Mercurial Alchemia - Everything You Need to Know
Transcript
Today we're going to be talking about Mercurial Alchemia. The goal of this video is to help you decide whether or not this is the kind of game that you would want to back on Kickstarter this fall. I have a lot I'm going to go over, including how the game relates to its predecessor, Mercurial. Uh the only thing I'm not going to talk about is exactly how to play the game. I've already done a full playthrough of the game, and if you want to check that out, you can look at the link in the description. But that said, let's go ahead and jump into an overview of the game. Both Mercurial Alchemia and its predecessor, Mercurial, take place in the same world, an outpost of Concordia. Although it's been 12 years, and the land has developed since the previous game. Here we have the Tik Khalier Bazaar where there are four different places where actions can be performed by players and a fifth place, the guild action where players will be crafting potions. In this game, players also have a player board which is double-sided.
One side which is the same for all players and another side which has unique player abilities. They also have a player card with a unique player ability and a loyal arcana which has its own ability. So there are many different ways to mix and match what you can do at the setup of this game. In Alchemia, players are going to be competing for the most prestige and they'll do this most of the time by crafting potions. The potions will be concocted using cards from the player's deck as well as dice and augmented by different powerups, the arcana, and other effects. And what you'll find, and as is shown in this video, every card is going to affect one of the attributes of the potion, either the potion's elements or its material. And many of these different attributes are diametrically opposed to each other. So, you're either moving in one direction or the other.
After several of these ingredients have been infused into a potion, it is brewed and it is scored based on where the final position of all of these attributes land. Those materials and elements will always give the player some amount of money and some amount of prestige points. There are some ingredients which are in your deck and contribute blight to your potion. Blight is something that will have negative effects and over the course of the game, the impact of blight on your potion increases. So players must wait strategically and it gives the game almost a press your luck element where you want to brew the best possible potion, but if you wait too long, the consequences of blight can really cause you to suffer. During the course of the game, players will be placing workers in order to buy more valuable cards or catalysts, reagents, and dice so that you potions are going to be getting better and better as the game progresses. Every round, players are only going to be placing one worker, but they'll always have the option to join the action of their opponents. So, in a four-player game, a player could potentially play four actions, their own, which they select, and three other actions if they pay the cost to join their opponents. Not to mention, players receive a bonus when opponents come to a location where they're already at. So, this worker placement mechanic is a lot more involved and will keep you paying attention to what other players are doing. When I first learned about Mercurial Alchemia, one of my first
questions was, what does this game offer that's new? Or said another way, if you backed the original Mercurial, why would you also want to back Mercurial Alchemia? So, I got a copy of Mercurial and I played it and I compared the two and I will tell you what I think this game offers. Mercurial Alchemia is an example of design brilliance because what David Go the designer has done is he has taken everything that's good about the original Mercurial and preserved it while taking everything that was tedious or annoying and changed it to make it better. Many examples of this. So, first the original Mercurial was instead of potions, it was spells. And in order to cast these spells, you were playing cards. And much like Mercurial Alchemia, uh these cards affected elements that were diametrically opposed. So, you either had restore or ruin. Just two things, restore or ruin. You could go one direction or the other. All of that worked so well. I liked that about Mercurial. Then Mercurial Alchemia identified that as good and then added more where you have these player boards where it's not just ruin and restore, but it's all of these different elements and materials and there's several different uh gradients where you're going left or right. They actually made it thematically richer because with all of these different uh potion ingredients and uh the effects of dice and stuff,
the potion is more complex. It's not just one gradient going one direction or the other, but it's it's several. I love that thematically. Uh, but then they changed something that I thought was really annoying about the original game. The original game was all about the manipulation of resources, dice specifically. So, you were rolling dice and you were using these dice to place them on the cards and then the cards were influencing the spell. And so when you rolled your dice, if you didn't like what you rolled, the only way to change the dice was to play cards in order to flip the faces of the dice. So you're sitting there and you're going, "Oh, I've got too many purple dice. I need more red dice. I can use this to convert to blue and then I can use this card to convert the blue to black and then I can use this card to convert the black to purple and now I have what I need or red, whatever I said." So, you're just converting, converting, converting, converting, and it it like it it just it's just so tedious. Every single move was just flipping dice over to new sides. And while I understood that thematically the game was about like you, you know, you're a you're an alchemist, you're converting the the elements, um it felt thematically very bland and tedious. And so Mercuria Alchemia, it's like it's like he identifi it's like David Go identified that and then what he did is instead of having it be all about dice, it's about dice and cards. So the players have the option to use their workers to buy more
dice and you can go with a diceheavy strategy or you can do a card heavy strategy and you can take your cards because you like the effect of how they influence the dice or you can take the cards because you like the ingredients and you like how they influence the potion. There are different routes that you can take in this game. If you if you like the original Mercurial, take a dice strategy. That's cool. It doesn't have to change. But if you don't like the original one, like like I kind of didn't like it. I mean, there none of it was horrible. It's just that what they've done is so much better. So, so now you can take it and you can go different ways about it and it's not so tedious. Another thing in the previous game that really didn't work was that when it wasn't your turn, there was very little to do. uh your opponents would be drafting cards out of the center so they could influence you in the sense that they might take cards that you wish you had. But when they're changing things around, you don't you don't get to do anything. Alchemia, a player chooses an action and you can join that action. And actually, it gives you fantastic decision-making space because you can sit there and say, "Okay, well, what I want to do is I want to buy such and such card. So, what I'm going to do is I'm going to go over here and take my snail action in order to get more money.
I can get more shells. And then I'm hoping that my opponent will go there so that I can join them. And then I can use the money that I just took on my turn in order to buy the ingredient that I want. Like you can actually sort of and you I I feel myself doing this in the game where I'm looking at what my opponents want to do and I'm planning and hoping that they'll do it so that I can join them. And you know what? Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn't work out. It's cool that it is that interactive. It's cool that the game is designed to make you pay attention and to reward you when you figure out what your opponents are doing. I love deep games that reward you for being interactive wi without being punitive. By the way, this isn't like, you know, you're going to your opponent's base and you're stealing from them. You're taking their victory points. You're taking things out of their potions. No, you're just getting benefits if you can forecast what your opponents will do and you can pay the resources or you plan to pay the resources in order to join them.
Absolutely love that. So there I've listed at least three things to make this game better. One, they've taken the coolest aspect of Mercurial, that diametrically opposed gradient of one characteristic, restore and ruined, and they've turned it into five. You've got the materials. You've got the um the uh elements. And then you've got dice which can be used very important part of your strategy or less important part of your strategy. Resources that can be used in the potion or they can be spent in order to join your opponents in their actions. And then that's the third thing being able to join your opponents in the actions. Planning around what your opponents are doing. Having a much more interactive game that keeps you engaged even when it's not your turn. absolutely love Mercurial Alchemia. Personally, uh if I'm gonna play Mercurial anything, I'm gonna be playing Alchemia. I'm not going to be playing the original. Uh the only reason I would play the original would probably be because as a card game, it is easy. It's a It's a shorter game. It's easier to play, but I don't think it's as engaging. Uh this is fantastic improvement upon the original.
I would absolutely 100% go for it, especially if you like the original. The last thing I want to do is analyze this game according to its perfect board game attributes. Starting with design. Now, when I learned that this game was about magic potions, I groaned a little bit because it's such an easy to do theme. Like, oh, you know, these different cards and they affect you and they give you different points. It's it's also arbitrary because it's all magic. Magic is not real. You can just make it be worth it. This is worth six points. This is worth three points. Who cares? It's magic. So, it's so easy to make a game where the theme is magic. And I get really tired of it. I almost didn't want to play it because I'm like, "Not another magic potion making game. It's too simple. Give me something creative."
But if you're ever going to make a magic game about making potions and you want it to be thematic, then do it like this. This just makes so much sense. Now, I put the the rating in the middle there between mechanical and and uh thematic because it is still very mechanical in the sense that like a Euro game, you're thinking about the problem space that you're in. Which which cards am I going to buy? It's a deck builder. Which worker am I going to place and which action space? Like, you're thinking about more the mechanics rather than the story. This is not a role- playinging game, but the mechanics that you play make so much sense in this potion game. The potions that I get so annoyed with. This one finally works because you get an ingredient and every ingredient affects these different elements in different ways. They go to the right or to the left. They c some of them counteract each other, which makes so much sense. You've got reagents and catalysts which will alter the effects or or optimize the effects. It it it makes so much sense, but you're not like next to actually cooking. This is fantastic thematic implementation um without taking away from a game that is still very much like Eurobased in its mechanics. So, that's a sweet spot for me, right in the middle. Moving on to interaction. One of the things I love about this game is that it is so interactive, but not in a way that is
punitive. Also, not in a way that's like the game is about interaction. It's not like social deduction where you're negotiating and you're only talking with people, but it's way over on the the side there towards uh interactive because or involved because you can plan your turns based on what you think your opponents are going to do. games where your turn depends on what your opponent does so heavily. That's what I call a lot of involvement for a Euro game and that's where that lands there. Uh for artistry, I feel like the art can speak for itself. Clearly, it's beautiful. I love the way the bizaar is illustrated. Um and I love the player boards. Now, I could just talk about how beautiful I think the artwork is. I I will I will say one note about it actually. I love how the ingredients are illustrated in such a way that the effects of the ingredients make sense and yet there are so many different ingredients in the game. It's not all, you know, the same card. I absolutely love that. Um, but I can just let the pictures speak for themselves. What I want to talk about is the clarity of the function of all the pieces. I love that the top of the playerboard summarizes what you can do uh on each phase of a round. I love how the powerups, they fit into the playerboard in spaces so that they just change what the symbol is. That makes it
very clear. I love the consistency of all of the icons. I like that the same icon is on the cards, which is also on the objectives that you can take during the game. This is a game where the iconography aids the playing and so it gets a lot of points for that as well. The only reason I wouldn't put it like farthest off is that like that's where I reserve for games where you're like literally painting the miniatures. There are no miniatures in this game, but other than that, the the functional artwork and the artwork itself is just very well executed here. For strategy, there is, you know, there's a mix here because there is a lot of strategic thinking, but there is also still a lot of luck. Uh, one of the things about game play that I didn't really explain clearly in my overview is that when you place your worker, you have to move your worker from one space to a different space. That's huge because it means that if you have just brewed a potion in the next round, you can't brew a potion again. You have to go to a different space. Also worth noting, you can't join an opponent when an opponent brews a potion. You can only join actions that are in the bizaar. So, because you can't brew a potion two times in a row, let's suppose you know your blight counter is getting way up high. You you don't have the best hand of cards, but you're like,
"Listen, I if I wait any longer, I'm going to go way too up on the blight tracker. I just got to brew this potion right now." So, you go up there, you brew your potion, you score it, you're like a little disappointed, maybe not as many points as you thought you can get. You discard your hand, you draw your next hand, and it's the best hand ever. and you're looking at it and you're going, "Uh, why can't I want to brew this potion? This is this is the best hand." But then you must leave the guild action and go to a different action. There is no way to brew a potion twice in a row, no matter what the cards are. That can be frustrating. Now, I will say that is like the one thing that could ever be frustrating. There is so many other things about the game. Like there are so many other ways that you can figure things out and make things really work out well for you that like I think the game more than compensates for this one complaint. But that's the kind of luck element that experience just can't make up for. Like sometimes the cards are just what the cards are. You've got that element of luck. It it still is more strategic than just luck based, but you know, it's something to be considerate of. Oh, that and the objectives. So, you're drawing objectives. The thing is, if you're drawing three objectives, you get to keep one. You can also keep objectives or you can discard the objectives that you had earlier. So, for example, you have two objectives. You draw three objectives. All three of them are better than the two that you already have. You can keep all three of the new
objectives and put the two that you've had the whole time back. Now, what kinds of object objectives are these? They're all luck. You could draw three awesome objectives. You could draw three horrible objectives. Like I always kind of complain a little bit when a game allows you to draw objectives midame or late game because you could just score so many points because oh look, I just I just happened to draw the best thing ever that I wasn't even strategically going for and I just got it because I got lucky. Like whatever. I complain about that. Again, I don't want to sound like I like I'm not in love with how strategic the game is. It's just that there are like elements of of just pure luck that little bit I get a little whiny about luck. All right. Uh anyway, last one is the complexity of the game.
How how complex is this game really? Um I you know it's interesting. The rules I feel aren't that hard. There's only four actions. They all amount to just buying different things. You're either buying dice or you're buying cards or you're upgrading your terranium. I guess like it it's not that complicated in rule-wise and it's really easy to execute the potions. You put the card down and you move on the different tracks according to what the card shows you. Simple, simple, simple. But what makes the game so complex is not how hard the rules are, it's how tough the decision making is. You're not just thinking about what you want to do, you're thinking about what your opponents want to do. You're weighing the costs of keeping these things that help your potions. You've got the catalysts, the reagents, the dice. All of these things are useful when it comes time to brew a potion, but the very same things are spent during the game in order to get extra actions, either to join or to perform a night action more than once. So, weighing that like, do I spend this or do I save it? That's a that's not a trivial decision. and you're still thinking about what your opponents want to do. So, there's tons of complexity and how much you have to think about in your turn, but it's not a very hard to learn game. That's the kind of complexity that I think is really fun. So, I put the complexity about here on my little meter. Um, so that's it.
That is my analysis of Mercurial Alchemia. In my opinion, back it on Kickstarter, yes, I think I would. And the reason I would is because I got to review an advanced copy of this game. And when I was done with it, I had to send it to somebody else. I had to send it to another reviewer, which is why I don't have the box in front of me right now as I'm talking about it. But I am still thinking about the game. You're going to think it's just hype. I don't say that very often. I really don't. I try very hard to find games that I love in the first place. And then even when I try to find games that I love, I still end up with games that I really enjoy and then I just kind of move on beyond them. Uh, this one is a real keeper. So, I'm so glad that I discovered it or that rather David Go discovered me and offered to share with me a advanced copy of the game. I think it's fantastic. And then I want to reiterate this one more time because this is really is the best part about the entire game. The best thing is the designer took a previous piece of work, Mercurial, and he developed it into something so much better. It is a it is a case study in improving game design. That's why I think it belongs on the shelf. It's so well executed in design. So, those are my thoughts. I hope you found this video helpful. Uh, see you next time. Bye-bye.
Whenever I watch board game reviews, I always want a closer look at the board game shelf in the background. However, you don't have to zoom in on the video to see what my collection looks like. You can check out my shelfie on the perfect boardgame.com. In fact, you can even make your own shelfie. You can find details on the perfect boardgame.com or check out the link and information in the description.