Mantis Falls: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Mantis Falls, a game of trust. Like life, a cooperative game that's only really cooperative sometimes. Uh Wow, that was such a good game. I thought I had you guys when Brett did the affliction. Honestly, I thought I had it. here's the thing. Okay, so I'm going to go ahead and say this. This game is easily one of the best trader games I've played. Uh I backed it solely on its premise. The trader mechanic for two or three people. Yep. Which is never done. I don't think there's a single cuz I just actually uploaded six to eight or 12.
Typically. And when they're better, they tend to be like good trader mechanics. And games require more players. Yeah. Like it's bad with less players. Resistance is is best seven or higher. Dead of Winter is better at five. better. Nemesis I actually think is worse with more people because the game is so long. But the trader mechanic itself, I don't know if it changes that much with it. It just it becomes a long game. Right. And that's what I'm saying is like uh Shadows Over Camelot is okay. Yep. Um and uh Unfathomable is fantastic. Battlestar Galactica is well, but those are uh those always of course better with six, you know? And when they were like, "Hey, two to three and that's it." They didn't add any salt Well, you can play solo. Am I the traitor or not?
Uh but they didn't add any stretch goals of it being like, "Oh, hey, here's a module to add four or six." They stuck to their guns to do two or three. And man, is it so solid. Uh to talk a little bit on the actual run-through, which we very rarely do coming on like immediately starting a discussion. The entire time I was like I thought Brett just didn't read the [ __ ] card. And he was cuz whenever he looked at he was like, "Yep." And I'm like, "He threw the game. Why he This is A RUN-THROUGH. YOU [ __ ] ME. NOW MY NOW MY CHANNEL IS SHIT." Uh And And then you played it you played the betrayal card with an affliction that was the exact same result. Someone has to die.
Yeah. And I was like, "Well, he only did that cuz he had was a full health and I'm a I know I'm a witness, so I'm screwed no matter what." Uh And damn. Yeah. So I So with that cuz I actually did have a way to heal you. Did you? I I had a uh suture kit. Okay. have healed you one. Um But actually that's the one that mattered. have mattered cuz Yeah. Yeah. And there was tincture yeah puts puts your last gasp down. Um But I'm pat myself on the back. I was like, "I got no I got I It's I'm losing no matter what I do." the right play. I knew it was the right play, but it's like, "Can I convince them Right. That was Yeah. That was a I mean and that was a good That was a good plea cuz it could have easily I could have been like, "Yeah, Brett's obviously the assassin. So all if I have it, I'll play tincture and I'll heal you."
Um Cuz what was your plan? Your plan Was your plan I mean for the record I was also What was your character? Uh I don't even remember. Urbanite. That's what I remember. yeah eight health and then I was the pugilist. So I actually had quite a bit of health. Yeah. So honestly with the I was trying to get to the end of the row to hopefully get a better action cards. There weren't any good ones. Two [ __ ] the killer and and the falls. Which is was hoping for because then I thought, "Okay, if I can eliminate one of you, Mhm. then I've won." You are guaranteed to win. So, all I was trying to do was, "Okay, Brett has kind of painted himself as the bad guy. Um I didn't think about the fact that he could shoot me, and it was a gamble. Cuz again, if you had shot Seth, I was fine with it.
Yeah. It'd be great. I mean, but I I I did have ways to heal. I had medicine. Yeah, but Um But it forced it out. It made Brett look more guilty, but it couldn't He couldn't be guilty cuz again, he would be, you know, witnessing, and you would know instantaneously who was the witness. Uh what's also really funny is I had the night owl, and I had uh sneakers. I was going to bum rush it to here. And I had my call call on a hit. And I had it played down, and then I was like I was going to do it on Brett, cuz I was like, "Well, [ __ ] Why would he play that? That's so dumb." It ended up working out, so it was the most brilliant move in all of gaming. And that's where I was like Like going through in my head, it's like, "Okay. So, especially right there, as long as you know the other person you're playing with on that side has a heal card, Mhm.
