#20: First Bites: Fate of the Winner's Europa
Transcript
Hello and welcome to episode 20 of the All You Can Board Podcast. I'm Braden.
I'm Dylan. And I'm Carlo.
On today's board game episode, our main course will be First Bites. Now, usually we have an appetizer, but since we only have a few introductory bites of these board games that we're going over, we're going to jump right into them. So, we're going to be starting with Trans Europa, Winter Circle, and then finishing off with Lord of the Rings: Fate of the Fellowship. So, Carlo, tell us a little bit about Trans Europa. All right. Yeah, this is a 2005 game designed by friends Beno Dange, who's probably best known for games like Fjords and Container. Um, this was a remake of a game from 2001 called Trans America, and it plays for two to six players, originally published by Real Grand Games. So, this is one we've been wanting to play for a while. We um, so far have enjoyed our games uh, by this designer who, by the way, passed away in 2007, which was the year that I looked this up the other day. This is the year that Agricola and Race for the Galaxy were both released. So, uh, tragic time.
You could have been designing games, uh, in one of the one of the greatest eras in board game history there. Um, so, Trans Europa is a network building game across Europe, uh, that's played over multiple rounds. It kind of has a variable number of rounds depending on the game. Um, but basically, everyone starts at, I think it's 12 or 13 points on this score track. And at the end of every round, um, you're going to basically lose points and the end of the game is going to be triggered, uh, when at the end of a round someone has reached zero and then whoever has the most points left is going to win. So, um, basically, you're trying to race to link your five cities. At the beginning of the game, everyone is dealt five random cards and, uh, they they determine which cities you need to connect to across Europe. And once you've revealed or sorry, once you've connected to all five cities, you reveal your cards to everyone else. And then basically the player who did that uh doesn't score any negative points. And then the other players will score negative points based on basically the long and short is like how many connections they were away um to to connecting to their other cities.
And on your turn, you just have three possible actions, which are just little variations of building your tracks. Uh, so I won't get into the specifics, but you're usually just building either one or two tracks uh on your turn, either over regular flat land or sometimes over water with these uh ferry rules, which were marked very clearly on the box as new with with new ferry rules, I guess, for this new edition. Um, or you can build over like mountains or whatever, which are also uh double tracks. So, I'll leave it at that in terms of general overview. Um, when we played, before I ask you guys a couple questions here, when we played, I'll just say right now, Braden absolutely wiped the floor with us. Uh, I think it's interesting that in the on BG, the description says, quote, "After three or four rounds, the player with the most points wins." Our game actually ended after two rounds because of how poorly I did. I think I got minus like I was down to one or two points after the first round.
I absolutely did like was did so poorly. And then the second round I I would have had like minus 9 again or whatever it was. So it triggered the end of the game there. And Braden, you did you Oh, yeah. You went out first like you had a perfect score, right? You ended with 12 or 13.
13. 13.
Yeah. And so uh I'll say right now before I let you guys jump in here, I enjoyed it quite a bit, but it felt like there's like I definitely want to play it again. Um how much depth like first off, do did you guys enjoy it? And also I want to know how much depth do you think there will be um like in subsequent plays and like how differently do you think we would be playing it on our second play, fifth play, 10th play, etc.
Yeah, like so I I really liked it. Um I'll start with that. I it's so hard to say after one play for this one because our game edited it quickly and so in many ways that incur it's encouraging for me to know that this game is like probably going to fluctuate in how long or how short the game can be depending on how the session goes. But it kind of remains to be seen like whether what we experience is like something we'd experience like often or if that's going to be sort of a rarity and it's going to normally go like five rounds or whatever. like we don't really know that yet. But I really I really liked it and I I just I think longevity wise I don't know if it's going to be a game that I want to play like 20 times. But I think that it's a game that if it is always going to play quickly and potentially be done on the sooner side or on the less amount of rounds more often. um it fits in in a rotation kind of nice like for for a game of of like when you look at the box when you were setting it up like I didn't expect it to be sort of that simplistic and I mean that in a good way. Um I mean I should have known with the fairy rules. Um but like yeah it's just like I I I was impressed like I I definitely um in interested play more. I just like I'm also wouldn't be surprised if after I play it like three more times, I'm not necessarily drawn back as much as I feel like I am right now. I thought this was a great candidate of a game um to show
off that exploring other games, especially from designers that you enjoy, even though that they may not be a hyped game or part of the top even the top 2000 on BG, which this game is. I'm currently looking at it 2351, right? Like it's it's it's nowhere, but you can still have like a really good interesting time, which I did enjoy it as well. Like I thought I was very surprised cuz I Yeah, like you said, Dylan, I had no inclinations going into this, like what to expect. And it it went by obviously very fast. And where I think this kind of fits in, like you said too, is kind of almost in the same realm as Caesar's Empire. Like it's quick playing. There's maybe there's not a ton there, but it's it there's enough.
Um, will it last? That's going to be I think the ultimate question for sure. Um there is some good tension there and I was wondering like you know because we were still learning the game um and it's a almost like a semic-op not actually though but like in a way where you're sharing roots and as soon as someone connects to another one it it almost the game speeds up almost exponentially in a way because once one person's connected and then another person gets connected like your reach all of a sudden just expands like wildfire. So,
I'm glad you mentioned the semi-ooper because I want to ask you a question about that, Braden. So, one thing I thought that it was really cool that I'm looking at that that I think, oh, here's a lot of potential, but I don't know if it would be realized in this game. I'm just seeing the opportunity for it. Is there's an aspect of when you were like the person in first, did it ever cross your mind that whether in that game or whether oh, after five more plays, I might consider this that you're like, I want the game to end sooner. So, if I can start to be more in tune with what's happening with Carlos's game, cuz at that point, I think Carlo was the lowest down. I was pretty close behind him, though. But if you're in tune with both of our games, you can try to like do things on the board potentially. Maybe the game allows for that, maybe it won't. Maybe it's it's sort of a moot point, but to like sort of rush the game. And counter to that, there could be situations where you're like, [snorts] I think I could get I could get back in front cuz I'm having a good round, but I can't let this person go below zero then because I need the game to last one more round. What can I do to help them along? That's why I was thinking the cooperative aspect, help them a bit, connect their routes cuz I want them to get most of their connections in in this round, right? And so I I think if the game can realize those things, that's super interesting and that makes it, in my opinion, like a a much more interesting and fun game to consider playing multiple times, but if that's something that you almost wish the game could do, but it never quite feels like it can. It almost feels like a missed opportunity then. And that's what I don't really have an answer for.
