The 6 Player Dune Imperium Experience
Transcript
so you've got a problem you want to play a tense strategic worker placement game but all the good ones only play four people and you just have too many friends well not to worry D Imperium uprisen has a threple based six player mode that I've been playing a ton of and wanted to talk about Dune Imperium is already a tight squeeze four players is super crowded like smushing four people into a coupe there's just enough space for everyone to ride but there's not much space between people so it keeps the tension high and that's a huge reason why it's so good but squeezing six people into the same space would make for a miserable time so Dune Imperium Uprising makes pretty chunky modifications to get six players working the game is larger but is bigger really better or does it all amount to unnecessary
bloat so to get it all working you start off by flipping over the board revealing the big board with some new space modified spaces and the return of some Classics like carag you add on the commander boards representing the exclusive Emperor and fman tracks which are just for those two players you add on tokens and the board stuff as per usual you make the decks as per usual just note that there are six alliances now but two are replaced by The Fringe worlds and the great houses as the feminine Emperor have been moved to the commanders you create the conflict deck but remove the tier one card and you hand out all your star index and normal pieces as per usual in the four player game mode and those four players are known as the Allies you give the commanders a special unique deck and special tokens place the score markers one for the Allies four for the commanders you draw out the objectives but ensure that each team gets one desert Mouse and one Chris knife and that's pretty much it the rest of the game is all set up as per normal that said some of the gameplay differences are pretty hefty the most dramatic change in the six player game mode is that the game is now a team-based 3v3 with two players leading the charge as commanders and the entire feel is more reminiscent of a game of tug OFW over a jaked cliff two players get thrust into the role of the commanders
while the other four players are the Allies each team has one commander and two allies and these commanders sit between their allies and will either be the elderly Emperor shadam Corino or Paul muad who would definitely love you if you turn into a worm commanders have a lot of new tools like powerful star index with new ways to score points new agents that activate the player on their left or right as well as they have a personal Alliance board with spaces they can only visit and a commander specific ability for their team with these additions Commander ERS also have some subtractions commanders do not have armies and will share troops and swords with their allies as well as they do not have influence with the forain factions and instead can increase that influence for their allies what this means is that conflict and many friendship points are not available for commanders now activation is the core mechanical difference of commanders unlike allies commanders have small cardboard agents that have an arrow that activates the Ally to their left or right of the commander the commander will then apply any benefit that isn't applicable to themselves to the activated Ally it almost acts as a half turn for that Ally and also encourages the commander to support both allies when needed for example if the Commander goes to secrets that Commander player will draw the entry card but since they have no influence with the Benny jzer the activated Ally gains the influence so what does this all amount to playing as
one of the two commanders will result in a dramatically different game feel and strategy than what you might be used to in the normal four-player game mode it does capture the feeling that you're actually leading your allies in their missions and helping them achieve their goals since commanders do not score as many points as their allies as they don't gain points from conflicts or from the normal four factions instead they are a large part of enabling the team's game plan this means dumping in more troops to swing of combat or pushing them up on the alliance track sometimes it feels like your commander is more of a babysitter than a leader but the true nature of the role is that they are the people who will pick up your defeated corpse and drag you over any Finish Line no matter what it takes now this isn't to say commanders don't influence the outcome of the game on an individual level they can certainly score through points through forging alliances with their unique Commander Faction board or by using their deck in some cases to score points or by achieving other objectives throughout the game the commander has less total potential to score points but the points are still extremely valuable like I mentioned since commanders start off the game with four points in comparison to the other players who start off at one point it is expected for them to score less points in the same amount of time and because of this it creates an interesting Dynamic some players really focus heavy on enabling their allies which lets their allies gain as many points as possible while other commanders focus
more on scoring their own personal objectives and less on assisting their allies it creates an interesting cost benefit analysis for the commander and almost feels like you're doing repeated trust Falls with your allies commanders as a whole are a pretty neat solution to a potential blo in problem at first I worry that the commander role might not feel as fulfilling as other players but the role offers a unique puzzle and really glues the team together the unique decks the activation of allies and the other minor rule modifications really Nails the feeling of being a commander without over stuff in the game uprisen six player mode has no treachery no Grand betrayal and you strictly win or lose together as a team but like any hierarchical thle the Dynamics of this team is two diads centered through the commander what I mean by this is that the interaction between the team is mediated through the commander the commander is the Hub and the two other players are spokes like a human bridge between the two other players the reality is that the two allies on each team actually have fairly minimal interaction with each other when it comes to achieving objectives interaction comes through by not ruining your allies objectives but direct help is fairly minimal the Allies play a game that's very similar to the normal base game but at the same time they try to be cognizant so that they don't step on each other's toes for example some
