Viticulture: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for vidi culture uh this is a game that has been a long time coming uh for for the channel um for some reason i just have never have never done it the main reason is because we'll shortly have the cooperative expansion on the channel but this game has been around for quite some time in 2013 when it came out this was stone i don't know if it was stone meyer's first game but it was their first game that brought in the uh automata the solo ai player that's i think that's actually where they coined the term but essential edition came out a few years later including like the best parts of things and then it also included the uh expansion essential editions as well so basically if you're gonna play vidi culture just get the essential edition because it houses everything that you probably really need to play the game um but uh with that being said what do you guys think of any culture i like it i've always liked it um we played this off camera um it was on our little meeple fill-out list oh yeah um i've always liked it yeah yeah what do you like about it i like that it's about wine i also just like the mechanics in general i like how it's set like it's separated into seasons um i don't usually plan when i play these games but this game i was like counting down
workers like i was starting in winter and i was like i want to do that but i want to do that so this is like how many workers i'm going to need yeah and that's how you know what i like to do yeah i'm not just just like right no this is definitely one of those like almost like iconic work replacement games that brought in the grande worker that really just opens up the the board because it stops you from like you can't really block someone like and you have one chance yeah although although there were a couple of times that i i know i want to do that but i think i want to save my grande worker just in case yeah yeah yeah exactly and that's what i always do you can use it only once um and i mean but i almost always hold on to it it's always my last worker i'm playing just because it can act as a regular worker as well and it would be interesting if they changed it to where your grande worker could only go somewhere that uh someone else had already gone that's true almost like the grand worker is the manager right right um so but uh brett what do you think i i'm split i have a fundamental problem with this game now after years of playing so many different games and playing another game that's very similar to this vinos i do have a extreme but fundamental problem is it because of what i just did or no no no that's that's perfectly fine that's a sweet move is it because no it's because
but did that uncover what you're yes okay well it wasn't your long um because i do it because i don't know what you're about to say so i'm going to say is you know as you know i am not the heavier thinking strategizing across multiple years and stuff like that so i didn't play a very strong strategy i just started out with i'm going to get all the workers i can right up front because worker placement that's your biggest resource problem right so that was my goal every single time i saved up three or four and i saved up one worker to get more work and then the one time i helped you that was the last one right and i wasn't even totally sure i needed that last one yeah right off the bat but yeah thank you in any of it but you know that just gives you so many other options then of course i become overloaded with options right um and do i want to save up resources so i guess so the options to say you no longer have to stress about exactly where you need because you have six workers total um i think it's six two four five is it five five regular one position okay yes six six uh yeah i had six uh and uh so it's like there's there's no more stress of where you need to go like you can just it was a little but not much it was it was more of well i can only do this now and i can leave this so the timing is much more important yeah and that's where i start getting bogged down and stop enjoying games so much is when i have to plan out things very carefully great news for people who like that right um but i didn't hate it it just just a little bit more than a real
effort that i really want to put into enjoying a game yeah i tried i i actually at at a certain point i tried going a minimalist approach and seeing i'm like can you win this game without actually having a bunch of wine because there's so many different ways to get victory points i mean i you could just pile up you know money and then just go trade yeah i mean because there's nothing stopping you from also like i could go there with my grande and then take another worker and go trade again as long as no one takes that spot yeah and it's like oh okay well i'll just trade in nine coins for three points and or what my actual plan was when i decided i then want to go minimalist i was actually i made a level seven sparkling i was going to go here and i was gonna sell a wine token a sparkling wine for four points and then you know place another one um and the fact that you can do that it's it's weird because it's like well that's great you can get victory points for doing a bunch of other stuff but this is a game about winemaking and i'm not making any wine yeah i'm trading yeah [ __ ] so the one time i went to sell this field i didn't particularly want to sell a feel i didn't feel like i needed the money right what i was going to do was go there sell it get the money keep the money and then the next year go there buy it back buy back and then just keep doing that getting one more point every time yeah exactly so it's like it's it's very strange and that's why whenever because we've played venus on the channel and i've i've always been like well which one do i like more this one is definitely you're for your more casual gamers venus is a very it's the heavy
