Skip to main content
Loading video...

Destinies Board Game Review - A Decent Effort But I Have Issues

Transcript 26:53

hi everyone welcome to another broken meeple review on this somewhat wet uk rainy day and have i got the hotness for you destinies this has been talked about constantly lately if you're a gamer and you haven't heard of this by now then what cave have you been living under seriously is number one on board game geek for the hotness rating right now and board game creators have been putting out reviews putting out nines and tens and fives out of fives and all sorts this is getting so much praise it's unreal now of course the question i have to ask then is is it all just hype or is there actually some truth behind all this praise well let's go into some detail and find out more destinies offers a fully story driven app supported rpg like board game experience without the need for a game master each scenario depicts part of a vivid world full of dark stories epic npcs and mysteries to solve each player takes the role of a hero on a quest to fulfill their own destiny each destiny is the final goal of a character and each has at least two completely different paths to victory composed of a branching series of quests players compete with each other to push the world towards their own destiny much like lucky duck games previous fare chronicles of crime the game uses an app and scan and play technology with qr codes to offer players a unique story driven experience full of dynamic events epic adventures and an ever-changing game world at every turn players discover new parts of the world presented on tiles explore them and pick one point of interest to visit

there they learn more about the story and make crucial choices about how they want to interact with people creatures or situations faced the consequences of each choice are meaningful and often change the state of the world forever by exploring the map and visiting the various points of interest players will gain experience which they can use to level up their free skill tracks these skill tracks determine how easy or hard it is to gain successes for various tests such as dexterity or strength players will acquire item cards which can be sometimes discarded for a special bonus used for a constant effect or ability or used in conjunction with some of the interactions via the app by scanning the qr codes players will progress through the story at their own pace before attempting their finale which consists of several interactions and skill checks woven together the first player to complete their finale and fulfill their destiny is of course the winner of course the box duration says two to two and a half hours to complete the game of destinies that is each scenario of destinies now that to the two and a half hours time limit is true in more ways than one when it comes to multiplayer in two or three player you are looking at about two to two and a half hours to finish a particular scenario this seems quite long though especially when you consider that the stories even though they are like you know their stories their general fantasy stories they're not the most shall we say in-depth stories ever and you've taken it in turns to basically take the app do your bits and bobs with it and then pass it on to the next player once it's not your turn there's pretty much nothing for you to do

except for listening to the story of what the other players are doing so two to two and a half seems a long time to go through this bearing in mind that sort of length for time is about as long as it should take a two to three player group to finish a game of detective in fact chronicles a crime that i mentioned earlier their previous fear from lucky duck you can get a scenario done in less than two hours easily and i would argue the stories in there are a lot more detailed and intricate than what is going on here if you play solo mode though that two to two and a half hours is actually how long it takes to complete the whole campaign wow i mean seriously we'll get onto the solo mode in more detail later but two to two and a half hours that's as long as it took me to complete the entire campaign in solo mode i'm not joking each scenario took me about 30 minutes way way too short for an immersive story driven experience and you know how i was able to do that because one i'm a little bit of a speed reader that kind of helps but secondly when you're playing by yourself you literally your turns are pretty much just go i'll go to that towel boop uh choices boop boop boop boop boop roll a couple of dice boo boo boop and turn n you know there's your turn like really really quickly now you might think well hang on a minute what about all the map stuff and everything you don't need it no you really don't in solo mode everything is handled on that app and we'll get into more detail with that later but you know with the app in solo mode you don't need half the pieces in the box you don't need the minis you don't need the map

