Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cthulhu: Death May Die - Discussion

Transcript 33:06

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm doing a discussion over Cthulhu: Death May Die. Yeah, this is an older game and I am going to be talking about it. One, because uh tons of content have been released for it. I'm going to try not to [ __ ] with the dice, you know, as I'm talking about it. Um but tons of content have has come out for Cthulhu: Death May Die since its original release with more content on the way. And it's always nice to go back and kind of do a re-review over these older games at this point. If I am not mistaken, I want to say that the original Cthulhu: Death May Die came out in 2019. Cthulhu. You know, I should probably look this up before uh 2019.

Hell, yeah. So, I mean, that's 7 years ago. And for a lot of these kinds of games, I mean, you're going to get coverage over it, of course, whenever it comes out. And then as some expansions start trickling in, uh but usually it's maybe a coverage or two and then you kind of move on. But it's spooky season uh by the time hopefully this video goes up. And what's absolutely fascinating about Cthulhu: Death May Die is this game was originally whenever I I remember whenever it came out, I looked at it and I saw CMON, you know, back before their uh financial crisis and their shell of their former selves. Uh you know, they were at the height of of them being kind of like a powerhouse of of the um board game industry.

And then you know, Rob Daviau's name is on it, Eric Lang's name is on it, all those people who I don't know, maybe it's just me and how I'm integrated in the hobby, but I remember when these designers were like, "Damn, this game is being made by Eric Lang. Holy shit." Uh man, just are those days behind us now? I don't know. Uh but I remember looking at it and thinking, "Eh, okay, I'm not really all that interested." And I'm like a huge fan of the Lovecraft uh board games, but

[snorts]

uh and the Lovecraft novels. But there was something about it that just didn't quite draw me to it. And then, you know, fast forward and I end up playing it and I absolutely loved it. And you know, then they did their their next season of of crowdfunding. I end up going all in on that, getting all the content for it. And it turned into this game that while had a lot of amazing content, formed into this Ah, this is so much [ __ ] to try and sort through if I want to get a different character or different, you know, enemies. I have to find all the the episode components. So then, I print off, I pay for the STL files and I print off this 3D uh printed insert for it all.

And it condensed it down into four boxes. Uh all four seasons that are out for it. Uh it condensed it all into that. I'm like, "Oh, sweet. It's going to make it so much easy easier to get to the table." And then I never did. And so the question kind of became, "Well, okay, do I really like this game if I'm not getting it to the table?" So uh my girlfriend and I, we've been doing we've been focusing on horror-themed you know, board games and stuff and video games. And we just got finished with Don of Madness and there was a moment I was like, "You know what? I'm going to I I want to play this. Let's set it up." And this is all a long-winded way of me still saying this game still absolutely holds up. It is so much freaking fun.

I And and the the enlightening thing about it, A was that the 3D printed inserts, yeah, while it condensed it all, my worry was, "Okay, you condensed it, but at what cost?" Because now is all the stuff still going to be all over the place where I still have to get all four boxes out and I still have to do all that. And they kind of, but it was a lot simpler to set it up. So, we you get it out and I, you know, I have her pick the god and I just started with season one scenario one or season one episode one. And the awesome thing about doing these re-reviews so many years later is all the hype for the game is dead. You know, there's no one no one talks about this game unless they're doing a a horror-themed top 10 list or their top 100 or something.

So, the the buzz for the game isn't going to skew anyone's, "Oh man, it's the new hot game. I got to either make a hot take opinion or I got to say it's the best thing ever." Whatever it might be. So, you get to come in with a fresh set of eyes. And then you get to compare this to all the games of this kind that have come out either to be inspired that were that were inspired by it or that are in the same genre of kind of dungeon crawlery kind of horror-themed games. Uh and you see, "Okay, I see the bones here, but it's not as good as these games that have come out after it." And that is not the case with Cthulhu: Death May Die. I know there are some games that have come out that do have that kind of that sanity element, which I'll talk about, but there is just something really unique about the way Cthulhu: Death May Die operates.