heavy euro um winemaking game but in that one you actually are busting your ass to make wine yeah and then here it's like i filled one order and it and i had a level one vine and i traded for the other two and then i just aged them up and i'm like okay and so while you can do stuff like that that that's all fine here's where my fundamental problem is i finally see what makes people upset about this game these cards are so [ __ ] like literally like your eight-point swing is impressive through no and this is gonna sound worse i mean but there's no strategy of your own yeah that's you like you didn't build up it's just like oh lucky me on this order lucky beyond like cause you just had so many visitors that's just like uh you know age wine you know phil wine likes like it's like you don't have to do any of the actual work replacement you just went to one spot to play cards that just let you do free [ __ ] and playing this game we played it also the other day and i was like yeah those cards are just so absolutely swingy it takes any strategy out of the game they're either really good or they're really just i'm gonna toss that yeah yeah very situational i don't know if you noticed me laying cards face down those are the ones i already know i'm getting rid of the year yeah i would or i'm gonna sell them last time you played i would just like kind of put them to the side because i'm like i know i can
get rid of this right if i have to get down right as soon as you're on i went well i'm not gonna use that and for other games and i've bitched upon on games in the past uh for this whenever you can top deck points i really start to not not like the game even if it's just me where it's just like oh like you play the card oh everyone can draw from here it's like oh okay hey look at that i'm gonna play that right now gain two coins for each empty field you own or gain one for each plant gain one point for each planted field you own like i mean obviously shitty for me but great for cat because she could have drawn this and been like oh look at that three points did i earn that absolutely not it's just look at that technically yes but you didn't plan for that ability yeah it is it's all random you earn it by drawing up a bunch of sp potentially special cards right yeah right and hoping because originally at first i was just going to avoid them because again that's too much for me to keep track of yeah but i kept getting free ones i wasn't going to use use a worker to draw well you can't here you can see to draw upwards no we'll draw fill orders but you can't draw visitors yeah um which i believe in the in in the regular video culture there was a spot to go i think it was in the spring or something you could go to actually draw them um but they changed it to that which obviously that's way more preferable um to only get like a few but but we end up getting so many anyway well you did well we all did i thought i thought we all had a bunch of different visitor cards i mean if they were coming out i wasn't i guess you played more i'm sure
um and that's kind of where it's like well if this game is no longer yeah it's no longer like man i i like what's the point of even saving up or aging or building these large sellers whenever i know for a fact that they're in there and i'll just you know keep just drawing them until hey here's one that lets me build my large seller for free yeah um i got i got a little frustrated up front when both of you got those cards yeah i'm gonna have to spend like 22 there at some point getting there yeah exactly and that's it it feels very unfair when it's like well i wish i could have drawn that yeah my balance is they're up for grabs for anybody yes but then it's a luck based game more than strategy it is no different than real life where you watch people and you're just like yeah i guess if that was the hand i was dealt sure right but we don't want to play life exactly theme doesn't always make good game mechanics yeah hey in your vineyard the merchant visited you great um but then if that's the case then why play you know like if it's so much like real life then it's like i'll just i'll just accept that as terms of reality and just not play this yeah i'm still thinking what would it be like without the visitors or the buildings well think about it uh it's also very frustrating whenever you it's like in what vineyard like because this is also breaking reality in terms of like theme why can't i plant the wines i want to plant i have to get super lucky that
because whenever i was drawing those my silo because my plan was to do exactly what cat did my plan was to constantly have an influx of wine age them move them over and be able to fill any order that came my way yeah but every single one i drew required me to have the trellis or the irrigation which they're very cheap to um to build but it's almost like a pain in the ass to be like ah okay i'll build a structure yeah i will say build it like this you have to have them you do and and until my final move you were right there in the lead or we were together right the whole time and you again filled no orders yeah had almost no grapes yeah and that was going to be an argument i was going to bring up once again it's like well i didn't even really play like i just did off [ __ ] to just get victory points i got i filled out one order and it was it was i think it was six points but even that was also kind of weird because cat even brought it up she's like my level seven sparkling got me five points it's like oh i had to save up to a level nine just to get one extra point it's like so it does it the orders also does don't say and technically it got me four but i had the fill plus one right and that's how i got six still oh okay because that's it was the extra point as well and that brought me up to 15.
