Skip to main content
Loading video...

Amsterdam (Macao) Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 20:55

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Amsterdam which is a wonderful player board game designed by Stefan Feld this one takes around 90 minutes to play now Amsterdam is a re-implementation of an older felt game called Macau which has been out of print for a very long time before I get started on my review of Amsterdam I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to acquiring board games here in England and if you use my link in the show notes all the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I've just finished a three player game of Amsterdam here and the board is gonna look something like this now at the top of the board you have this kind of dock area where you have your own little boat and you're going to be sailing that boot around trying to deliver a specific Commodities to specific locations so you can see here that this particular block of buildings here wants these barrels and if you are the first person to do it then you get four points and each person after that or you can do it again yourself is going to get diminishing returns now you also have these warehouses which accept any Goods but there's a lot um smaller capacity to store those where only uh one Warehouse can store one good and randomly at the start of the game there's going to be all these different kind of Dock Workers allocated on these different docks and the idea is you want to be delivering these um colors to their matching colored Piers if I'd live with this brown marker to this spot but I can move in my boat

around then I will be able to move that to this area here and again the sooner you do it the more points you are going to get the bottom half of the board is where the kind of map of Amsterdam is and you can see at the start of the game all of these Commodities are going to be randomly distributed on each of these little Islands I suppose and you're going to have to spend a certain type of resource in order to acquire those tiles onto your personal player board with aim of delivering them to those docs later now you can also see that throughout that map of Amsterdam you have this track which is an initiative um turn order and if you really push further you can end up acquiring points as you go and in the bottom left hand corner of the board here you have the black market where when you end up acquiring these tiles you can swap them with another one if you want to or you can put one onto an empty spot and end up taking two coins the game is also going to include this communal cardboard here which just stores these decks and also tracks the round you're on it's also going to store these bonus tiles which you can use throughout the game there's going to be a bunch of these resource cubes now there is a separate board that comes with the game which is used to store these Cubes but personally I think it becomes a bit too much of a table hog with that so I just use these standard component holders there and each person is going to have their personal player board which looks like this now before the game starts you won't actually have the cards here but again this is the end of a three player game but this board is generally just going to store these shields of yours to show which Islands you control and it's also going to show what's what's on

your barge including these people here and it's going to store your money and these windmill tokens which are simply used to track which cards you've used the game is also going to come with these resource Wheels which is kind of the resource management system in the game it's going to come with a bunch of dice here matching the resources and depending on the Play account you're going to put out a number of these bonus tiles matching certain areas within Amsterdam which is going to be viable for competition when it comes to area control at the end of the game the game plays out over 12 rounds or 10 Rounds if you want to play a shorter game and of course the player with the most victory points at the end of the game will be the winner so the first thing you're going to do each round is to reveal a certain number of these cards now there are three different decks you've got these map cards you've got these character cards and you have these building cards too and the arrangement is going to vary depending on the Play account so let's just say in this some three player game we revealed two character cards one building card and two cards now in turn order you are going to draft these cards and add them to your player board here now when you draft these cards you have to consider not only what you need to spend on them which is going to be these resources here so this particular card here wants two brown cubes and a pink Cube I'll be also going to have a look at the ability on what it offers you so you can see here they do a bunch of different things and I must admit the symbology isn't the best but this one says like when you play a building card you can do it for one resource Cheaper by the looks of it or this one here for each different type of map card you get you get a victory point

and these all do different things at different times so you can see that some of them are always going to be active like this one here which is a infinite symbol and this one here is only going to be relevant during the main action phase and there's a ton of different cards here as you can imagine like this where if you use this particular type of map card you can get a coin or you can discard a pink Cube to get a coin or discard a uh a gray Cube and get a coin at a point and so on now when that draft happens you are forced to take a card and add it to one of these five slots below your personal player board now if you have no room to place one of these cards then you are forced to take one of these penalty tokens which will end up acquiring and accumulating negative points the more you collect and that can really ramp up so you want to be making sure that you get these cards played before you end up drafting a new one and once you've completed the card draft you're going to go into the resource distribution phase which is when you are going to roll these six dies and select two of them now the color of course is important because that's going to relate to the different resources you need you might want those resources in order to acquire certain commodity tiles here so you know if I really wanted these um these two cups here I might want three black resources um but obviously I'm also thinking about which cards I want to build because I want to get them played and not end up acquiring those negative tokens there but let's just say I ended up choosing this brown one and the black five so I'm going to choose those two resources I'll select them from the supply there and add them onto my resource wheel now

