Hegemony - A brilliant & challenging simulation - TCbH Review
Transcript
The capitalists are fighting for closed immigration policies to distract from their intense lobbying for lower wages. While the working class struggles to unify and promote worker rights, a dwindling middle class is trapped in between, valuing their own prosperity while delicately providing small business opportunities. And the government is trying to figure out how to win the favor of all of these while not getting completely morally or quite literally bankrupt in the process. Oh, I'm sorry. Did you think I was talking about something other than board games? Because today we're talking about Hijgemony. He hijgemany hijgemony. A complex heavyduty simulation of the struggling tensions and interdependency between these classes. which may sound grim, especially in the context of, we'll say, some recent events, but it does a pretty miraculous, if broad job at showing the intersections between these competing points while also trying to be, you know, a fun game. Hegemony is a two to four player asymmetric game where each player represents one of these classes.
In every game, one player is the capitalist, providing the most job opportunities, international trade, and production of resources needed by other players. However, they are dependent on the labor provided by other factions and taxation by the government with victory measured by secured neolbertarian governmental policies at the end of the game's five rounds and accumulation of wealth. Similarly, one player is the working class, providing the largest portion of the workforce, balancing population growth to provide more labor with the food, medical, and luxury needs to achieve prosperity, advocating for more socialist policies, and gaining strength through focused labor negotiation with additional players to round out the middle class, a mechanical and philosophical compromise between the other two, and the state that is largely automated in lower player count games.
All factions have their unique mechanics, advantages, and disadvantages. Rounds involve players taking turns playing a card from their hand, either for the effects listed or discarding it as a cost to take a standard action available to their class. Generally, this interacts with the labor market from building new businesses to assigning workers or proposes a policy change to be resolved at the end of the round or impacting the number of your factions cubes in the voting bag pulled then influenced your media to determine the outcome of policies or buying or selling various goods. Once players have each taken five turns accompanied by a heady list of possible bonus actions, the round is complete. Some cleanup happens, including drawing up to seven cards.
Then play continues until five rounds are done and the game ends. Okay, so first off, can we be real? This game is big. Like real big. not insurmountable and certainly rewarding, but it's got a ton of nuanced mechanics and all sorts of important strategic connotations that are going to inform every single decision that you make, which will have important ramifications for everyone else at the table. Even experienced players are going to want to budget a full 3 hours at least if you're getting a full fourplayer player account and not wanting to feel rushed. But it's worth it. Part of the genius of Hijgemony is that unlike other hyper asymmetric games like Root or Cthulhu Wars, games I love, but where the asymmetry, the distinct way that you intersect with the game and that you accumulate points is really just about leverage over your opponents. here. It's all about what your faction contributes to the ecosystem and what pressures you can put on and are being put upon you that necessitate compromise, which gives it this really weird almost semi-ooperative feel. The capitalists are going to have to assess what the working class is going to put up with and incentivize them to work for them
over working for the state or middle class or even potentially going on strike. But you have to balance that with wealth accumulation. Likewise, resources have to be made available, hopefully selling at a good profit, but not so much that the players who consume them, middle and workingass, aren't turning exclusively to foreign sources. So then you might, I don't know, decide to lobby for really high tariffs ostensibly to encourage local trade. But if you do that without establishing infrastructure such that the other classes are able to obtain from you the very important items that are needed to survive and thrive, then you're going to ally the other factions against you.
Huh? Why is that sounding so familiar? Heck, as the working class, you want more social systems, but you can actively see the state's funds dwindling. And without measured tax policies, the government can suffer collapse immediately reverting numerous policies to a much more restrictive, borderline totalitarian state. In each case, your prosperity isn't really about defeating other players. It's about finding that perfect balance between collaboration, coercion, and control. It is very challenging. It's kind of devious, kind of exhausting, but ultimately super fun. Learning hegemony was a chore. Not just how the game works, but understanding why you do what you do. There's a heavy barrier to entry. Also, even though it looks drier than a box of cornflakes in the San Jose sun, it's very emotionally charged as these are the systems societies are built on. And there are many people suffering under crisis and exploitation simulated by this game. For some, that'll accompany a dark sarcasm and a degree of roleplay as the capitalist uses mass media to favor privatized, aka their healthcare, then buys a private island, whereas the state tries to balance taxation and incentives of the most wealthy to help gain the approval and assist prosperity of the most vulnerable. For some others, this can be mechanically or emotionally too much.
What I really love though is like the best teaching tools, it gives you a similacrim to question your own points of view to understand pressures experienced by those navigating issues outside of your own. Sure, I love liberal immigration policies, but when I can see the impacts of imbalance between available labor and lack of jobs, problems start to rise. And oh boy, is the state even going to survive with low taxes and high minimum wage. It's a flawed system though, as it removes personal conviction, irrationality, and demagogue obsessions over power from the equation, which is probably for the best. But as a faximile for real world structures, it can only do so much when you assume everyone is operating from a self-serving but ultimately rational perspective. Now, a lot of this review has been about the tension between what makes this game kind of difficult and also what makes this game really cool.
But I want to make something clear. This is a good worthwhile game with pretty remarkable balance given the level of asymmetry involved. And if you're in the midweight euro zone, but you're heavier game weight curious, then this is a pretty logical next step for you to take. And the game provides a lot of comprehensive resources to help you along that journey and a surprising level of balance in adjusting for lower player counts. Even going so far as suggesting that if you're learning the game to play it in its two-player mode. Speaking of which, keep in mind even if it's still fairly robust at that two-player count with those specific factions having a lot going on, if you're only ever planning on playing this at two or even three, there's going to be a lot of content that is just forever locked away in the box. with the most dynamic and beautifully messy way of playing the game being with three or four players where you can see the full intersection and levying of competing priorities against one another. For me, hegemony was an intimidating though ultimately extremely rewarding surprise.
A heavy brain burner that's gripping but also taxing. I mean, mentally taxing, intellectually taxing, emotionally taxing, but well worth the investment. This isn't the type of game that I want to reach for super often, but it is the type of gaming that makes me love this hobby. And that is our review. But let me know, what is your thoughts on this game? And what do you want to see as another sort of intersection of realworld events and simulations of tense subjects that can be broken down in a fun though enlightening way? Uh, put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.