Skip to main content
Loading video...

El Gaucho Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 19:59

welcome to jnit games today I'll be reviewing El Galo this game has you herting cows specifically trying to get large herds of single types of cows and the bigger the herd the more money you're going to get when you sell it off the main mechanic of this game is Dice pool drafting where you roll dice into this awesome coral and then pull them out to evaluate a variety of actions first I'll show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's a starting setup for a four-player game of vacho we've added these cows to this field and we've added them to each row until we meet or exceed 20 in the values which is why there's only two cows here and then each player is started by putting one of their figurines in some of these bonus spots down at the bottom of the board the star player grabs the dice and they roll it in this pretty awesome Corral that keeps the dice together and then it makes sense to kind of sort the dice out by their die roll to see what their options are then the player must activate two of these dice now if they wanted they could grab two dice and combine them together so they could take these two sixes for instance and make a 12 and by doing that they can look out to this field and claim one of these cows in this case they could put a standing up GAO on this 12 bull right here because of that value instead they could have taken just one of these sixes and instead put this figure laying down because you'll see there is a small six in the far right side so that means you're kind of halfway towards claiming this and on a future turn or as a future action right now you could grab another six to stand that person up but instead maybe they want to claim that but not go too crazy on it and do something else with their other die so another option would be grabbing a die to utilize one of these actions down here instead of claiming these cows cuz I think that's pretty self- explanatory if you pull a

two you can put a standing up person here if you pull a uh four you can put it here or add two together to get an eight so down here you'll see these three spots all have a one two and three Pips on them so this player could take this one for instance and take one of the figures and add it to any of these spots you'll notice there is a spot for all of the players so you're not blocked out of a location when somebody else is in it like this one for instance however the player is um this case the blue player is not allowed to take this six and put another uh character down here because in setup they put a figure down there so uh let's say for instance they take this one and they add it down here so as you can see you're either going to take one big action by combining two dice or two slightly smaller actions now there are these bonus actions down here which you can use as many of you want on a given turn however you're not allowed to utilize the action the turn you put the figurine down so the blue pair would not be able to use this but they could use this down here which is the um hidden cow steps something like that that's not the official rule but what happens when you pull this figurine back is that the player gets to look at these four hidden cows and they get to pick uh up to two of these you'll see down here that they can grab two if the value of both of them are less than five so in this case they might want to take well this three and this two because they are the same color that's pretty great they'll put these two face down and then these get added out onto the fields uh in an open spot so they could go here for instance and as the final part of this powerful action they get to put standing up GAO figures on each of them once a player is done with their turn you move to the next player and they're going to pick two more Dice from this grow but obviously there are less to choose from so they could for instance take this one and this one right here

and this is the green player so they might want to put the uh five down there and the six down there and that could just end their turn or they could use this action which I haven't talked about which gives you a a third die that you get to evaluate and it could be any number that you want so they could pull this person back they can say it was value five and then put a laying down GAO on this spot here because there's a five in that far right corner now that the green player is done it moves to the red player and they might want to take this five and this four for instance in this case they might put laying down gaoua figure on that four and one on this five but now they're going to evaluate this figurine that's in this spot now this allows them to do one of two things the first thing that they can do is they can stand up two of their laying down goutos in the field so they could just pull this guy off to stand both of these people up and it's a very powerful action however the other thing that they could do is they could pull this person up to steal a GAO from an opponent that has a laying down piece so they could pull this up to kick this green piece out and then they would put a standing up red figure on that spot so a very powerful spot here now fortunately for the green player it's a it's a bit unfortunate they lost claim on that cow however they get paid out money equal to the large value on that cow so in this case it's kind of insurance the green player would get $10 and money is directly correlated to victory points you don't actually spend the money in this game so green gets a constellation prize there and finally we have the yellow player unfortunately there are only three dice left so they have pretty slim pickings they might grab this four on the two and instead of doing anything with the cows out here they might just go ahead and put this down here on the four and this over here using this too now this spot down here