and you do it, right? You say I'm a witness, and if the person heals and then returns fire to someone else, you can prove that they're a witness, and then it's instantly know who the assassin is that you have to kill. That's true. Yeah. Now, the assassin has to go Or that there's no assassin. Or that there's no assassin. Then you definitely gung-ho to try to kill one of the two people. Mhm. But here's the interesting part, cuz there were so many times this game came so close. I have multiple ways to wound Yeah, I did, too. people, and I knew I knew chances are like I'm like, "He could be the doctor. He's one wound away. That'll knock him down." Uh but he could have also been a pugilist. Uh but anyway, so whenever I played the the call on a hit card, um it was you and I. Yeah. And I was like, oh, it's it it damages the other player. I'm like, well, I don't want to damage Zach cuz I believe he's he's the other witness. So, I pulled it back and I think I just did another bum I didn't think I played the sneakers or something to bum rush move further.
Yeah, so when you knocked me down the time before, so looking back, the last event this event that I stopped Mhm. Um I shouldn't have because I had advantage which would have healed me and I had tar so you wouldn't have actually even moved cuz I was going to play tar first to seal you and then heal myself three. Mhm. Or two. You wouldn't have been able to call in a hit because you would still have been stuck over there. Yeah. You would have wasted calling in a hit technically. Yeah. That's what and I should have just done it have played it then? Well, I don't know cuz he has to cuz he wouldn't know that I played it cuz I just said I was going to stop it. Um We would both hit our health. Um Then it would have been a tie and Well, I cuz I would have healed two. I actually would have stayed exactly where I was going five and going back up. I would have been at four and going back to and then going back up to four. But it would cause him to get wounded.
Yeah. I think funny enough the card that I randomly lost in an ambush was my call in a hit. Yeah. And I'm like I'm like, son of a [ __ ] But then I got car bombed and I was like, well, I'm going to make it to the end and I'm just going to [ __ ] blow everyone up. Like, I can't win. I was stuck in the middle the entire time. Like, I'm like, well, I know I'm a witness. I so I lose no matter what cuz I didn't think there was an assassin or I thought Brett was the assassin. That's what I was trying what I was honestly the player what I was trying to convince everybody that there was no assassin in the game and just slowly hit people. Yeah, but it didn't matter cuz like in with that particular card it doesn't matter. It's taking to try and convince someone there's no assassin cuz it's like, well, if it if that's the case then we lose. Yeah. So, let's just call it. And you You honestly negotiate and mind game that way cuz it's like, well, let's call it something." You can be like, "Well, no." It's like, there it is.
Yeah. There is the assassin. Uh Brett, what did you think? You've been awfully quiet. He's just reveling in his genius. I was I had suspicion. I was hoping. I was your first play. You walked out of the diner and bailed. Uh first turn or second? It might have been the second. I think it was. But like first or second turn, you were just like, "Nope, someone's an assassin." And just took off. Yeah. No, actually I misunderstood the card. I I was assuming that it would be the survivors. Oh, I see. Oh. Someone had to die. The other two are witnesses. The witnesses win. So, you know, I I screwed that up. But I was able to cover for it in a genius manner by your your incredible outrage throughout the entire game.
Sold that I was not the assassin. So, the only thing is hope that you were and take you down and and it kept getting a little easier and I finally pounced. That is true. And what's fantastic about this game, um I kind of hearken it to the Resistance because the Resistance is pure deduction and bluffing. Mhm. Um that's why it was on the on on the top five trader games. Mhm. Uh but this obviously has way more going on that makes it like I like I would never play this like I'd rather play this over Resistance. There's no reason to play this one because you don't need seven people. Yeah. If you have seven, then play the Resistance. But it does the exact same thing that Resistance does is if I'm on the good side and I keep getting blamed. I I'm not that good of a liar to be like if I'm starting to get more and more agitated, it's like he's probably a good guy.
Yeah. And I didn't even know I was getting that agitated. I was more defeated cuz I'm like Why? Why did YOU DO THAT? I'LL say I thought I'm pretty good at um bluffing trader games. I'll say trying to lie on unseen is super difficult. It is really, really difficult. Super difficult. until you've seen them all and you're familiar with them. Yes. Yeah. So, that is it's not a negative of the game, but that is something to definitely bring up and they mention it in the rulebook. So, first up, another positive, the rulebook is fantastic. Yep. Um, the way it's organized is is very streamlined and it's saying the game's not hard to understand, but they definitely tell you, "Hey, here's the modular expansions. They're already separated, so you don't have to mess with them. Play the play the game a few times and then throw in full circle."
