Skip to main content
Loading video...

Middara is Magnificent! | Solo Review (+ Tips on Reducing Table Footprint)

Transcript 30:29

hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss midara on intentional malum act one first to give you some background uh there's a few other party based Dungeon Crawlers I've played prior to this and those are Gloom Haven Shadows of Brimstone and Star Wars Imperial assault and they're all within my top 20 solo board games of all time I played through the entirety of mid's first chapter which amounted to about 10 encounters total each encounter took me 2 to three hours on average and factoring in setup time reading the lengthy story and taking time to upgrade my characters between missions which is a huge element of the game outd estimate I spent about 30 to 40 hours with the game over the span of 2 months which by the way it's the longest a game has ever stayed on my table okay so now let's move on to a gameplay overview in midara you control four youthful characters named Nightingale sik rook and Remy you embark on a campaign where you'll go on missions which are comprised of one or more encounters so basically each Mission can have multiple dungeons that you will explore during these encounters you'll explore diverse environments find loot and fight various monsters controlled by an AI system combat consists of using stamina points and exhausting your character skills and gear to navigate often difficult terrain and position your characters effectively to then roll custom dice in order to resolve spells and attacks among other

types of tests like jumping or story events a red revealer is used with a campaign book to uncover how to progress in the mission as well as discovering Loot and random events throughout dungeons in between missions you'll typically have have a prepare phase where you can visit vendors sell or purchase gear and spend XP points to upgrade your characters in multiple disciplines as well as go on optional side quests before progressing on the main story and as I mentioned previously the upgrade phase for your characters is a huge element of the game and can take up some time so that you can figure out how to build your characters most effectively now let's talk about what I liked about midara first let's mention the components it has fantastic fastic quality components and one of the coolest details about the tokens and dungeon tiles is that they have UV spot so certain parts of the dungeon and tokens uh are glossy so for example in certain dungeon tiles where there's water the water part will have UV spot so that it's reflective but then the rest of the dungeon tile will be matte and it just makes them looks so much cooler than most other dungeon tiles that I've seen in other games and same thing with the status tokens so uh in the front you'll have a text based status token description and then on the back uh there's no text and it's just an illustration so each status token has a unique illustration and a lot of them have a UV spot just like the dungeon

tows so I just love that detail about the game if you want to learn what each status icon uh does uh you know you can just uh you know memorize the illustrations the game includes tons of gorgeous Minis and standies as well as awesome custom dice also I think this is one of the better inserts that I've experienced from a game of this category but if you want to set up quicker I think it could benefit from a third party or custom insert so yeah you'll definitely feel that you got your money's worth just from the component quality and quantity I also love the presentation of the game with its gorgeous and sexy anime art not to mention the Fantastic graphic design work all text on cards and books is very clear there's a small amount of iconography and it all works really well okay so another thing I really love about this game is how quick it is to set up a scenario now let's not confuse that with how much time it actually takes to pull the entire game out of the giant box and set it up uh on your table what I mean is once you have already pulled out all the components and arranged them on your table the act of setting up a dungeon actually just takes a few minutes it's very impressive so Ty typically when following encounter setup instructions all you'll need is an average of four to six dungeon tiles which are all double-sided so there's many possibilities of different dungeons that you'll find throughout the game and just a handful of tokens for objectives and then your Miniatures and some enemy

Miniatures another thing I really like about this game is the exploration good Dungeon Crawlers will typically have some kind of timer element so that you can't indefinitely explore so there's this urgency token mechanic I in the game where if you spend an entire round without certain things happening like an enemy dying or being activated then you add an urgency token and if you reach four urgency tokens you automatically lose the scenario so yes this means that you're not going to be able to stay in a dungeon just exploring every cranny every time but in most cases you'll be able to if early on uh you complete your objectives and Destroy every enemy in the dungeon uh you're going to be able in most cases to explore every part of the dungeon and other Dungeon Crawlers are so urgent that they don't allow you to just uh you know relax a bit and explore so this game gets away with offering that while still adding a timer that will put you under some pressure before you have to move on to the next encounter and yeah the exploration here is just so much fun because I always look forward to uncovering what a loot chest will contain uh because that's when you use your red revealer in the campaign book and sometimes when you enter certain tiles of the dungeon uh you'll uncover events sometimes positive sometimes negative so it always keeps things interesting when you don't know what's going to be around the corner so another thing I really love about this game considering that it's a campaign

game is that there's no giant map board that you have to separately open in between missions when progressing to the campaign much like Gloom Haven or other games do where you have to either have a secondary table to do the in between Mission step of the campaign like the town phase if you will or if you don't have enough room for two tables then you have to clear the entire table just to add the map so here there's no such thing the town phase just all takes place if you just read the campaign book and there is a campaign tracker sheet where there's some pen and paper elements where you'll keep track of your party's XP levels and certain achievements or Milestones that you'll reach throughout the campaign and whatnot but yeah it's just all very minimalistic when it comes to how it handles the campaign progression uh so no uh giant board no map tiles like Eon trespass nothing like that it's just a campaign tracking sheet and the book so you won't be required to clear your table to take to carry out those steps which I just really really appreciate another big plus of this game is the combat system the combat system here is just so detailed and fantastic it is pretty complex but it's just so much fun and it's so crunchy so the biggest element of the combat system here is the custom dice that you'll use uh so when you roll for tests or for combat attacks uh you'll have to decipher you know what the dice do with their icons and

calculate damage so it's a bit mathy but crunchy in a satisfying way so I enjoy rolling the dice and figuring out uh the outcomes and spending my symbols to boost my attack but the other elements that make the combat so interesting is elements like line of sight flanking casting spells jumping which when you move you can jump over gaps and if you fail your character actually dies and they fall to the precipice but your characters can be boosted by other characters nearby to add to their jump test or on the other side of the precipice they can be caught by another character in case they fail the test so yes there's this huge positioning element for trying to flank your enemies so on top of the cool custom dice uh there's also tons of skills that will Aid your character in carrying out combat effectively uh but then there's also a Terrain and positioning element so you're going to encounter very tricky terrain uh throughout dungeons so you're going to have to figure out how to navigate it there's break attacks kind of like in M Knight so when you move close to an enemy and then you move away from them you provoke an attack so you have to factor that in and be careful because break attacks are free so you have to really try to avoid your enemies getting free attacks from you moving uh in their vicinity so yes when you combine all of that the terrain the skills the custom dice the break attacks the line of side the Spells the combat system in this game is just as crunchy

and satisfying as it gets once you've wrapped your head around it it's extremely detailed and it'll lend to some really cool moments and stories as well I also lik the random initiative system very similar to eon's n where each character has a card and you shuffle a deck and then you put them in a row and that's what will determine who acts first each round and I know that some people are not fans of those types of systems but just to let you know I think it worked out really well in this system and it led to some pretty tense moments where you're hoping that the enemy won't get a bunch of turns ahead of you uh but on the other side of that coin is really cool when after you Shuffle the decks you get to act with all four of your characters before the enemy acts so yeah the initiative system here I found it really fun and I would not change a thing about it another thing I liked about the game is the loot system so so there's various types of things that you can Equip to your character like relics armor weapons accessories and you draw from a loot deck to determine how much gold you get from the feeding characters and in that deck sometimes there'll be the rare card that will give you something other than gold it can be a mundane loot card or it can be a very rare card if you get extremely lucky with a d roll which uh it happened to me early on and it got me a pretty meta gaming item which made me build a character around that item somewhat so yeah the loot here in this game is pretty cool I've played some

Dungeon Crawlers or RPGs where the loot can be weak uh but I can tell you the loot in the game is very good and the loot is a huge aspect of the character customization so let's now talk about that so to me honestly the biggest selling point of this game is the character customization it is by far the best character customization that I've experienced in any game of its category and the character customization early on while you familiarize yourself with the different disciplines is a game in of itself because you're going to look through all the cars that are available to you and you're going to try to figure out how to build your characters and one of the coolest things about it is that any character can be any class there's bar any restrictions and characters can have abilities from multiple classes so there's so many possibilities and it's not just the abilities from the classes it's also how you combine that with the loot but thankfully the four main protagonist characters they're asymmetric so each of them have certain strengths and weaknesses which will help you lean on those strengths when building your character so for main maxers there's definitely a very effective route that you can pursue when building certain characters based on their innate abilities but you can also just build whatever sounds fun and to add to the layer of customization there's also this upgrade system where uh you can add upgrades to your weapons and there's dozens of different upgrades that will do stat changes or give you

combat or exploration abilities so the possibilities folks are endless with how you can customize your characters in this game it's pretty Bonkers and there's a lot of documentation out there that you can fine for Effective builds but I just kind of went with my gut and so my party composition ended up being Nightingale as an Archer support seek as a DPS Mage Rook as a melee tank SL healer and Remy as a 200 weapon DPS that focuses on reach and flanking and it's always an absolute blast seeing the effective results of my character builds uh in missions after I spent all that time you know building them so the whole Pro is very satisfying I love it but yeah do keep in mind that early on you're going to have to read through a lot of cards to try to figure out uh how to build your characters because it's not just how you build them at the moment it's the upgrade path in the future what you plan to add to them uh later so it will take some time couple hours minimum early on you know reading all of those cards and figuring out what you're going to do with each character and the system does offer a way to uh you know reset your characters if if you want and it does cost gold but you know you can just ignore that if you want and just rebuild your characters however you wish I have not done this and I've stuck with my builds so far though okay so moving on to another positive of the game for me and that's the story so this is by far the most engaging story that I've ever experienced from a board game and not saying a lot because I've never

really cared about a written story in a board game until now and like a lot of people have pointed out about the story in this game uh the character dialogue can sound pretty juvenile at times and it's very anime tropy indeed so if you don't dig that then maybe you won't like the story but I ate it up and I genuinely enjoy the main cast and I am invested in the story and I want to find out what happens next but keep in mind that the amount of reading in the campaign book is pretty extensive but there is a spark notes version of the story that you can find on the official midara website if you just want to see the main story points and not have to read so much and the final positive thing that I want to bring up with this game is the value proposition I think that even if you pay full price for the game it's going to be worth every penny like I said I only played the first chapter and that's given me between 30 and 40 hours of entertainment and there's still another five chapters ahead of me and it is very much a complete package there are expansions and I read a lot about them considering that I like the game so much but honestly folks I just don't feel the need to buy any of them I think the game comes with so much content as is there is one minor thing where I do think that it could be improved which I'll bring up later uh but it feels like a complete game and all of the expansions to me they feel very much optional okay so now I want to move on to a couple of mixed points first is the enemy variety now this was almost a plus okay uh don't get

me wrong like I said the amount of content in the box is incredible now the thing is there is a particular type of enemy called The Cave sickles which you keep encountering over and over and for the first 80% of the game it really didn't bother me at all I would say even 90% the amount of times that you would see these cave CES uh it really wouldn't bother me they're Dynamic enough okay they're like the uh the Baseline enemy that you're going to encounter and they're again they're interesting and dynamic enough that they didn't get boring for like the first 80 to 90% of the dungeon but by those last couple of dungeons it really started to bother me that they would just keep throwing swarms of these things at you and I just wanted to see them throw all types of enemies at me because there's plenty of enemies in the box but you know I'm just following the dungeon instructions and those are the enemies that they give you now there is an expansion that will add these uh variants for enemies and it includes uh variant of cave sickles uh so that is the one thing that I would like to add to the game at some point so that I don't see the same stats and abilities for the cave CLE all the time uh but there were uh plenty of other types of enemies that were thrown at you throughout the first chapter that were very interesting and when you combine them with the cave sickles it was extremely fun facing them throughout the campaign but yeah I would have appreciated them including the cave CLE

variants in the box for a bit more variety but other than that uh like I said the enemy variety is almost a positive just the you know if they had just included that it would have been perfect but yeah there's plenty of enemies that I haven't even seen yet that I'll encounter in other chapter so there'll be more now another mix thing for me is the rule book so my copy of the game is uh the version 1.2 so it has gone through a lot of feedback and refinements and for a 100 page rule book it's pretty good the thing is I think the explanation for line of side and sphere of influence is a bit lacking uh there are a couple of supplements that I downloaded from borging Geek that help clarify it with some diagrams uh but I really think it would have benefited from more examples of of uh sphere of influence and line of sight it includes plenty of examples for flanking which is fantastic so I never was ever unclear about flanking examples but yeah more sphere of influence and more line of sight would have been appreciated because it's still a bit fuzzy even after I read the rule book twice I was not very clear about it and I had to go and ask uh a couple of examples that I had throughout my campaign on borain geek I had to ask uh if I was interpreting a line of side or sphere of influence correctly and also I found the index a bit lacking for again with this many terms there were multiple occasions where uh I was looking for a term and it wasn't listed in the index so I had to

