Stifling Dark: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock and today I'm doing a discussion over the stifling dark now this was actually a game I have uh done a preview for uh whenever I had the Prototype version and I did a kind of preliminary discussion over it uh back whenever it was either still on Kickstarter or you know getting ready to end on Kickstarter I I don't remember the time frame anyway I had played the Prototype version of this and now I have the fully uh produced copy of the game and I'm here to give you my thoughts on the stifling dark if you're not familiar with it this is a one verse medy hidden movement game where one player plays a one out of three adversaries and the other players play investigators who are trying to to find evidence uh on a board while also trying um to not be killed or in some other way that the adversary has to win um and here's the thing hidden movement games at least for me at this point in time are very difficult for me to not necessarily like but for me to like above the others that are kind of stables in my collection so uh Fury of Dracula Leathers from White Chapel um I have another one called anomaly but I haven't played that one in a while so I don't really remember um but those are
kind of like the two that I'm like yeah these are the ones that I I they're just really good and I'd rather just play these um and I've played some of the newer ones that have come out recently and they just haven't really hit for me mind management I'm not the biggest fan of uh Sniper Elite not the biggest fan of uh uh last Friday was okay so it's like it's more of just a maybe this isn't a genre for me anymore but I got to say stifling dark is really good like it does a lot of things really well I should say there are some decisions of this game that I'm not the biggest fan of but it is kind of a breath of fresh air because this game runs on a gimmick so um the gimmick of this is and I'm G pull all the all the stuff out the gimmick is that the board uh and I'll use I'm just going to use this cuz the this is the adversary mini board is there are two maps in the game there's The Sawmill and the uh amusement park and then there are three adversaries in the game and one thing I will say is I wish there were more locations like more boards but I get it's a smaller team so maybe they could do more stuff in the future for I don't really know how how well this game did good enough to get produced but I like to see more locations and things like that but this
is the uh uh the adversary board on and they're double-sided and what this game utilizes are uh dark spaces so there are dim spaces that just cause kind of one movement point to move into and then there are dark spaces that cost two how ever the players will have these flashlights and this is the main gimmick of the game and it works wonders I think this is such a cool and thematic uh mechanism in this game so whenever players are done um with their turn they can spend a charge so you only have a limited amount of uses uh before you have to start gaining your battery back to drop your flashlight down on the board and there's these white lines on it that show what the player is able to see this does a couple things one it reveals any items or tokens that are in the lit spot it also can reveal the adversary um like if you're playing against the butcher the butcher basically can only move and hide if they're in the light so this actually can do a couple things it can block the adversary from moving it could turn dark spaces now into light spaces which allow other players to move through without the Restriction of extra movement this is such a cool mechan M and makes it extremely thematic like whenever characters and investigators are moving around the board it's like okay you know going to use my flashlight to see if I can see anything otherwise I it's I can't see anything this is also kind of
a double-edged sword for some people because if you step into the spot of the adversary or an item and you have not lit it up you don't get to see it so everything is on the mini board all the tokens and stuff are on the minib board and only until they are revealed do they show up on the main board that's when the one player places them out for them to see so thematically it is kind of like like it's like whenever you're looking for like a car battery or something and it's like oh man yeah I'm totally I can't see that even though I'm on the space directly I get why they did that otherwise it's like what would you really use the flashlight for except to see items uh and the adversary it's like I kind of get it but it is a little thematically weird that if you're on the same space as an item or the adversary that you just don't know anything about it unless it's lit up that's a little bit of a kind of a I mean it it leads to some funny moments for sure uh so I kind of give it a pass that's not really a negative on my end um but yeah I remember seeing this game uh being well not really demoed being showcased at Gen Con a couple years back and I was like oh that's really interesting um and I think I like hidden movement game so I'll give it a shot uh so that is is just a a really neat Twist on the kind of like the hidden movement thing oh man
apparently I have an alarm I'm supposed to wake up now um that didn't happen I did not wake up at 11:00 a.m. uh the other thing is in a lot of his movement games the one player is typically running from everyone it's one of the reasons why I like Fury of Dracula so much because it kind of has that cat and mouse like being chased but then it's like oh now it's night time like time to you know turn the tables and attack you guys in this one it it has like a kind of like the investigators are the ones that are really the ones that are running um they can just kind of do things turn the flashlight to make the adversary not be able to attack it's like they deter the adversary instead of you know combating it uh they have items and stuff that can do all that but they're not fighting it really and in in this game it's like yeah I'm the one that's going after you I'm the one hunting you down I'm the one you know wounding you and and uh causing you guys discomfort uh while you're doing while you're doing all the extra stuff I'm the one trying to kill you things like that and that's another kind of flip on the hidden movement genre because again it's like well I'm the one that's running from you so you guys have to just try and catch me so that is really cool um so let me go into a
couple things that I uh I'm not the biggest fan of in this game and I'm pretty sure that they're the exact same issues I had with the production copy uh or the Prototype copy although more finalized uh in the produ in the Prototype copy I had like four separate rule books and it was like all over the place obviously that is fixed uh they have two Rule books they have the adversary book and the main rule book I actually am not the biggest fan of how these are written it feels like the cool core rule book has stuff kind of a little all over the place it wants to be minimalistic and not overload you with rules but then there's a [ __ ] ton of tokens in this game as well as it's like okay well here's some rules for the adversary set up but actually go into the adversary book and look into that and then so you are kind of going back and forth and this is something that a lot of kickstarters are doing lately where if you just need to look up a question you don't know which book you're in it's like um like hey where like what what does this token mean okay is that an adversary token is that a player is that a is that a board token is that an investigator token who knows uh good like does have fun finding it if you're trying to find Icons it's like I I don't know where they're at um so the rule book does just enough to teach you how to play but I still feel like that you're going to be in this a little more than you really should be for kind of actually how simple this game is so that's that's not the best I
I really like there's people that you can hire to write comprehensive Rule books it's not the worst like it's not like I'm sitting there like I have no idea what to do you will grasp how to play the game but you're still going to kind of feel like I don't really know what that is uh like a good example and this could just be a user thing I when I first played this I could not find where the adversary starts on the board that's a pretty big thing and you would think it'd be in the adversary setup I literally could not find it and I'm sure someone's going to be like it's actually on this page and it's most likely in here but the fact that it wasn't so obvious to find is like a very like annoying thing it's like that should be a big deal everything else is described in setup and stuff but something like that as like where do I start as the adversary anywhere cuz if it's anywhere okay um but yeah just little things like that you're going to like on the back of the core rules is like map features but like not all these map features like those are also in the uh in like the map in the scenario section um and then they have a whole example around how to play but then it's like the player boards and cards description like what the cards and things mean those are in the middle of the rule book instead of at the beginning uh so it kind it cuts to like okay here's the investigator and adversary setup and then it goes into
okay well now here setup changes for different players then it goes into the round structure and Concepts then it goes into how the the investigators play but then it doesn't it it doesn't go into what the adversary does on their turn because you have to go into the adversary rules and one thing about this game that they should have done is obviously the adversaries should play different 100% um and they do and that's fantastic but they needed to have like core rules it's kind of like an asymmetric game like route for example where it's like here's general rules apply to everything here's how every faction piece moves got it anyway now here's the specific rules about your faction that's how it should have been and it doesn't feel that way it's like they completely omitted the adversary and the core rules because they had the other adversary rule book whenever it's like the adversary rule book at least to me should be like how your adversary uh plays differently uh so it's just it's it's the the rule book's just not not amazing the other thing is and this kind of is all all my main issues really pertain to kind of setup and one thing and I mentioned this in the in the Prototype because I I I remember it being brought up whenever I play tested it depending on the number of players uh the adversary has points of interest
tokens that they play secretly on the map and these points of interest are these yellow circular spots and the points of interest will be kind of items that the characters can find and you place them up to two spaces away from each of those so in The Sawmill there'll be five points of interest tokens okay well those are there and that uh that um uh incentivizes exploration if the characters investigators want uh if they want items they're going to have to go out and find it but the way the setup works is depending on the number of players let's say you're playing with two investigators they get to pick two of those points of interest and have those tokens removed and the players start with those items here's my problem with this is let's say this is the yeah so this is The Sawmill the characters start down here and they will always start down here on the ore orange green spots and they adversary or the points of interest are here here here here and there so those five well if they pick these two up the very top because they always start down here there is no reason for them to ever go up here because they're only going to need a certain number of uh evidence tokens so just by removing these two tokens the characters have no reason to go to the lumbered and the Kiln because