Uh, which definitely adds a lot more interaction. Like so many cards of, "Oh, hey, take a condition. Take their cards. See what they're doing." Um, and so I would say the game definitely shines with full circle. Um, but this Uh, it does mention that there is an element of What What did they say? Can't see the rulebook. Yep. Um, There's a learning curve to it. Learning curve, yep. Yep. The game of countermeasures and anticipatory tactics that become increasingly rewarding with experience and skill. Uh, which you never see in these games. Yeah. Like for them to straight out be like, "Hey, by the way, there's a lot of cards in here that are going to be either they're going to seem overpowered or they're going to seem completely useless."
Yeah. And it's understanding the game and what events can potentially come up and reading your opponent to be able to utilize them effectively. To me, it's kind of like like Twilight Struggle in that sense of two-player tactical games. Sure. Where you kind of got to know both decks to understand what is going to come up Yeah. potentially. And how they how they accurately because it's like this game I think normally in most games where you can know everything about it, it you know, falters. It's just like, "Oh, I've seen that. Okay." But this one I think the game elevates because then you know you it becomes way more of a of a mind game between players. Oh, yeah. And there's almost nothing in here that I think allows for random I mean yeah, you draw from an action deck uh but not every card is useful.
Yeah, no yeah. You can run into well, I didn't even get a chance to draw that card, but there's so many ways for you to force players to discard or to steal from their hand. Or for you to discard this self-destruct. I mean, I had four bullets at one point. Yeah. I was like Did anyone have a gun? I did at the end. So So literally He was going to get to the end and just start open firing. When we were required to discard all the cards in our hands, I got rid of all my bullets and then drew a gun. Oh. Yeah. Yeah. I I honestly, the only thing I had going for me was I was just sulking down the street. Uh cuz I was like all I had was just I had knowledge like from cards. I knew what events were coming up. I had a bunch of cards in my hand. I was pretty much playing defensively just to see.
Which as a witness that's kind of how you need to play anyway. Yeah. Um Yeah. Wait for the assassin to reveal himself. Yeah. Which a good assassin won't. Yeah. Yeah. And then the other time that we played this game and I I I do kind of wish there were more actions by night and actions by dark just for variety. Yeah. Um but I will say the reason probably why there's not there's only five uh is because like then you then you know like okay, now I'm the last one. Okay, then that means the other two either they have them which adds more mind games or they're in the actions by dark. So it's always limited. You don't have perfect information, but you do have some information. But you could have more and still just put three and two. So the first person would know exactly the you know, the other two cards that you guys are going to have to take. Like I knew someone was going to take car bomb.
Right. Um I took doctor because I was already damaged once. And I I like this is going to save me at some point." Yeah. Yeah, I ended up getting car bombed and then Well, and then there was like there was one card in the deck the last time we played this. I don't even think you planned on me killing myself. Yeah. cuz you were just trying to prevent the event and I stacked on top of that. Cuz my plan was And Brett was the assassin anyway, but my plan was I think you're the assassin, I'm going to do falls. So, that will kill you if you heal yourself uh some way, which actually that prevents it. But, then the event will take And like I had two ways of ensuring that you're probably going to die, which would have ended up losing us the game. Um Do you guys have any any negatives? Anything about the game that you don't like?
Cuz I still don't know whether Brett, do you like this game? It's kind of been Zack and I going back and forth. It is, man. Yeah, it's social deduction games are not my thing Mhm. in general. Um and traitor is also not my thing in general. So, combining them in a small group of people um greater, that's a little bit better because it's a little more focused. The The problem that I have with like The Resistance or Avalon Mhm. is there are so many possibilities to keep track of Right. Yeah. that I just don't bother and I just kind of play random. Yeah. And everybody thinks that I'm "What the hell are you doing? Why are you thinking that? That's suspicious." Cuz Yeah. cuz I don't have a strategy. Right. Well, those other games also almost every single social deduction traitor game falters on the sense of meta. "Oh, you've been the traitor in multiple games that we've been in, so I'm just going to automatically accuse you."