The best thing that I think that is about it, at least one of the best things, is how seamless this game is. Cuz so many games come out now, and because it's 2026, and there's a there's thousands of board games that come out, you have to always try and be unique. You have to be innovative. You have to be quirky. You have to be odd to somehow not be like, "Well, this game is all right, but it's just like the 10 others that I can think of." Um but at that cost, you make it almost unintuitive to be able to get into your game. And whenever you're looking for a game to just get to the table, to be able to sit down and maybe play with someone new, or maybe as a refresher, like it was as a refresher for me, and it was a new player for my girlfriend, uh we it it was it took 5 minutes to teach. And I I kid you not, I did not read the rulebook. I referenced it maybe on on a few things, but just by being able to look at the character card and see what you do on your turn, it I was like, "Oh, yeah. No, it just It was like riding a bike." I'm like, "Yeah, okay. Yeah, you do these three.

You have three actions you get to do on your turn." And okay, they only says you can move three spaces. So, if you move and well, then in this game, when you move, the characters actually or the enemies actually follow you. So, that's something to take into consideration. We had to look up what fire did, if it hurt you when you were standing in it, but it's like, "No, if you move out of it, you take fire tokens." But very little things like that. And that is so rare for a game that I have not touched in years.

So, it it was amazing to just be able to come back to a game that is 7 years old and just oh, yep, no, it. I I remember exactly how this is played. I even remembered pretty much how to set it up. I mean, that's the only time I kind of extensively really looked at the rulebook was by being able to just have the set up I didn't actually I don't even think I had the set up page open that long. I said I just flipped over the back of the the episode card and I was like, oh yeah, this is how you set it up. But I couldn't remember if okay, this is how many cultists you have in the episode total or if that's just for set up. And so I looked in the set up and it said, "Take all the enemies referenced." I'm like, "Oh, okay." So, that really kind of blew me away of being able to teach this game, okay, you take three actions, here's what they do.

Every time you have to do a roll, you roll these dice. Every exclamation point is a success, every tentacle, your sanity goes up. [snorts] Um and then, you draw mythos card at the end of your turn. That's going to do something. It's going to spawn enemies. It's going to have an effect. You know, when three of those symbols show up, the Ancient One advances. And then, if you're in a space with enemies, they fight you. If you're not, then you draw a discovery card. And then your turn's over. And that's it. It It And it really highlighted how a little goes a long way. Uh because man, I've just [clears throat] the games that I've played lately that are in this genre, uh while being fantastic, if I were to come back to them, even a month later, I feel like I have to be like, uh well, let me refresh myself.

And the amount of times I've played this game compared to some of the more recent ones that have come out in, you know, the past year or so, are you know, pretty much equal in uh in, you know, number of plays. But, this one just has such a simplistic approach to it uh that it kind of turns into quality over quantity. There's not a ton of stuff that is happening, but you're invested in the game the entire time. There's still high strategy, there's a little bit of luck. The game has amazing mitigation with the stress uh the stress track. And it's also a small footprint. Now, mind you, we just played the first episode, but in later episodes I've played, this doesn't turn into this insane table hog weird game. Um now, don't get me wrong, I love Horror on the Orient Express. I think that game is is really, really good, but my main complaint was it's this massive [ __ ] table hog where you have to get creative with how you're setting it up. That's like, "Okay, let's all just get cuddled up next to each other so we can see the board." You know, it it gets really weird.

And this game never does that. There's never a moment where people are just like, "What's happening way over there?" It's just It just works. So, that was something that I found that was amazing to come back to this game so many years later. And it What was even cooler is the things that you see from recent games that people were inspired by with this one. Uh the main one being the sanity track. I know that that's how that works in this game. It's of course the the probably the more unique thing about it. And then of course, later on you see it in Grim Coven, you saw it You see it in um [ __ ] What was it?

There was another game that just [clears throat] did that same kind of the the closer you are to death the more Oh, uh technically ATO does that. That kind of double-edged sword. Um this game kind of did that first. And even though I knew that that was the main draw to this one, it was still really cool to go back and explain it again and be like, "Yeah, see, and and here's the really neat thing. Like whenever you go up on sanity, okay, not only do you have to pop off your your disorder card, uh you get to level up one of your abilities. Oh, but you know, now you see that that green die underneath that? Well, now every time you have to roll one of, you know, make a roll with these three black, you get to add in a green to it."

And it's such a small thing, but that's such a cool element even all these years later of being able to think, "Oh, every time I make a check, okay, I rolled two tentacles. Hmm, actually, if I'm like two away, do I want to spend my stress to reroll those? I don't think so. I got three successes. That's going to kill the Byakhee I'm attacking, and I get to go insane." And you can sometimes use that to your ability, depending on which disorder you have. Uh in this in the game we played recently, I had the codependency one. And where we were at, um we were playing fighting against Hastur. Hastur moved to the yellow um the yellow gate, but on the way, cuz the way the fire was spreading and stuff, my character actually I wanted a bunch of fire tokens cuz I had ways to if I would take wounds from uh fire, I could dish it out instead. And I was like, "Great, I'm going to run past this fog area that has seven fire in it and just blast people with fire, but I don't That's my only way of really dealing damage. So, I'm actually kind of, you know, uh the other the other character, my girlfriend, she was pretty much going to die if she followed me. But so I was able to roll and or move out of that area and then roll, go up to a new

sanity spot, trigger my codependency, which was basically, "Hey, if you're not near someone or if you're not near your codependent person, one of you either have to go to them or they have to come to you." I'm like, "Okay, you come to me." I'm screaming, I'm having a meltdown. You rush to me, doesn't count as a move or anything. So, it's like, "Okay." So, we were able to avoid that, which was is just a really neat way of triggering what is inherently as viewed as kind of a negative effect that could just be kind of a a positive one. Um and then she went and ended up doing the final blow to Hastur cuz she had this really broken um ability as Fatima. But that is such an awesome awesome element.

It's always been the coolest thing again of being able to Okay, every time I'm going up because you only have six levels on this sanity track. Uh so, you could if you like all three of your abilities, you could just go two, two, and two on each one or you can max out two of them. And but you also don't want to necessarily go that high. You will be powerful, but you are most likely just going to die on your very next roll um unless you just get really lucky. But, I I think this is one of the best ideas in cooperative gaming that I have that I've seen. That double-edged sword element has always been so cool. And then the way that the characters are designed and there are 90 something characters, uh I think.

I'd have to count them again, but there there's a ton and there actually technically more content on the way. But uh I I think it's always been awesome cuz every character has like their own unique one. Like the top one, this is unique to who this character is. But then you always have this this pool of two of two other abilities, you know, you might have a few people with marksman, you might have swiftness, you might have brawler, you might have whatever it might be. And I don't know if they've if they purposefully looked at the character, you know, if they looked at Fatima, saw Read the Omens, and then thought, "Oh, okay, I bet you Arcane Mastery and Swiftness would go well with her." Or if they just literally put all the abilities on a randomizer wheel, hit the you know, clicked it, and then up, she got Arcane Mastery, and spin again, and she got Swiftness. That's who the All right, Fatima's done.

I don't know how they did that, but there's never really been a a triplet or a trio of ability on a card where I looked at it and thought "Okay, well, this one makes no sense why this person has it." You know?

[snorts]

Like the the character I was playing was Agent Friday and he had What was it called? Secret Secret Information, Marksman, and Toughness. And all three of those made sense to him. And honestly, I just picked him because we were playing on a Friday.

I didn't want to think too deep on it, but every character, that's the other cool thing about Cthulhu: Death May Die, none of them are your traditional characters from Lovecraftian stuff. You don't see you know, well, now I'm drawing a blank on all of their names. You're not seeing Ashcan Pete, you're not seeing Shooter McGavin,

who's I I think that's the guy from Happy Gilmore.

[snorts]

You're not seeing Monterey Jack, you're not seeing Roland Banks. And I love all those characters. I love being like, "Oh, I know who this is." It's sense of familiarity there familiarity. But this one was really cool. You have Fatima, you have uh you have Rasputin. He's in like the core game. Um you have Bill Nighy. You have a lot of the characters actually end up looking like real actors. And that was just always a neat a neat touch that I thought was just a really good They could have easily just done it with all those characters that we've seen before in Eldritch Horror and Arkham Horror and all that, but it was it was a new take on this kind of um Lovecraftian uh game. Actually, I think

[clears throat]

Unfathomable does the same thing. I don't think those are familiar characters either. But so the characters are awesome. They whenever you're looking at them, you might think, "Oh, well, their layout is similar, so they must not be that deep." But the game just feels good. Every time you level up, it's always, you know, I remember she whenever she was leveling up for the first time, she was reading all three of what what they were. She's like, "What do you think?" Uh I was like, "I don't know. Pick one."

[snorts]

And she She's like, "Oh, well, they're all good." I'm like, "I know." They are all good. Every one of your abilities when you're leveling up, all of them are good. And some of them might just be situational. The Agent Friday ability, he had these tip tokens he can give out, and I never leveled it up. Um but it cuz but they came in clutch so many times because the tips allowed you to move two I was allowed to move two, deal Actually, I have them right here. It's move two, heal two stress or deal a wound to an enemy in your space as a free action. That's huge. Being able to move two for free, uh and to have a character who can roll six dice and, you know, do all her elder signs are treated as a success. Like, it's disgusting. So, the combinations you get with the characters and their abilities uh based off the episode they are in and the god you're in allows for this really cool and high variety game.

Especially with the amount of content that there is for it right now with with four seasons. Um and you just don't It feels like you just don't get that kind of variety anymore. Um and I mean cuz let's say let's actually funny enough let's take let's take another uh another game that's kind of in this in this genre uh that I was already talking about, Horror on the Orient Express. Um it is a really good game and it is a deduction style game. So, it does play It It plays completely different. Uh but it has this a similar vibe to it. And that game kind of I don't know. It just feels like whenever you're comparing it to a game like this one that I could see the game feeling samey after mult after multiple multiple plays. Like, with this one what makes Cthulhu Death May Die so, you know, such a high um like a high not not high stakes. It's more like a high value game uh for me is that you can pick the same episode and even the same god and get different characters and it would feel different. And that is, you know, insanely important. Is it might, you know, in the grand scheme of things it might still play out the same,

but the the way the mythos cards come out and the way the discovery cards come out, mixed with just your character's abilities, will have you tackle the episode in a different way. And that is almost enough. Uh well, that is enough, but they went a step further with this one with the way that you actually set up the episodes, which is again an awesome way. And that is when you pick an episode, you pick a god, and you mash the mythos cards together. The discovery cards stay the same. Those are all episode-based. But, with the way that you pick a god and its special abilities, Haster is all about these yellow sign tokens, uh for example, but the gods have their own unique ability. And then they're going to have their own unique enemies and monsters.

And then their own unique mythos cards. It is very similar to how Final Girl is and Terrorscape, the two other horror games, uh surprisingly. But, with the way that you can mix the killer and the location uh for Final Girl and for Terrorscape, mix the killer and the and the location, will give you a completely different strategy and way you're going to interact with the game. This does the exact same thing, except instead of a location, it's you pick an episode. And that is just That adds so much variety to me, and that is super important whenever you're looking at a game to try and get to the table as much as possible, because again, it feels as if there's these games that are coming out that get really high rankings with a lot of reviewers, possibly myself included, and it's like, man, this game is a [ __ ] nine out of 10. I am loving it.

And then, you know, they they've played it twice and that's the longevity of the game. And either they never touch it again or they play it again later or it's just there are a lot of factors that go into a ranking, but a game like this is you could again play the same episode over and over and just I'm going to play with Hastur. I'm going to play with Cthulhu. I'm going to play with Azathoth. I'm going to play with the Black Goat. All with the same episode. And it's going to feel and interact differently. It's it's amazing. It's it's such a simple It really is a simple design. I mean, to make all that balanced or fun. Actually, I've heard that there's a combination of episode and God that my friend swears by is impossible. And that might be true.

You might need things in certain combinations to go 100% your way. You might need, you know, the specific ability or the specific discovery card. But and you might have games that go 100% your favor and it ends up being still, you know, a you know, a breeze. So, but that adds to the fun element. You know, you're not going to win all the time. You're not going to lose all the time and that to me creates a balanced and fun cooperative experience. I'm one of those people I think board game difficulty is, you know, asinine. They It It to me it never feels balanced or tested. You know, whenever it's you look at some ways to bump up the difficulty like 20 Strong, for example.

It's Man, I barely won on basic. Oh, you have five difficulty levels? Yeah, I'm not ever going to touch those. Or hard mode in Final Girl or or or you have games that are just actually as they are like Frostpunk and no one's ever won episode one, you know, or scenario one. So, I'm not one of those people that when a cooperative game hits the table, it's like I like to win, of course, um, but I will find myself getting extremely bored if you win all the time. Um, because then it it feels as if you figured it out, okay? The game doesn't have any, you know, it doesn't have any expansions. We, you know, we've kind of played, we've seen everything that it has to offer and I've never lost and there's nothing else to it. But, oh, I know there's difficulty levels. I don't want to [ __ ] touch those cuz those are probably just going to make the game feel broken. It to me board game difficulty feels like a video game difficulty where all they did was just increase the health of the enemies and made the the enemies you're fighting bullet sponges.

That's not good difficulty design. And all that is is to wrap around and say that Cthulhu: Death May Die gives you with the way that the episodes and stuff are set up to feel like okay, this one went our way, that was a lot of fun. Let's play again cuz it doesn't take that long, either. Let's play again and oh man, we got our ass kicked. Okay, well, let's set it up and try again. You know, it gives that that feeling of let's just try again. You know, let's keep the same characters and see if we get you let's strategize yeah, strategize differently. And okay, this isn't working. Okay, your ability isn't really helping out that much. Okay, let's pick a different character. Things like that, but you don't have to mess with any arbitrary difficulty. So, it it is a incredibly fun, simple to play, but highly innovative and and, you know, a game that stands the test of time.

I it it I I have Cthulhu: Death May Die relatively high in my top 100, um if I remember right. And [snorts] that was after not really having touched it in many years. I mean, it's probably been a good few years since I've played it. And I even got like the season 4 stuff. I have the Cthulhu the massive Cthulhu with the Relic Rising the uh scenario you can play. And I always told myself, yep, I'm going to get it played and I just want to organize it. I just want to do that. And then I never I never did. Um but it's it was really cool to be able to come back to it and be more into the game than I think I was whenever it originally came out. Which I don't know how that's possible.

Uh I think I just have like a different sense of appreciation for games nowadays. Um where funny enough I was talking about this with a guy in one of my comments is with how many games that are coming out, you know, it has to either be consistently supported, but it can't be too supported because then it gets bloated to where it just becomes unwieldy. Um but it then if it's not supported, it eventually just gets forgotten and you move on. So, to have a to have a game come out and it really kind of has to be exceptional to kind of stay within a collection. And I was running on the idea of having all the Cthulhu: Death May Die content on I remember it being really good.

But I guess I don't really know if it's still is cuz tastes can change and you know, you can play a game that you remember liking many years ago and then it's like, "Oh, this kind of [ __ ] sucks." And this was not that. It was

[clears throat]

And hell, this might be a shock. The small tiles didn't really bug me that much. Like it was I was at I understand now. I I've had this epiphany cuz I I know that's the biggest complaint. It it it it still sucks, but you know, cuz as soon as Hastur came on the board, it was like, "And this is why it's a pain." Cuz he came on some small tile and and stuff, but

[snorts]

I what I have now what I now view the small tiles is at it's like, "Oh, it's not a math it doesn't take up my entire table. It's all centralized and focused here in this 4x4 area or whatever." I And that was just kind of nice. So, I don't know. I mean, yes, I would much rather have the tiles be larger so that everything that could be on the on the tile can be. But but yeah, I I really didn't end up hating the small tiles. They just it kind of worked. Now, this could just be the scenario we played and it just kind of worked out for us, but yeah, I I don't know. If this is if this is one that you have been eyeing, um and you know, you might have been on the fence about it, then I personally think that this game is is going to be a classic.

I think after 7 years, it still stands the test of time. Um and honestly still lands better than most uh most games of this of this genre that I that I've seen lately. So, um I think that's it. I think that's my thoughts on Cthulhu: Death May Die. I have a I have a geek list on BoardGameGeek where I put up like video ideas on on there for a ton of different games, whether they're campaign games or episodic games like this or or whatever. A few other standalone games that um I just have ideas for.

On that geek list, if it's not there, I'll have to add it, but uh after playing this one, I kind of want to do a series on the channel where I just play every episode, especially with the new Was it Forgotten Reach? Forbidden Reach? The new content that's coming out uh I think this year. Um that should be coming out. So, I kind of want to play this as an episodic pick it like season 1 episode 1 boom, and then just put all the investigators on a randomized wheel and just two-handed um to play. So, if that's something that would be interesting to you, let me know in the comments and um yeah, that's it. That's everything. Oh, on a scale of 1 to 10, where do I have this sitting at right now?

[snorts]

It is sitting at a nine. I'm going to give it the all all-important 10. Nine is already insanely high. And I don't know what it was that was keeping it from being a 10. Maybe it was a 10 at one point, then it dropped to a nine. Um maybe I gave it a nine cuz of the tiles or something, but going back to this game again so many years later, and again with how easy it was, I I it's insane I was not I never had to look at the rule book or had to sit down and reread it. I was just Oh, yep, okay. Nope, I got it. And just the fresh perspective that I have on it so many years later and the kind of the new appreciation I have for it.

I got to have to bump it up to a 10. This game is amazing.

[snorts]

So, that's it everyone. That's my thoughts on Cthulhu: Death May Die. Let me know what you think in the comments below and like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful

Progress saved