is the cattle thev spot now of course they can't use it on this turn but they could use this person on a future turn to steal a already grabbed cow from an opponent from their player area but I'll show you that in a little bit once all players have taken a turn there'll be one die left and at this point we are done with the round we're going to pass the starting player marker to the next player in this case will be the green player and then we are going to look to the field and any row that has a figurine on every single cow in it is going to get activated so uh if we look at this top row we see there's only one so we ignore it but this second row here even though one of them is laying down that's still one figurine on every single cow so every player who has a standing up GAA figure on a cow will immediately take those cows so the red player is going to get this one and the blue player will get both of these this laying down figure stays here and now we have to refill the row until we have 20 or more values so we start taking cows randomly from the top of the stack we have 12 plus 4 that gets us to 16 and then plus two more gets us to 18 and oh this blows us way over so that round is officially over the green player will grab all the dice roll them and we'll do the same thing going around the table just like before when a player acquires new tiles they have to add them into the cows that they may or may not already have in front of them in this case you must always add the tile to the right hand side of a type of cow that you already have in this case it's the light brown and once you add the second tile you're actually going to be dictating the direction at which these are going to go in this case it's going to be ascending because we go 7 to 10 with this now means is in the future if we ever put a cow here that does not match

this direction of going up then we are going to be forced to sell all the cows that are below it so at this point if we don't want to sell these cows we need 11 and 12 so in a future round if we grab this 11 we would be totally fine however if instead in a future round we take this8 cow then just like I said we have to sell everything that does not match the direction so this eight8 cow is going to remain here and we have to sell this herd we now get money or victory points equal to the value of this herd and the value is the number of cows times the highest value cow so in this case it's two cows times 10 or 20 points it's also worth noting that cows grabbed at the end of the same round can be put into their area in any orientation they want they probably wouldn't want to go 3-2 but they do have that choice if this blue player wanted to do that let's Now cover the final three action spots that I haven't discussed just yet this one right here is the sorting house and when a player pulls a token off of this house they actually do this when they're bringing the cows into their area after kind of purchasing them from the field and this allows you to sort one cow into the correct spot kind of putting it between a bunch of cows in a herd so you don't have to break the ascending or descending but when you pull that off you only get one cow and you do that so it could be pretty powerful the next kind is the cattle Thief right here so let's say the yellow player pulled this off now what they can do is they can steal a single cow from an opponent's um area where they've already grabbed the cow so in this case they could grab this cow right here and then put it into their area which is pretty nice they already had a seven but as a constellation prize to the blue player they're going to get money equal to the value of the cow just stolen so the blue player in this case would get nine

money the final action spot is this selling house when you pull a figurine back from here it lets you sell one of your herds of cows right now and then you add five more points to the end of it so normally you can only sell when you put um a wrong cow on the end if it's ascending or descending but this lets you do it when you want to so in this case the yellow player could sell these two it would be 2 * 9 or 18 points plus five and it'll be a 23o herd because they pull it off from that spot the game will keep going until all cows have been taken from the face down stack at that point you will do one final round where players will not even roll the dice they'll just evaluate all of their bonus actions and then every player will sell off all the herds and whoever has the most money at that point is going to win the game let's now begin the review for El gacho and we'll start with a few positive points the first of these relates to the cow field and how interesting a mechanic this really is specifically I'm talking about putting your goutos down onto the different cows and having the field only get taken once there is at least one um figurine on every single cow whether it be standing up or laying down this gives you a bunch of interesting things to think about specifically when you are taking these cows you have to put them in order or else you break them up and you get probably less money than what you wanted so you are sometimes putting uh one of your GAO figurines out in a cow that you really want but you don't want it yet you want to do one or two other things first so you might hope to well well first of all you could put your GAO laying down so that you know you won't take it even if other people grab the cows on that row or you could just figure that there's a lot of other stuff

on that row maybe it's a really big row so you'll have a couple turns until that gets taken the flip side is sometimes you really want a cow right now and you might find yourself um putting your figurines down on cows that you don't actually want just to make sure that that row scores so it's a really great idea also when you take into the account the idea that the laying down gaos can be bumped out by a special action versus the standing up ones are secure I like that you can spend a little more resources and be totally secure in where you're at or maybe Press Your Luck a little bit and have a tentative call on a cow and then maybe grab it later or if you get bumped out you do get some money so altogether it's a really great mechanic and it wraps the whole game together the whole game is centered around pulling the cows out of the field at the right time and the right cows positive number two relates to the GAO special actions that you can take on the bottom of the board I really like this addition to the dice pool drafting game in particular three of the locations can be activated with a one two or three and they are pretty strong locations especially the one that gives you a wild Dy to use later that essentially lets you cash in a die that you don't care for to be the exact die that you need at a later point in the game and that's a great way to deal with um maybe a poor role especially if you are late in the turn order and you have very few dice to choose from well it's rare that you really have nothing to do in your turn you can almost always valuate put some people down on those lower actions especially those three that go to the 1 two and three and be pretty happy with your turn but in addition to that you