depending on the PIP value that I've just chosen it is going to go on that location so you can see I chose the brown one which is one resource on the one spot and the black five which is these these big five cubes there which will go on the five spots now it's important to say that everybody can choose the same ones if you want to there's no kind of turn order distribution there you can take what you want and once you've taken your resources you are going to rotate the wheel anti-clockwise one space like so and anything relating to this Arrow spot is going to come out and be used will be available to be used this round now if you ever rotate the wheel and you cannot actually spit out any resources then you're going to be forced to take another penalty token so you can see here that if you end up drafting the higher valued resources you're going to have to wait a long time until they come back round available to be actually used so let's take a look at all the different actions you can do during the main action phase so the first of which is to build one of your stored cards here so these are not available to be used yet you just have the option to buy them and of course you'd cash in the resources and put that card in your Tableau and ready to be used the second action is to actually use one of these cars out now a lot of the time they won't need resources or anything but sometimes they will you'd cash in those resources and then tap those cards to show that you've already used it this turn now the next option you can do is to acquire one of these Commodities of course by spending the resources on here so let's just say I spent three of these kind of purple

resources I'll take that like so I put one of my player crests onto that matching spot because at the end of the game this is important because each connecting of each connecting Shield of your own is going to be worth three points each at least in your biggest group so that's a good Viber way of scoring points there and when you acquire these resources you're going to add them onto this little storage area of your personal player board another thing you can do is to push along the initiative track so for one resource of any type you can move once like so but for every other space you have to cash in any two resource so for example if I wanted to move it to here it'd be one resource and then two resources if I wanted to move again it'll be another two resources once per turn you have the option to use the bonus tiles here so in this example you can spend one coin in order to get a victory point and to move two along the initiative track and these vary quite a bit so this one here says you can spend five coins in order to get 11 points and a resource Cube and the other option is to move your boat around the dock area so for each kind of speed bump you run into you're gonna have to spend an additional resource so let's just say I wanted to move my yellow boat here from this area to this yellow dock I'd have to spend one resource of any type and then another resource of any type now of course the idea is that I'm trying to deliver these certain Goods to these certain locations in order to get those points um but also it's important to land on these kind of crane areas like so because if you end up on one of these spots you can end up moving all of the

Commodities you've collected from your storage area onto your actual barge meaning that it's now eligible to be scored and also if you ever go to a dock where there's a a dock worker there you could end up acquiring them picking them up and putting them on your barge and if you do that you get a coin with the idea of trying to deliver them to their certain docs and get these victory points from here which we discussed earlier now something that's also important to say is that the earlier you make these deliveries the more points you are going to get as you can see here in the first seven rounds you're going to get bonus points for making deliveries on either those Commodities or those Dock Workers like if you get one done in the first or second round you get a massive bonus seven or six points or you know when you get the sixth seventh round you get two or one points respectively and that is essentially how the game plays out over 12 rounds at the end of the game you're going to add up all the points you've gained during the game and add them with your endgame scoring in relation to your biggest connecting regions of your player pieces here you know three points for each one of those you're also going to have a look at the majorities of these at different areas here which was set up during the you know setup of the game like for example on the player depending on the player count you know if you've got the majority in those areas in a two-player game you get five points but in a four player game you know you get first second and third place there's also the potential to acquire these end game scoring points that look like this like in this example if you end up getting your boat back to the original starting place on the dock area then