But you were in first, so I just like did you feel any of that? I think what you at least what I was considering in that first play was just getting your roots as fast as possible because if you are the one able to get that then you're not losing any points right and if you don't lose any points you're not going to lose um straightforward and the one thing that I kind of thought when approaching like the second round that we had was let me build a route that other people want to connect to. It's almost like building a route that is is pulling people to you instead of you going to them because then they're spending their turn connecting to you,
right? Instead of you spending your turn connecting to them. So the more that that happens for you, right, the more that other people connect to other people and then you get that connection, the more efficient that you're going to be in getting to the places that you need to be. And yeah, like determining when to do that connection is also
um pretty important too. And you really want to ideally I think delay it as much as possible so that you know you take one connect one connection connects you to everything and then the the game is over from there. Um and I think it's hard to determine to be in that semi co-op aspect because you don't know where other people are going, right? And I don't think I think maybe let's talk about the spirit of the game. I think it would be kind of maybe outside the spirit of the game saying, "Hey, are Carlo, you're going to Berlin, right? You're going to or you're going to Oslo, right? Like, I can help you."
I wonder. I don't know. You think you think it would be out of the spirit of the game?
Well, I think it I think it depends on the positioning of people's scores. Like the fact that the fact that the game plays over multiple rounds and and you you know the scores is the game's giving you information similar to what we've talked about before with Lost Cities where you play over three rounds and you're going into round three and you have to play based on how far ahead or far behind you are, right? What level of risk do you want to take? And so in this if there was like I was thinking about this later like we probably should have been trying to build away from Braden specifically to ensure that he would lose points in that final round
and I don't remember and I know that you all place your starting thing in a starting and like I don't know how much we control we could have had based on turn order and whatever but I just I feel like there was a missed opportunity for us in that second round to kind of like yeah not not make it as easy for Braden to connect as he did.
What what I will say though is the way that I positioned my pawn was essentially blocking off one category of those cards cuz I knew you guys had to come to that corner of the board at some point, right? So my goal was to connect up to where I could on like that half of the board and kind of essentially dominate that half like kind of scoop out the bottom left half quarter where Spain is. Not Portugal but just Spain. Um for for for context that
you had to bring it up.
Portugal destroyed us and trends are open but now you got to drive the night.
Braden is Braden is a known Portuguese hater just everyone knows. Why am I on this podcast?
Dylan, I'm going to say right now that explains both my and your poor performance of both ending the game with zero points as we were just too too distraught.
You're still by Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. So, just carving out that point so that I knew you guys would have to come to me at some point. It's just a matter of how long is it going to take for me to get to where I need to go versus you guys. And then
it does make me wonder then like how I'm curious over multiple plays if it feels like when one person takes a bigger lead if there's still an opportunity for people to claw that back or if it feels like at some point they have like it's too insurmountable. I mean like I just don't have enough context to know that at this point.
Well, it's just interesting because you can't score points to get back in it. The only way to get back in is to attack the
Well, that's what I mean. So, do you have to really like is it you have to start like do you have to start changing the way you approach the the rounds if it's not just about you getting to as many of the locations that are in your hand as possible, but it's also how do I how do I either help or hinder the other people based on what I want their scores to do. Right? So, it's it's it's something I can't determine after one play, but I'm curious. I would say enough that I want to find out the answer to those questions. Um, and I just want to highlight my favorite things about it or some my some of my favorite parts about it were the scoring. I think that that scoring is super unique. I love games that do scoring in a different way. Like even though I like Burgundy more than Tuskanyany, I like Tuskany's interesting way of scoring. Um, and I really liked it here where it's yeah, like you you are losing points and the game ends when someone hits zero and then whoever at that point has the most. I just I think that's really interesting
and I think the reason potentially for that could be just to incentivize the selfserving nature of it, right? Rather than working together because it's the person who gets the least amount of points. So you need to hold your own so you don't lose. So
right, it's it's the conflict of wanting to serve yourself but also connect to other people's roots but then that potentially gives them more reach. Right. So,
and I just realized another game that does this but without a a formal score is Moon Colony Blood Bath. You you are degrading the whole game, your engine, and then the first person to lose all their resources ends the game. Whoever's in the first place at that point wins. So, it's like it's the same trigger but just without like a formal like I currently have 20 points. It's just who has the most. I can't remember what the resource is, but when you run out of that resource, it's people. I think it's humans. Uh when you run out of that resource, the game ends when one person does. So, it's Yeah, but it's just not something I've seen a lot of.
Yeah. I I equated this game to kind of like a game of snake where you don't want to touch the other snakes until the right moment.
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah, it almost it reminded me a little bit just of the passive aggressive nature of like Terrammystica where you're building but you kind of want to get close to people but you almost are inviting them
to make the final, you know, like it's you're not it's not confrontational but you have to build next to each other and wait for someone to come to you sort of thing.
Yeah.