Yeah. And if you can get everyone to agree with you, there's nothing that person can do to convince anyone otherwise other than cheat and show their card, you know? And that's always kind of a problem cuz you shouldn't meta. There's no reason to in those games. So then, but the fault the other is like in the um Unfathomable game we played, I just kept I wasn't even a traitor at that point. I And honestly thought Brandon was. And I got everyone to agree he's in the brig. I kept convincing people to keep him in there. So, they're there Eventually, I was like, all right, yeah, let's let him out. And then I became the cultist, so it worked out. Yeah. But, that can be very frustrating to be like, there's what why can't I say anything to get you to convince me otherwise? Well, because the game inherently makes me distrust everyone. Yeah. Yeah. So, more people causes that gang mentality.
and less mechanic. Yeah. The The Resistance in Avalon Mhm. so simple and straightforward that there really is nothing that you can do to either cover or to try to accuse other people. Yeah. You know. It It becomes, okay, well, I've played with this person enough. Seth is getting really mad. He's not the traitor. Unless he somehow learned to get really mad when he's lying, which I have not figured out that skill. Yeah. Um or you just stay calm and collected, but then at that point, you're not helping your case. But, you're right, yeah, in in this one, uh cuz I did start like out at It was really towards the very end when Brett was healing himself and he kept He kept helping Yeah. in small ways, but I'm like, it's not enough. And you weren't You didn't show anything. So, I I was still like, well, we [ __ ] lost.
Yeah. This It doesn't matter what I do. Uh But, yeah, in Unfathomable or in even Shadows over Camelot, those games do have like, no, look, I'm doing everything in my power to help. Yeah. Apples 31. Mhm? Apples 31. Yeah. Oh, I forgot. I kind of wiped that one from my memory. No, that one That one is fine. Uh But, I mean, there's just enough going on that you can cover yourself. You can bluff Yeah. uh effectively. Yeah. In in the games with virtually no mechanic, there's, you know, nothing to do. People go with their prejudices and it's over. Yeah. Pretty much, yeah. Um and that's why Resistance really sucks unless you have like max players. Yeah. Yeah. Because then chances are people are keep accusing you, then you could still be the one that's getting accused and your team can still win.
Yeah. Uh Zack she uh so uh So did but out of all the ones you have played, like do you like this one more than those or do you is it still just kind of lumped into that group or like Okay, so Uh I it's it's one of those that I say I I appreciate the originality and the cleverness and the the difference that it that it the different twist that it has on the whole genre. Mhm. Um and again as far as I know this is the only one for a small group. As far as I'm aware, yeah. Yeah. So all the other ones are much larger to be effective. So in that I really appreciate it. It's kind of like art. You know, there there are art that I really understand this is great and I really appreciate it. I don't like it.
Right. I don't enjoy it. Right. It's in an art museum, therefore it must be good. I don't like it. Like for example, yeah, I like I don't like portraits like art. So like when when you go to like Crystal Bridges in Arkansas or something and you can I get to like the the people I'm like I know this is all amazing. I'm very bored. I want to go to the scenic stuff. Exactly. Yeah. So I got I got you there. So but you know, this is a great game for well designed, well made for what it it tries to do. I think it accomplishes it excellently. Uh Zack, do you do you have any negatives? Do you have anything that stands out that was kind of like well, that's annoying? There were a couple of cards that seemed pretty useless. So I don't mind that for you know, if a card's useless or not because some of it was situational cards. Mhm. To me, they did a really good job on some of the language.
Oh, Other things like um other player. Okay, at max you have three players. So just call them primary, helper and bystander, something like that. Or active players. Yes, would have cleared up so many cards. Mhm. They do make it clear by the definitions in the book. Yeah. But you have to have those ingrained or you have to read it. Or you have to come across a scenario where it's like other player, I guess I can include the bystander and it's like, oh wait, no, that's that's weird and then you look it up and it's like, oh wait. Or like the marionette includes the bystander theoretically, but then it doesn't Yeah. as other player. And I think the reason why is because when three players you you have to play with the triad and so every other card that says other like they would have had to change the wording on every single card to apply to three players when you're only including that for a small amount. Most of the cards it's a this is this feels like it was a two-player game, but you can play with three and honestly I don't see a problem at three.
Nope. Cuz I think the bystander the bystander which is very weird because it sounds like you are effectively not playing. Right. Yeah. But what I viewed it as was there's a lot of cards that can include them. Mhm. I they come up pretty frequently where it's like, "Hmm, can you help?" Yeah, yeah, I can help. Okay, I'll I'll play this card. But And they can contribute to the overall. Yeah, they can they can siphon their hand so they're able to do enough so that whenever it's cuz you're only a bystander once Yeah. uh in a three-player game, but what I found fascinating of being the bystander is then you don't have other things distracting you so you get to observe Yes. and be like, how are they interacting with each other? Yep. Oh, Brett's sweating. Why? You can purge cards, you can show help whether you're good or bad.
Yeah. Uh so you can help others with passing cards. Yeah, so you're like, okay, listen, I'm going to put down uh whatever. Like you put down teamwork and finally I got chameleon. That's why I was like, "Hey, does anyone have teamwork? I can help." Uh but then it's like, "Oh, okay, you you can't heal. All right, well then as a bystander I'll put this down so whenever you draw." So you're you're a lot more involved than I feel like the rules kind of give off. Yeah, and like if you know you're going to hit ambush card because if you're the bystander, you're going to be the first active player, you can place a card down, right? And you can basically say, "Hey, don't draw. I'm just trying to get, you know, keep it safe." True, yeah. Um doesn't necessarily keep it safe, but at least you're negotiating with players and interacting. So, it's not like you're just taking off turn.
Yeah, and not nothing is binding. Like there was a in the last game it was like uh there was the the cut wires. Yes. And I was like, "I'm just going to take this so this doesn't get used." Um and then that you cuz you can also like I had tools in my hand and I was like, "I'm just going to hold on to this." Yeah. I'm just going to I'm just not going to use it. I don't want anything screwing me over. Uh yeah, wording was very weird. The ricochet card was the biggest one that we came across where it's like it damage was Oh, did you have it? I did. I knew it. I knew someone was hoarding that. Well, it's I And not that I I it's I didn't know for certain, but I'm like Well, I've only had a couple of turns. I knew it was going to be you because I'm like he played that [ __ ] card, he's going to hold on to the ricochet so we can't attack him. Yeah. Uh and that's why I burned it cuz I thought you were going to try and kill me, so that's why I burned it to see what cards you were playing.
Got you. Um but yeah, for the rest of this turn all wounds received by you from any source are instead received by the other player. That to me immediately sounds like you have to you play this to in inflict self-harm to the ricochet to the other person. But the book clears that up and Yeah. with more words. With more words. Yeah, like a whole page. Which I mean I'm glad that that's there. Yep. It's like that they just included that. Yeah. I'll say just concept-wise and cards and everything, it it's pretty good game, pretty solid. Yeah. Yeah. The theme is awesome. Oh, yeah. I don't quite get the uh iconography for some cards. Like uh like why is contention Oh, I guess cuz ram's headbutt. Yeah. Uh there was one in here though that I like, what is that?
Uh like why is that the the the picture they chose? But maybe I mean obviously it wasn't that big of a deal. Ooh, one thing we did have not brought up yet are allies. What do you guys think of allies? I have no idea. Two games I never got a chance to use one. I actively prevented you from getting them. They I felt like were the most different in power levels. Yeah. So like um Mr. Nash over there, he's two and yet lets you have another card in your hand. Mhm. And I honestly cuz I had him at the beginning of last game and then this game, I felt it. Yeah. I felt it bad. Yeah, it it uh I didn't feel as overpowered having eight um but I do definitely feel like man, I'm not drawing eight.