um but it's frustrating that you have to if whenever you start out with orders because it's so random the orders you have to get also have to match the vines that you happen to draw so this game which is why in the early game i was drawing vines yeah crazy to get the combo that i was really looking for right and so you just and eventually you get it and but then it could be like you could have been spending your entire time doing that just drawing and then i could have the one you know visitor that oh plant two things you don't even need the equipment yeah i know the first game we played oh you will you played that one i had that one last game where it's like oh i don't even oh this is a level four that needs both okay well lucky i have this visitor that lets me plant it for free so i don't even have to worry about my two things anymore i didn't even cultivate what i needed i just whatever i pulled i was like you're planting it yeah you're getting what you need and you're planting it because i didn't do that last time and i didn't plant until like until wait later way earlier yeah so this was more of kind of like an experimental game for me to kind of see if you could go so like off because then it comes down to well then everyone's playing the same game like everyone needs to build the trellis and the irrigation who gives a [ __ ] like just that's what everyone's doing first uh because you have the grande worker you are pretty much able to and the way the turn structure works like everyone's gonna get to get them built and then everyone's drawing vines and then it's just kind of a race to who can fill their orders quicker than
anyone else so then it's like okay well i'm just gonna wake up at two every single time just because you can't take the one spot yeah and even then it becomes a luck game based on are you drawing the right orders right yes that's that was the super frustrating part because like the wines that i work i was able to like plant or the vines i was able to plant like the second one i drew when i drew uh in order i think it was that one was a three white and a seven rose and it's like well i don't even have those vines to plant and at it's at a certain point in the game i now can't go back to try and find them right so i'm already behind because you guys have already planted your uh your vines and you have all the visitors that just let you freely make wine and then freely fill orders so because that's also the other disgusting part about the visitors where it's like um it's like oh man this lets me fill in order i get to play two okay well i have three orders fill that one fill that one oh and i'm gonna go here and fill that one three orders and then that's that's the game yeah like like and most of the ones that let you fill orders give you an extra point so if you just stock up really that's probably one of the strategies is just fill your entire seller and then just get a handful and then just like top deck those winter visitors fill multiple orders and then it's like okay so that's six that get that's seven points oh lucky me i also have that thing so that's eight
points oh here's another eight pointer and then there's a three pointer so there's a 19 points right there in the 25 point game and everyone else is like i was i was i was trying to run a vineyard like slow and steady came close pretty much i mean i'll take you know 22 points off of not playing the game yeah oh yeah i mean that's like 20 well in the essential edition it changed it used to be 20 points okay like was the end game but it also this was a very dumb rule 25 points was the cap so if you hit 25 and you're like well i get extra no you don't it was a very stupid rule which they obviously changed um in the essential edition but i think for me vinos is just if i want to play a wine making game that's just the one i'm going to play i want to make white wine so i'm going to build vineyards and go into into into countries and and that request white wine you know that's the strategy i feel like i'm making there's no luck where it's like oh man i wish i could have gotten five points for that you know visitor yeah so so what's good what's what's good about the game um because this is one of the most beloved it used to be one of my favorites but well i mean at the time it hit some of the greatest buttons yeah it hit its niche perfectly yeah and so it was loaded and it was praised and a lot of
people have not gotten yeah but there are some better spins on it now yeah uh it was also imitated a lot it's a niche theme as well like i can only think of two games that are about wine making yeah and this was i'm sure much earlier yes yeah vignos came out yeah they said what 2013. no vino sorry yeah yes
i lied the first vinos edition came out in 2010 oh wow it came out before and then the deluxe so this is the knockoff uh yeah wow the the the deluxe edition which is what probably a lot of people have played that's definitely the one i've played is um that was 2016. okay but but yeah um vide culture came on 2013 interesting this mechanically is a weird mishmash of of of game mechanics that don't mesh perfectly yeah but they really don't conflict either they're not confusing and confounding each other no i mean it's definitely an engine replacement it's definitely a work replacement fundamentally but there's also an engine building aspect um and there's of course luck to it but each of those where's the engine um building the wine in these into these into these i wouldn't call that a i don't know if i would call that an engine just because you need to do like it's it's broken up like yeah you have to do something to plant the harvest then you have to go do something else to then harvest it and you gotta do something else to make wine like i think it's too broken up to probably because an engine for me is like i'm gonna do this which then allows me to do this this this and this and it's like a running thing that's my own kind of that makes sense um thought process um but you're right it's nice like it's satisfying that you can be like i'm going to harvest like these things and that comes down here and then like i really like aesthetically the glass beads you place them on and it