But I just Yeah. Braden, hearing you talk about like even just hear like watching you play and then now this is cementing even just hearing you talk about it is like you clearly grasp this game on a level that I just didn't um but it's exciting to see
I don't know I think you're downplaying it like the again even just where like I didn't observe the kind of like choke point that you're talking about about like building here to make sure that like if you wanted access you had to go through like I don't know I wasn't looking at like all of the connection points on the map and I I guess like as much detail as you and like I you I I don't know. Um
it was also the combo of where my cards were, right? Like I and like where everyone else positioned their pawns. I I positioned my pawn not on a city but in between that allowed me to like essentially make a line so I could still be connecting to my cities but also essentially kind of blocking access to that like lower left corner. It just it just worked out that way. I guess I just like when I think of I I felt like my cards in the first round even when I revealed everyone was like oh that was very unlucky and whatever and I was like okay fair enough and then like the second round I went in and I felt like I had better cards and then I still got like again it would have been like minus nine and you got a perfect score both times. So like clearly there is skill and randomness doesn't play that big of a part in this game and that's part of what's exciting is like for a game with such like two pages of rules you're still like which spot do I start on at the beginning of the round? What do I do on my first turn or two? like what intentions do I reveal or not? Where when do I try to connect to someone else or when do I hold off and be stubborn?
Like how risky should I play this round based on the scores? Like there's a lot to consider for such simple rules.
Yeah, I I will agree. And even just like where you're placing your trains, making sure that you're not going to other cities that you don't have. I think that's the biggest thing, too. Like I think someone connected to Kiev uh for me already, so I didn't even have to do anything there. And that was like slam dunk for me, right? Like so, you know, going around those cities, I think, even though it may seem prohibitive, is also probably better for in the long run for you if you don't have those cities. Yeah, it's cool. It's It's definitely worth exploring. It's definitely something that um you know, I would I would be hungry for more.
I was going to say, so would you say you are hungry for more? I am also hungry for more. It's It's made me hungry to have another meal of Trans Europa.
I'd like another bite at least, you know.
Yeah, another bite. It's like
I I definitely want to play this at least a few more times. I think I'm very curious to see, especially based on this designer's track record. Um how much more we'll uncover after subsequent plays.
Pun pun intended track record.
Oh, choo choo. Well, the train
trains leaving the station here. Uh, we'll be right back after this sponsor message.
All you Can board is proudly sponsored by Victory Pints, our local game store of choice here in Winnipeg, Canada. We strongly believe that Victory Pints is the gold standard of board game stores, not just here in Winnipeg. Their main priority is having a wide selection of games, many of which you won't find elsewhere. They ship Canadawide, $15 flat rate or free shipping for orders over $200 and even take requests to try and order in specific games. They also have a used game section where you can trade in games for store credit and maybe even find some hidden gems that others have traded in. Note that the used game section is only available for in-person purchases and trades. again located in Winnipeg at the corner of Henderson and Hespler. Check them out at victoryypines.ca.
A massive thank you to Victory Pines for all their support over the years. And we're off to our next game. Winners circle. Uh I'm hoping that you follow that.
No, no, no. What I'm hoping for is that you insert a horse noise. Although now I'm saying it now. I know that that's not going to
Are you joking? I'm going to keep that in. Are you
That's not going anywhere.
Yeah. Are you replaying noise throughout the episode?
I'm going to use it multiple times.
But thank you. I'll take I'll take it away from here.
Tell me about winner [gasps] circle. [snorts]
Winner circle. So, if you haven't guessed uh by that uh creature noise you just heard, it is a horse racing game called Winter Circle from Riner Kitia. Uh from 2001, I believe may also know it as turf horse racing or royal turf. Um plays two to six players. Um, and if you've uh played it's it's not super similar to these games, but it has a lot of the same um uh foundation as some of the racing games we've seen recently in the way that it has a three round structure. And so you're going to be doing you're going to be doing three different uh races with these horse placing bets. There's seven horses uh in the race. Each one gets its own color and you're going to have three betting tokens. Um, two one bet tokens and one two bet token, which you can just consider like doubling doubling your bet. And the ones are just straight straight up bets. Um, and the way the game plays is there for these seven horses, you're going to shuffle up this deck of tiles, uh, and you're going to deal them out to the seven horses and they basically are going to have different uh, values for uh, that equate to spots on a die that you're going to be rolling. And so some of the values come up more often as in they could have like say I think three spaces is the most that one of the symbols has on the die. Um and then there's one that has two spaces uh on the die and then the other one has one or something like that. I can't remember the exact breakdown, but the whole idea is that some of these symbols are going to come more often and so you can have higher chance of that horse activating with
that number versus other ones that are rarely going to come up might move the horse like 20 spaces on the board. And so after these tiles get dealt out to each of the horses, we are going to be placing bets based on how we think that these values are going to play out in the race to come. And the race is is really simple. You're just rolling the the dieice um and determining which horse are going to move. But the strategy comes into that there's no set horse that's going to move. Uh the player who's rolling the die is going to get to apply that value that shows up on the die to whichever horse they want. And then that horse cannot be selected again until every horse has been selected once. and then they reset and and we keep going until uh three horses finish the race. Um and so what this means is that even though you're placing your bets at the start and that is similar to other uh betting games that we've seen recently, games like Hot Streak, um Ready Set Bat, there's different ones that have done races and betting and all this kind of stuff. But the interesting thing about this one is that there is this uh strategy and tactical uh decision-m you have to do where you say, you know, am I going to apply this value that's really great to the horse that I have bet on that I want to win or am I [snorts] going to use the same value to tank another horse then maybe someone else is going to be trying to win with because I see that if I leave it out there too long eventually they could get the die roll that they want. Maybe there's everyone else at the table has bet on that horse except for you. And so you tanking that horse punishes a bunch of people at the table versus just affecting yourself. Like there's a lot to weigh in the decision-m and so you're going to be doing this three times. [snorts] Um, one other thing I'll call out is the first horse to cross, I think it's spot 18 on the
board, will get this pace chip added on, which is $100. That just increases the bet. And if you have placed your double bet token on the horse that gets that pace chip, that also doubles the pace chip as well. Uh so that's another thing is which horse can reach space 18 first and uh once three horses have crossed then all the bets are are or sorry the round is over and all the bets begin to get applied and pay out or not pay out. Um and as we saw there's many instances where they didn't get paid out in in our game. Um but that's that's it in a nutshell. I'll leave it there. There's some other little nuances but that gives you a bit of an overview. Um so I'll throw it to Carlo first. Carlo, what was your what was your initial reaction of Winner Circle? And specifically, I'd love to know like because we've played a lot of racing games recently like uh with Hot Streak, with Magical Athlete, with Ready, Set, Bet, like h how did it feel amongst all those? Did it stand out? Did it mix in with them?
