Messina 1347 Review
Transcript
thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to drive through review 750. today we're going to talk about Messina 1347 this is a new game from the design team at delicious games which is Vladimir Sushi and he's co-designing this one with uh let me try to get the name right Raul Fernandez aparicio so delicious games is the original Publishers over in Europe Rio Grande games is bringing it over to the states uh this is an interesting game theme one so if I had to try to sum it up in a terrible way it's a Euro game a lot of moving Parts a lot of mechanics so if you love Euro games you're probably gonna like this we'll get to the review part at the end but the theme is interesting kind of timely for now uh basically there's been a plague in Messina and what the players are doing is they're kind of coming back to the city trying to get rid of the play get rid of the pandemic if you will and then try to re-establish and rebuild the economy rebuild the town and all that kind of stuff set up establishments move people back into the City and so on so it actually achieves that little spoiler there's some very very abstract means but it does get there so let's take a look at the table I'll walk to the mechanics then I'll come back and give you my thoughts at the end okay I got everything kind of set up here there's basically three kind of main parts and I actually got them all on the camera here
this is kind of three parts are going to be entering interacting with first let's talk about the part up here at the top and we'll go over this in some more detail in a minute but this is obviously the score track there you can see how he keeps score going around you have these three tracks here which certain actions in the game are going to allow you to move up here and these will kind of unlock new abilities give you new workers and things like that that you can use to employ in the game here's kind of a round summary which we'll look at in a minute and then you have the turn order track up there and if we zoom in just a little bit there's some other little buildings and things like that that you can buy little wagons and things like that are going to come in useful so that board is going to be up there and then you have the main sort of City Board this represents the city and this is made up of these hex tiles here and this is somewhat randomized this is what it'll look like at the start of the game roughly over the course of the game you might be adding uh well you will be adding new hextiles based on this kind of like little stack of tiles that you will draw which will randomly tell you where to put stuff out and if we take a look at these what these are are a little little places where you can do kind of like work replacement action so if I move my worker here I might have to put out the plague if there's a plague Cube on that tile there there might be some citizens here that I might have to rescue or recruit if you will and they'll be on top of that that'll Focus there we go so this is that's how you will interact with that so you might find the plague you might rescue and quarantine or just recruit different types of workers and you have a little work replacement action here and then down here we will tell you kind
of like where to put plague pieces in certain pieces and then here at the top you can see a cost there to sort of repopulate the city so that's what these tiles are and then you kind of have like your own player board here which is made up of a few different things so we can see here we've got like a bonus scoring a little track there and this is double-sided as well as this board is double-sided as well and each player will get their own board like so what you're looking at here is the a side there's a b side to both uh these two boards here so they recommend that you play with the a side there and then you've got spot here to put buildings to put some of the different citizens in here and then some of the other kind of work buildings over on the side there so this is kind of your main sort of player board and then you'll be interacting with everything again up here on the city so now what's going to happen here is I'm not going to get too crazy with the mechanics because it would take kind of a while the game isn't so bad to play especially familiar with any kind of medium to sort of heavy Euro game this is right going to be in your wheelhouse here so you have here the city every round you're going to flip over a new boat and it's going to go into one of these kind of ports here it's going to bring the plague with it each round here you're going to flip over and it's going to tell you which port to put those in and also where you might add a new uh City tile as well and then what you're going to do here is you're going to rotate this wheel every round like let's say we'll just do it
there so you're going to put plague tiles on any rats that are standing up and facing to the left whereas if we were over here it'd be any of the rats that are sitting down facing to the right so let's say we did that one and so we would find these spots here let's take a look at the board so for example we have a nice little setup here of these three rats are facing to the left and standing up and then you can kind of see that one at the upper right hand side of the frame there so there we know that we would put in some of these plague counters here so they're going to come in on these now the other thing to notice here are the colors on this so you can see all the nuns are going to come in on the pink tiles here so these two kind of it's kind of big like magenta and then so these will come in here so we'll put some nuns there like this and then we'll do the same for the other three types of workers here so you've got the nun the Craftsman and the nobility there one thing to note here is you can see this nun came in she's all by her Lonesome so she's safe from the plague in that case this one however you will when you go to sort of rescue here you're going to have to put her into quarantine because she existed alongside that plank Cube there so around you can kind of seed the board with new citizens new workers and then new play cubes that you've got to fight and then what's going to happen is players are going to have workers in their color and to start out the game let's just zoom out a bit you're going to take and put a worker out in a spot and then you're going to take the action there so in this case I might collect a coin so I get a coin there and then I might get to activate
what's called an overseer which I'll talk about that that's on your own personal board and so this is the overseer for the Nobles there or if I go here I'm will need to fight this plague token and then I can rescue the nun there now to fight the plague token you need these fire tokens here and so you have these sort of these are sort of you called strength one fire tokens now later on in the game you'll need strength to fire tokens so these counts as strength through there's still like one fire token they don't count as two tokens they count as like a strength two think of it like that so start the game off though fairly easy to get rid of that except to discard that so we'll fight that when you every every time you defeat uh the plague in such a way you are going to progress up this track and then you're going to get the reward so you see in that case I'm going to get a coin or as if we zoom in just a little bit there you can see actually if I get defeat a second one I can go up either of these two tracks there because you can see those two books there right there are the same icons as what's above there so you defeat two of them and then it gives you a bump on one of these tracks here and then eventually you might unlock a new worker as you go up there and that worker that you get you can use immediately that turn although it's going to increase the cost of something what you can do is here you can spend one money per worker that you have unlocked you can see that right down there to advance one of these tracks as well so at the start of the game it's cheaper to kind of spend money to move
up these tracks which is possible on your turn but as you get more workers and unlock them it becomes more expensive so it's kind of a balancing act when you want to start kind of pivoting in that way and this is just while we're looking at the top of the track here you also see unlock some other special abilities and so on and then you start to get points at the end of the game so they can see these Point banners here at the top so we've got these different points as you make your way further down the track there and there'll be some other things that interact with these little ribbons here to get you extra points at the end of the game but you'll get points for moving up the different tracks and so on and the other thing to keep in mind since we're on this board as you can see the turn order there is defined in such a way and that is going to be based on this chart over here and you can see the left hand side of this there should be a little Cube here there it is and the term is going to be defined by who is kind of the highest up on these different tracks so different times of the game you're going to be going first but not based on kind of The Usual Suspects it's going to be based on these different mid game conditions of where you're at and it's also going to kind of Define for you the outline here so this tells you how to flip over the boats this is going to tell you to add new tiles add the new plague cues add the people and then the sort of the strength required to defeat the plague so you can see you only need you know the the one power fire tokens here whereas the double ones you need those to fight the plague at the end to kind of stamp out that final part of the plague and there's also a little
indication here that we're going to swap out the buildings here so these buildings these kind of work buildings here at the top you can see there's one in the middle there you've got ones for each of the different types so you can see here this one is for the Craftsman for the nobility and so on and then you've got a stack there in the back those are going to come out at the end in the last couple of rounds because we'll talk about these in a minute but they're kind of like these are kind of ongoing benefits that you'll see there and then the other ones will be immediate because at the end of the game you're not going to get much out of them so it kind of switches them out which is nice so anyway that's all kind of driven by some of this moving up the track and the turn order and all that kind of fun stuff so again as people start to put stuff out so we'll just kind of do this now you got your first round done right and then what's going to happen is now everybody's got workers out there so the next round what you can do is you can move to an adjacent spot and then you'll just kind of lay your worker down to show that it's been used and then that's how you're going to activate so then now you're going to move around now to jump more than one space you're going to have to pay a coin and actually I did that in Reverse you want to lay them down at the end and then you pick them up and use them it doesn't really matter we've actually played it both ways so just make sure you get it right um but yeah so yeah the trick is that you cannot use a hex that's already been used so however you choose to indicate it the rules say it's by standing up so you lay everybody down and move them so they're standing up so nobody else can go and use there but if I was hadn't used this hexat and you moved there before I was able to activate them then you could do that just because it's a figure there but if the hex has been