like it like uh enlarges the number magnifies it yeah it's a worker placement with so many options and a a worker that lets you do whatever you want anyway that you know part of the fun and strategy of a worker placement game is the limitations this doesn't have that that's true uh for some people yeah it's less frustrating for people like me who hate the fact i can't do that again right somebody's always there right so but i mean it has a lot of interesting mitigations to overcome some of the problems of any of these mechanics um you know like i'm drawing a bunch of crappy cards well there's a way you can sell them and get points yeah or money or yeah i think with the essential edition specifically um i don't i don't actually care for the star system it feels like they almost took that idea like i i think i'd have to look at when this came out but i think it came out the same year scythe did um that was coming out that was part of tuscany originally yes yeah and i think that just adds it it really adds nothing like a small area control yeah aspect just to go and get more free random [ __ ] cards uh yeah that's the other way you can get visitors right and then it's like if you did work your entire time and you're like yes i hit 25 and then it's like oh i get you know eight points over there so it's actually i surpass you and win it's like that's not even [ __ ] that's like this offshoot of just whatever of the game yeah
um it feels like they have added that as a layer of complication that it really doesn't need um it's not bad but it doesn't enhance it's almost like it's it's a minor distraction and it really doesn't enhance anything well it's almost like whenever they expanded the board because in original viticulture it was just summer and winter and then you had like abstract spring and fall yes no it happened yeah there weren't actually workable it sounds like they needed extra spots so they're like how the [ __ ] okay uh let's add stars and let's just throw those in um because it i get it it's supposed to be you shipping your wine like thematically i guess to these different countries but i mean venus does that and it's it makes more sense there it's built into the theme rather than being on a edition um and i also don't like the residual payments i think that that's actually in like that's you know inconsequential just because it's so easy to get money well i'm over here with [ __ ] yeah it gets 18. it gets you nothing at the beginning when money is critical yeah and then you end up with lots of money when well most of us when it doesn't really matter right well cat kept spending like hers like the only reason you and i have as much money as we do is because we sold i think she never sold you gotta make money yeah um but it's like i would almost do away with the residual payments or make it victory points like yeah i can see like i i see why it's
there you fill an order so that's like them constantly buying that yeah that's your reputation that you're building but or make that an in-game thing you get extra victory points how high you are but then again that just adds more to it could be insult to injury where it's like oh well i got all the lucky draws and now my residual payments are higher so now it's like oh i get five extra points at the end i will point something out real quick though is that i've heard you on many occasions say i don't want to try to fix a game and yet you want to try to fix this one you want to think of ways that it could be improved right well also shut up no i don't i don't mean i just mean it's good enough that you want to say okay it just needs a couple little tweaks right rather than just no yeah i think it's fundamentally wrong yeah i've had this in my collection for so long that it's almost like weird to not like it as much anymore um but once again that's just because my taste in games has has changed into the fact that if i want to play a game that's of this theme i want to play the heavy strategy game and vino does everything does it does everything for me um if people just want to kind of do a romp of winemaking drink a glass of wine while playing this and not a can or a can of wine and not really give a [ __ ] of of who the visitors are or or any of that play is an abstract game that has a theme yeah
um then i i know why a lot of people like this uh but i think my tastes have just changed that those kinds of randomness where it's like hey here's strategy but there's also so much random thrown into it yeah it's not something i enjoy because i want to strategize and i can't yeah like there's no point even cat said during the run through she's like i just do whatever is handed to me yeah and that's what i said people might like that yeah like i started off with a strategy and then i just i don't know what i'm gonna do i'm just gonna do whatever right i built something i'll just keep milking it you never want to use the yolk totally forgot about it once again my plan and it changed as soon as my starting [ __ ] was drawn was like there's no point in me doing this was to do exactly what cat did have all my and then have the yolk and then i mean the silo was gonna be great because i was gonna constantly just be like harvesting and i was just this was my my my grape areas my crush pads were gonna be full i was gonna move all those over and then just get a bunch of like but it's weird because it's like well you can do that because it's a race to 25 the game's not long enough for you to do that and to be honest i had no idea i was going to hit 25 with that move i honestly thought it was going to have to keep going i wasn't adding it up and going oh if i do this i wouldn't just well i mean even then like a six point swing is huge like and then so whenever you were at seven and then you were at 24 it's just like well there's really i mean i already had the pass so there was nothing cat and i