it's like well we can go to the office we can go to the garage and we can go to The Sawmill itself to get our investigator Tok or uh evidence tokens that we need there's computers in every single room here so um so yeah just by having setup alone be like we're going to take those two tokens uh you cut off half the board I really dislike this because you're bored in a game like this should be you should incentivize investigating you should incentivize like well we know items are up here we exhausted all our uh items down here so like why why cut off half the board especially where your starting position is always the same it is always down here on the green spots so there's no reason unless you're playing a full five player game which we'll get to that in a sec where you need of all the investigator tokens that it's like like if if you're not playing with five players um then you're not going to ever have to go up to the top of the board I think that's kind of annoying um so that's that's kind of disappointing instead of just having all the uh points of interest tokens why not just hand out a certain number of items to the players I mean theoretically you could just house rule it and I might do that where it's like okay um like flip
over how many points of interest okay you're there's two investigators you get two points of interest I'm just going to take two random ones from the pile and flip them and oh it's four items okay here you go here's four items that's what you guys start with and you can get more because but you're going to have to go out of your way if you want more that just sounds like a way better uh option um to have players come up here um the other thing that I wish that they had about like the boards is there's not enough customization of it like so there's light switches in every single room that's fine these are buildings they have light switches uh to make make the rooms bright there's computers in every single room and there's medic uh you know items that they can come get I almost wish that the computers and stuff could be customized in some way like not every room has a has a computer so like if they do have the evidence they still have to find a computer because thematically it's like this is supposed to be like a rundown Sawmill one why is there active you know running electricity and computers that work but it'd be nice if they're like oh okay we have all the evidence we need now we need to go find the the actual computer which we know is on the board somewhere that would also cause you to use the uh flashlights a lot more that would cause you to be like okay well if you're going to make the kill and the
lumbered like not searchable well it's like well [ __ ] maybe we need to go up there because the computer might be in there uh it just it feels like eventually the scenarios are kind of kind of going to get tiresome because the boards are always going to be the same like the items are always going to be within two spaces of this so at 136 like that only leaves a certain of spots to find it it's going to items are going to be in that open area if the players don't choose to grab them um and I will say and this is kind of going to go into my other slightly negative uh G uh point is uh this the the points of interest starting with items taking tokens off the board is only a problem in a lower player count game it does feel like this game is meant to be played with five meaning the one adversary and four investigators because um the way the different setup works for example it's um so how much evidence is required to be turned in for the investigators to choose their objective in a two-player game it's two three player game is three and four player game is five so again there are five different zones on the board meaning for investigators you now have to go to every single location number of points of interest investigators start with a two investigator in two investigator game is two three is one and four is zero again
now that means there are five zones in this there's the office The Sawmill the garage the Kiln and the lumbered those five zones now all five of those zones will have um evidence tokens that people have to get and they don't take any points of interest off the board so my argument of being like Oh take the top two because you're never going to have to go up and uh investigate in a four investigator game with one adversary so a five player game all that is kind of moot which means that if you're wanting to play this game with lower physical people you're probably going to have have to have players run with uh multiple investigators which is not hard like it's not like the the player turns are so complex that you're like uh that's too much to handle it it absolutely can be done uh but if some people don't want to run multiple investigators then it's I I I I think you are missing a lot because another issue that you have with running with less than four investigators and even three is a little bit better but I also tried this at two you're going to lose I really feel like you're just going to lose if the aders because in a two-player game for example if they I'm dying if they split up the the investigator or the adversary is winning like last last time I played
