Mandala Stones board game review
Transcript
this episode of brains on games is about an abstract game where players are choosing and arranging colorful stones to score points welcome to brains on games i'm dr brian mcdonald and this episode like i said we're going to talk about an abstract puzzly spatial kind of a game where players are choosing stones in a way that's going to allow them to score points it's a game that was sent to me by the designer not too long ago a game called mandala stones now this is a recently released game so this isn't a preview this game is already out in the wild but it is a game that can be played with two to four players it can be played by kids age 10 and up and you can play a game in about half an hour let's take a look at mandala stones there are three boards that you have to think about when you're playing mandala stones this one down here at the bottom is well probably the most important one because this is where you're choosing the stones from you're going to choose stones from this board and then each player has a board like this their artist board the player board where they're going to place those stones and then later use them to score points there each player has a victory point tracker up here at the top of their player board the third board that players have to think about is this one right down here again on the bottom i think on your right if my spatial skills are strong enough but this is where you put the stones when you've scored them and you might you might score some additional victory
points uh by placing stones on here it also dictates when the game will end one of the things that i like about mandela stones is that it is a game that's fairly simple to understand but there is some complexity in terms of how you play out your turns so it's easy to explain easy to bring new people in it's fairly easy to set up there's a limited number of choices in terms of what you can do but the way those turns play out is going to be different every game you start with an empty board like this the board has circles on it and these little flowers and you're reaching into this bag and you're pulling out the colored stones in order to one at a time you're placing them on those little flower spaces until each one has a four stone tower then you randomly place these artists on these four spaces of the board there's these little circles where the artist can go the stones and the artists are going to have one of two patterns there's a flowery pattern like this one i don't know if you can see it on the camera it's sort of a flowery one they're the same on the top and the bottom so it doesn't matter what orientation you place them in and there's a pattern that's more round that looks like this and those you may be able to see are the same patterns that are on these stones if you choose to pick so your all you can do is pick from the board or score from your player board but if you choose
to pick which is what you have to do on the first turn because you don't have any stones that you can score you choose one of the artists and you move them to another one of these circles on the board let me see where am i going to put this guy i'll place him right over here so now i've placed the artist i get to choose some stones how do you do that well you can only choose stones that have the same pattern as the artist and you can't choose a stone that has another artist adjacent to it so if you look around here i've got three of these flowery patterns that match the artist and one circular one so i could choose three if it weren't for this artist that's right here but this artist is blocking this one so i'm only going to get two stones this time once you've figured out which stones are available to you you have to choose the one that you're going to be begin your pick with which means that they're going to go that stone is going to go on the bottom of the stack that you're choosing so you pick a starting stone and then you go around clockwise and you take all the eligible stones you have to take all the stones that are eligible you can't only take i couldn't only take one of these if i'm eligible to take two in this case let's say i'll take a red one first and then i'll take a purple one and that's how the stack is going to go on my player board once you've picked your stones you're going to place them on one of these empty spaces you can't
stack them up onto a space that already has stones on it but you're going to place them on an empty space here on your player board these are where the towers go when you begin to score the towers each of these stacks has a different way of scoring they're going to earn you a different number of points once you've picked your stones and you've placed the the tower that you've created on your player board then the next player gets to do the same thing choosing either to pick from the board or to score some towers that are on their board and the play continues in that way okay i've set things up now i'm only one player but i i pulled i picked stones as if i were playing the game it's a little easier for me because i don't have someone else moving the artist around and trying to take stones too so i wasn't competing with anyone but now i've got my player board filled each of the towers has some stones on it if this happens i have to score because i don't have an empty space to put anymore i can't pick any more stones once all of these tower spaces are full on my board and maybe i would have scored before i had everything filled up when scoring you need to have at least two stones on the top of your stacks that have the matching color it doesn't matter what pattern whether they're the flower or the round circle they have to have the matching color in this case i can't score red or yellow or purple because i don't have two of those facing up on two different towers i can only score blue and you can score in two different ways if i choose to score
just the color i would take these three stones off and i would score one point for each of them but it's much more interesting to score whoops it is much more interesting to score by the tower instead because that's what's going to earn you lots of points why might you score by those chips it might be to get a different color facing up on the top it might be to clear a space so that you'll be able to do something different or pick some more stones next time so you might just be trying to get things out of the way or you might be trying to earn some points on this the the scoring board over here which we'll talk about if you choose to score by the tower you need to have at least two towers with the matching color stone on top again the pattern does not matter if i were able to score this one scoring is according to the number of towers of differing heights i have on my board here i've got one of height one i've got two of height three of height two and one of height three so i've got a one a two and a three that's going to earn me three points if i were able to score from this spot which i can't because it's not blue here you score according to the height of your tower but you score four points if it's height one two if it's height two and one if it's three or four this is also by height but it's one three four one this is by height again one two four six so this one wants to be short this one wants to be taller but not too tall this one wants to be the
tallest one and here you score according to the number of different colors in the stack plus one so for this one there's two colors so i would score three points because i can score three different towers because the blues are facing up i'm going to earn four points for this one i'm going to earn this is height three i'm going to earn four points for that one so that's eight and three points for this last different color so that's 11 altogether once you've taken those those stones off your board and revealed whatever's whatever color is underneath you're going to put those on this spiral board here and they start in the center let me make sure that i get them on the right spots and if i had been able to cover up this spot or this one i get plus one victory point or plus two victory points but i didn't cover those up so i get my 11 points from those three towers i move my little hockey puck up to the number 11. if i manage to get more than 50 there's a plus 50 token that i can put on my board but i didn't do that this time obviously and this is going to start to fill up as each player scores more and more stones the end of the game is triggered when a stone covers up this number of hands according to the number of players in the game so in a two-player game the game would end here you're only going around this far in a three-player game you go a little bit farther in a four-player game further still
once you do cover up that space so i played a two-player game a few a bunch of two-player games with my son once you cover up that space then you make sure that you finish the round so everyone has the same number of turns and then the game is all over and that is mandala stones in a nutshell it's super simple in terms of the actions you can do you're choosing either pick or score and there's only a few ways that you can do that it's more about how things are arranged on the board in order for you to maximize your points you are using a lot of visual spatial reasoning skills when you're playing this game just look at the way this board is laid out you've got to think about which colors do i want to choose how can i maximize the number of stones the number of points by stacking the stones to a certain height can i block another player from getting the number of stones that they want i will tell you you know if on on this tower where you you you get six points if you manage to stack it up four high uh my son and i were constantly trying to block one another from being able to get four stones first of all it wasn't common that you'd have four of the same pattern around one circle and second of all boy you had to be able to do that when there wasn't somebody adjacent to one of those stones who was blocking you so you're you're thinking about where's the other player going to go where are you going to maybe you don't want to move this artist because it's blocking something you know the other player is going to want you're also thinking about what order am
i going to take those stones in what color do i want to have on top and then you're reversing it because you have to start with the bottom and build it up so there's so much spatial reasoning that i really appreciate and then on top of that you need to plan ahead to maximize those points i took all of those blue ones off and now i have right now only two towers i can score for not very many points there's only one color here this is only worth two points over here what am i going to do i i need to figure out some way to get some extra points here i might not want to score maybe i shouldn't have scored those those three although i had to score something i i is by scoring those three i've left the next player who scores is going to get that plus one victory point maybe even if they score four towers all the way up to plus two so it does uh complicate things in terms of the planning and there's lots to juggle in your mind as you try and take an organized approach to work towards a goal what are the skills involved when you're working towards a goal and planning ahead if you're if you're doing any of those things those are executive functioning skills super important abilities tackling things in an organized way uh resisting your your first impulse and and thinking ahead about your moves and like i said planning working memory is one of those executive functioning skills that whiteboard in your mind where you juggle information and there is a lot to juggle you're not just well i mean you're doing the mental math of figuring out how to maximize
those points you're doing some spatial prediction here but there's one other complication that i didn't even mention each of the players is going to have two of these special cards that give them extra victory points it's like a mission that they're going to to have at the start of the game so you shuffle these up each player gets two of them and then they might be working towards this one says you'll earn seven victory points if you end the game with at least three redstones on your player board that's a lot or more redstones than any other player so you get two kinds of options there six victory points if you end the game with exactly three stones on your board you only get to score one of those but boy if you're thinking about that you're thinking about the towers you're thinking about blocking the players you're thinking about whether you're going to score and maybe leave things open for the other players to get some extra victory points my goodness there's a lot of working memory going on when you play this game and like i said it's so simple that 10 year olds can understand it but mastering it i think is a really good i mean it gives you an opportunity to practice all kinds of skills uh the other thing i would say is that because it's a game that's so simple to explain i mean the options for your turn pick and score are on this one little tiny card this little square card the rule book is a little bit bigger but i mean it gives examples it's not much bigger than that
i i mean it's also a game that you can pull out for new players people who maybe aren't as into strategic board games but it'll give them a chance to kind of exercise that brain power in a way maybe that they don't often get to do because who who plays games like this all the time if they're not a regular board gamer like i am thanks to the folks at board and dice for sending mandala stones we had some fun playing this game and i'm looking forward to playing it again so i can just practice more and maybe get some some good strategies under my belt so i can trick my son and make sure that i defeat him you know we we were pretty evenly matched in the games that we played together so if i can practice with some other friends i'll be able to beat him next time we play if you have any questions or suggestions for me you can leave them in the comments below this video or you can email me at brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.ca is the website that's where future episodes will go and the previous episodes are up there already brains on games is the twitter handle and the facebook page and the instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified about future ones you can head on over to youtube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully i'll see you next time
you