Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ayar is Osprey's last big swing - TCbH Review

Transcript 10:11

IR is weird. Beautiful, clever, original, yeah, but weird. And you could dismissively sneer and say that it's just another abstract point salad game and not be entirely wrong. It's undoubtedly ambitious. And given the recent news of Osprey publishing shuttering their board game biz, maybe the last big swing from a company that in a little over a decade established themselves as a mainstay of the hobby with a strong focus on thematic authenticity, production, and surprising affordability to the designers, the artists, and other internal staff who made Osprey what it is, what it was, salute. Now, like I was saying, IR is weird. Set in the mythological origins of the Incan people, players are clans aiding the four pairs of IR, the male and female children of Inti and Mama Killa, the sun and the moon. And on the table, this game looks appropriately epic, though we're at least deceptively bigger than it is. Multiple boards, loads of beautiful pieces, along with some of the classiest meeple work I've really ever seen. But the actual act of playing the game is extremely simple.

Your player board has a grid where you place a ready worker at the end of an available column or row, move the corresponding color piece on the public central board the indicated number of spaces, then place one house from said column or row on any space behind the traveler on the board, taking the one of four possible actions indicated by that space at the strength equal to the now revealed spaces on your actions column or row. Yeah, I promise that the action system actually makes a lot of sense once you wrap your brain around it. Now, these actions, think of them like four distinct mini games. Grab some pots for set collection, farm some maize for long-term investment, weave tapestries to complete the spatial puzzle and race up the lake to lay claim to the most lucrative woven islands in Titicaca. All of this is simple. Like, honestly, each individual action is simple and they're pretty well sequestered from one another. This isn't a game where you're doing something on one action path that has triggered effects that is going to make something happen on another one and you have all these cascading impacts.

No, they're overall pretty distinct and carrying out your individual actions, your individual turns, is simple. But, what makes it so complex and why you have a dizzying amount of information on your UI is that timing is everything in this game. Each of those mini-games, well, they score sun and moon points differently, which on the whole you care significantly about because your end score is the lesser of your two total point totals. Sun points come from the Inti dial, whereas the male travelers cross certain points on their journey, everyone will increase their dial based off of how well they're doing in the corresponding task for the benchmark that they crossed.

Then, at the end of each round, you gain sun points equal to the current total on your dial. So, early game investment means you reap a lot of late game rewards. Moons, on the other hand, tend to be easier to achieve, but less frequently awarded. Each round, the male traveler furthest behind retires from their journey and joins with their twin at the bottom of the board, who then meets him at the end of her track, which, surprise surprise, there's a bonus fifth mini-game. As players uncover quadrants of their action grid, they can put a temple on one of the remaining female IR tracks, which will cause you to score moon points, sometimes bonus moon points, when that person retires. But, you only have one temple for each mini-game, and you can't reassign it, so you have to choose carefully. If you have some dope investment in the pottery game, maybe you want to hold off in playing it to see which male IR is going to last until the end. But, placing earlier gets you the meaningful bonus points. In either case, when the pair unite, they're removed from play. They're no longer part of the game, and your corresponding action piece that moved the IR, well, that's retired and placed on one of the moon scoring positions on your own action board, another of the few opportunities you have to trigger moon scoring. The point being is that this game has very simple interactions, but timing everything so you actually manage to reap points out of it is so

complex, and you can sink so much mental energy into trying to make sure that all filters through correctly. I mean, you can spend the first two rounds, the first half of this game, getting virtually no points from this, then in the back half having an utter explosion of point rewards. And this is compounded by buku bonuses for uncovering complete action rows or columns, and the fact that each round your action potential greatly diminishes. I mean, you go from the first round having five action selection pieces that correspond to the four colors of IR, and then a fifth wild one that can be placed and then activate or move forward the sojourner of your choice, to the final round of the game where you're only taking two actions, the one remaining non-retired IR and the wild one. Those last couple of turns aren't any more complicated than those at the beginning of the game, but the final IR's retirement can make up over half of the points that you're going to score, especially from those temples as moon points. So, it makes for this weird kind of lopsided cadence to the game.

It's both more complex and simpler than you might expect. It's both a larger and shorter, smaller game than you might expect. Ultimately, the best way that I can put it is that it's just weird and unlike anything else that I've ever played. I suspect that IR's greatest strength is going to be the biggest turnoff for detractors. This particular timing to make use of your few opportunities to score, both through retirement and when travelers cross their thresholds, means there's massive opportunity for big brain scheming. Being able to see far ahead and control the flow of the game so things happen only when you want them to happen to great success. And it also rewards hyper specialization, meaning you might forego entirely one or two of the mini games.

More casual players who want to dabble or aren't critically thinking about the long-term tempo will be punished. Further, they have to think hard about the balance of points. Each of the mini games are simple, but keeping in mind how and when you'll benefit sun versus moon is an extra layer that the analytical minds will thrive on. Though more instinctive and tactical-minded players, including myself, care to only crunch so much. The game itself doesn't feel inaccessible, but the skill ceiling very much does. Thankfully, one particularly smart design move is the inclusion of llamas, a collectible token from various bonuses that the end of the game, due to a Peckham's law of llama universality, each llama can be flipped from sun or moon side, then filtered through a llama conversion chart, the name of my new math rock band, into sun or moon points to balance out your score. The thing that I want to emphasize is that I R has the feeling of a really complex, intricate, and larger game while being pretty true to the time frame that it lists on the box. I mean, heck, you can knock out a two-player game of this in under an hour and that includes the anguish, the analytical agony that you put yourself through in figuring out how best to see through the matrix and score those points at the timing intervals. As I've said, the game itself is pretty easy to play in principle, just so many

layers of consideration. Personally though, I find it more academically interesting in its design than out and out fun, but that might be just more my preferences as a player. I also would have loved a bit more sense of investment in the game other than just capitalizing on points. Yes, you do get these little tokens for various things that can be allotted into your player board to unlock additional strength in the core actions or some passive benefits, but there doesn't really feel like there's any opportunities to sacrifice time now for more efficiency in the long run. This, in my mind, is absolutely a try before you buy type of game, but I suspect that the people who like this are really going to love it and it's a game that I'd be happy to play more of than the type of game that I've come to admire Osprey for putting out over the last many years. It's completely original, gorgeous, and feels thematically grounded or at least authentic if altogether abstract in what it conveys. And if it's one of their last big swings, it's a weird, very cool note to go out on. And that's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite weird, but cool, academically interesting, but maybe not necessarily just out and out fun game that you think of when you hear this review.

Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching. Thanks for supporting. Thanks for doing all the things that help us grow. No money exchanges hands from publishers to us, so we are always benefited by those likes, subscribes, comments, checking out our Patreon, and of course, sharing our videos out on the interwebs. But above all else, thanks for being such amazing community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved