Spirit Island Board Game Review - Still Worth it?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews to play for his unboxings but generally like to talk a load of bollocks what's up gaming in general in this video we're going to be talking about a cooperative area control war game i suppose you could call it a war game we're going to be talking about spirit ireland and in this game you'll be taking the role of spirits you'll be trying to fend off invaders by giving the indigenous inhabitants assistance with your special powers that will allow to kick their asses kick them off the island and win the game so in this video we'll be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we tell you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back we'll tell you whether or not spirit island is still worth your time and bother is it about three or four years old i can't remember i don't care so remember if you are new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button subscribe all right and we'll see you after this bollocks so spirit island is a cooperative area control slash war game a lot of people say they say i'm all going but because you'll be engaging in sort of semi-combat with an opponent let's call it a war game right so the first thing you are going to do is you're going to choose a spirit you'll take the corresponding spirit board you'll populate it with all the discs and all
that that you're going to have to stick on the board right then you will make up an island-dependent army plaza and you'll put the island together and you'll place the starting components whether it's the little mushroom hut things on the ball and some invaders and starting spirit counters onto the main board that will be the star itself there's also a board off to the side which contains fear tokens these are used to instill fear final thing into the invaders and there's a deck of cards that you'll be revealing that will help you out as you go through this deck it will make it easier to win the game yeah so this game follows a set number of phases the first phase in the game is the spirit phase and this consists of three sub phases you've got to grow phase you'll be gaining energy and then you'll play and pay for power cards so the first thing you're going to do is you're going to grow yes you'll be choosing one of the options at the top of your player board this might mean that you can put some discs onto the main board to indicate where your spirit has presence it might mean you can take some extra cards or you might be able to gain energy which is basically the currency of this game and energy allows you to pay for the use of power cars that will allow you to wage war on those nasty invaders so next thing you'll do is you'll gain energy this is basically where you're going to get paid you look at the highest uncovered icon on your player board and you'll gain that much energy and you put it to one side so the next thing you're going to do you're going to choose from your hand power cards to play you have to pay the energy costs listed on the card and you'll also see these cards are in two
categories you've got a fast power and you've got a slow power the fast powers will act before the invader has their turn and the slow powers will act after the invaders have torn up so once you have completed the spirit phase and you'll have the invader phases where the invaders run a mock and tear to shreds what you've just accomplished in the spirit phase so the first thing you're going to do in this is you're going to do the blighted island phase if the blight card has been flipped this means that if all of the blight tokens have been removed from that card and placed on the board then nasty stuff will happen it's going to make the game a lot harder so you one of the things you want to do in this game try and prevent different regions for becoming blighted so the next thing you're going to do is you're going to activate any of the fear cards that you have gained up to this point you'll gain fear cards by moving fear tokens from one portion of the main board to the other once you've done that you'll gain a fair card place it in the space that allows you to activate it right now and these are always really really good right so the next thing that you're gonna resolve is the invader actions this could be ravaged it can be billed and it can be explored and there's cards that will be revealed round by round i'll tell you which locations will be ravaged which ones will be built on and which types of terrain the invaders will explore so if there are invaders on that specific type of terrain then they will deal a certain amount of damage they'll either damage the land or they will damage the harm which is the indigenous population of the island right next thing they'll do is they're going to build so if there are more towns than cities you will build a city and in all other cases then you'll build a town you'll stick the specific miniature in
that region right and then the invaders will choose to explore the island and this is where new invaders come on aboard on like coastal regions and then what you do you'll advance the invader cards that way right not that way that way so the next thing you do is once the invaders have dumped all over your property then you'll be able to activate any of the really shitty slow powers they're not actually that she it's just that you've just got wang about waiting for that bloke to knock your door with that massive lump of ganja i mean and after that you'll do a bit of cleanup right so there's other things you've got to be mindful of those elements in this game on the power cards and on your player board there's little colored symbols and if you could meet the requirements of that ability that's listed on your player board then you'll be able to activate that during the phase that is specified on your playable right and this could be quite handy to give you extra actions to take aside from the power cards you're gonna be playing right so there's loads of loads of other little knitty itty-bitty things you'll be able to destroy the invaders kick them off the land they'll be going backwards and forwards like i said there's loads of little itty-bitty rules in this but that's the general idea is that you'll be going backwards and forwards the invaders will be trying to explore build and ravage the land you'll be trying to use your spirits abilities to aid the dahan and kicking them off the island and essentially if you have met the requirements of the main fear title whether it's remove all of the invaders off the board if you got to terror level 2 and there's no towns and cities on the board then you win if you get to terror level 3 and there's no
cities on the board then you win right that's how you win the game but you can lose if there's too much blood on the board if the last blight token comes off with the bright card you are screwed if one spirit is destroyed which means i've got no presence on the board then you lose or if you need to draw an invader card and there's none left then you will lose the game or spirit ireland if you do all the other then you win it got it so what do we like but spirit island so the first thing that we really like about this game is the insane amount of variety that is packed in this game okay the corset does feel like it's half baked right it does feel as if the branch and claw expansion was deliberately kept out in order to make extra money so the corset does feel a little bit lightweight but having said that if you've got all the extra stuff that's available for this then the amount of variety is completely and utterly mind-boggling i mean i think there's like i said 24 spirits or 18 spells i can't remember the exact number because there's probably spirits the synergy between the spirits and the white oh all meld together means that the bloke who created this eric sang tested this game until he went blue in the face there's just an insane amount of different variables in this game so you might choose the vital strength for the earth and the special ability of this one is the earth's vitality and it says that you can defend three in each land where you have a common black hole now like a temple type thing where basically where you've got two presence titles right and their innate powers the ones that use the little glyph type
things they say once it's turned the target spirit may repeat one power card with an energy cost of one or less which is pretty good but this geezer is quite cumbersome he doesn't move around too much but his defense attributes mean that he is tough as old boots right or you might have the shadows flicker light flame the special rules of this one gives you the shadows of the dahan whenever you use a power you might pay one energy to target a land with the heart regardless of the power's range power cards or your innate powers and there and eight powers are you get to gather one invader so this means you could draw invaders towards you to either kick their ass or allow somebody else to kick their ass if they've got a power card they'll have to do that way so there are a huge massive number of these spirits they're all different there's a range of complexity to simple to highly complex way and really i mean i don't think i'm going to be alive long enough to go through all of these even if i live to the ripe old age of 52. so the next thing that we like about this game and we sort of alluded to this in the previous point and this is the training of abilities together whether it's your own powers or laying the groundwork for somebody else to do something really powerful right so these power cards are divided into major minor powers you might have the voracious growth this is going to cost you one energy and it allows you to choose either two damage or you can remove one bite right it's a good way of getting rid of blight yeah or you might have divisions of fiery doom with this really scary face on it
and it allows you to gain one fear and push either an explorer or you can push a city or a town away right a couple of examples of major powers you might have the unlock the gates of the deepest power this has got like some sort of huddle well it looks like that iron creature added a sinbad movie it's gonna cost you four energy and it says target spirit gains a major power by drawing two and keeping one without having to forget the other power card that's one of the things about this game is you get the option of forgetting cards in order to gain special abilities right you might have the twisted flowers murmur or tomatoes well it's a bit of a mouthful it's like stuff in your mouth full of broccoli this is gonna cost you five energy it allows you to add four feet and it says if the terror level is two or higher you get to remove two invaders right so these power cards are integral to the chances of you winning or losing this game so the final thing that we really like about this game is that it's a fantastic silent experience right this doesn't quite match up with major knights still not my favorite solo game of all time right but it's close right the fact that if you plan it on your own you ain't got to worry about all the other people in the room means that you could just concentrate on what's in your hand don't have to worry about anything else and also if the game goes pear-shaped you could just pack it away you don't have to worry about anyone else thinking no let's carry on let's see what happens right so when you get to that point where all is lost you could just flip the table and nobody will know about it so what don't we like
about spirit island well that's too much to mention but we'll try our best to make it as concise as possible right so the first thing we don't like about spirit island is that you get swamped very very quickly and a lot of the times that we play this we get to the point where everybody knows that the game is lost right but for some reason just keep on playing and you're just playing out inevitable failure and that's when the game falls flat everybody's enthusiasm for the game drops it just feels like you're edging closer and closer to the cliff and well in fact that you've actually fallen off the bloody cliff right and you're just cascading down waiting to hit the full it's very unforgiving game and unlike games like robinson crusoe you always feel that you've got a chance to beat the game more often than not reaches a point where you think i'm done and there's no way back and that sucks so the second thing and probably the thing that me off the most about this game is that it doesn't work as a multi-player experience well and i'll tell you the reason for this is because if you're playing with more than two players it works with two sort of but any more than two players you've got too many brains thinking about what they're going to be doing and this game relies on chaining different powers together and activating powers at the right time if you've got four five six people playing this game if you've got multiple brains thinking about what they can do then you're just gonna get swamped in all these different ideas trying to figure out what is gonna work best when who's got the best power card
trying to remember all the power cards because remember all text based you've got text to remember on a power card as well and it just feels like this box the game down it disrupts the flow of the game whereas if you're playing solo or with two players you've just got yourself or another person to bounce ideas off and that seems to work better right so this doesn't work as a multi-player experience so the final thing it's not the final thing but it's the final thing we're going to talk about because i don't want to bore you to death right you're probably enraged already but the the final thing that we don't like about this is that you've got to check each of the regions based on what cards come out of the invader deck right this reminds me of dominant species or dominant feces as we like to call it that game done my head right in because you have to check for dominance on each of the bloody tiles right and this just brought back memories brought back connotations of the mind-numbing sensation that i felt playing dominant species because you've got to check each of the regions that the game tells you to and when you get into the last stage of the game each of these regions is going to be swamped with invaders or presence tokens or with the dahan or whatever and it's easy to lose track about which ones you've checked right you're going around thinking did i check that one and you're asking people did i check it i don't know can't remember we'll check it again did i add something to that region i don't know i can't remember so it's too easy to get bogged down in check-in rechecking checking rechecking and i hate that i hate it so to summarize it's spirit island worth your time at bother
today and in the future so we are going to say no not a very popular opinion i bet but we're going to say no because it doesn't work as a multi-player game in our experience it's an area control game that has so much variety that's probably got a little bit too much variety i mean the corset suffers from say not a distinct lack of variety but it just feels as if they deliberately left out a branch and claw expansion with the beasts and all that sort of thing deliberately just to make a bit more extra money yeah but this doesn't work as a multi-player experience in our opinion it's best played as a solo gamer and a push a two-player game if you have to like i said you probably do need to get at least the branch and claw expansion to feel the full force of this game and if you have got the expansion and you are planning on batting one off on your own then we really do recommend spirit island but as this is a terrible multiplayer experience if you're not going to be playing with yourself so to speak then we can't recommend spirit island because it's just a headache-inducing mess of a game that tries to be more than the sum of its own parts right so there you go spirit island remember if you're new here please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button comment and all that and we will see you in the next video
you