this was at two and I was playing as the Butcher and they split up because obviously they need to find investigator tokens if they pair up it's going to take too long to find everything because you're limited on time it's like okay well I'm just going to hyper fix it on one person like and that's the butcher just has to kill one investigator to win and if you start with like an eviscerate attack and it's like oh I just have to put bleed on you twice and you die yeah no one can stop you if you if that one person that's being targeted does not find the butcher then they're just going to they're just going to die uh thematic I mean it makes sense it's like well yeah you're alone and you're being targeted by this one crazy guy with a hook but again what's really cool about this game this is going to I'm going to turn turn it slightly into a positive is when you have multiple investigators there's a lot more coordination and this is so obvious it's just like well does it's a Cooperative game you can coordinate but like for example is like if players are like wanting to search the Lumbers shed and all the investigators get to go before the adversary gets to go then one person can like run up here drop their flashlight into this section and let even if they don't find the adversary then the other players can now run in here with a being unhindered and then like let's say they Dro their flashlight you know to search into the lumbered okay well then another player can run in there and search and they can drop their
flashlight you know over down here so that means that if I was going after as the adversary if I was going after any of these characters well they've kind of made a shield and a wall that prevents me from try to get in they've actively blocked off the sections unless I want to run into a window which makes me make a noise token so uh just you have a lot more of that and that's just two players and it's like okay now we've got this area locked down someone else running maybe flip the switch or start searching for the you know we found the evidence token so run in here and grab it and then the other person can run trade interact and trade and then get get to the um get to the computer just there's a lot a lot more of that whenever there are multiple players plus you everyone has minor abilities everyone has major abilities there's I mean they don't have any items but now they can start searching for items it's just uh this is one of those that is either a five player game or players are running multiple characters um which again is very easy to do there's not like the player turns are not that complicated so it's it's easier to do um but at the same time more players they don't have have any items um the adversary gets more abilities that they can use it's more like the butcher for example gets to stalk more characters so it balances out way better versus like well I still
have my attack and ability and you're all by yourself and I'm just going to keep stalking you and then now you have bone Gill and now I have stalk and I'm going spend that to attack you and now you're dead like that's kind of how a lower player count goes um the the other thing and this is more of kind of a fiddly nature is there are a ton of tokens in this game ton of little tokens that are either for each adversary has a bunch um players have a bunch the uh just the board like tokens can be placed on the board there's a bunch of those so just there's a little bit of fiddlin with that uh it's mainly more of an issue with a storage solution uh kind of thing which they did okay like it could have been worse like if it all fits but yeah whenever you have to find one particular token and it's like oh which bag is that that's just not the best I will say that they did I don't know if this was always planned but I remember specifically the Prototype did not have this um I think there was like these standies for the characters that the adversary had to have behind his board and they were just way too big and it was very very shitty they did make very little tokens that are circular size for this board so that what's great is the adversary doesn't have to actually look at the main board to see where everyone's at as long as when they move like he does look and kind of takes a their little token it's like oh okay so you moved for from 2011
and you ended on 147 okay so now they have everyone's placement and they have their own little token so they can move around and see where everyone's at that's really nice I do think this is still too big and it does jut out from the screen uh so if you have kind of a smaller table players sitting next to you might be able to see uh some tokens and stuff on the um on the thing I also don't know what how I feel about the screen the screen has the three adversaries on it and if you if they make expansions this kind of becomes moot because if they make more adversaries well then they have to make a new screen and it's like okay well which it's like oh time to play the game well [ __ ] uh which screen do I need for which adversary am I playing it's nice initially and I get why they did this because it's like well well I need to know what I do on my turn oh here's the adversary I'm playing this tells me that is nice but I would have much rather had like you you you don't you don't need the art on here this all this could have probably been on two screens for the text for the three adversaries and then you have like core rules almost like a dungeon master screen where it's like here's general rules for the players general rules for the adversary uh that the it's like that you don't have to search in the rule book for like this I mean the the quality is nice but this is like kind of like a