Yeah. I only can get seven. And so to me some of them felt like very overpowered for the number that you need like Nash versus um Mr. DeMarco did not feel like he felt like what you would want with two. Yeah. Like easy to get, so now you can randomly get three. Yeah. That's great. That's awesome. That's true. Um Mr. Edwards, he's four. I draw one additional event card during event I mean that is really good. Yep. Uh that gives you a lot of information. Which to me that's that's four power. That's you need four of him. Yeah. Um Cuz that's going to be difficult to get. Yeah. Yeah. Um but there were a lot so but I do think the allies are cool. Mhm. think there's as many things to either get them slash remove them. So once like you know Brett has random ones, I have random ones.
Now the fact is neither one of us can complete the set. Yeah, that is true. There it they are easy to get and yeah, I feel like you are playing kind of more hate drafty with the allies than really getting the rewards. I mean you can definitely combo if you're communicating with a partner and be like hey, I'm going to move out and I'm going to make I'm a phone call someone." Okay, well, I'll let you. So, then I'll let you get the four. Yeah. Um but at the same time though the the the higher powered ones the ones like there's a lot of events that remove allies. Like action cards that just wipe them and cuz so even though you need a set of four for him, you don't one removal wipes them all. And then as soon as someone takes one of him, then you you can't get him.
So, they're really powerful. They are easy to take away, but yeah, Mr. Nash, I think he's probably the only one that I feel is most um overpowered at his cost. Yeah. cuz I mean you and I play magic, so card advantage is is huge in a lot of games. Especially in hand management games. Yeah, but I think it is kind of it's not as overpowered as it could be just because just cuz you have more cards doesn't mean you have good synergy. Yep. Which I hardly ever had in in [ __ ] Brett card, man. That like threw anything I wanted to do cuz I'm like yeah, I have quick thinking and contention and grenade, but why play them? Yep. What's the point? I'm just going to sit in my car and blow it up and take someone else out with me. People have to die anyway, so might as well make it two people.
Uh but the best thing about this game in my opinion is the fact that during the Kickstarter ended this game I'll have to look it up cuz it was not expensive. No, so I think it's on their website right now like for 35 bucks or something. Cuz I'm pretty sure it's still on know if that's like I don't know if that's like a deluxe edition because this is a you know, it's not a felt map, but it's it's not neoprene either, but it's a cloth map. These their cards are held instead of these wooden pieces. But let's see, Mantis Falls. There it is. My pledge was Ah. Okay, I know why. It was 150. And the reason why um I was like I felt like it was like 30 or something. It's because this is the only game I have ever done that it was 150 to get a personalized card.
Okay. That's why. Cuz a lot of them are like, "Hey, $1,000 for you to get a mini." And I'm like, "But what if your game sucks?" Yeah. And the 150 wasn't that bad of a burn. But I was able to give them a picture of my cat. And they did a fantastic job drawing her in cuz this looks exactly like the picture I sent. And they made her a cat detective. And it's it I love it. It makes me so happy. And she's she's pretty good. Cuz they also were like, "Hey, like what do you want her to do?" Like I'm like, "Well, this game is kind of like uh what what do they call it? Um sleuthy? Yeah. That kind of era. I'm like, "Oh, make her a detective." Sure, sure. Like a cat burglar or cat detective or something. Yep. Uh but I will say the the allies are still kind of probably the weakest part. Yeah. You get information from them uh and it goes both ways. Like if you're looking for a card, you know what they have. So you play keep away a lot.
And if you can't get them, they're good. Um You mentioned the events were uh hard to bluff on. Yeah. Uh yeah, they they really are. Because there was one event whenever and I knew what it was, it literally says nothing. Yeah. saying win in fact nothing bonus nothing. Yeah. And I'm like, "What's the point of that?" But then it's like, "Oh, [ __ ] this thing." No, the point is to be like, "This thing is good uh it's like four health and it deals red damage." Yeah. Like, "Okay, I can't do anything. Can you?" So you make them burn their cards and then you're like, "Okay, yeah, nothing happens." Yep. So We survived. Yeah. Ooh. Yeah, okay, we got it. Yeah, yeah, that's pretty much what you what you would say. All right, yeah, we got it. Unfortunately, there's no bonus.