could have done um because as soon as you did hit 25 it goes till the end of winter and you did it right at the end of winter uh so i mean it was it was a solid play um that i didn't plan at all yeah and i think that's another thing i why i like vino's better is because it's not a race yeah two victory points um there's a certain oh that game never ends there's no victory points there's no point at all uh no it's it's there's a certain set number of rounds and then two of our most victory points at the end like i wouldn't mind so much about the uh the visitors if it wasn't giving constant victory points which has a sure fire first to 25 is ending the game yeah so do you have any problems um nothing that you guys haven't already said do you agree disagree with us so you guys like just suck it up i mean yeah shut the [ __ ] up no i love the visitors yeah no i i agree i mean it is just random i mean i think it's you know it's a game that came out many years ago and years ago it just failed pretty time better games have come out since then better games have been made that's just how the market is the market is inflated as is so that's true i like it yeah yep um i would say would you like better this or vinos but you don't remember vinos and i'm pretty sure you would probably say this this
huh who made things you know how i feel about him you said you liked vinos yeah i do but i think yeah you know just how my brain works i'm a very cultural brain european
you don't deserve me at my at my yoast or you don't deserve my video culture if you can't handle me at my venus it's like what that's probably some weird board game hobbyist they got married they made overbought
no the world doesn't need more of you um well that's disappointing um but i liked it thanks you liked it yeah i know you did great you got eight points at the very end i didn't enjoy and frankly i didn't care about winning i wasn't focused on that i was focused on doing well yeah but i wasn't like comparing myself and again it's always interesting to see stuff like that happen because it's like i wonder if the opinion shifts if that happened against another person i mean like at that point you're dealing with personality type like if you're gonna be a sore loser you're a sore loser thank you for pointing fingers i'm trying to make it no i'm trying to make an observation no it is well it's like not saying you're a sore loser well no because it puts it into perspective like i'm just saying if you're consistently mad and you're just like what does didn't happen to me well okay that's not what i'm saying that's how you're reading into it like i'm just saying it's your personality yeah you're projecting get this work out because because if someone does like an eight-point swing like that they're not thinking of oh how would that be if someone did that to me because it's like oh yeah that was so cool but then would it taste better and would it would more things open up if it's like oh wait yeah that was kind of unfair though i got eight points out of that you know but i don't know that's kind of uh because obviously people are going to be more critical in games that when either they're not doing as well um but it's it's always like is that justified oh yeah because i lost and i still like
it so yeah but you're used to losing it's like um what's what's the what's the the cool mj trait uh expect always expect the worst because then you can't be disappointed right energy treat mj saying is what i meant to say yeah yeah spoiler yeah i guess yeah always that's the worst there's still three people who haven't seen that movie like that was from like the first spider-man homecoming i think she says that oh can't always expect the worst because if you met michael jordan or michael jackson you know that no mj from spider-man always expected i was like the worst because then you can't be disappointed that probably he has said those words maybe not in that exact order but he has said them publish that uh but yeah like i would say the game is not too long for for what it is it didn't feel like it was an endurance it didn't i didn't get tired of it uh a couple more turns and i probably would have this one was about an hour but the one we played the other day was like two and a half that one we had a lot of distractions and i was i was re i was learning the new and i was remembering right stuff that i had screwed up probably my favorite thing about the game though is actually i love the wake up chart i've always liked that like alchemist has that i just like that kind of like hmm because that's just another decision to make to be like man do i want to wake up i'm not going to get anything i go middle chances are they aren't going to go before me and they went before me
it's like and i'm last um but once again kind of going last doesn't really matter there's never a time where i was going and i went last almost this entire game and i it didn't affect me get better bonuses yeah so uh i don't know i think for me this is kind of now showing its age uh i mean i would still play it yeah like if people would be like hey you wanna play video culture like sure um but you won't suggest it probably not like if everyone's if anyone's gonna want to but that's that's the hard part is someone really for some weird reason wants to play a game about wine i would suggest vinos but that's also something i'd have to teach them and not everyone is up to not everybody wants to [ __ ] pour another work replacement everyone but they should no they should no
that's i feel like almost the exact opposite of what you do with one of his games then you'll understand cool yep all right on scale of one to ten what would you guys give any culture the essential edition i think with its age i will give it a solid seven seven i'm saying seven i'm actually at a six okay um but still like above average for you guys slightly above average for me um like it's still not fundamentally bad but you definitely have to go in with a non-strategic mindset at least so sure still not horrible but that is our thoughts on vivi culture let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time i've taken this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you