have the cow um thieves which adds a little bit of um pressure on other people to um maybe sell their herd before they generally want to but of course you do get paid out insurance when you take that it's just it's almost like a cold war effect like once somebody puts a person down on the cow the spot everybody's like a little more wary but sometimes that person stays there the whole game and then of course you have the secret cow spot which is I think everybody's favorite spot I mean technically I think it's not actually called secret cow spot but we always call it secret cows oh we're going to go get some secret cows and it's just fun because you get to look at a variety of cows and then put it right on the board with a standing up gouto it's a very strong action but as a six it's often times going to get taken so it's somewhat rare to get those but you can make sixes happen with the hero of the rodeo being the wild die so there's a variety of ways to evaluate all these things and honestly I think my favorite action spot is the uh number five slot which lets you stand to laying down people up on the up on the field or kick somebody else's lazy GAO out and go in there with yourself because it could be really efficient by putting a couple laying down ones then pop them up both up for a single five action later on there's just a lot of interesting decisions to be made with all those actions down at the bottom and they're just a great addition to the game positive number three relates to the great table presence that this game has specifically with the art and component quality of the game um talking about the art you have great cow illustrations where you have um I guess the same style of cow for all the twos and all the threes and all the fours they all look the same but they have different patterns on them but it's great because you have a huge variety of different

cows like some are really mad and some are really happy and some are confused and they just look Goofy and I I really enjoy them uh when you look at the entire board in general it just has a nice aesthetic appeal for the kind of ranching Style game you're going for and of course I'm also talking about the dice Coral which is amazing you um put this thing together put it on the board it kind of sticks in and then you roll your dice at it they Bonk around and they stay in there it aesthetically is wonderful mechanically it's great cuz it keeps the dice from splashing around everybody else's spot and it just thematically makes a ton of sense right you are trying to herd cows well here's a Corral I I want to shoehorn a dice Corral into pretty much every dice game at this point it's such a neat mechanical um addition into the game it's just a good looking setup now let's discuss my one neutral for the game and simply put analysis pysis can crop up in a pretty big way this game at times now when you roll these dice they each are a possibility of several things that you could do you could pull those dice out in order to put people out into the field to grab some cows or stand some people up or um put people down into those special actions that are down at the bottom of the board and of course you probably already have people down there so you want to think how you want to utilize those pull those off in order to do some better things that you're trying to do on your turn and especially if you are near the um the front of the turn order if you're like the starting player there are just so many possibilities for you to use and it feels like many of them are good and it sometimes feels like it's hard to figure out what the best thing to do is and I've seen some people lock down pretty hard it's hit me it's hit several of my friends where you just you just start to spiral and you just end up having to

just back out and be like I'm just going to do this just done my turn that's okay and just move on because it sometimes feels like you're just you could fall down a pit forever trying to figure out the exact perfect turn and um so as long as you're self-aware that analysis paralysis can happen within this game and within yourself if you're the player it's okay you can pull back and play the game well just try to not take too long in your turns CU you will definitely start to push the patience of your opponents around the table all right now I want to discuss my one negative for the game and it's a pretty big one it relates to the overall Swingin of the herd scoring now if you remember you multiply the number of cows by the highest value cow that you have and that's the points you get and that means that a single cow can have a humongous uh impact on the overall score that you're going to get for a specific herd if you've got like the two four five and eight and then grab the 12 that's a humongous swing in points from the herd you had to the herd you now have with that one single tile and of course the uh flip side works too if someone is able to steal that cow away from you it's another massive swing back now the second part I don't have a big problem with because there are ways you can get around that while you're playing the game you can take the special action to sell off your herd early before somebody can steal that cow away from you the bigger issue I have with this is that it feels like a very dominant strategy if you want to win at elgjo you've got to make the biggest herd you possibly can maybe a second herd that's not quite as big but you got to focus you got to early in the game figure out what's going to be the herd you go big on and spend the entire game building this humongous herd and then selling it for

tons of points versus trying to make lots of different herds you know this is a game with a bunch of different types of cows in it I want to be successful at the game by doing a different strategy like okay one person's going big herd strategy well I want to make like five different herds and they're all going to have like three or four cows in it but I want that to be viable and it is not at all from what I've been able to see that person usually makes nowhere near the amount of points as someone who's able to pull off this astronomical huge herd that they usually building towards the whole game sometimes the person who wins is somebody who sells off nothing in the middle of the game because their herd is somewhat impervious to the thief and man that's just frustrating to be in somebody the other person's position where like I tried to do something different and it's now obviously it's not going to work next time I play El goucho I also have to go for big herd strategy and that means if everybody knows that then you're playing the game and everybody's doing kind of the exact same thing almost for different herds and then you're not even really competing for them as much I just feel like the game suffers because this feels dominant I feel like this game really should have made um another style of play doing lots of different hers uh viable and it just is not the replayability for El gacho I feel is a bit under average and the reason for that is actually the negative point I just talked about that there feels like there's a dominant strategy where every time you sit down to play Al gacho if you want to win you have to pretty much do the same thing now from a general Euro standpoint it feels like it has a a expected amount of repail ability from a mechanical perspective uh whereas you have these cows that come out kind of randomly and so one game we might be

going for this herd another game we might be going for a different herd and you know the way the dice are rolled is going to give you different options and might lead you in one direction or another as you're playing the specific game but like I said it all culminates back to putting all of your energy towards a single strategy of just making the biggest herd you possibly can and because of that it's definitely hurt the replayability of the game significantly because it feels like there's not a whole lot more to explore when I'm playing this game again it's more just can I do this one thing better than everybody else who is also trying to do that one thing alalo plays two to four players and I played the three four player game several times but never actually tried the two player game all that being said I feel like it's probably best with three the reason two is probably not quite as good is cuz well you roll more dice into that Corral so you have more options I think two is probably fine but it's going to be a little more tip fortat when it comes to grabbing the cows from The Big Field as well the four player game I found could go a little bit long mostly due to analysis paralysis like I talked about earlier there's so many dice being rolled there's so many cows out there in the field and there are so many opponents who are trying to do things it can just take a while until it comes back to your turn especially if you happen to have a simple turn and then everybody has a slow turn it can feel like you go long stretches of time before you do something particularly interesting and that is a bit of a problem it played okay at four I would not refuse to play it at four but I I think all these things considered makes three the good sweet spot in conclusion El Galo is a fascinating and solid dice pool drafting Euro that is somewhat hobbled by the issue of having a

dominant strategy and having the scoring be so incredibly swingy all the other mechanics that are in this game feel great and seem like they mesh together really well with the dice pool Drafting and the bonus actions that you're trying to do as well as just trying to make those sets and putting your workers out in the field trying to maximize um getting all the people um on a specific row and getting those cows back there's a lot of great things here but it's all dampened by this feeling of you've got to do one thing really well and if you don't do it well then you're probably going to lose and that's just getting those really big herds and if some everybody's trying to do that the one person who gets the biggest swing is going to be the one who wins and I've oftentimes found that the winner gets a lot more points than the loser like doubling of points is a thing that has happened and this is the game where even the person who loses is probably going to have over 100 points so these are humongous scores and I think that that does water down the experience and it's made it it's made it less fun for me uh it's become more of a frustrating experience as I've played it more and more I actually really like this game the first couple times I played it but now that I played it I don't know I think six or so times now that last time was very frustrating and I I'm not sure how many more times I'll potentially even be playing this game because of these issues and because I just don't feel like there's that much more to explore in the game when it seems like it's got one thing that you got to do and you better do it well so ultimately I don't really recommend the game I did have fun with this game for several plays though I will give you that so it is not a terrible package it's just a bit of Its Own Worst Enemy when it comes to that swingy scoring at the end I'd like to thank all the people supporting

this Channel Through patreon including the produo level pledges if you too would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com jongetsgames also if You' like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved