Biome Review: Finally, A Nature Game Where You May Eat The Young Of Other Players
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is farell and we're Bor of it and Welcome to our review of biome the new Challenger in the crowded Wildlife theme with terrific components scen in this one to four player card driven game you'll be attracting different wild life to different habitats within your biome each one providing you with a unique action that you can utilize yep so you'll be playing plant and animal Cards into your Tableau and this is going to broaden the strategies you have on offer as you can activate them to do different things you'll also be hopefully adding a bunch of really cute animal uh and you do get opportunities to get plenty of them MH so before we get into how to play and what we think please note we have provided this as a review copy by the publisher and it is the deluxe edition biome has three endgame conditions if a player reaches 120 points if a player fills up their player mount with cards or in the fourth season of year three each round is a season and Four Seasons make up the year at the beginning of each season all the players will play simultaneously while they draw cards collect resources and play one card into to their habitat then everyone will
resolve the seasonal effect which changes every season finally players will pick one card on their player mat to activate an action your player board or biome is split into three habitats and each card will have a preferred habitat showing where it can be played along with being one of seven types of cards I.E your standard bird mammal tree type tags these play into achievements which give play set goals something like have four mammals in your biome points will come from pretty much every corner like when you play a card claim achievements or activate your cards of note when discussing points are these spring and summer seasons in Spring birds that are next to trees and rabbits that are next to plants will create nests full of babies then in the summer Predator cars will try and eat the babies of other players the surviving babies have a chance then to be fed and then players will earn points for any babies fed and any babies eaten it's worth noting that there are also multiple ways to play by them within this box so there is a standard game and an advanced game most people start with the standard game and this will have you only having seasonal events in spring and summer the aforementioned breeding and predation if you play the advanced game you have uh events in all four seasons and the events are a little more more trickier a little more meaner such as in uh full
you only get to take one resource instead of two uh due to the lack of resources and you're also restricted in that you can't take two of the same resource in your resource Gathering phase so a little bit more complex there there are also a number of mini expansions such as natural disasters and bful biome which kind of alter the gaml uh a little bit uh just kind of yeah add little bits here and there um which we found relatively interesting uh Bountiful biome was our favorite mini expansion as it just kind of creates more spatial decision- making but it's also worth noting that in the deluxe version what's different is it gives you uh component trays made of this kind of egg carton material which is super nice it gives you uh the Bountiful biome mini expansion and it gives you screen printing on the chicks and the uh rabbits so those are the main differences I I think I want to start by just talking about what probably a lot of people's first impression of buying will be uh I think when you first look at it you're going to think wingspan because you have the board with the cards and there are a lot of birds in this game uh you have the different habitats uh and it's also uh in the back of the rules kind of directly referenced then I think if you're a more experienced board gamer you're going to kind of read the rules and you're going to go where are the decisions I'm making
coming in because there's a lot of steps uh and micro steps and you at least I certainly thought when I read it what decisions am I going to make here because it seems very much you play exactly one card you do this but what I'm glad to report I think both of us are is that it doesn't particularly uh feel like wingspan at all uh which I think is everyone's first first thought uh despite the fact you're playing cards to different habitats and it also actually has a surprising uh amount of kind of decision making based upon the fact that you do have these kind of micro actions yeah I remember when you first got it out you said to me not sure what the game is exactly here but yeah so we were very pleasantly surprised because actually there is a lot of game a lot of decisions and I would say like a lot of puzzle there's what cards you play because you want to be able to activate their actions and then within that you have ones which are maybe resource producing some are points producing they're predations there's that kind of decision there's also a bit of a spatial puzzle about where you place them exactly in each habitat because rabbits need to go next to plants in order to create babies Birds need to go next to trees to to also create their nests so you need to think about that there's also the uh some of the achievements as well particularly I kept going for one which made you you have diverse rows or habitats so you had to get six out of the seven types in
each um either row or habitat and I absolutely loved doing that one I have to say because you really had to consider where you place them not just within the habitat but potentially across them as well and it was fun to me to try and then combo that with cards which gave me actions where I could draw more CS to try and up the chances of of making the diverse rows happen and at some point just kind of accepting maybe it wasn't going to happen and trying to Pivot so yeah pretty much everything you're doing down to even which resources you take is actually quite an interesting decision because we always say we really like games where most of the decisions are kind of interesting right at each step and for me this really ticks up box yeah completely it's definitely a very engaging game biome is surprisingly engaging because of the rhythm of the game it's pretty much all action all the time because the first part of each season sees players doing actions simultaneously of course you're very focused on what you're doing there and you don't have any downtime and then even when it gets to the seasonal events and it goes to turn order you're still very much interested in what the other players are doing because of the predation are they going to eat your babies in spring and summer also in the activation phase some of the actions will kind of give players points give players food or resources so it also means that you kind of stay interested in what other people are doing or you can benefit from it and also at that stage even though it's in turn order
those actions are usually over pretty quick so again the downtime is super minimal so that makes it a really really great game at any player count because of that one of our friends who played it said they really really enjoyed it because of this and yeah the quote all action all the time actually comes from him it's also really good at two players because of that you know kind of interaction stays pretty much the same is all about the predation which can kind of come from that player or that player so it doesn't really matter how many players there are we would say though this kind of comes at the cost of kind of ease of flow of the game or smoothness especially in the phase where players are doing things simultaneously because there are a lot of micro actions as part of that so when you have to discard cards down for example to a hand limit of eight if you discard two you get a resource but then in that phase also collect two resources so it can just sometimes be difficult to remember where you're at in each step one of the key elements that we both greatly enjoy is the way that biome allows you to build out your strategy through the cards you play each card has its own action and while some of them can be good for uh generating resources a lot of resources very quickly a lot more are about scoring and it allows you to set yourself up uh and because there's such a variety of different kind of cards and ways they will give you points you have
a lot of options there from ones that have you collect a lot of resources uh and you get points for that to ones that maybe want you to have different cards in your biome uh the kind of card types and then you'll score off that um some will have you give things to other players uh and a lot of them will actually come down to luck so maybe it'll be flipping a coin or drawing a number of cards from the deck and seeing if you got a certain type and there's just a lot of fun in that and I've just really enjoyed game to game to game kind of carving my own path forward and kind of getting everything I want and then there's also really interesting rhythm of what do I activate when um because the game can end without you expecting it and you don't want to leave some of your kind of big Point players unused so very fun in all that elements and then when you add in the fact that you can kind of breed rabbits and birds and if you feed them you get a lot of points from that uh that's or even you know predating on them or being a getting a one of the two vulture cards and kind of picking up the remains there's a lot of points to be had and that's just a whole another angle to to how you set yourself up um and yeah just I just really and we both really like that element of it there are a lot of luck elements in biome for example some of the actions on the cards come down to a coin flip to decide the outcome some actions will have you draw
a certain amount of cards out of the deck and if a selected one comes out or selected type you'll get a better reward than if it doesn't and the success of predation also comes down to a dice roll I really really enjoy this element of biome I think it adds a bit of spice when compared with other games that are Maybe similar and it's pretty much on you to decide if you want to go down that route and leave your game a little bit more up to luck because not all of the cards are are luck based you pretty much always have a pretty decent hand of cards and a variable choice in what cards you're going to play and you don't have to and you won't activate every card on your board so you can always choose to play one of those cards and then just not activate it and activate something else or just not play it entirely the pred can also be mitigated by planting plants in your habitat where you have babies because the way the dice roll works is the opponent with The Predator has to roll more than the amount of plants that you've got in a habitat so if you have three plants then the player has to roll four or higher so very much on you to mitigate that so I feel like it is within your control now while the luck can be fun in this game there is one area where it has kind of riled us up the wrong way and that is to do with the achievements which are by far our least favorite element of the game and we kind
of have differing opinions on how much we dislike them I think we both agree of a level that they vary in how difficult they are to do making them a little bit unbalanced and we also agree that they're a little bit uninteresting as well um and generic but I definitely think that they're probably the weak point of the design because they give you so many points for doing them first or second uh kind of compared to other uh ways you can get points in the game but you're very hampered by luck of the draw of what comes out and this game does not have any uh kind of wild suits so you're very much stuck with uh what you draw and the biggest problem here is that not only would an achievement kind of say you need to get four Birds it will say you need to get four Birds but you'll have to get one in each habitat and you have a kind of one in seven chance of drawing a bird card on average but then if you need a specific habitat that obviously then add kind of the one on three or one in three probability on top of that and it's kind of like if you would think to Wings band scoring if you're familiar with that you would never be asked to have birds in a specific habitat with a specific Nest type or something like that because the
probability goes too far against your favor and while we've never cared particularly about you know games like arova or tering Mars and the kind of luck of the draw and the card shuffle here I found myself frustrated way more than in any other game I've played just of not trying to get the right cards um so I think it is one area that will house for all a little bit just because it kind of is the only area that's really introducing some frustration to our games of biome final thoughts I think for me again kind of All Odds when you look at it and you first read the rules uh biome has been a great experience uh you know it's got the production it's got the game play I think there are elements that won't go over some so well with some people I think I personally am not a big fan of the way achievements are done mainly tied in with the card Randomness and the fact you don't have that wild suit and you're kind of trying to get both like two symbols on one card which kind of amplifies but the momentto moment gamepl the kind of decision making the strategic planning you do of putting yourself in for certain things and trying to set yourself up um the fact that like a lot of times when you're moving which we haven't talked about on the points track you're getting rewards and you spin those in to doing more stuff uh a lot to like about it for sure for me yeah I agree and I think I'm less bothered by the kind of Randomness than
you I totally get your points and agree so if it's something that would potentially bother you than you know something to consider but for me I quite like the elements of Randomness and like I talked about I do think you can mitigate it or just pivot your strategy there's plenty of kind of flexibility to be able to do that so I actually really really love this game I'm quite uh enamored with it to be honest yeah so big recommendation from me if this type of thing you think you're going to like it yeah I mean if you're into your nature games and you don't care how many you have then I think this is definitely worth picking up for sure so that was our review of biome we hope it was helpful if it was please consider subscribing and we really appreciate you watching so we'll see you next time byebye bye