you'll get a bonus eight points okay so let's get into the review of Amsterdam and I want to start with probably my favorite mechanism of the whole game which is the resource wheel here I think this mechanism is fascinating and I love the way it works when when you're choosing the resources you want you have the option either to take you know the small amounts but have them available to you immediately or you can take the bigger chunks of resources no there's fives or sixes but you have to wait you know five or six turns in order to use them at your disposal so I really like the way that works and especially you added with the fact that if you don't have anything or one of these empty spots when it comes to rotating then you are going to take one of these um you know punishment tokens which is not good so sometimes you'll be forced to take you know the one or twos even if you've not really got a massive plan for them just so you don't have to suffer those negative tokens because these do ramp up quite significantly and can hurt you badly if you um if you end up acquiring too many um also that added pressure of the uh the card capacity here you want to be making sure that you are at least shifting some of these cards out of here not only because you want the abilities but because again you can end up acquiring these negative points so it's good that it does put you under some pressure here but not too much you can kind of Zig and zag at times and end up taking the easy options here even if you don't have the massive desire to utilize the power of that card but because they're going to be relatively cheap to buy like it's not going to be difficult for me to acquire two brown cubes

but the ability isn't necessarily the best whereas the mixed ones like this like where you're having a bunch of different cubes meaning that you've at least taken a few turns in order to put them all on the same action space then their abilities are going to be much better like in this example whenever I take a one value die as a resource then I'm going to get a bonus two coins and money in this game is extremely valuable something I definitely learned the hard way you always want to be making sure that you have money in your pockets in order to utilize these tiles here because these can swing the game massively if um somebody keeps on getting them and you do not and a very important thing I did not mention is that when you end up taking all your resources from the wheel and of course you'd have much more than this in the actual game if you don't spend them all then you can only actually carry one over to the next round so you can have a ton of resources there but if you don't have a plan for them then they're probably not going to be used to effectively and you could have been wasting them all so you do want to be aligning them with the card You're Building yes you can use them just to kind of move your boat around the dockyard or you can use them in order to you know move the along the initial initiative track which is very important you know this is definitely something you want to be competing in because you'll get first dibs on the drafting you get first dibs on getting the buildings that you want because you know the map is quite tight and sooner or later you will be stepping on each other's toes and you might both want the same particular block of buildings there to add to your connection or to start competing for those majorities

the pick up and deliver part of the game is simple but it's done very well I like the way that you can plan your moves here and you know you can plan effective routes by thinking you know I'm going to move my boat here I'm going to load up on the Commodities I've selected that's right next to the place that I want to deliver it to let's get in there before the other players do so I can get those big chunk of points there um and at the same time I might be on route to something else and then be able to you know pick up a certain dot worker or drop one off and so on so you are rushing to get these done and again you can actually think ahead and think you know what I'm going to live these here I'm going to pick up this commodity then then I'm going to drive to here drop it off here and so on so I do like the way this all comes together I think it was a very cool touch and Feld has been known to do this before where you are incentivized to get out of the gate strong and hot because you know if you get these deliveries done early you're going to get a massive bonus of seven six or five points which is definitely quite significant but if you do that you're probably going to be falling behind on getting these cards down and establishing your engine early and something I've learned the hard way is that you do want to have an eye on these cards in getting them built and not neglect them because this is a 12 round game and the earlier you get these cards built especially the stronger ones it means you have more rounds to exploit them and that can really put you in a strong position if you do end up building those good cards so it is a kind of a cool two-pronged approach there where you know do you want to neglect this and go for those bonus points or do you want to play the long game get a cool engine down and then try to win that way

resource distribution the game does have quite a strange flow to it because sometimes you'll be taking pretty pathetic turns and maybe only having one or two cubes and you're not being able to do much with it and then because you end up stockpiling a bunch on certain um action spots you can have this whole kind of um section here full of resources and you have some kind of Mega turn where you can get so much done and because you are kind of playing um you know not level with the other players it might mean that one turn you have nothing to do and your opponent has loads and the next turn is vice versa so just something to bear in mind though that sometimes you might have to sit back and let your opponents really mull over their tones when yours takes you know a fraction of a second there is a good degree of player interaction here you are of course going to be competing in that open draft there making this initiative order very important I like the idea that again you are stepping on each other's toes in order to acquire the Commodities that you want because you know the flow of the game is going to mean that if you all go for the same thing then the deliveries are going to be worth fewer and fewer points so you might want to go for something else but of course everybody is going to want the same thing which again leads back to that initiative track now I must admit I felt like this this majority part of the game was a little bit tacked on I don't dislike it but I don't think it was highly necessary either but generally yeah it's quite a competitive game and you want to be beaten by other players to the punch and doing most things in this one now I think the time investment of the game is also pretty good you are looking at 90 minutes to play this one in a three or four player