Okay, so I have to say like I was really surprised by how much my assessment of the game changed throughout as we were playing because at first and like you know even at like just after the rules explanation and the first like round or so it was feeling like a little bit more decision-m a little bit more control than games like Hot Streak or Magical Athlete, but not a ton because the way that you make your bets at the start and understanding those dice probabilities and stuff with those different logos. And I think what you were saying was so the the horse logo is on three sides. So you have a 50/50 chance of rolling that and then the other three are each on one side. So you basically have a one in six chance of three of the icons and then a 50/50 chance of the other one. Um and so early on like again there's another one I this is just a night of doing terribly at games I guess but like I did very poorly at winner circle as well. I think I ended with like $200. Um, and I kept thinking like at first, so maybe I'm getting unlucky. And then watching again a couple of the players we played with, I think it was Sheney who did like super well and Dave as well, just racking up money and I started to see what they were doing and how they were kind of hedging their bets or even just dividing which horses you bet on. I found that super interesting just to kind of like, well, if you put all your eggs in one basket, like you bet on three different horses that have similar dice values versus betting across different dice values and where is your score and who are you going in with? Do you want to be betting on the
same horses as specific other players? Do you want to mix and match? Like, how are you distributing your bets across the track? What do you choose to move as you're, you know, on your turn? And suddenly by round two or three, I suddenly realized like, okay, there's similar to what we were talking about with Transopa, like there's more skill to this game than is initially apparent, but it's still really silly and it's still like I felt like not only did it give you more control than games like Hot Streak and Magical Athlete and and Ready, Set, Bet, but I enjoyed it more on my first play, even though it was longer. Normally these kind of games I'd like to think of like, yeah, it's better when it's like 30, 40 minutes. I don't need to have this kind of silly rambunctious type of act. Like we were yelling, trash talking the whole time. Like I was wor I was tired at the end of playing this. It was a bit of an event.
It was about an hourong play and yet I was like, man, I can't wait to play this again actually. Like I feel like I'd approach it differently and I just had so much fun kind of like shouting at people around the table. Um so yeah, that's that's kind of my initial thoughts, but I'm curious to hear what you guys think as well. it. Uh, I think this particular game I also did really really poorly. I' I've got the stats here. Uh, Carla, you were at 150. I was at 350. And I think I that was my only positive uh win was at the very last race of the the whole
I mean you you had a good final race, let's say, because I'm pretty sure did you not go into the final race at zero?
Yes, that is correct.
So like I mean at least take solace in that you had a good you by the third round you had figured it out.
Yeah. Well, kind of still. Um,
yeah. I mean, I I agree with you, Carlo. I think this this one took me a little bit by surprise. At first, I was kind of like, "Okay, this looks interesting. It's the horse racing game, but just there's definitely more to it. I think when I would approach this one again, too. Would love to play it again." Um, it's this this one seems very group dependent, I would say. Like, for our group, 100%. This is a slam dunk. This is like up the alley of like the rowdiness of Lords of Vegas, you know, we're talking like we're we're purposely mispronouncing names of horses, you know, and like just like
accidentally that was there was no intention. accidentally at first. That's a little
eventually. Uh I we should also just mention we did play this with the full max six player count which I I suspect I'm not I I'm really really curious what it'll feel like in other player counts cuz there is some cool rules in the book uh in the rule book as well for the ways the game um changes a bit when you play with two and three for instance. But I I just have a feeling that playing with the full six, even though it is group dependent, is going to feel the best just because you have so many more tokens and and uh bets and and placement around the table to consider. Which that's the one thing I wanted to call out is like I was surprised by how cool and how much I enjoyed the fact that where the people are sitting at the table and who place bets on what horses came like made the strategy so much more rich. Like there was times where it would be at a certain person and they're making a decision and I'm factoring when it's going to get back to me, but I'm seeing, okay, the next three people that it's going to they're going to choose which horses that you we apply these symbols to have all bet on the same horse and are all hoping that this horse hits a certain value. And so like and Carlo, I think you called this out before a bunch of us where it's like we needed to do we need to to tank that horse is like that's the language we used a lot in this game. We needed to like purposely pick bad rolls that came up for that horse before it got to these three people who were in succession at the table because those otherwise we knew there was three chances they were going to roll this ideal value.
Sometimes it was the horse that shows up three times in the die. And that's a part of the strategy I I sort of clued into too late and I didn't figure out how to balance with my own interests as well. Right.
That's an excellent point. I'm so glad you brought that up cuz that was definitely some of the juiciest stuff and and you don't see that in a lot of games where you're thinking that strongly about turn order and about like I have to do this now because otherwise there are three opportunities in a row that are going to just absolutely wreck our chances of winning here if we don't stop this person right now or stop this horse. And yeah, I think that's something you get you'll get more of at the max player count because even just thinking that with four players there's less tokens out there. there's less crossover on who's been on the same horses. That's something I think that almost emerges at only probably five and six players um in the way that we experienced it. And I wonder if that just like elevates Winter Circle to being a better game and and that sort of ends up being why it's probably going to be best with six, I think. But again, still curious to try it at like four, especially to see if it holds up. Yeah. And with more players, right, there's less control from you because there's other opportunities for other players to be rolling the dieice, right? you've got fewer chances to roll and get what you want and place it onto the the horse you want, right? With fewer players, you get more opportunities to do that. With more, there's more chaos, which I think is is great. And you're you're bargaining.
You're trying to like, no, no, come on. We're we're together. And like, yeah, like you guys said, where you place your bets.
We were yelling around the table that they're trying to convince people to make certain decisions like Yeah.
Well, that's the thing. Even in the bet, even in the betting phase, even before it gets to the dice rolling, during the betting phase, you're looking in like one horse has four or five people already betting on it. And we did we mentioned that one of your three bets is a double, right, for each round. So, yeah. So, that's super interesting, too, because you see like three, four people put their double down on one horse, and you're like, well, I don't want to go there anymore. Like, this this value isn't going to be there. Or you look and you're like, ah, this one horse doesn't look great, but like nobody has bet on it. like maybe maybe it is wise for me to bet on that one horse since no one else has like I don't know there's especially after the amount that I've played games that other people like you know there's a couple the two games that come to mind can't stop and challengers in terms of games that so many people dismiss as like these games have too randomness they're pure luck whatever and I've come to appreciate how difficult it is to kind of like understand probability and make decisions based on the information that the randomness provides rather than just like cursing your luck when it doesn't go well. And that's made me appreciate this game so much. And and I want to see if it has that level of depth replay.
Like I don't think it's going to be like those kind of games where I want to play it hundreds of times, but um yeah, especially at those higher player counts. I I would love to revisit this. I just think it's super interesting that we sort of saw this like surge of uh racing games come out. And I I say surge, I'm not saying there's a ton, but I think of like games like Ready Set Bad and Hot Streak and Magical Athlete that in this in a short span of time all sort of came out and seemed to be trying to scratch a certain itch um and just like doing it like and and again it's different audiences I would say for Hot Streak and Magical Athlete to some extent, but it makes me wonder why like there's this great game that came out all the way back in 2001 that kind of in my opinion like I still think I like currently after one play only. I still like already said bet more, but I also think that there's a possibility that if I play this more, I might end up liking this more. And to say that about a game that came out well before them, like there's like a opportunity here for like marketing wise for them to be like now is the time to re-release and re like publish uh Winter Circle because like I think it does it better and the audience is clearly there for this type of game.
Um, but I was just super impressed. It's like a It's like a I don't want to say it's like a board gamers version of Ready, Set, Bat, but like it kind of is in that way. Like to
I know what you mean.
For lack of a better term kind of thing, you know? Yeah. I consider myself
it gifies it the most. Yeah.
Yeah. You you got a little there's more control over it rather than like a pure betting experience like you're Yeah. H having your hand a little bit on like the gas pedal or not not a hand but like a finger.
Right. Just just a little bit on the gas pedal.
Really?
I was going to say insert brain horse sound, but you know what? You did it. You did it yourself and I'm glad for it. All right. Now we just got to wait for Carlos horse sound now later on in the episode. But tune in for that.
That's going to that's going to be his verdict.
That's going to be in section three of Lord of the Rings. Actually,
tell us your verdict in horse, Carlo.
Hey or stay.
No, I can't. It's got to be It's got to be off the cuff. But uh I just got to say real quick if we uh I got to throw Long Shot the Dice game out there too. Dylan, I know you haven't played it. Braden, you have I would say of the ones we've mentioned, Long Shot the Dice game is the one that's most similar to this in terms of like the kind of
added rules and control that it gives you, that one has the more silliness of like pulling horses back and like there's a bit more sabotage. And that one, the ending feels like it can drag just a little bit. So, this this to me, even over one that has more going on, I would prefer this over Longot the Dice game.
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. And I'm sure there's I mean even Camel Up. I mean there's other ones as well that we have played or haven't played, but it just seemed like lately there was all these that kind of came out generally close together and it just Yeah. Now that we played this one, it's like I I don't know. This might be one of the best ones. And it came out what is that like 25 years ago?
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Wild stuff.
Okay. Before we before we move on and give our verdicts and whatnot, can I just can we talk for just a moment about the art and production and and whatever? as we got to we got to play the dice tree version which is like the sort of deluxified version with all the painted uh horse miniatures which are really nice but there were still some issues but I just have to draw attention cuz the version I have is the old like face tof face games one and on the board and the actual horse colors are like it's basically just like seven sh it's like black gray brown
tan beige
and white and Yeah exactly and one more like take your one more earth tone color of your choice basically and it's like why why were these the choices like
yeah yeah 100%. there was there's room if that's why I almost part of me is like yes this is the time to republish it and get it out there because like these are the things you can improve if you're going to do it again and it shouldn't be that hard but like that and and also just like the metal coins in the version that we played were really great great to handle and sort of especially like yeah it just and and there's like there's other external solutions like that that's not the deal breaker but it is nice when you can just sort of have that in the box and be like tied to an exclusive to that game. Um, I really I liked it. I liked the the uh deluxified version, but I in both honestly in both versions, I think that there's room that they could improve with everything that we've learned over this space in the last 25 years.
Yeah, maybe some really nice artwork for each of the horses. Make them give them some some personality or something. I don't know.