used that round this is the important part that you can't reuse it again so again so after you've got all the workers out there you're just going to be moving them around back and forth again if you get new workers they're going to come from off the board in the first round that you get them and then they'll have to start moving around there and there are all kinds of different things here so you can some of these spaces will allow you to move up the tracks directly they'll get you fire tokens they'll get you uh wood tokens here that you can spend to build some of these buildings that I showed you at the top and all kinds of different things what else is out here oh one thing you can do here is you can actually upgrade your workers here so you can see so this is kind of you get the noble there on that side but then you might upgrade them to that side and they'll score you a point as well for doing that so we talked about rescuing these workers now let's talk about where they will go on your board now when you rescue them if they were in an area with a plague Cube you have to put them here in the quarantine Hut where they're going to have to sit now you can but build and buy buildings in here and these quarantine hunts to actually give them the ability to do something so these will provide you income on your turn so they'll provide you you know a fire token and a coin or this one will provide you a victory point and a coin there and then the next round they're going to move one slot there and then the next round they'll come off and then you can put them onto your sort of board here this is where your overseers are so this looks a little bit complicated it's not too bad so you have three overseers and you can
see they matched the different types so we have kind of the church area here with the nuns so this is where you can put your nun workers and then your Craftsman can go up here and in these two areas and your nobility over here so once you either pull them out of quarantine you can put them over here or if you got them on a space that didn't have a plague token you can put them directly into here now you can also build these buildings over here like this and again these are for different types and these These are kind of the work buildings here and so this one you need to have a uh Craftsman or an upgraded Craftsman and this one for example needs an upgraded Craftsman because you got the yellow side there and so the cost here is on the left and you'll put these off to the side of your board there and that's another spot you can put your your workers there so let's take a look what happens when you activate an overseer so let's say we activated our nobility here so we'll take the noble one and we'll move it here so this allows us to activate either of these two spots that it's connected to but you need to have the right citizen in there so in this case we'd move it up here we don't really have a choice because we don't have citizens in both spots so this allows us to upgrade any of the other citizens we have anywhere on our boards or any of the buildings so we maybe we'll just upgrade this guide is for fun so we did that now next time you activate this overseer you're going to have to make a choice to go this way or this way and when you get this spot you can activate any of these pieces in there any of these three spots and then the same with this one now you can upgrade your overseer
and this will allow you to do the thing twice so if I go in here I can activate any two of these spots here and same here if I get all the way to here then I can do something on this side and even something in an unrelated side if it's the double uh if you if you've doubled the overseer you can do two on this side and one on this side just a little Special Rule and then once you get all the way back home you can activate any three citizens anywhere that you wish there so that's a good way to do the loop and so it's kind of an interesting little sort of Oddball Tech Tree here we can kind of go left or right on each of these things and you try to get them around and sort of bunch them up together so that you know when you get the middle part you're activating both sides it's a fun little puzzle there and finally what we're looking at our player board here I want to show you one other thing here so again you have these bonuses here and these are going to be asymmetrical so there's different ones for each of these so if you can have the number of buildings here that you've collected the number of boats you've collected a number of these markers that you've put out which I'll talk about in a minute and so you're going to have a number of those you're going to get take actions to raise your multiplier here let's see I had an example here here we go so anytime you take an action with the scroll here you can increase one of your multipliers on there and so this kind of gives you an end game strategy to go forward with this little widget here and then there's kind of one final action that you can do here on the main board let's take a look so once you have purchased actually
let's zoom up a little bit here let's go over here you can see those wagons there at the top okay so you can see they cost different amount of resources here like so and then so you can see this one has the cost of gold and then two wood and you get six points for that at the end of the game and these are stacked up in a certain order as well so on your turn instead of activating a spot and moving to that spot to use it for its ability in this case to move up that track what I can do is I can move there pay this cost in this case would be coin and I have to spend workers from either one of my work buildings or my city with the overseers and spend those two types of workers and then flip over kind of like tap my wagon which I can unflip at the end of the round to use again to put out one of my population markers and then I'll score eight points in that case and that's really all the game is is moving your workers around on this board up here and then you won't be repopulating really in the first probably three four rounds but definitely in the last two rounds you can start to repopulate there you want to have built gotten some wagons to do that because that's some big points you can see a lot of these are worth a lot of points there so let's walk through uh there's a player that players will get let's walk through kind of the end game scoring here and we'll walk this to save an idea of how to win now the one thing it shows here is rats which I didn't mention uh it doesn't happen too much I've seen it happen once in a while but as players learn the game it happens less and less if you go to a place with a plague Cube and you fight the plague there are there