tiles you all you really need is what goes on your player board so your skill markers the dice and the item cards and when you don't have to spend time going through that deck of tiles going all right location 44 location 46 etc you'd be surprised how quickly you can get through a map and you're thinking on a minute what about the frame of reference of the map it's all on the screen the only thing that isn't there is where your personal player piece is and if you can't remember the location placement of one mini this is the least of your concerns hello hello anybody home in terms of ease of play this rule book is a plus grade material seriously this rule book is easy to read it's got large font lots of pictorial representation and icon reference on the back there is ease there's no way you can get a rule wrong with this there's nothing that complex in this game really to begin with and in combination with an app that is definitely a step up from chronicles of crime honestly this is the easiest story driven game i have ever gotten into the fact that there's even a watch it played video for this which ultimately seems kind of pointless no offense to rodney but seriously you should have just put your feet up and taking the day off and like you know taking some hard-earned rest because frankly i don't see how it's physically possible if you get to wrong with this book and the app you can literally be up and running with your first scenario in the first five minutes of reading this it doesn't take long to skim through it and even then the setup pages takes you into the app and into the scenario so you can pretty much just play the game and learn it as you go it is that simple definitely

not going to flummox anybody even new gamers to this kind of style of game story driven mode and this high praise continues with the app itself it is a step up from chronicles of crime it's yeah i mean chronicles already had a fantastic app this one's even better it handles all the operational aspects of the map reveals the points of interest the various choices you can make in each scenario like in the interactions themselves as well as skill test results it does everything you need it to except for tracking where your miniature pieces which is kind of odd but you know as i said in solo mode you don't need to care and honestly in multiplayer you don't overly need to care i mean you can pretty much just pass the tablet around and just remember where you were last and you're pretty good really the map tiles almost seem a little bit redundant but if you want that visual reference it is there in terms of like some nitpicks i have with it though there's not really a lot to nitpick this app on except seriously lucky duck would it kill you to put a back button on your app yes okay you might get the odd player who's going to cheat by choosing a thing on the app and then thinking oh that wasn't particularly good i'll go back and choose the other one whatever let them cheat let them play the game however they like but for those of us who accidentally pressed something when they weren't meant to do that and they have no way to undo the action it was a pain in chronicles of crime in this it's not as bad but still it's something that would be nice you know a back button can't be hard to program guys honestly for ease of play great rulebook great at top marks

so a little hit and miss on the duration but such good praise for the ease of play so we're going to continue on that front right oh my dear doctor you have been naive yeah things are a little bit on the downward spiral when it comes to the tactics and strategy not all bad but well let me tell you more firstly the solo mode there's two ways to play explorer and challenger one is meant to be kind of like the free-for-all mode thinker the adventure mode in journeys in middle earth it's a bit like that but the challenger mode is the time pressured version where it only gives you so many rounds to complete the scenario fulfill your destiny occasionally it might extend your timer but you have to know exactly how it will do that it's not like you're given a clue as to how that's gonna happen but for the most part it's very time pressured i'm just gonna say it right now do not play challenger mode it's john's party you are fined one credit for a violation of the verbal morality statute i'm sorry it just is if you play challenger mode the time pressure is so ridiculous that when you are playing a game if you do not go to the specific locations you need to go to and pass all the skill checks that you're meant to at least the first time if not maybe the second time on some of those checks you will not succeed the scenario with the limited time you're given the standalone scenario that you do for the training mission gives you eight rounds eight that's it you have a mac tile segment like a whole map world that consists of a good 10 11 tiles i think or something like that 12 max

with one maybe two interactions on each usually two occasionally free and dynamic events happening as well there is no way you can do everything in those eight rounds you have to know exactly where to go you've got to be like sherlock holmes from consulting detective so what happens is that you play the mode and you go through it and you fail and then you play again and then you're like well i know what to do there so i'll avoid that bit i'll go to this bit right quote and then i'll go oh no fail and then third time it's like well i'll go to that bit and see whether oh no what i fail does this really need bells to you yeah it's time stories it's the same problem that time stories had for people the multiple runs where you fail and then you go back to the start and you rinse repeat that's what challenger mode is you play it you fail and then you if our time stories logic go to the places that you couldn't do before it's almost as if this was like a direct module that could be plugged into time stories it almost could be to be frank the challenger mode is not worth your time trust me on this so okay explorer mode should be a lot better than well again yes and no yes you have all the time in the world to do what you want to do go around the map explore this have a drink in the tavern go talk to this old guy maybe you know play some dice with some gypsy using that down the bottom of the city whatever you want to do you can basically go for the adventure at your own pace and events will still happen based on what scenario you're doing however the problem now is that you have removed all the challenge in challenger mode you have too much challenge to like frustrating the amount of challenge whereas in explorer mode