Yeah, totally. I think just Yeah, I'm trying to make them easier to identify. I think in the other versions, like the nondic tree versions, it's easier. Just has like a solid color. Easier to tell which horse is what, right? By color. That's that one. Not a problem. But the the dye version as like beautifully painted. Very cool. Just at you at a glance, tough to tell which horse was what. It's like, oh, is it? You got to look at the the little sash on the back. Is this number? Okay. Is this a tiny number two? like it's, you know, it's a it's a very minor thing, but it's definitely a prime target to be improved upon for sure.
100%. [snorts] So, uh, Braden, then what would you give this, uh, for your verdict?
Yeah, I think, you know, um, if I was a horse, I would be looking for that bag of oats because I'm hungry for more. I'm I'm I'm I'm dying to play this one again. I love this kind of environment when it comes to uh games and this is a fantastic hybrid between that like craziness of ready set bet but still having like a little bit of control and strategy at the same time and you know it's it's kind of silly. It's it's a little ridiculous but um yeah uh it's really good.
Yeah, I'm right there with you. Hungry hungry for more. um even more enthused and more hungry than Trans Europa. Uh I really I left at this one with a positive impression. Um Carlo, what about you?
Hungry for more as well. I don't know just comparing to Trans Europa, I don't know if I'll like it more. I think because of the it it again it was not only was it an hour probably double the length of of Trans Europa but it took a lot out of me like socially like that was a lot of energy of like yelling at people and getting excited about stuff that didn't pan out and it was a bit of a bit of an emotional roller coaster so I don't know if I would play it quite as often as Trans Europa but I definitely want to experience it a bunch more.
Yeah, that's totally fair.
Kevin, don't you dare move number two. I swear to God. Sorry. I'm just having some PTSD right now. Oh, well, I mean, speaking of moving from place to place, uh, let's talk about Lord of the Rings, Fate of the Fellowship. Um, you know, Froto and the gang going from a bag end all the way down to cozy old Mordor. Um, so for those of you who don't know, uh, this is designed by Matt Lecock, published by Zman Games, came out last year in 2025, plays one to four players. Um, and this is a essentially the very bare bones explanation is a co-op/solo Lord of the Rings pandemic game through and through. It's the easiest way to explain this. um you've got different characters that you're controlling that have different abilities and powers and let you manipulate um things on the board and you have different objectives you need to complete. One of which always in every game of course is to destroy the one ring in Mount Doom. Get it to the get it to the uh volcano. Toss that sucker in there. Um this comes with a wide variety of characters. I' like at least I feel like 12 maybe. I'm I'm not even sure off the top of my head, which is it's just crazy.
Um, and a huge variety when it comes to different objectives in what you need to do in the game. So, there's four objectives that you need to do in a beginning game or starting game, normal game, whatever it is. You can increase the difficulty I think by adding objectives and um adding in different um uh in essentially no they're not pandemic cards but they're called skies darken cards in this case. Um basically where stuff gets worse. You know you shuffle the deck it intensifies.
We played introductory like we played the the first one. We we played like normal, so it's like four.
Yeah. What the whatever the suggested um objectives were and stuff too characters.
It goes up to legendary where there's six skies darken and six objectives.
Yeah. Which is crazy.
Yeah. Six objectives seems wild.
Yeah. So you're it's like pandemic. You've got a um hands with locations on them. You can use it to trade uh cards. You've got different symbols on those cards um which you can use for different things for fighting orcs at different locations which are essentially kind of like your disease cubes in a way. Um you can use it to take over a stronghold. I'm not going to explain exactly what all that means. Um but no, again to the very bare bones here, this is Pandemic Lord of the Rings super thematic and I'm curious. So, this was uh Dylan and I, we played this um in August. I'm curious what for one thing just to begin with, what was one thing that stuck with you about this game?
um like to not to counter what you said cuz I agree like and I I would that's how I would explain it to everyone too but like as much as it is like very pandemic and you see the DNA and like every aspect of the game pretty much I was also surprised by like how much they're able to like live in that space while also making it kind of it almost made me forget about pandemic like at first I'm like oh like pandemic oh similar to pandemic and then by the by like us being half an hour into it it's so thematic. It's so unique with the map that it presents compared to other pandemic games obviously because pandemic like they were especially the original based in our world. This is obviously in a fantasy world. Um the fact like the way that you are trying to move around troops and like influence the troops positions usually to like achieve objectives. Um, it was really interesting and like even though that's similar to like the disease cubes and us moving around the board, there was something about the way they presented that just I like after I made that first correlation very quickly I forgot of the similarity because it kind of did it independently like it did it in its own way. Um, there's like true just to quickly say like there's troops for all the all the different um factions. I can't even remember them all but like essentially they're all represented by different colors. Um uh it's like the dwarves and the elves and gondor troops and things like that.
Rohinians.
Yeah. Rohanians. Yes. Uh and so like they're these troops are going to be on different spots on the map and you might have to bring different colored troops to different spots, but you you have to utilize your character's abilities. You have to navigate the Naz ghouls that are in the regions as well. Like there's a there's enough there that it very quickly sort of stands on its own and separates itself to from Pandemic while still being built on those foundations. And I just I found that interesting. I guess I didn't know enough going in and so I thought it was very much closer to the way that um the Lord of the Rings trick taking card games felt in comparison to the crew. They felt individual, but they it felt much more inspired by I was like, "Oh, this is built off the crew's foundation." This has that, but it very quickly just sort of goes off in its own direction, I felt like, and makes it its own. And I just really I thought that was really cool.
Yeah. No, I and I completely agree with you too, Dylan. Like I I think calling it just a pandemic game is too simplistic. Like it has its own Even just the way the map is laid out. I think at first, like you take a look at that map and it's like what is going on? There's like a million different arrows going different ways, you know, like this is the most confusing thing I've ever looked at. And then
it does look overly complex.
You start playing it and then you like reveal a card, you're like, "Okay, the guys go from here." And you just follow the colored line. and you're like, "Oh, that that actually makes total sense." I think there's a lot of great things that were thought of when it comes to at least the way the game plays like that. Um, and yeah, it's less about like diseases moving around, but like manipulating troops, taking battles in different ways. The the eye of Sauron is bouncing around to different locations and making sure is it's not where Froto is, cuz if you draw a certain card, that's going to be really bad for you. And
the objectives make it like it's already a very thematic game, but the objectives make it feel even more thematic because besides the one uh of Destroying the Ring, they change every game, but they're all within like the world and the story line of the the books and the movies. And so you're you're there are familiar objectives, but they're they're different. and and I just like that kept it more thematic to me than than pandemic even was because it's it's there's just more varied and and sometimes you're doing vastly different things in one game to a next game and you almost expect that only in sort of like campaign games or or games that offer an evolving narrative of some kind and it doesn't it's not an evolving narrative game. It's just like it kind of is able to accomplish that by just saying we have so many objectives and they come out in different combinations and depending on the difficulty sometimes you might have six which is crazy. So yeah, I really liked that aspect too and it just like added to like an man if there's one thing a Lord of the Rings board games do very well in my experience with them so far is just they nail the thematics. Like they just they make it key to build in that game and I just think that that's really really great. Yeah, even just like the amount of symbols you need to sneak into Mordor, right? You need like these stealth tokens and yeah, there's so many other mechanics that we can talk about about like rolling searches and don't need to get into the nitty-gritty here, I think. But it just what I really liked about it and our play specifically Dylan was I liked much again to the core of
pandemic I would say is I liked talking about the different moves that we could potentially make and do. Um and having we know each of us have two characters and you get four actions with one character and one action with the other character and that kind of dynamic was also really interesting too. Where do I want to spend those actions? And having that back and forth talking about our plans, too, about where we're going. I'm going to drag these over here and do this over here. Oh, something changes. Really great. Really enjoyed that. There's a lot to talk about, a lot to think, and getting other people's perspective is really something that that I enjoyed about this game. And yeah, like you said, the thematics are on point. It's it's insane.
Carlo, how do you feel as someone who hasn't played this game, but you're hearing us, but is you're not even just hearing us talk, but you've heard the entire board game space talk about this game for like a year.
Yeah. And the the most interesting or the most intriguing thing to me about it, every time I hear people talk about the game is that aspect that you just brought up, Raiden, about the four actions with one character and one with another. I think that's such a smart thing to do because there are certain times playing like I I've played base Pandemic, Pandemic Iberia, and I've played one or two of the expansions, but I think that's it. Um, but you can get that feeling sometimes in Pandemic where you're kind of stuck with the role you have. And sometimes your decisions feel a bit narrow in terms of like well I'm the medic and like I obviously have to go to that part of the board to take care of this thing right now or I'm the like whatever quarantine specialist and I know that it makes sense to quarantine here or and just having that option of these two characters and where you split your actions. It also makes it feel like if you if they gave you two characters and you had to just pick one or the other, it would also feel like one might feel a lot more useful and just leaving the other one there, not getting much use. So, the fact that they give you the second one and make you activate both in different amounts is just I don't know.
I really really like that. That's the part that intrigues me the most as well as just seeing how the extra elements like because it does sound like a more elaborate version of the pandemic system. So, and which actually leads to what I want to ask you guys. So because I think overall you guys have played more pandemic kind of versions or variants than I have. So based on the all the pandemic system games so including you know the the original Iberia Fall of Rome all that kind of stuff. And then including the thematic offshoots whether that's World of Warcraft, Wrath of the Lich King, Star Wars the Clone Wars which I don't think any of us have played either of those and now this legacy versions etc. Like, do you suspect that this will end up being your favorite version of Pandemic out there? And if so, by how much? And if not, then how much better can they make it? And where do they go from here?
Just like more IPs. Do you want something more complex, more streamlined than this? I think for where I stand, really, I would have to give a verdict until uh my wife and I have played it. I have a [clears throat] feeling it might be slightly too far on the complicated side when it comes to that, but I did I will say I did play this solo as well and I really enjoyed it solo. Um, and the way that they handle that.
That's actually I was going to ask it if you had played it solo yet.
Yeah. So, I'm kind of in the I think it's like it's it's a happy middle ground where it's it it to me at least it's not too cold when if it's like maybe a little bit too simple. Um but it's also not too hot where it's overly complicated. I'm in that like Goldilocks, you know, right in the middle, you know?
Yeah. whereas like I I would I I'll say that I I would be surprised if it ends up that I like it more than base pandemic. And the c the reason I'll give for that cuz I I really liked it and I was really impressed and and like I I think I went in very hesitant just because when I've been caught up sometimes in in the hype that happens in the board game space with certain games and then playing the game I it's not that the games have always or been only hype but they just sort of haven't like ever quite achieved the levels of hype that lately that games some games get. So, I went in hesitant and it definitely like I was like, "Okay, I get it." Like, I see why. Especially for someone who's a Lord of the Rings fan and especially if you if you haven't played much Pandemic or you only played a little bit or you love Pandemic, like it almost just seems like a no-brainer. But for me, it just it it added a level of complexity to pandemic that I am personally not like as not not I don't even want to say not as interested in, but I just don't see myself getting to the table enough. Um, and that's because to me, like the allure of Pandemic, and I haven't played Pandemic now in a while, but like the allure of that, the allure of season one of Pandemic Legacy was that it is this accessible co-op game that in many ways like teaches you certain things about board games, like allows you to sort of like make mistakes or piggyback off of the people you're playing with and not feel too out on your own. Um, and it just like it's been evolved on in a in
many other ways already that aren't quite as complex that I would be more interested in. Whereas this one, it just feels like the solo aspect is great to know, but it just otherwise feels like I don't know when I would necessarily like if I had a copy of this would be suggesting this over base pandemic because at that complexity level, I think there's other games I'm more interested in playing than ones in the Pandemic Foundation of games. But that's that's literally just me. if as some if someone like loves pandemic um a lot more than I do and I know there's a lot of people out there who do. I think if you're hungry for like this kind of experience and you might be at that point like especially if you're a Lord of the Rings fan like this might end to be one of your favorite games. Like it does it does what it does very well. Like I was very impressed. I just think that I might be slightly the wrong audience or it's like the wrong time in my life for it if that makes sense.