any plague cubes left after you're done fighting you're gonna take a rat so for each rat that you have you're going to move back down the fire track on the main board You're Gonna Lose That many spots you're also going to lose a certain number of points based on the number of rats that you have so you can have one be okay and then you're going to get the points for uh how far along different tracks you are score your Scrolls which is your end game bonuses right which you see there and then score your points for your population for every three of these things in any combination you get a point and then whoever has the most population uh tokens on the board gets ten seconds seven third three and so on and that's it okay so that is Messina 1347 and we'll walk through my three pillars of review here we'll talk about uh player count I have played this at all player counts so plays one to four players not sure I mentioned that at the beginning I would say I don't really like solo it was all right it was a good way to kind of learn the game I had played it I think a three-player game the first time I played it and then I played it solo to kind of like you know teach myself a little bit more because the first time you play it at least for me it was a little bit overwhelming it's kind of abstract in terms of like you know what's a good idea to do which I'll talk about in a minute there's a lot of things going on you're trying to build buildings fight the plague recruit citizens use that funky overseer board and all that kind of stuff so it works pretty easy like you you know take a worker Pleasant thing do this stuff easy enough it's hard to figure out what to do and why to do it
um so this single player game was kind of a good way to learn that but not really that interesting it reminded me a lot of another Sushi design the praga where you kind of flip over these tiles and it kind of drives the AI um I liked Prague a little bit more honestly solo than this game but if the other player counts I really liked all the other player counts two three and four um it didn't feel too much different obviously there's a little bit more kind of blocking and stuff with the worker placement but I didn't you know I could play it either way two three or four is fine it didn't seem to take too much longer let's see what the actual time in the Box says 60 to 140. that seems about right because you can definitely play this as a two-player game in about an hour or even in a Solo game in about an hour once you get to four players because there's a lot going on there's a lot to consider um it's not too complex I don't think I think it's a little bit abstract but I don't think the complexity is there and so 100 is a little over two hours and I think that's a fair assessment uh I wasn't keeping the clock honestly um when I was playing it but last time I played it was four player actually and I think it probably took us not quite two hours but I think there was only two of us had played it a few times and two of us were new um but you know it's a group of folks that play lots of games so um it wasn't too bad that way uh yeah so that seems about about that right for the play time and um now as far as what is this game like I don't really know I mean
it does remind me of Prague a bit which is kind of like Vladimir Sushi's game from the year before and it's very abstract Prague is very abstract um this comes together theme wise more than Prague does for me I would say praga is probably I I don't want to because compared to Prague the whole time but praga's probably seems more of a clever design to me because it if you've not played praga I don't know how to say the rest of it I just called praga praga de Kappa regni or something like that I did a review for it it has this crazy wheel thing that's just super super neat it's just a really cool thing and you you know kind of March your workers down and then you go up this thing and you can kind of go up these Cathedral steps at the end and this is a really funky bizarre just real clever design it's fun pleasure to play but the theme like this this checks out you know like pretty quickly um and it's one that I've played recently and still enjoy I I do like this one better than praga it doesn't quite look as good I guess um but the theme of this really comes in and the reason it comes in is because of the Arc of the game for me because at the beginning of the game you're really kind of focused on fighting back the plague and kind of cobbling together your recruits and getting some buildings and kind of getting your economic engine started but kind of Midway through the game you start to Pivot from fighting back the plague to really focusing on your industry and then you start to switch to actually