you have zero challenge like no challenge whatsoever because as far as i can tell even when i was just dilly-dallying a lot of the time there's no way to fail the quest or at least you've got to be if there is a way to fail the quest i didn't see it yeah i i haven't gone through the app and purposely just tapped and turned 50 times to find out but there were scenarios where i was really just running around in circles and still didn't fail when you get to the finale it just basically is a case of how long it takes you to get through the set finale as opposed to oh well the finale didn't happen you lose the game so and even then by the time you get to the finale you're powerful enough to take on superman so what difference does it make it's not like you are going to fail so with explorer mode it's basically just go through the story and just see what happens so okay multiplayer is the savior at this game right not exactly the problem is yes it solves some issues with the solo mode you spend more time playing the game you've got people around you you get to see more of the stories pan out at once the problem is multiplayer mode brings in its own share of issues firstly do not go into destinies as a gamer or thinking that this is a gamer's game if you're a euro gamer you're not going to enjoy this flat out you won't enjoy this even i had slightly like wrong expectations when i first came into this and i had to kind of change my tone a little bit as i played it more to realize ah yeah this is much more a family game this is something that i would expect parents to get their young children into for a light story based game you might as well call it destiny's

quote unquote my first story game like my first scythe my first ticket to ride that kind of thing this is basically my first story game and the reason for that is is a it's super light i mean it's 2.0 on board game geek i mean i don't trust that rating that much but come on even 2.0 is quite generous for this this is a very light game but also the game is essentially a big luck fest and that's another problem you don't really feel like you have a lot of control over what happens to you overall you've got a different path to victory okay great but with the three characters that you have for each particular scenario there's essentially two paths per character but they overlap so you might like jail with someone else or you might have completely different ones whatever but it's entirely luck of the draw or lack of the path you take as to whether you get to yours first before another opponent does because you're racing each other to the finale but let's say i gotta go find two ritual items i go over to the marketplace ah there's no ritual items here oh great well where do i go now whereas your opponent had to go kill three monsters or something goes to this random village hut oh my god monster kills it and they're already in the lead because they just happen to go the right way and the interactions are pretty basic i mean you go to a hut and it may give you like one choice it might give you four or five choices but your turn doesn't end until you leave so you might as well do everything there which kind of is a bit weird but you know you basically just decide which skill check am i gonna roll and go with it now before we get into the

second half of this review please consider leaving a thumbs up on the video it means the world to me to know you appreciate the content also don't forget that this channel is sponsored by zatu dot co dot uk in the description you will find a code for five percent discount of anything you purchase off their website if you like the sound of this game or anything else i've reviewed on the channel and you want to save yourself a bit of money while purchasing some great games consider visiting zatu.cod at uk and making a purchase today now on to the rest of this review so in terms of the aesthetics come on can this bring the game up a notch yes to a point over production is a word i would use a lot of the components in this are really really good though the tiles are cool the um well they're basically thick car but they're still good mac tiles the dice are fantastic these are some really nice looking chunky dyes with custom facings on them really really good they're a joy to roll there's very thick tokens for money and experience points and the points of interest and the slightly redundant trade token tiles that barely get used but as i say very good thick tokens i mean honestly for those in the kickstarter who've got the metal coins it almost seems kind of pointless really because i think the coins are already good enough without getting the metal stuff and you really didn't need the play map because frankly you're laying a few tile cards down and in solo mode you don't even need the tile card so the mat is incredibly redundant at that point and then you've got the miniatures which really what was the point the miniatures are complete waste of space yeah there are a couple of good ones in there there's one pretty big miniature

that's really cool and a few normal sized ones but the rest of them are so tiny tiny it's ridiculous i've never seen miniatures this small since warhammer epic remember that game warhammer 40k epic where you did these massive grand scale battles and the miniatures are like this tiny it's like that in this game and they're supposed to represent like you know some npcs and your player characters but a lot of the time because you can't tell which minis what at a distance you end up moving other players meeples quite a lot or you just can't tell which one is supposed to be yours in the first place i actually don't know which mini is supposed to be the huntsman dog pig pig loaf of bread so i just picked any old generic meatball and just ran with it it's that hard to make them out you're probably going to want to stick with them or paint the bases to distinguish them but then honestly i would have been perfectly handy if this just had standees it's not that the minis are bad quality apart from the diminutive size it's just why do we need them for solo players you don't even need the tiles with the minis it's completely pointless but even in a multiplayer game would stand ears have been too much standees would have been fine they would have looked good you could have had good artwork on them hell i would have taken tokens tokens circular tokens on the tiles for as much as it really matters but of course kickstarter plus minis it goes profit that's exactly what happens whenever a kickstarter happens you gotta put minis in it otherwise it will never get money that's unfortunately the sad rule of kickstarter these days but you know the minis they're in there but

this is why you've got a box that big you know you really could have had this in a much smaller box if you just had player boards item cards and a bunch of tokens but the minis take up a good third of the space in the backs and they're just really not that needed okay destiny you gotta fight a little bit harder here come on what about immersion this is a story based rpg style game so naturally this is gonna be rated very heavily on immersion factor is it great it's good it's good it's good but not great their stories are fine but they are your everyday run-of-the-mill fantasy trope stories there's nothing in these stories i would consider to be unique particularly innovative or really top-notch writing to be honest it's it's fine they're passable they will keep you entertained for the one time you'll need to play this you know more on that later but yeah the stories are not going to suddenly give you a lot to remember after you're done playing a game i've already forgotten the plot of a couple of the scenarios already after playing them a couple of times it's they're just not that memorable i think chronicles of crime did a lot better and i know i keep bringing that up but come on this is the direct comparison you know people are going to ask this question but the stories in chronicles i thought were more detailed they were more intricate they threw you for a loop at times you know they threw in good plot twists here there's not really many plat twists it's just very bare bones now granted as i said this game is probably best geared towards families and young children they keep me entertained for the 30 minutes it took me to get through them

but then i don't really remember them much afterwards but that being said the theme is still strong here you know with the item cards with the app itself providing some good ambient noise in the background as you go into each point of interest you know it does immerse you into that world granted i wish there was some more voice acting in this app because literally the only voice acting you get is in the intro that's it seriously i would have liked to have had voice acting for the actual interactions you came across with npcs that would have been so much better but also some music would have been quite nice as well oh yes you've got the ambient noise but the only music track on the entire app is this one track that's annoying it loops during the menu screen and it's a bizarre choice of track it starts off really soft and suddenly blows out your eardrums with this massive epic like crescendo at the end for no reason whilst you're still basically deciding whether to press the start button or not it's a really bizarre musical track and it's the only one there i would have liked to have seen a bit more done in this to up the immersion factor but i get that that would cost a lot of money and be quite tricky to do so maybe my expectations are a little bit too high on that but as i say the immersion is good the the theme is strong but don't go into this thinking it's going to have this really complex intricate story with a campaign that links back to other things that you do and honestly the phrase it uses uh what's the phrase on the box it mentions about a dynamic changing world or something i've got to read this the consequences of

each choice are meaningful and often change the state of the world forever you what you might make a choice that will have like a tiny impact on the current scenario you're playing and even then it's not the biggest change ever or not something that drastic but no don't go into this thinking that the actions you do in campaign one are gonna drastically affect like campaign four whatever it's there you could honestly play most of this campaign in standalone mode and you'd be pretty much on par with what you were doing already and finally the replay factor does this game warrant the fact that you're going to play this multiple times sadly this is a failure as well this isn't enough reason for me to play through these modules again honestly i was kind of done with these after one play but two plays is the absolute max you're gonna get with each scenario and i mean the absolute max because the scenarios will play out the same way with the same dynamic events every time you play it so that doesn't change so the only thing that's different is which destiny you go for but the problem is there's not a huge amount of distinction between them and some of them overlap if i'm playing the witch for example i might have collect some ritual items or go kill something okay fine if i play the huntsman i might have go kill something or go talk to people those two on the previous ones to kill something are the same goal just on two different characters so essentially you only really have three distinct paths that you can take with three different characters but the

paths themselves don't really lend to a greater deal of storytelling it's just a case that you might go in a slightly different direction and encounter a few different interactions but considering these interactions are very basic it's not like when you play the mode a second time it's going to be wildly different and like give you a completely new branching storyline no it's the same storyline just from a different perspective this is one standalone scenario for in a campaign as i said there's only so much link in them anyway but we're talking five scenarios that in solo mode will take you less than three hours less time than it takes to watch the justice league snyder cut to finish that's not a good time length for a game to be perfectly honest i mean that's like exit level styles of you know like time it takes to finish now if you play multiplayer you're probably looking at a good say 10 hours of time 12 absolute max which is not bad but again once you're done it's kind of obsolete at this point you can't even really play it multiplayer after playing it solo because you know where to find certain things it gives you a massive advantage against the other players if i've played through the standalone scenario once or twice with different characters i cannot play the same scenario multiplayer with anyone because i know exactly where to go they'll be floundering all over the place trying to find their respective items or kills and i can just basically go point a point b point c and win you know completely ruining the experience so

honestly replay value is nowhere near as strong as it could have been so in summary destinies should have blown my mind sadly it feels like a bit of a disappointment and a step backwards from what we had before with chronicles of crime chronicles of crime is the superior game easily much great attention co-op mode you know a chance to actually lose the game as opposed to like get beat by an opponent being the only way to lose the scenario and like decent stories intricate plot twists much more detail you know just much tighter i think that chronicles of crime was but destinies is by no means a bad game but i think it's got a very specific target audience and i don't think it was marketed to say that the competitive nature i don't think works i applaud luckyduck for trying something new i'm all up for innovative ideas and i was keen to see how this would work i just don't think it does this should have been a co-op mode don't have this racing each other to fulfill your destiny quicker just have a few different story branching paths and have people work as a two or three man team in order to complete the scenario i just think that would have worked a lot better but there are good things about this the story's not great but they're still decent enough so there's a good amount of theme there is certainly a very you know decent amount of effort put into the production value of this it looks good it's got quality components and the app is fantastic it is the easiest story driven game i've ever played i mean you want to get families and young children into this or non-gamers even this is definitely

one of the best ways to start them off into this genre and if you're playing a solo you will get through it pretty quickly and it won't take up much of your time it just should probably maybe take up a little bit more of your time in terms of a replay perspective so there are some problems i have with the mechanics but i don't think i'm the target audience for this but i gotta speak my mind and speak honestly this is a game i was really disappointed with and i cannot understand where a lot of these other reviewers are giving it nine out of ten and five out of fives it's like did we play the same game i'm not entirely sure although to be fair a lot of them didn't play it solo so maybe that's a factor but i gotta be honest here although as i said different audience families this works just not for me i think it's a bit of a disappointment but overall i'm gonna say that this is more enjoyable for me and less frustrating for me than ever fields was the similar story driven game that disappointed me i'm giving this one a six out of ten i can't give it a seal of endorsement not for my current market not for someone like me i just don't think it measures up anywhere close to what other creators are giving it but i think for families you could find something good here i didn't hate my time playing this game i've played it i'm done i have no desire to play it again but i think that families are going to have a good time with this and i think there are people who are going to be big fans of this and fair enough i can see why it's still a decent effort and i would like to see lucky duck take this concept and run with it really fine-tune that app even more i mean it's already a

great app but go nuts with it take the co-op nature to the next level and maybe if you want to do a competitive story game just have a bit more work on it you made an effort here i applaud you for it just didn't really work for me so that's it for me on this video if you liked what you see please consider leaving a thumbs up and leave some comments in the video to discuss the game further did you like it did you not like it i want to hear your thoughts as well we all like different things and it's cool to get into these discussions if you want to check out more content on the channel then in the last week i put together a top 10 list for most essential expansions i also like to do collaborations with other small creators and in the last week i teamed up with the lighting up initiative to also talk about five other disappointing games check out the content that's on the channel and i'll be in touch soon take care and remember it's only a game bye for now

Progress saved