But that game come or that kind of bluffing comes in when you play this game a lot. Um I got nothing else. I got nothing else to talk about unless anyone has outstanding negatives to bring up. I can't really think of one. I would like I mean there is another expansion we haven't tried, the Under the Roses. What does that bring in? I will bring up what I consider to be a negative. Oh yeah, go ahead. Um which is simply based on there's a couple of cards that require matching cards. And they're they never came up. I had them several times. Yeah. And they're good cards, they're powerful. Mhm. They might be overpowered in some situations. But never got a chance to use them. Yeah. And at one point I even had two of them. Two matching cards. Yeah.
But because they were different suits, I could never play them at the same time. teamworks? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that happened to me last game. I was like I was like, "Hey, I got them both oh." But but there are cards that allow you to add other cards into your Or your own tableau. Or you could or you could pass it face up to somebody and declare here's the intention. Or repetition that allowed you to copy a card in your tableau. Yeah, I didn't see that ever, so. It's chameleon and it yeah and I had it. There's also repetition that Oh yeah, your repetition the card, yeah, sorry. Uh there are yeah. What I think this game does you're adding in the additional cards for the expansions, then those even become more difficult. True. True. Uh Minor. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. I mean that's something that's going to be valid to bring up. If you are really trying to cuz I would would you I wouldn't call this a strategy game. You have strategy to try and read people, but I wouldn't ever really like I wouldn't try to top deck.
Like personally um because even in the in the help card book it even mentions, "Hey, by the way, yeah, Ricochet is really good, but you're holding it in your hand and it might be useless if you're a witness, or it might be useful if you're the like You got to play it at the right time. Like you got to guess that the person's about to just slaughter you. So to me it's a lot guesswork versus like better answers Doctor's Bag way better. I agree. You can Anytime someone plays one of the three healing cards, you heal. Uh where is Doctor's Bag? Was it in here? I had it at the end. I had it for a little while. Yeah, so what does it say? It's a condition, right? Yeah. Whenever you reveal a suture, medicine, or advantage, then you heal one of your wounds.
Yeah. And the suture heals the other player. So yeah. Uh so I mean it is strong, uh but once again like Brett said, you need those other cards. Yeah. The nice thing about this is you keep it indefinitely. And there's no play the other one cuz it is it's a condition. Yeah, so I mean the the um Suture is not. Well, the condition like that one is like like I played it earlier, but really it's like oh, I know you have seven health and you're at six. Okay, I'm going to play this, and I'm going to steal your Doctor's Bag. Oh, and you can't take this from me, otherwise you will die. Yeah. So I The multi-purpose cards are just so fantastic because I would view I wouldn't view the Doctor's Bag as as OP, but That's just my kind of play style. No, I don't think it is, but it's it's synergistic with other cards.
Yeah. And every card Yeah, they they do have a usefulness rating in there, but they even said what is useful. Yeah, what's the like It's arbitrary. It's exactly. Ricochet like I was sitting there when I saw like you guys I was like [ __ ] that card. That's so broken, but it just so happened to be amazing in that moment in the in that moment with the wrong card, but the right card, and you you basically killed me and then and then Brett won. Yeah. Um but you were just trying to protect yourself from the event, and I'm like I'm going to try and [ __ ] kill him. There's an earthquake, I'll push him off, and then I fall off. Yeah. So, what's also great is the game kind of works very abstract, but I feel like a lot of a lot of theme is pulled out of this game. And the fact that they have their own soundtrack is awesome.
Yeah. The artwork plays into it perfectly. The artwork is really good, very minimalistic, but really good. Um A little eerie, but not like overwhelming. Yeah. Yeah. Scary. Yeah, it's not scary. just how you would feel. This is kind of how I would feel walking down a dark street Mhm. in an unfamiliar area. With a person or a few people that you're like, is Wait a minute. Because like the the how to play, I think she did a really good analogy of like uh you meet up with the witness at the bar or at the diner, and then you leave. Was Was this Was this the person you were actually supposed to meet? Or did the assassin kill them and take their place? And it's like, so the entire time, where a lot of games um are like Dead of Winter, its major fault is if you know for a fact, cuz there are ways for you to see people's roles, if you can figure out that everyone's on the same team, the game is wickedly easy.
