Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:56

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to More Games Unlocked. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over Dinosaur Island. What? What is it? 2017 when life was good. Uh yeah, so one, there's a couple reasons for us doing a review over this. Uh well, actually three reasons. Like one, it's uh fun to always go back and re-review uh games that were all the all the buzz back in the day. At this point, this game is eight years old. Came out in 2017.

Um I remember where I was when this game came out. Uh cuz I think you showed it to me. Yeah.

Uh cuz this was like the epitome of Kickstarters back then.

It wasn't super expensive to get the

Wasn't super expensive. Yep. So they had a lot going for it. I want to say this is the game that put Pantosaurus on the map probably.

Was this their first game?

It wasn't their first game.

It wasn't their first game.

This was their kind of their biggest

Okay.

hit at that point.

Yeah. And funny enough that from for the most part their best games are their dinosaur ones. But so that's one reason. Second reason is as of the time of this recording, they're going back on Kickstarter for a totally deluxe upgraded version of the game that is pretty much just hopefully just a streamlined jued up blinged out version of of this. And the uh the third reason is because it's it's an old video on my channel. So, how does this game hold up eight years later?

I think it holds up extremely well.

Yeah.

Like, I really, funny enough, don't have a whole whole lot of issues with it. And it's very fascinating with how much buzz this game got. Pretty much no one talks about it. You never hear anyone talking about it. Especially I don't even see people talking about the the current Kickstarter, right,

where it's like, "Oh man, I've been I've been waiting for a Dinosaur Island version that had magnets." Like, thank God. It is uh a worker placement game that was broken up into four four phases where you are building up a dinosaur theme park. Uh, and I mean if you love Jurassic Park, you get to play it in board game form without the IP of Jurassic Park. Brad, what do you think? What do you think of Dinosaur Island 8 years later?

Well, I haven't played this game in at least 5 years.

It was and it was pretty easy to jump right back into which, you know, cuz it's it's one of those games that when we

when I showed it to you,

y

back in the day, it's such an easy teach because you just teach it. It's like four little segments of a game and you just teach each segment and it doesn't take

long to learn how you how you how you go and stuff. I like the um he you don't have the box cover and all.

I do not have a wooden insert that I'm tired of.

Everything with this game is like this whole '90s themed stuff. I mean like that's the first player mark the slap bracelet and

hell yeah.

Bring these back.

There was even Pog or like Pogs that came in in the

Oh, really? in my case

and stuff like that. So, it's all like '90s themed and art is like psychedel like bright colors and stuff.

Well, I have the I have the I always think these were like gorillas. So, I have the

but I have the rule book and then their their expansion Totally Liquid is even more like

right

retro. So, you know, it's it fits like that. But even after playing it for 5 years, like my my uh opinion of this game hasn't changed. Like it stayed the same even though it's an older game.

Yeah, it's this is almost a game that I feel would stand the test of time with even without having the expansion. Funny enough, we we played this again with the expansion, didn't even touch it. Uh, now they do they did a lot of really cool stuff here. And it's almost weird because we're talking about this game like we're we're unearthing a relic from the 80s. Like what they did here was really cool uh for its time. It's like was 2017 really that long ago. Uh, but you just see the evolution of Kickstarters. Like if this their current Kickstarter is like 150 to get like everything. And I was like, "God, that's so cheap." Oh my. Just because now every Kickstarter is like,

if this was done by Sean or Awaken Realms, it would be 300ucks.

Yeah. Three, 400 bucks with every micro expansion of every single dinosaur, it'd be obscene. Sean would have a huge miniature of a T-Rex.

Yeah, that's a scenario. The T-Rex, I'd buy it, but well, maybe not. Sean doesn't seem to uh release their games anymore,

but it it they did a lot of really cool stuff with the with like you mentioned the different phases and the slap bracelet I keep [ __ ] with. Um, but when you're teaching this game, because I've heard people who didn't like the phase system because it felt disjointed in that how does phase one affect phase three and phase that you're doing? But I

I don't see it.

Oh, yeah. Phase one very much affects phase two.

No, no, no. It's not that it doesn't, it's just they're just not seeing it connect when it's not all in one big big board. Uh yeah, they they definitely do you. But it's like when you're teaching the game, it's like, okay, here's what here's how phase one works. You only have you see these workers, they're only for that. And it's just such a clean experience. Phase two is you're buying stuff to upgrade your lab for phase three. and and then all of that. I mean, phase four just kind of feels almost like the outlier, even though that's the culmination of everything you've been doing is to phase 4. But one thing I did kind of find out that maybe can show the cracks in this game a little bit is how much fun you have in the way this game is is based off your objectives, right?

Because the way these objectives happen to come out was all hyper specific on get as many dinosaurs in your park, increase your security level,

and then the game's over.

And it doesn't incentivize you to be like, "Oh, well, I want to get this really cool Dunlio Dunlioas or whatever how that however that's pronounced. That's where that's four excitement and four points, but increases my threat by four and it's a it's a cool aquatic creature." or you finally got the T-Rex. But by that point, it's like, well, I already hit two objectives because I got three herbivores and then they're super cheap to make. So now the game's over.

Yeah. My plan was I was just going to start loading up T-Rexes if I had another few rounds because of stuff. And I was just

And in a normal game, you would have that, but for some reason, the way these objectives happen to come out, it's like I'm going to go cheap because they just want a lot,

which to some people might think, oh, then that just increases replayability. If your game is swayed by how the objectives are coming out, these same ones aren't coming out. So, it's going to change how you play.

Well, and that's the other cool thing about this is there's three levels of this game. Like, you can choose a short game.

Yes.

A medium game and a long game. So, you can you can even vary

how long

you want to play.

Yeah.

You know, we've tal we were talking before this round, this game, and you know, short seems way too short. Like, a game can be over in no time.

This is the sweet spot. I've played the long game and where it's really fun and you actually get to really fill in your part, which is cool. The game just takes a It takes a lot longer.

It takes a long time. Yeah.

Yeah. I believe I have played this game at every single uh length and I agree with you. I think medium is kind of the sweet spot, but it's like at this point I almost want something that's in between medium and long.

Yeah.

Yeah. Cuz I like filling out the part more cuz like this round with with the objectives like I had nothing but dinosaurs.

Yeah. I finally bought except for one food place, right?

One food place. And and that was just because I had my excitement level because I had so many cheap dinosaurs, my excitement level went up that it's like, okay, I guess I'll um I guess I'll just find a spot to put all the all the people that are coming in. And that that was the other crack is that if you get a lot of little dinosaurs, then you're going to also increase a lot of money because you can have so many dinosaurs to come see.

So if someone's trying to go for the really big dinosaurs, yeah, it's going to probably even out. You get one T-Rex

that's or well, I guess your T-Rex increases your threat or not your threat, your uh excitement by

three. But if I had four of them in here, that would have been 28 points at the end.

Oh, there's seven points. Yeah, they're seven points each with three.

So you and if you have four of them in there, then that's 12 excitement versus the max of eight that I could get. So it does behoove you to get the bigger ones, but it just takes so many so much energy that based off the objectives, you're not going to have the time. So, and long just kind of feels like, yeah, you fill this out, but it's like this comes out really well and cool, but then the rest of the game is kind of like, well, I don't I don't I my lab's full. I don't need any more stuff.

I can only hold so many specialists, so this stuff doesn't really do anything. So, phase two is a wash. Phase one is very important based off how the DNA dice come out because you're going to need them for this. So you're really living for a little bit of phase one, no phase two, majority of phase three to see the culmination in phase four.

Yeah. Phase two is like a setting up stuff a little bit

and filling out your board, I guess, with the with the logo.

That's true. The attractions

attractions. Yeah.

Yeah.

But they're so expensive.

Yeah, they're insanely expensive. But again, if you if you're able to do this and you do have a lot of money,

and it's not that that's really a big complaint. It just

those are the little things that you see 8 years later whenever you see so many of these maybe not necessarily these kind of games that come out, but

the the refinement of worker placement over the years has

and that's what I'm hoping. I have literally not looked at the new stuff, but it would it would be

um it would be cool to see if if they cleaned up anything like that or if they're like

magnets. Well, that's the thing. Like in my opinion with this game, like if you have the deluxe version of this game, I'm I'm not backing the other one because I don't Yeah,

even if there is little improvements, it's not I don't play it that often to right

to

upgrade this this version. Yeah, I am backing it mainly uh just because I hate the wooden crate,

which back then when I was getting I'm like, "Oh, that's awesome." But as we see whenever you kind of like

whenever you organize it in a almost weirdly deluxified way, you're less incentivized to play it. Mhm.