go hunting for whatever page discussed that term and yeah it's a 100 page rule book so it will require lot of time to wrap your head around the game but it's 100% worth it trust me another mixed thing I found was the amount of upkeep for a solo player so the optimal way to play this game is with the full party of four characters the game does offer a variant where you can control less characters but I did not read good things about it so I stuck with playing the four characters and this isn't an outright negative or positive I think it's okay uh I've played games where controlling three characters wants to even more upkeep than this and I think a big part of why this works pretty well upkeep wise even while controlling four characters is thanks to the fact that everything comes in card form there's no pen and paper elements so everything has a card and you can just keep track of everything with your cards now I do have a fear that as the campaign progresses and I gain more abilities and more complex gear that the amount of effects that I'm going to have to keep track of might get out of control but we'll see all right so now let's move on to a couple negatives and then some final thoughts okay so first is the fact that the game is a big table hog and I don't mean just from the amount of components that you're going to be surrounded with and it's because of the amount of cards that can belong to a character now I came up with a solution to try to minimize the amount of footprint that each character takes uh so I'll show you that at the end but yeah you will need a pretty big table for this and each

character can have so many cards attached to them that they can occupy a lot of room but again came up with a bit of a solution so I'll show you that at the end hopefully that'll help you and the other thing that I found a bit of a negative is the amount of time that it takes to put everything back in the box and vice versa so I timed it and it took me almost an hour to break everything down and put it back in the box with the included insert so I estimate that if I come back to this game a few months from now and I pull everything back from the box and try to arrange it on my table that will take me about an hour and that's not counting the the amount of time it will take me to relearn it because again it is a 100 page rule book and that's the one thing that I'm a bit scared of how difficult will this game be to relearn after a long Gap I definitely don't want to have to reread that whole rule book because it took me quite a while to do that I did print and write a bunch of cheat sheets for myself so hopefully relearning it won't be a nightmare but yeah if you don't play this game for long gaps do expect a significant amount of time having to be spent relearning it it okay so now for my final thoughts to me this is by far the best scripted campaign Dungeon Crawler that I've played to date to me this replaces Gloom Haven completely I don't think that I'll ever have any desire to play Gloom Haven except for nostalgic reasons because it was after all my one of my first solar board gaming experiences a Gloom Haven jaws of the lion I still hold it in high regard

uh because of its ease to learn it uh and its value proposition with how much it cost so there's a couple things that Gloom Haven Jose of the lion does uh that are fantastic still but when it comes to the components the art the story the actual dungeon crawling the character customization the mechanics uh I think that midara blows Gloom Haven out of the water so if I had to keep this or big box Gloom Haven I definitely would keep midara now the other game to me that contents with this in the Dungeon Crawler category is Shadows of Brimstone but the thing is they're pretty different in the sense that it's a lot more procedural and has that emerging narrative element to it uh is way less scripted so there are kind of two different beasts in the same category I still love both to death but if I want the scripted uh game with the story uh I go with midara if I want uh you know just a emerging Story game uh there's Shadows of Brimstone and also Shadows of Brimstone is definitely less rules heavy and it allows you to control less than four characters and it works really well well so they both have their strengths and weaknesses but yeah when it comes to the big box campaign uh based Dungeon Crawler uh yeah midara is definitely the best one I've played today Star Wars Imperial assault follows it up really closely just because how much I love Star Wars and it also lets you control less characters so it has its strengths as well it's less complex while still being loads of fun but but but midara is way way crunchier and as I

mentioned earlier in the review this is the game that has stayed on my table the most to date but yeah while there's definitely a lot of other games that I want to play this year that I want to discuss I don't think it would have stayed for more than one chapter anyway I think I need to take a break with it before I come back for the next chapter for sure and I want to shout out Kevin erskin from one player Guild who host the uh top 200 list because his opinion seems to align with mine a lot so I've respected his opinion a lot over the years like me he considers Mage Knight the number one solo war game but he said that Dar almost replaced his number one spot so when he said that it definitely raised my interest in this game a lot and once I tried it I definitely agree with him it's a fantastic game and it's top 10 top 20 material for me so yeah I definitely respect his opinion A Lot in games and and our taste is a lot and a lot all right so now I want to show you the solution that I came up with to reduce the amount of foodprint for each character in midara okay uh so the first thing that I want to uh bring bring up is this overlay that I created uh for each character so I did buy the official sleeves for the big cards okay uh and what I did was I added uh this I created this myself I think I'll make a file and Link it okay in case that you want this okay but you could just make this yourself if you wanted uh just add a piece of uh tape and write this but I'll share the file okay so what this is is this helps me keep track of my inventory

slots Okay so I added that on top and then I laminated it and I use a dry erase marker for the amount of slots that are occupied but I also use a different color for the upgrades so if my core is upgraded um there's a different color dot there to indicate that that item is upgraded okay uh so then I also printed this from the file section I took a file uh a custom fanmade file and I printed it and I cut this part out specifically right so this is to help me keep track of what color dice my character is using okay so I just add this uh notches here uh using a dry erase marker okay uh to know when I need to do a combat or conviction or casting test uh I just uh glance at this and I know immediately okay uh now I also added a armor uh a armor uh Square here so that I can keep track of it here in front of the other stats and the big reason why I added these two things specially is because uh I I use this grid uh so this was inspired by um by Kingdom Death monster you know how people use um binder Pages for their character item grid I wanted to do something similar here so what I did was I took these Euro seves okay and I uh glued them uh as you see here okay

with double-sided tape all right uh so that it gives me that grid and I use this grid specifically for items that do not need to be exhausted okay you can still use the used tokens for per encounter cards okay uh so that way you don't have to have everything arranged in a huge grid for each character you can only look at the relevant uh information now some items will give you stat increases okay but I keep track of that here so I use a dry erase marker with color so that I can keep track of my stat changes there so even if I cover uh a item with my character card I just keep track of the stat changes there okay and that way I just need to look at the per encounter abilities at any time and when I use it I simply put a token there and that's it okay and if I have other upgrades or familiars I can just put them near the character now here I have my U discipline abilities okay I have them stacked here and here is where I keep my stack of exhaustible cards which I typically move down to here okay when I use them here's where I keep my stack of consumables I don't have any at hand right now for the video okay because I don't want to break down the whole box to go find the consumable deck but uh here is where where I would keep the consumables unex unexhausted items and then exhausted items go here and then when I exhaust an ability I move it here okay so this layout works really

effectively okay but you do need that grid okay oh and by the way when you have um upgrades you can just tuck them here on their cards and that has worked out for me so far okay even if the upgrade is not attached to the weapon it goes to that's fine typically all you care about is the passive when you attack uh so you can keep track of what weapon has what upgrade there okay and uh I typically sleeve them together like this later if I need to store in my backpack and I do suggest that you give some kind of overlay to your characters in order to keep track of their dice their status uh and also any and any changes to armor Health defense and movement you can keep track of if you sleeve the character card uh with some uh highlighter dry erase marker okay uh and yeah since you're going to be covering these cards with your character if you decide to do this uh then yeah you need to keep track of you know your invent slots okay so that's what that was for but this has worked out really well and I almost forgot to mention here I have my backpack okay so this is the little backpack that the characters have uh to carry some side items okay uh so I keep track of them here okay and by the way this is a um this sleeve that I use here this is a hero siiz sleeve okay so it's basically the sleeve that you put over a sleeved card so they're a bit bigger these are KMC hero sized sleeves this is what I use for the uh backpack

okay um there you go uh so yeah when I uh need to store an item I put this here oh and by the way I almost forgot to mention so this black tape that you see here that's a friction tape which I have a short video that you can watch okay uh so uh I'll leave that there for you if you're interested so yeah this is one of my favorite things is some some friction tape it helps keep things in place okay uh so for this grid I added a couple pieces of friction tape and it it helps it stay in place instead of it moving around on the table okay I also added a little stripe at the back of the uh character card in order to help it stay in place like that okay so when you uh when you press them both a bit like this it stays in place right it's kind of like the back of a mouse pad right uh so this works out really well and it really helped me reduce the amount of fiddlin while playing and also keep things compact while still showing me all the information I need okay so I highly suggest that you try this especially as a solo player if you want to control the amount of footprint and reduce fiddlin right so I want to thank you so much for listening today if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section and if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one

Progress saved