Yeah. Uh and even in this one, it's kind of like you never truly feel, at least in in our experience, that you were ever 100% safe. Yeah. Cuz it's like, man, why uh like, why is everyone just working? Like, why is everyone helping out? And the entire time, even until the end of the of our first game, I was like, I don't [ __ ] know. I'm just going to try and kill someone. Yeah. And even the two that we played tonight were radically different. Yeah. Yep. First one, we made it almost to the end without anyone really being very suspicious and all kind of wondering. This one, right off the bat, Yeah. gone. Yeah. And I will say the full circle nobody directly attacked me constantly, either. Yeah. Even knowing that that was the right idea. Mhm. You You knew. You did.
I felt like That's true. You, as the assassin, knew you were in the clear. You were out like a fool. You could have run into me, and he would have just gone right along with it. Yeah, pretty much. So then I I tried to do it a little bit and say, you know, well, pretty sure, you know, it could be a mistake and we might all be, you know, so like the amalgamation where I heal myself one but do one damage to you. It's not that aggressive, but it's a little bit like, here, we're going to stick you just a little bit. we'll make I take two damage. I'll just take it. Yeah. And then he kept healing then he was like giving me cards and I'm like, I was just so [ __ ] defeated. But I think what kind of screwed up your plans was whenever you tried to book it to the end you got your ass kicked. Yeah. Like those those three ambush cards just really [ __ ] you. And I'm like, well, thanks. Cuz I thought you were just trying to get to the end because he you were trying to not get killed by him, which you weren't. But I was like, yeah, run for the [ __ ] exit. I'm right there behind you. Wait, I'm not. You guys took off.
Uh so uh the expansion under the roses, under the rose, is an optional variant for advanced players that offers new forms of forms of combination building and resource management and creates powerful opportunities for deck manipulation. Uh each player is paired with a random agent under the rose, a mercenary that offers impactful effects in exchange for a price. In the end, these agents will not let players escape Mantis Falls until all debts to them have been paid. Randomly deal to each player one horizon card and one sky card. Players align these two cards face up in their playing area to make their agent under the rose. So essentially they give you yeah, like this this for example is you have kit and you have like uh I mean, this actually looks relatively complex. We haven't played with this, but like it like grenades and baseball bats have no effect on you. Uh and then he has an underground like ability has these, but you have these redeem cards. So essentially you have to pay them back before you gave it even escape.
Hm. So they have fantastic expansions. I just would like just more, which is always something that I always give to games I really like. So, we'll see. I've never heard this company. Have you? No. Distant Rabbit Games. Are they on BoardGameGeek? Well, they will be, but Yeah. Uh publisher, right? Who's the designer? Doesn't say. Distant Rabbit Games. They uh Uh Adrian Carrard. Carrard. Yeah, this is literally their only game. So, I will be keeping an eye out. Mhm. All right. You guys got anything else? Cool. All right, on a scale of 1 to 10, uh we'll start with Brett.
No, we'll start with Zach. You're you're guest on the channel. We'll uh we'll have you So, I'll probably do a solid eight. Eight? Yep. Nice. Nice. Brett? I'm going to say seven. You know my disclaimer. Yeah. Yeah. I think it's great, but it's hard for me to judge. I really like it. Um He wants to say a 12.
I think I might give it a 10. Like, I have very little complaints. I just think that for a social deduction, it'd be a nine original, but I'm going to give it an extra point for the fact that there's no other Like, I thought this was going to bomb. Yeah. Like, I'm like a social deduction and it works. Yeah. Yeah. Like, that is absolutely like fascinating. So, they must have play tested the hell out of this to make it work because it for all intents and purposes, this should be like Okay, you're obviously the traitor, or overpowered abilities, or something. But, for it to be superior to other long-standing traitor games for less people, um I I got to I got to give them an extra point for that. So, I think it's fantastic. It it probably won't be for everyone, like we like Brett, you know, for example, other people might find more complaints of wow, I wish I could draw the Ricochet card or or whatever. But like there's I I don't think there's a useless card in there and they the production quality is awesome.
Um so yeah, I'm going to give it a 10. This game is fantastic. So, that's our thoughts on Mantis Falls. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.