards into your compost pile as for these Rainbow Cards you're going to see it triggered by the red action as well as the next two actions and generally the rainbow cards allow you to pay one thing in order to get something else now the next action the teal action is the watering action and it allows you to place sprouts and take more soil for everybody else it allows them to either add to Sprouts or take two soil and the teal cards that triggered are also very similar generally speaking they allow you to put even more Sprouts on cards and then the yellow action is the growing action it's the action that's going to let you get the most cards the active player will get four cards for this action and add two growth tokens whereas everybody else gets to choose between drawing cards or adding growth tokens and once again the yellow cards are pretty similar they generally just allow you to do more by putting more growth tokens on your Tableau thematically this game was not what I expected you look at the game you look at the Box you look at the photography and all of the cards and it's easy to think that this is a game about building an island and you're going to be focused on trees and shrubs and like the different geographical features but when you actually play the game you find out that you don't really care what's on the cards it's all it's not what the cards are but rather what they do so you you look less at the pictures you look less at what the names of the

cards are and way more at the symbols on the cards and that kind of abstracts the game a little bit so it kind of has this theme in a figurative sense but not very much in that literal sense of like what the topic is on the cards and if you look carefully you can find some examples that do show thematic meaning for example you look at this giant sequoia card and the Giant Sequoia card lets you put eight growth tokens on it that's more than any other card in the in the deck so Giants Koya that makes a lot of sense but then you have a lot of other cards like this Atlantic puffin this is an achievement card a fauna and the objective here is to have 10 or more cards with an even point value so what what is that objective have to do with anything it's kind of abstract right but nevertheless when this comes out you know you're going to be looking at cards that have a certain point value at least in this case so um in that in that way it's kind of like survival of the fittest you're holding let's say six cards in your hand it's your turn to play a card and what you're trying to find is the card that best fits the situation in in that game state so considering all the objectives considering what other players are doing considering what you already have on your player board which of your six cards is the best to play right now so

thematically the game is very big on adapting and the cards are just kind of abstract feeling for theme I would give this game about a five mechanically I think this game is brilliant what they've done is they've taken two very popular mechanics uh Tableau building and engine building and they've added to that simultaneous gameplay so that as you play this game you're not wasting any time waiting for your turn you've always got something to do somebody else chooses an action and it triggers your card effects that's fantastic fantastic it's very satisfying that the game just gets more and more amped up the turns get more complicated as the game goes on and with all of the achievements and objectives there's a lot to pay attention to but it's so much fun everybody I've played this game with has walked away even if they're a little confused by the rules teached they've walked away saying I would play that game again it was just so fun to see what was going to happen so for mechanics I would give this game a 10. but the return to strategy though it does kind of feel like the game is playing you like I had said earlier when I was talking about theme this game is all about adapting and you are adapting to whatever the cards are that you draw you can decide do you want to play one strategy or another and try to go in a certain direction but if you don't draw the cards you may have to Pivot and the player is going to play well is somebody who comes up with a reasonable strategy

but can also pivot based on their luck so that they can kind of capitalize on the cards they get and you may shift on how you're focusing um but because of the achievements and the objectives every game is very very different so what works in one game is going to be different in the next game and that adds to the replayability value a lot so I think it's more of a tactical game playing one turn at a time rather than a strategic game where you're planning out um a long-term strategy for strategy I give this game about a four for the component rating usually what I'm talking about here is both the Beauty and the artwork of the game and also how well the components function and here is really where the game has its biggest flaws because the the photography is wonderful I think the entire game is a gorgeous game but there are many aspects about the components that I I was irritated by so I'll give you a few of my biggest complaints one the player boards are just slightly warped so that you can actually spin them on the table like you see here and that means that the pieces that go on the player boards are even more likely to slide around and as you can see there are no grooves in the player boards to help things stay in place and of course there are no grooves on the cards as well so when it comes to placing things on cards all of the Sprout tokens they

have these very clear spaces of where the spouts should go but they're going to be moving around all the time and it kind of feels a little messy you want to get things a little bit more clean but I guess you can you can deal with that the Sprouts don't have to be in a nice row they can be scattered on the card but then the growth tokens this kind of baffles me a little bit because the growth tokens are supposed to be stacked and the way they're designed they don't sit straight on top of each other so the higher the stack of growth tokens is the more the stack leans and so your alternative is to is to split up the growth tokens but then that kind of interrupts the aesthetic of what they're trying to achieve the whole point is to make trees to make it attractive with trees of varying Heights and if the growth tokens don't stack properly then you can't really you know benefit from the satisfaction of how they've designed it to be the thing the fact that things could so easily move around or fall over or spin means that you're gonna have to play this game very carefully it also takes up a lot of table space and you need that table space because if things get cluttered you're just going to get confused about after you know somebody bumps the table and everything gets scattered so ultimately when writing components even though I have to say the photography is fantastic and I love it because of that lack of functionality

especially in the growth tokens I just think it could be a lot better so for components I give it a five for complexity this is not a very complex game but I don't like teaching it so let me break that down first it's not complex because what do you do there's only four actions and when you choose an action it triggers your cards that seems so simple problem is they're twofold one when you're teaching the rules there's three ways to augment how many how you get points on a card you've got the Sprouts the growth tokens and the compost and when you're learning the game for the first time they all just kind of seem like the same thing it's all just worth victory points so then the question is well why why what's the big difference why use growth tokens instead of sprouts and you say well the way that you get Sprouts is through these kinds of cards or this action and the way that you get growth tokens is from these kinds of cards or that action and so depending on which strategy you go more towards the teal cards or more towards the yellow cards and how that's going to work out you might want to build more trees trees have a capacity for more growth tokens and plans have more capacity for sprout tokens and blah blah do you see where I'm going with this it's just a lot of explanation I wish the rules boiled down to something that was a little bit more intuitive especially For the First Time

teach um but you know people get through it they've endured they play the game and eventually it all makes sense and they come out fine in the end but you got one more interference there which is the number of objectives you've got terrain cards that give you objectives personal objectives public objectives you've got these achievements you've got so much going on and claiming those achievements is something that happens at the end of your turn automatically it is so easy to lose track of the achievements and the objectives it's just too much the the rulebook actually says that for your first time playing you should not play with uh so many objectives to simplify the game a little bit and I really advise that so it's a simple game that I don't like to teach that doesn't mean the game is complex it's just kind of this caveat about it being simple I suppose for complexity I would give it like a four or a five maybe more of a four I want to be really honest and and do this review just right so that you can understand the things that are finicky about the game and yet know what the game does that makes it so enjoyable regardless of the finicky portions and finicky is a good word because really adding those Sprout tokens managing the growth tokens and keeping things on their board and not

sliding around it's finicky and then you've what what is what is what does anything mean a lot of it lacks explanation it's just kind of these arbitrary like you know this card triggers getting these things and this card spends those to get that blah blah blah not a lot of meaning what you play and yet building the engine the core of the game is building a synergistic engine of all of these interrelated parts and that's what you do in the game what does the game want to accomplish it wants to accomplish this ecosystem of things that work together and it wants players to adapt and the game does that and it's enjoyable to do so even though I would like to see like a little bit more meaning in the cards and even though I wish that there that the growth tokens would stack perfectly and even though I get annoyed every single time the Puffin card comes up because it just seems so meaningless to me I'm willing to forgive all of that because the game one it accomplishes it what what it wants to do it does it in a way that's fun for me and it's extremely efficient you were constantly playing this game there's not down time it's not boring and while there is a lot of luck I approve of games that have a lot of luck when they're a lot of fun I enjoy the fact that the luck in this game is all about trying to get as many cards as

you can and then choosing the best one to fit inside your ecosystem that is that is what buildings Island should be about um a lot of my complaints about other games are resolved in this one so I have made criticisms for terraforming Mars because I think of it as being a more scientific game and I would like there to be more planning involved and I see there as being too much luck so I say terraforming Mars has you know too much luck or I look at wingspan and I say well the game is so isolated and you spend so much time waiting for your turn and this game fixes both of those one the game is much more naturally about adapting I think thematically it's much more consistent and then as far as waiting is concerned there is no waiting this game fixes things that I've had trouble with in other popular games of like mid-level complexity now at the end of the day what am I going to play in different situations if I was playing a two-player game I would still play gizmos gizmos is still my favorite engine builder game and as long as there aren't too many people around you don't have to wait long for your turn this game is superior for four five players because it keeps everybody involved the entire time and I love that about it so those are my thoughts on Earth thank you so much for watching this video if you're interested in the

game do consider using affiliate links in the description because those help support the channel a lot and I really I do really appreciate it thank you so much for watching and I'll see you next time bye

Progress saved