Uh I mean it's it's the Everdell effect where I had this wooden crate and it's not in my shelves where I'm looking at them. So it's over there and I'm like, "Oh yeah, Dinosaur Island's over there." And cuz I have I don't know where it's at. Uh it might be down there. I have Dinosaur World and that's just in a box,

right?

So it's in a regular box, not a wooden crate. So

Well, in the world of 3D printing now, the wooden boxes aren't

Oh, yeah. Because you could just print an insert for this.

Exactly. And and the what I've learned, especially with like the Gloom Haven second edition insert, is the wooden inserts are designed to store the game. The 3D inserts are from people who are playing the game and they're designed for you to be like,

"Okay, now we're ready to play."

Yep.

Um, but this game does have a lot going for it. Obviously, I'm not sitting here a I'm not like hired by Pandasaurus. Uh, they wouldn't ever hire me anyway. like two of their games

like Far Away. That's one.

That's true. That's three. Uh but I've but Emerge and Dead Man's Cabal was trash.

Dead Man's Cabal wasn't any any better.

So, uh so I'm not out here advocating for if you have all this stuff, then it's probably not worth it. But that's kind of where where I'm at. I guess the question is for you and and for me since it's we've probably taken so long to play it. Did replaying this game kind of incentivize you to want to play it more? Is it or is it kind of has it fallen into that category of games that you'll break out every 5 years?

No, I think cuz I mean it's one of those ones, you know, you're getting refreshed on it again after 5 years or whatever. I mean it's one that Amy likes. I know. So we just

I have a couple thousand games now. It's just like

these kind of games do fall back until you play like oh yeah that was good. It kind of moves up the hierarchy a little bit to get played more. It's just

when you have so many games

you can only play you only have so many hours in a year to

Yeah. so many times to try and get it to the table. Even though this game does not take long to to play at all. So, yeah, a lot of stuff that they've thrown in here. I I would love to see like I think more lab building is would be cool. Uh I love the idea of the plot twists. Those are always kind of a fun little wrinkle into the game without completely breaking it. Um I did find myself though by while we're playing it because I had kind of a system that I was like, "Oh, I don't really need anything in phase two or in phase one." like you kind of run out of things to do. So, it it is it is still a good game and I think to some people it' probably be a great game. I don't think it's the score I gave it all those years ago at this point.

Um, you have any negatives on it?

Not particularly. I mean, like

not enough slap bracelets,

you know? It it does surprise me and I remember being surprised about this the last time. This just the the cost of the attractions seems wild, you know, and and stuff like that,

especially cuz they're added to the row,

right? So,

like that's such a weird thing cuz it's not really worth it.

So, I mean, but that's not really I mean that's that's maybe that's something that changes, you know? Who who knows at that point, you know?

Yeah. But uh but no, I I mean there really isn't. I mean this is a this is a pure theme ripoff of Jurassic Park like you said earlier. I mean you have the amber the amber dice which are awesome

which are so cool.

You know it'd be even cooler if they had like a little mosquito mosquito in it or something but

but uh but no, you know the metal coins are awesome because they're like tokens that on the back of them have

you know dinosaur island on it and stuff. Um, but like I said, you know that if you have this version, I think you're good. Unless something gamebreaking is changing. I haven't even looked at the deal because I haven't been

I looked up to see if there was an upgrade pack and they flat out said no because they'd have to completely they're they're replacing everything. Yeah.

Like it's a completely overhaul of the game. I will say though, funny enough, because I remember when the expansion came out, I was like, "Oh, finally." Like, and it's a modular expansion. adds like PR events, adds uh spe like specialized attractions that you can have. Uh obviously adds the marine dinosaurs that was included in this. Well, one of them, the mar the marine creatures. I I actually don't think you need it. You really don't.

I have it. Like I just have the upgraded base game. And

yeah, as coming back so many years later, it feels like that expansion almost bogs it down a little bit. Now, the marine creatures is a nice add-on, but the riskto-reward factor isn't worth it. Like, they increase your excitement by four, and they're worth four, but your threat goes up by four.

It's like, geez,

it almost seems like if one of the game objectives was based on on that when is the only time cuz if one of those had something to do with water creatures, Yeah. it would have been possible than doing that.

Yeah. Another game mechanism that I think is archaic. you see it a little bit um in I feel like I played a game recently that had this and I really don't like it. Uh is when the game ends, you finish out the round, then it's over. I think that needs to die and you always do one more round.

Yeah.

Cuz so many people are building up for like okay because then it's like if you get one more round then everyone doesn't feel like they're just kind of like oh gez okay I guess well there's no way I'm winning. Yeah. versus I was trying to plan for next round and I guess I can't. So, and some people might say, "Well, then keep an eye on the objectives because it's a player thing where you're trying to end it, but you can only do so much."

Well, [ __ ] I mean, you you threw out so many dinosaurs that one that one round. I mean,

you bought that thing and you threw out what, three or four dinosaurs all in one turn.

Yeah, it was it was one buildup phase and then uh to do that then I kind of sat on DNA and then I was like, "Okay, boom, boom, boom." And then they were so cheap

to build that. There we go.

Hit that. And that was actually two objectives I was able to hit,

right?

Just But I think also the rule book is atrocious to look at. It is it's just no no lines, no no separation. It's just a wall of weird text.

It looks like a type like it was typed on a typewriter.

Yeah. Yeah. No. Okay. I that's what you meant.

Yeah.

I was like, "Yeah, of course it looks typed." But no, it it just is unappealing to the eyes looking for stuff. The wording just it just feels it them doing an upgraded version of this game honestly makes sense,

right?

Uh and I am excited for it, but I I would never say it's this game is oh this game sucks. Really go out and get the upgrade.

Right.

Uh but in the past, Brad, if you had to guess what I gave this game in 2017, what would you think? I give it a 10. Oo, I gave this game a perfect score. Now, I'd give an eight.

Eight's where I'm at. Same as I I was going to say what I was looking up because I saw the designer.

Uh Jonathan Gilmore, he did Dead of Winter

also along with other stuff.

Interesting.

Yeah,

Brian Lewis is the principal in American Dad.

But yeah, Dead of Winter was his probably other really big one. Um,

that game kind of interesting.

Dead of Winter could go for an upgrade.

I need to play that again. I just don't have a group. But I I really love the game. I just haven't played it forever because

So he did Dinosaur or Dinosaur Island, Dead of Winter, Wasteland Express, Delivery Service.

I remember that. Path of Light and Shadow.

I am aware of all those games.

Flip them up. Dead of Winter.

I am aware of all of those games. I have played

62 game credits.

Okay.

A lot of [ __ ]

I have played two of them. Dead of Winter in this one. Uh the other one was oh wait I remember seeing Wasteland Express Delivery Service.

I owned it at one point but it wasn't great. So

it looked like it was Pick and Deliver and that I mean that's like Fetchqu Quest the game almost but

Vault Wars which is an awesome one.

Oh yeah.

Anyway, so I Yeah, it has dropped two points which anyone who actually thinks scores matter might be like oh so it's not a perfect game. No. And it probably never was.

No. I mean, is Endgame really per I like it would be amazing to look back on games I give tens this year in 2025 and if we're all still alive eight years later later uh to look back on those games and be like was that a 10? It's it's very hard to maintain a perfect score cuz you're you're a victim of the the uh you know the hype and and FOMO. So yeah, I I specifically I remember even having that conversation when I first did this review of giving it a 10 just because I was enamored by how the different phases work. The theme was really good. You didn't really I mean you had work replacement games but like it all flowed so well with the lab works and now it's like everything here nothing is egregious. Everything works.

You get to learn the game and remember the game. So, which now there are some games you play and this it's like I I don't remember. I don't remember how to play that.

Well, eight's really good still. I mean, that's

what eight's really good still.

Oh, it is for sure.

It is. Yes. So,

this actually got me more excited that I am backing the current the current Kickstarter. Uh cuz I was you always have those moments where it's like I remember that game being really amazing and then you back and upgrade you back something then you get then you play and you're like ah [ __ ] this isn't actually that good anymore, right?

Um this did kind of re rehestablish that this game is extremely solid and they did a lot of really cool things back then and stands the test of time. Yep. Which is always awesome.

Uh Brad, you got anything else?

I don't think so.

All right. Well, that is our thoughts on Dinosaur Island. I guess kind of totally liquid, but let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved