Nocturne - Board Game Review - What Does The Fox Say?
Transcript
hello I'm the from the broken me this is a show where I Rave and rant about board games but usually more the latter here we are starting a trend of AEG games AEG pretty much gave me the whole back catalog when it came to review copies of essin I've got nocturn let's go to Japan underg grve the Cascadia Rolland rights I'm pretty sure there's was was there another one well yeah it's right in front of me you doofus nocturn so yeah I've got plenty to oh yes and Waffle Time couldn't forget that one so plenty to come from AEG over the next few months and we're starting with the most requested of the lot from the viewers of the show no term this one is from AEG and Flatout game so this is the same combination that brought to you Cascadia H even uses best so b as some of the artwork there's definitely a lot of like okay is this like a sequel to it well Cascadia is a very different game okay you know this is one of the best Gateway Games in existence it's still to this day is probably a top 10 Gateway game but get it out of your heads that this is not a sequel to Cascade here they are nothing alike in terms of how they play okay this is a very different game altogether so what is nocturn well KN turn is a game where you are bidding or casting spells whatever the theme means nothing here you're effective ly bidding on tiles and those tiles score in different ways or have little triggered abilities and effectively it's set collection but how you bid for the tiles is based on a grid mechanic so it's not just simply choosing a tile and I'll bid this much for it there's a little bit more Nuance than that and then there are
two rounds of the game where between rounds there's not only opportunities for you to get more tiles by another mechanic but if you've got stuff left over you can make yourself more powerful for round two so there's almost like a little bit of a catch- up mechanism here and there it's not a Gateway game it is supposed to be light you know the Box claims a 30 to 45 minute time frame one to four players so the question is can AEG and flat out do it again so in nocturn as I say You are bidding for tiles now this is set up with an example for I believe a two-player game but basically it scales based on player count and you have a grid of tiles like so you have a bunch of spell tokens which is effectively your currency for bidding on various tiles but it's not simply a case of going I choose this to right let's all bid see who wins little bit more to it than that the idea is is that you'll pick one of your spells so let's say a low one start with two choose a tile and place it on face up the other players then have the opportunity to outbid you but if they outbid you it's not just a case of going oh all right I want that mushroom as well I'm just going to you know bid this what they have to do is they have to place it on an adjacent tile so if I decide I want to go to this one I'll put my free on it therefore I'm now trying to win this tile with a free where you go hm well now I can only go adjacent to that one you know what I wouldn't say no to that herb I'm going to put a five on there so I've out bid you and now we're bidding for this tile effectively you know and then the next person you know they could say well you know what do I
want it or not yeah you know what I wouldn't say no to this skull over here again you got to go adjacent I'm going to biid with a seven and then it just carries on until eventually everyone except one person has passed so there's kind of like a movement around this grid as opposed to just picking one tile the one that you start the bid on isn't necessarily the one that gets one at the end of the round or the end of the phase I guess and when you win the tile you basically leave your marker there because some objectives in the game actually score based on the patterns you leave behind you take the tile it will score points in various ways like points for Unique sets points for getting loads of the same points for getting certain amount of mushrooms like you know two mushrooms are zero points three mushrooms are 13 you know that kind of weird stuff some other effects besides but for the people who lost it's not necessarily all over because if you've already won your markers go back anyway but if you lost you have the opportunity to put your marker on this Sprite board here and essentially what this is is that you'll have tokens on here that go in descending order so for example you know you know if I put a six it could be at the top uh green puts in a three pushes the two down uh then I put a one down here green decides I'm going to leave behind a five so we budge these ones down and fit the five in here and they get kicked off the end of need being it scales by player count but the idea is is when the round ends which is basically when all the tiles here have been nabbed or everyone's passed then you go in order from high to lowest and you get the choice of the tiles on here so there's more tiles for you to potentially get by using tokens that you
lost a phase with so there's something for winning and something for losing now the effects as I say they're pretty standard I mean this feathers you get loads of points for getting lots of feathers eggs you compare who's got the most eggs and then they're worth points based on how many who had the most eggs mushrooms are specific skulls are just flat victory points but also they provide symbols like the skulls and the plants where you can basically fulfill these concoction cards which are basically just get the symbols and you get the points so another way to score points there you've got some objectives each round so you got three Twilight ones to begin with which there's quite a good variety in the box and then when you rinse and repeat for round two you've got some different end of end of game scoring goals that revealed so you've got a nice bit of variety there you've also got a player power that you can use once per game the fact that they put this in as advanced mode just beggar belief I mean for crying out loud it's a really straightforward power you use once in the game and then you flip it over you lose two points who cares you're going to end the game with like about 80 to 100 points anyway and it's like why would you not use the Ability it's not really Advanced people I mean technically um there is a family mode that you can play in this game and it's like like well just play the family mode then if you don't want to use the advanced power it just seems weird but you know other than that uh the rest of the game uh oh yes the and the shadow tokens you have these big blue ones here when you finish the round if I've got any of my spell tokens left then you go from highest to lowest amongst all the players and you replace your lowest tokens with these big ones like 10 9 8 7
6 5 normally your tokens go one to S Max and you have like an automatic win veto token so for round two to get like 10 n and eight leaves you with some very powerful tokens but they don't give you any points for controlling areas on the board or anything for objectives so that's kind of like the Stick of the game you play two rounds in the same fashion empty out the tiles round one's done change the goals distribute out the shadow tokens and take what's off here and then rinse and repeat for round two new set of tiles new set of tiles same sort of thing and then count up the points as you can tell this one definitely is a step up above Cascadia in terms of complexity it's not the most complicated game ever although Cascadia is not that difficult to learn from the rule book this is a little bit flaky I found this one a little bit tricky to understand some of the points so much so that I actually got a couple of rules wrong in the first like multiplayer game that we had it's the setup's fine but it talks about two bits in particular which don't make sense from the rule book at least not easily one is these concoction cards if you skim the rule book too quick you'll basically read it as being that you scored the highest of the two values here depending on which of those banners you get but then you realize oh wait the book scoring example basically has it as oh I see if I get the two at the top I get that many points and if I'm also able to get the bottom row I get the higher of the two values then is that right it's it's it's little kind of weird and Flaky the other thing is that there's a roll in here called Corner
cutting or was it what do they called it they called it Corner something Corner casting uh where is it a you Corner C Corner cast is just basically because you've got to go adjacent to these tokens that you flip down you can basically have a situation where let's say for example um uh like this one's already occupied this one's already occupied and then somebody comes along and wins this one it creates a situation where there's a tile where If you bid on it nobody can go adjacent to it so it's basically an auto win hence Corner cast and this basically allows you to basically stick your lowest token possible on it win an easy tile but then the turn order shifts that is also explained quite shakily in the rule book and trying to describe it to players is a little bit flaky as well I found that there was a few people that tripped up over certain ways that the rule book phrased stuff and there's a couple of other FAQ moments that the book does not explain for example there's a a tile here that copies one of your other items at the end of the game now it doesn't copy symbols fine it copies the type fine I need another of this mushroom I need another skull okay there's reasons you would want to do that that it doesn't say you can't copy things like runestones and cursed chests which allow you to draw cards or tiles from a face down stack but if you do this at the end of the game is that allowed do you copy the minus one point on it do you instantly trigger the draw free stack when you do it why would you do it it's it doesn't say you can't but it's such a weird rule that it one that should be explained it's just it's not a
terrible terrible rule book but I do think some aspects are a little flaky and compared to something like Cascade you're not going to easily grasp everything in here there are a few things that kind of trip you up now that being said the game is reasonably goodlooking I mean the artwork is kind of wasted yes it's Beth soell but you know much like in Cascadia it's not really showcasing her artwork except on the cards well here it's the same thing these tiles don't really show off Stellar artwork that best known for the best artwork is frankly on the box and these character cards of which there's four of them you know so it's not exactly showcasing a lot everything else in here is kind of uh basic and standard but you do get a lot of tile so you are getting some mang for your buck now as much as I've said a few negatives there the positives are still pretty sweet this one does have a nice amount of tactics in it it's not really a strategic game yes you can sort of go oh I'm going to try and collect these mushrooms or I want to try and get a bunch of feathers but there's a lot of tactical opportunism that you've got tactical opportunism that you've got here because there's obviously trying to win a tile but then the way that you bid on these tiles with alternating these tokens is like well where do I start my bid if I want to win a tile that's down here perhaps I should start up there and hope it sort of Coes his deck down but then obviously if you start bidding on these tiles and somebody knows you're gunning for feathers for example and it's like well hang on I better uh head off in that direction so that we're not going anywhere near the feathers and then it's like are they willing to bid higher in order to get it back round so there is an element of what Tel you want but also an element of hate drafting
against other players particularly when there's four of you uh the also the fact that you have this board where you actually sometimes want to lose a round you're thinking you know what I'm going to put in a high one I'm going to put in a five here but I'm hoping that you'll outbid me because I reckon you really want the tile next to it you can have that tile but then I'm going to put my five up here kick out these ones and then suddenly I've got like first dibs for tiles that I actually want later on and then even then you could win a tile for every token you've got but you might be like well you know what that's only getting me a couple of points I don't desperately need an egg I'm not likely to win it so I'd rather hold back and pass cuz that's way I now get the shadow tokens for next round and so my round two can be more powerful than my round one there's just a lot of little nuances in here that's really cool from a decision-making perspective and from you know a fact that each round plays out very tactically now this does have a KnockOn effect in a negative way this is not a game you want to play with ap players oh my God especially with four of you four people gets a little bit cha iotic on the grid as well as makes the game very long and AP PA will destroy this game because there's a lot of things for you to consider about where you start how much you bid what players are after you what tokens they've got what tiles they want what tiles you want whether you want to go on this board there's a lot to consider and people will freeze up it's definitely a couple of steps above Cascadia in terms of that complexity level which then Beggar's
belief that this game dares to put a 30 to 45 minute time frame on here 30 to 45 minutes is fine if you're playing a solo and maybe with two players 30 to 45 minutes with 3 to four players is pretty much damn near impossible if you're going to include a teach because you got a fair amount to teach with some of these rules as I said the book makes it a little bit flaky but man I mean I've had a four-player game of this take you know at least an hour if not an hour and 15 minutes to play You're going to play nocturn easily for twice as long as you play Cascadia you know it is a bigger time sync and when it does take that upper end of the time scale because of the decision- making that people can freeze up on it does outstay its welcome it really does need to be a game that's done in dusted in 45 minutes and you can do that solo and two player free barely four no chance in hell and so this isn't a game I want to pull out with four especially as the bidding around this grid gets a little bit insane with four now solo I actually think might be the best way to play this game because solo plays out pretty much the same you do your turns as normal but the AI has a deck of cards and you flip it over and depending on what it says on here it will try to outbid you it will tell you which direction to go so it plays in a slightly unpredictable fashion compared to a human player but still you have to be wared as to is it likely to out bid you will it not will it go on the Sprite board it's done very easy you can pilot this with no trouble at all from this little mini deck but you can gain the
system a littleit because you can coax like some of those Corner casting things I mentioned before but also when you see what tokens they've got and what you know they don't score for tiles you know you're trying to score yours you can try to almost gain the AI into certain positions you know in order to benefit yourself so it's not entirely a random luck Fest there's still a cool little puzzle that you're trying to do and of course when you play the solo it's pretty quick also like Cascadia you've got these scenarios at the back of the book that you can play with different setups for the objectives and what character you have so easy normal medium for the achievements exactly like Cascadia has which to be honest the solo mode in cascader is fantastic solo mode in here is pretty damn good as well these scenarios make solo you know fun to play so nocturn is a solid game but it's definitely a couple of steps below the likes of Cascadia Cascadia is a gateway game this is most certainly not a Gateway game you know this is for light this is a light game but there's a lot of things that could trip up people or Force the AP player to think way too much about what they're doing on their turn and you know 30 45 minutes is touch and go at the best of times it's you know it's certainly going to require more of a rules teach the book doesn't make it easy in that respect on certain aspects so this one feels like it grinds its gears a bit more than Cascadia did I know I said that they are two very different games but I'm just trying to give you an idea in terms of you know weight and complexity and you know smoothness this one is a fun game with a
decent amount of tactics involved a you know a little bit of strategy in there but it's also just that little bit more clunky than I would like from a light game and you know it makes me not want to play this with too many players if anything I mainly want to play it as a solo game but then when I've got something like Cascadia and that I'm kind of like well maybe I'd rather just play that one it's hard to tell so it's got its place but I don't think it's an amazing game I'm giving it a seven out of 10 I still recommend it I think it's a good game but that's as high as I can really go you know the it diminishes a little bit at the highest of player counts and you could almost maybe bump it up a notch if you want to only play this solo but it kind of averages out a bit like a seven out of 10 it's good but I don't want to bring this one out anywhere near as often as some other games that I might do you know the theme is completely non-existent you know casting spells whatever it's bidding tokens for for grid for you know for tiles and whether you've got your to tokens and a pattern might score you points for objectives it's like whatever the concoctions is literally just collect symbols so you know nothing about this formatic at all it's just got some cool little tactical things which is what brings us up to something like at least a you know deserving of a seal but I do wish it was just a bit shorter bit smoother little less clunky you know those bits do hurt it seven out of 10 still solid but yeah if you're going to put the two in front of me Cascadia is no content so that's it for me on this episode of the broken
me I think it went a bit long for a speed review but never mind don't forget to thumb it up on YouTube and thumb up on boring when he goes live on the page let me know your thoughts do you think this is a game for you if you played both do you prefer one or the other you do you share the thoughts or not uh let me know also uh what you think of all the other Essen content that I'm going to be doing over the next couple of months there's plenty to come trust me on that one take care and remember regardless of whether you believe you're a fox Mystic or not let's face it you really won't it's still only again so bye for now