game but I did find myself engaged through the whole thing because you do have to do so much forward planning in this one it's not a game where you can just kind of wing it and hope it works out because you are going to be really bitten um you'll hit hard if you do that because you're going to fall behind on getting these cards built and you're not going to be using or maneuvering around the um the dockyard efficiently I think my sweet spot in terms of the player counts here is three players which is just the general case when it comes to stefanfield games for me my second option would probably be two players and then the four players and the reason I say that is because of what I mentioned earlier where you can end up having quite lengthy turns and when it's a four player game you might have to sit through a couple of late returns before it's your go so yeah bear that in mind but generally I think it scales well there is a solo mode which I haven't played you know I'm not a solo gamer so again I cannot testify to how good the solo mode is I'm generally happy with the production for this game the board is a little bit garish for me but I don't dislike it all the components themselves are high quality like your player pieces are nice and robust standard wooden Euro components such as your meeples and your your tokens the card quality is also decent here this all linen finished cards which is what you'd probably expect when now you are playing these prices but I want to again um kind of put some criticism on the symbology of the game and this applied to some of the other games in the uh Sevenfold collection the um yeah the symbology isn't always the most intuitive and I would probably recommend getting your language dependent cards so you can know what they do just at a

glance and not refer back to the rule book the game is also a bit of a table hog that I mentioned earlier that um this isn't actually um all the setup I have here doesn't actually involve all the pieces so there is actually another board which stores all the Cubes but that would be so huge I don't think I'd even fit it on this rather large table so bear that in mind and you are building a big Tableau of cars out as well so you are going to need a big table to play this one but yeah everything else is good the resource wheels are good they work as they should and yeah generally I'm happy with the production okay so let's share some final thoughts on Amsterdam so there's a lot I like about this game um I want to go straight to the resource mechanism here I think this is absolutely brilliant and when I read it in the rule book I thought that's simple but very cool and it turned out in practice I liked it as much as I thought I would very interesting uh mechanism there there is the potential to build some very cool engines especially if you focus on getting the build early and you can build some very cool things and some of these cards synergize with each other in very interesting ways so yeah another facet of the game that's you know leaves you a lot to discover now I will say I think there's a pretty steep learning curve with this game I think in your first game or two you're going to make a lot of silly mistakes um but for me the idea that I want to come back and rectify those mistakes and do better is a sign and you know a sign of a quality design there so that for me has left me intrigued I want to do better than I've done before and I think I can do that now I've got those kind of Kinks out of my system but I think it's going to be a somewhat polarizing design at times because I

know pick up and deliver isn't everybody's cup of tea I personally generally like um pick up and deliver games I think this is one of my favorite ones I think the pickup and deliver here is done very well and it's not the main feature of the game it's a significant part but it's not the dominating part or at least not the standout dominating part which I think is a good balance amongst the other things here so yeah there's good competition I generally love the way that failed utilizes initiative and making makes it such a pivotal part of the game and that certainly shines through here as well and it's just a very cool game um definitely unique in the way it feels and you know Feld has made lots of games now and the idea that I keep playing them and I keep feeling you know I keep feeling satisfied and interested by playing them more and more it just goes to show that he is one of my favorite designers and I think he's just an absolute Genius of a man so yeah if you like file games I'm pretty sure you'll like this one um I yeah if you if you don't like pick up and deliver maybe steer away from it but generally I'm very happy with the design and um yeah definitely um intrigued to play it more and yeah it's up there for me so that is Amsterdam it's going to get a accommodation from me and um yeah I probably expected that anyway because I am such a failed fan boy so there we go that's Amsterdam

Progress saved