repopulating the city and using some of those resources that you've gathered up to go and kind of send people back home send them back to work and all that kind of stuff and so I like that the Arc of that is you have the real kind of um focused approach to fighting the disease at the beginning and then kind of shifting gears and moving back into sort of uh we'll call it an everyday kind of normal life or there's a vibrant economy going on and the game really kind of sells that to me again through a lot of kind of very abstract things one thing that's interesting though about this is you have kind of the physical space of the city which is cool I like how the work replacement is is proximal you know you have to move adjacent to your spot and so there's some kind of spatial stuff there so that kind of just that little bit of spatial stuff kind of adds to a little bit of the theme there and then you have this real funky overseer board thing which is really kind of a fun puzzle to play with if it feels like a very kind of managerial logistical kind of vibe so you have that kind of part of it and you have kind of those kind of sort of the tug of war between kind of the different sort of classes of folks you know the different sort of roles that people play in the society so you've got the clergy the nuns and the Craftsmen the nobility and stuff like that and so you've got to kind of use them in different ways I will say the theme kind of breaks down a little bit because based on some of the bonuses and stuff it's like well I'm getting this bonus from a nun and not a Craftsman that's I mean if I want to nitpick and stuff I can do that it doesn't really
matter to me because you have really kind of a fine-tuned well-oiled machine in terms of the mechanics and the competitiveness side of it and the resource management and all that stuff so any kind of you know stumble slightly with the theme there is fine you know and there's no no reason to say that the church didn't help out with this other thing and then you know there's some cooperation there that's kind of hidden under those abstract layers I feel like I'm trying to make excuses here I'm not um but I say the general Arc of the game fight the plague start to Pivot start to repopulate that's really cool I really like that it's timely because we've just gone through this pandemic and stuff and it's cool I like that it's it's historical it gives me a good feeling you know because I don't know if this is intended or whatever it's just kind of a personal thought it's like hey we kind of been through that where we went through the pandemic we're you know for better worship or however we look at it we're trying to get our way out of it and then you know trying to get things back to normal where we can kind of exist um uh in a kind of a normal way a vibrant way right and so to see this kind of setting back here is historical it's 1347 so this is you know a thousand years ago not quite but you know several several hundred years ago and the folks here in Messina and lots of other places around the world through these periods of time have had to deal with just just Mother Nature coming and like swiping you across the face and and taking you out of your Rhythm you know and taking you out of your um your expectation of comfort and
survivability and all that kind of thing so I really like this for that I think it's that by itself even though it's it's abstract right we're not we're not really dealing with the daily lives and kind of the personal problems of the people during this kind of period right and some of that is probably more important you know the uh you know and I know I don't mean this to sound fuzzy or anything but it's like we're not dealing with the mental health of the people and sort of the emotional state and the well-being of people going through the black plague I mean which is horrendous um you know we're not dealing with it at that level and that's unless a lot of times how you have to deal with that level as a person but being able to step back away from it you know 700 years later um is interesting to kind of look at this and look at the kind of this the logistical part and it's not again it's not like concrete and we're not talking about the logistics of of the time and and all those kind of simulational types of aspects everything's abstracted everything's kind of removed a little bit you're only dealing with things like kind of a real fundamental philosophical level of kind of managing the space of the city managing sort of an abstract logistical board but for me I really like that and I really appreciated that and was it gave me a good feeling every time I played it because again you're successful at the end of it even even when the game sort of collectively as a group of players you've cleared the city out of the plague and then you've started to rebuild the economy and some people did better than others okay so I really like it for that and I found
honestly a little bit therapeutic um for that that was cool and sometimes I think abstraction is good because I don't have to get in I don't have to get in the muck in the mire I don't have to be faced with the actual reality of the thing I needed time to step back but I'm still kind of dealing with it I'm still kind of dealing with just things that that real sort of synaptical level of putting together this puzzle and trying to solve it and get through it and it's fun and it's competitive and you know we've had a good time playing it and uh and now it kind of pushes and pulls on all this kind of euro-y kind of mechanical buttons at the same time so that's a really good kind of bonus feature there so Messina 1347 really enjoyed it definitely recommend it uh it's one of my favorite Sushi designs you know I still have underwater cities that's the one that I keep going back to I've been playing it a lot especially during this pandemic the solo mode for that is really good um this one I'd put right up there I always call I think underwater is my favorite than last will this would probably be like a number three right there I haven't played last one in a while I really like last will um the one I haven't played there's one I haven't played here because the Pulsar or something or other I still haven't played that one I played just about all his other ones though so this would definitely be in the top three but I haven't played Pulsar everybody's like that's his best one okay well anyway this is good thanks foreign