little much that doesn't really do a whole lot of good uh so yeah like most of my main negatives are actually with setup and a little bit of weird production uh issues I do uh like the event cards that pop up are thematically tied to the location the scenario is thematically tied um like the two locations do have different rules and kind of how they play um I also like the fact that like whenever players find the uh enough evidence and submit it then they pick their escape thing and like in The Sawmill for example uh you can either banish the well that's banish the butcher you can either fix the truck or power the gate uh in the um you can banish the [ __ ] banish the cult you can do service tunnels or fire the flare for the uh amusement park uh I think that's really interesting where it's like you're kind of in this location and it's like oh forest fire is happening at the Sawmill [ __ ] we need to okay we're going to try and fix the truck so then you have to that kind of kickstarts the end game and now players have to gather all these components to the truck and that kind of becomes like the big finale where it's like oh [ __ ] they're trying to get out all right now I'm going to go after them really try and attack them um it has a really good EB and flow very very thematic and this game can also be
really funny uh if you go into like the schlocky horror thing uh it could also be really creepy so it has both of those balances of like yeah that is kind of like if you're like shining your flashlight in an office and then like the butcher is like yeah I'm going to place a uh a uh spine chill token on you which is like that clearly means I have line of sight to you and I can see you and I'm looking at you through a window uh and that could be horrifying and it's like where is he so you can really get into both mindsets here um I also like the fact that the character's a ton of characters in the game uh I like the fact that they have their minor powers and a major power that's pretty much onetime use but there are ways for you to get it back um but if everyone uses it it's like well we got to okay we have to kind of pick who's getting theirs back that's really neat I like that you can Sprint and that gives you extra movement movement is very fluid in this um so yeah like I think for a I'm pretty sure this is the first time publisher I actually can't even remember who the publishing team is um I also really like the the cover for the game but for again I'm going to say it's a first time uh publisher I think that they are 100% on the right track what I would like to see um cuz they have an expansion a very small one called Nightfall I haven't played with this but it adds flashlight
Powers so there are these large flashlights that can potentially change you know what kind of flashlight it is so that's that's a neat little mini expansion but what I would like to see in the future is I would like to see more more adversaries of course um and more ways to just modify like the board maybe just way like different starting positions for the investigators um more tokens and stuff that like characters and investigators can find uh so it's just not a lot of dead space where it's like yeah you just really want to go to these buildings that's pretty much it um like I'd like to see a little bit more of that and I think they can absolutely do stuff like that um so the negatives I have for the game really aren't major for me to be like this game sucks uh but it's like yeah I mean it' make the game a little bit more fun like a little bit more kind of like oh we want to try and find stuff but that causes us like imagine if they had to be like like if there because there's nothing that can go down here there's nothing down here so it's like what would incentivize players to go this way you know like down in the corner cuz all the stuff is up front so even have this bottom part of the map if there's nothing for investigators to come search for um so it's like having ways for players to kind of be like well there's a a circle of candles over here uh you know I'll try and see if there's
anything there yeah you risk it's risk reward the investigators do kind of go off on their own or maybe they can be like hey you guys go look in those buildings me and this player are going to go this way and hopefully find something and if they do it's great if they don't then it's like [ __ ] we're on our own here that I think would allow a lot more to it and the the designers could absolutely do stuff like that just a update to the locations or maybe if they're doing more maps they do stuff like that so I think they have a lot of room to work with I'm hoping that they do more I believe the designers have said they want to do more for it they probably have a bunch of ideas uh so we'll see um and yeah that's that's pretty much my thoughts on on stifling dark on a scale of 1 to 10 I think as of right now I'm going to go with a seven it is a seven out of 10 it is a good game uh I am keeping it in my collection it very much could go higher like I don't see this game getting any lower Seven's like where it's at but if they make some changes or they do more adversaries and more scenarios and More in like exploration kind of kind of thing um then I could see this going to an eight maybe even a nine if they kind of pump it with some some content but this is a really good starting spot uh and I'm excited to see what they do so that's my thoughts on stifling dark let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other
than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tents or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you