Yeah. And I that's kind of what I was alluding to a little bit by giving my true verdict when it I haven't played with Sarah yet because I think it it might be that extra layer of complexity that you're talking about might be a little bit too much for like that pandemic level experience that I'm looking to like have on my shelf in a way too. But it is there if we want something that's a little more complicated and is co-op, right? like it's got a good blend and we're like, "Hey, I haven't played a Lord of the Rings game in 2 hours. Let's let's try this one out."
Yeah. Yeah,
that makes sense. I'd be very intrigued to try it, but I like I'm not going to be requesting to try it out myself probably, but um yeah, if you next time if you guys are playing it, let me know. I'd love to check it out.
But I think you should give a verdict based on what we've said, which is either uh mouth wet or mouth dry. Oh wow.
Are you are are you foaming at are you are you drooling at the mouth to uh to take a bite into this game or are you looking for another course at the table? Why does it have to be one extreme or I I guess if I guess if I had to pick one, I'm looking for another course. But like if I'm hungry, I'm not going to turn it down. If it's this or no game night, I absolutely sign me up to try it. Like this or here's the thing. It this is like when I hear
I guess the way I'll put it is like I hear you know there's a lot of these games that we we talk about amongst us. We've talked about on the channel before about like trying to keep up with games that other people are talking about and we place a bit less importance on that these days and and whatnot. And I think the fact that it's one cooperative and I see the game length on BG says 60 to 150 minutes. Like if there's a chance that it's going 2 2 and 1/2 hours, like co-op games already aren't usually my favorite. There's a few I really like, but the ones I do are usually like play between 15 minutes to maybe 45 minutes kind of thing. The idea of playing a two or two and a half hour cooperative game like is kind of a hard sell for me for game nights these days. like I don't want to spend the whole or majority of game night playing one long cooperative game. So, I don't know. I'm I would be more likely to try this either solo on or on board game arena before like playing it at a game night with people.
Yeah, absolutely fair. Um Dylan, what's your what's your verdict on this?
My verdict is that I'm feeling satisfied after my play. I'm This doesn't mean I'm not going to like play it again. And I I think I I definitely want to play it again, but I also if someone told me, you know, you're not going to play that game again, I'm content with that. I'm not necessarily necessarily hungry for more, so to speak. Uh but yeah, I'm very satisfied. Like I I I was happy to have played it and I I had a really good time with it. It's just going to be, I think, a hard self to be any sort of anything close to a mainstay for me.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm also in that kind of camp. Um I'm satisfied for now. It's probably something that I will definitely come back to. Um, you know, whether it's solo or playing with my partner. I think, um, it's
Do you think if your partner likes it and is like, I want to keep playing this and and you're still enjoying it, do you think that that has the potential to upgrade to Hungry for more?
Absolutely. Yeah, there's no doubt about it. Like there's if it if it's something that becomes like, oh, like this was really great. Like I like the little bit of like thematic and that adds enough to it that the complexity is not uh so much an issue. 100%. Um
I just want to make sure that when your partner listens to this that she knows all the pressure is on her.
That's right. That's right. It's all on you and we're going to have to figure out exactly how this works.
Um
and please tell me you guys had the soundtrack of one of the movies playing.
Oh yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
I was gonna say did we have Yeah, we did. Yeah, we absolutely.
It's like it's like it it should come in the box. Like it's just that much of a necessity.
Just like scan the QR code and then
yeah to play a soundtrack. That is a great idea to start. Or maybe they already do that. Was Carlo or No, that was a fan curated site that you were using where it's like suggested music for the board game. Oh yes,
but like including a QR code in the rule book saying here's a a curated playlist and maybe even have it some of it be like copyrighted songs. I don't know. Like but like just something you listen to while you play but it's specifically confined to. That's a good idea. someone should take that and then credit us and pay us.
I mean, it was your idea, but yeah, I'll I'll take part of that payment if you're offering.
Yeah, I think um we'll we'll see where it lands in the long run here, but um yeah, it was it was good. I think uh it'll it'll come out solo for sure. Um definitely want to go back to it one of these days. We'll see what it's like in the future.
We'll check back in with you on an appetizer after you've played with your partner. Yeah, absolutely. That's a great that's a great way to end off here, too. Um, hey, thanks so much for listening, you guys. If you didn't know, we got a YouTube channel. Uh, it's All You Can Board. Guess what? Patreon, Discord, as well. Come engage with us. Reviews also help spread the good word of board games here on All You Can Board. So, please consider leaving one on your platform of choice. Otherwise, this has been episode number 20 of the All You Can Board podcast. Thank you so much for listening and we hope you'll join us again in two weeks for episode 21.
I'm not even going to say bye. That was just perfect.
I was I was going to I was going to do it again and I was like I'm just going to wait. We're going to wait to see if we can love it. I love it so much.
That's good.