rounds will Prelude with a public discussion on each team on which Ally might want to go hard and stay hard in the combat and which Ally might be more interested in collecting resources or which influence track they want to move up on yes it's all teamwork but allies do not interact directly except for a couple of spaces which do allow for troop deployment and a trade of resources on the other hand the commanders are the Crux of their team dragging their exhausted allies across each and every gruin Point bumping them up with troops and and swords making sure that they are friendly with all the factions and keeping the team together since the commanders can activate each of their teammates at least once per round it becomes a bit of a game of trying to figure out what your allies need and trying to figure out how to achieve it and I like this type of teamwork a lot because it's a game of trade-offs there's a commander focus on each Ally at the same level do they focus on themselves what is the plan for each round and and since commanders are expected to score fewer points they are incentivized to assist their team and it's a unique role that presents interest in choices for the commander and for their team intelligently this game scores the total points of the entire team after the endgame phase is completed so it's not so much a race to 10 points like it might feel in the four-player game mode but instead a more communal effort to score as many
objectives as possible and you want to trigger that endgame when you are confident you are going to outscore the other team even with all those sneaky endgame secrets and much like any polyamorous relationship communication is key to keep three people happy and in the real book it is recommended that all discussion between the teams are public there are no secrets that aren't shared with the opposing team and this is how I played for the vast majority of our games it is undoubtedly the preferred way than playing with private information between teams it's very easy to realize that when groups have the option to disclose private information there is a lot of piggy back in which unintuitively reduced the feeling of teamwork having one player call the shots without any risk really reduce those moments where you need to trust another player for example can your commander go to highliner do they have access do they have a way to get enough spice all of this loses tension when everyone on the team knows exact what's in each other's hands on the other hand requiring only public information increases the tension and actually creates a new strategical choice of whether or not to disclose information in some games it's a full-on discussion on what the team game plan is while the other Commander is trying to find counters to that plan other times the game is completely quiet and everyone is holding on to their secret plans from the opponents and it's almost like your commander is trying to read your mind
it's an interesting dynamic because showing your plans might be necessary for success but can also risk it if the opposing team can counter asymmetry is a beautiful thing when used correctly it allows for a breath of gameplay strategies creativity and ultimately a new way to think about a game and in this six-player variant it implements asymmetry in a way that's beyond what's found in the four-player mode and I have a bit of a problem with it in six player Uprising so in this six player version each of the commanders gets a brand new 10 card deck which is awesome it has some overlap you know the signant Rings the seeet Allies convincing arguments but the other cards are amped up and provide a unique Twist on the base deck which is great I'm a fan I think both of these decks are flavorful neat and balanced there's nothing wrong here and I like these decks it's all good stuff but here's the part I can't jive with and it's not even really in the rule book but on each of the Commanders personal faction boards there are some bad game designs that Force both teams into a very distinct yet stale play style and let's talk about this the six player game mode goes heavy into a lower accurate duel between the emperor and Paul which is great and super neat Until you realize you are being forced into one over Aran strategy every single game and it feels painfully stale with the muad team his board says
when one muad Ally gains the maker hooks the other Ally also gains maker hooks on the emperor it says your team can't gain maker hooks game start move a nonf fman card from the Imperium row to the throne row so what's my problem well my problem is that this is forceful and bad reductive asymmetry these two board specific blurbs severely limit and simplify the play styles of each team in almost every single game and it doesn't matter who you have as as an ally the muad team will Rush one Ally for maker hooks while the emperor team will go for those high value cards that he places in the Imperial tent it creates an overarching game plan even before the game starts and you know the first four or five games I really enjoyed it because it was cool and thematic and everything worked well the emperor using his vast powers to snatch up the most powerful tools while the muad utilizes desert power of the sand worms it was cool but then it got not stale and every game started off with each other's team recognizing the strategy of the other team people would say we know the MU team wants hooks ASAP and we and they want to get rid of The Shield wall and the emperor we know he wants those high value cards in his Imperial tent for his team and look I think the two sides are actually very well balanced the pros and cons of each side work well but only if they play into their strengths it isn't that one team will steamroll the team
and of course there are deep and strategic decisions that need to be made to best overall execute these strategies it's just that gets predictable in a way that feels detrimental to a long-term enjoyment of this game mode you know the MU deep team will go for worms every single game and you know the emperor's team will go for deck building both strategies work well both are deep but having the same game plan each and every game gets stale put simply if mu Deep's team does not go for the worms they will be losing huge swing potential and if the emperor does not go for those extremely high value cards they will be hamstrung each side is strong and well balanced but because the team's asymmetry is so powerful it subtracts from other possible strategies for each side of course selection of allies leaders will change individual play style but the team as a unit will have one over Aran plan which can't be neglected no matter what combination of leaders are in play the overall plan for each team remains consistent between games this is frustrating because the use of Team asymmetry is the largest problem in the entire game mode and look I like asymmetry almost all of my favorite games use a asymmetry but instead of asymmetry creating new strategies and new ways to think about the game the symmetry of these Commander boards forc the team down one Pathway to
Victory and it restricts gameplay decision space it's frustrating that there are so many limits when you play on either team and instead of enhancing the game Space it creates a sense of staleness after just a few games and when you compare these to the actual leader cards in the same game the leader cards might encourage a certain kind of play style but you can pick a versatile character or go against the obvious gameplay strategy of the character you pick in this this six player game you are forced and restricted into a certain game plan for the whole team and I get what they're going for in the future we can see expansions where there can be new commanders and new boards like imagine lady Jessica who might have her own unique text box on the board I totally get it and that's a cool idea but that's not how the game is structured now and with just the two commanders with this level of forced asymmetry it really dampens the variety of the matches it's easy to imagine in the next expansion there are four other leaders each with their own Faction board and with their own flavorful asymmetry and that's truly what I would need in order to try this game mode again and again because the game as it is now is hamstrung by rigidity and creating more flexible play styles for the teams would really enhance that experience to put this differently some of the very best parts of Uprising are restricted from each team often your teammates will feel frustrated that they are forced into a strategy and that they
will need to lean into it for victory it even feels bad for the emper team to go to some spaces because you know you won't be able to get those warms through Hooks and it feels bad having some of the most fun cars just plucked away it doesn't create a new challenge it just limits strategies in a way that's ultimately predictable and creates stale boring games yes it's thematic yes it makes sense in the lore but Uprising was never really about the lore in the first place you can have the emperor get worms in the base game and you can have the mued player use saer car heck even fade can be best friends with the fan the theman is fun but this game shouldn't be a slave to theme as a consequence of gameplay some games meld theme with the gameplay throughout and its entire game design but Dune Imperium isn't one of those games it's best when it has tough decisions and moments of tension and a lot of that decision space is sacrificed in the six player game mode for theming and it's frustrating because all the core mechanics of the six player game mode work really great I don't have a problem with activation or the spaces or the unique Commander decks or any of that I don't care about how the sword master is different I have a problem with how these two blocks of texts absolutely Crush strategic diversity and fun so how can you fix it well let's just cover this up and this and let's replace this card and there we go viable play Styles in
abundance and I know you think I'm nitpicking but I very much love that there's a six-player variant of Dune Imperium truly having six people play in this big complex often brutal game brings me joy from the misplays to the mind syns the game is good it's even great it's just not the thunderous smash that I wanted it to be and when a game is tightly as put together as Dune Imperium Uprising remixes itself there has to be some give and take uprisen adopted a holy refreshing approach on six player work replacement and adds in a thematic approach to game playay which strongly encourages each team to play into the story the game is trying to tell but at the cost of the story there is a loss of strategic Freedom the lower accurate storyline the designer is trying to tell takes away from the agency of the players and it really does force certain play Styles off the table and the first two times I played I was truly captivated I wanted to try it all I wanted to play as the opposing team or play as the commander on both sides and experience the vastness of strategies but after more and more plays I've come to realize this game mode has restricted the game diversity that I've had in my four player games and I find myself wanting to play that four-player game mode instead the game was less interesting after about half a dozen plays and I felt myself and other itching to go back to the four player game mode just because it felt so much more interest in from game to game put simply our
interest in the four player mode increased after each playthrough and our interest diminished after each game of the six player game mode for this reason I'm giv Dune Imperium Uprising the six player game mode a 9.6 out of 10 on the first few playthroughs and an 8 out of 10 on repeated playthroughs averaging the two out it's an 8.8 it's great but it does doesn't reach stratospheric strategic Bliss that the four player game mode presents I see excellent potential for this game mode to hit the highest health Highs but it needs a little bit more I would start off with new Commander boards that allow for more fluid play Styles and some final thoughts a lot of my friends love the Dune franchise and whenever we have a big game night we want the best experience if only there was a dune game out there that really had emphasis on six players that really took asymmetry in a direction that is both lower accurate and encourages creative play Maybe adding some luck some interest in combat mechanics with loads of content maybe even capture the backstabbing and betrayal that's so core to the Dune world I wish that kind of game would really exist wouldn't that be a Dream well maybe one day