Tricky Twist Review: Twisted Trickster
Transcript
Mike, a few years ago, you and I reviewed a set of of games from designer Taylor Reiner,
who you called Taylor Rener at the time.
I did. I did. I think it was because I was just so hesitant to give anybody else the name Reiner.
I think that's
that I had [clears throat] a mental block. He's a lovely human, though. And if anyone deserves that name Reiner, it would be Taylor.
It would be Taylor. He designed a little game called Short Zoot Suit, which has now been picked up for wider distribution from Sitdown Games, uh, beefed up in its production, and now it's called Tricky Twist. So, this is a trick-taking game, uh, with a few little wrinkles here. I'm going to go ahead and explain what those are, and then we'll be back to give you our thoughts on it. Here's Tricky Twist set up on the table for, in this case, three players. This hand of cards will be kept secret from all other players, but I have it face up just for display purposes here, uh, for the overview. There's also a bonus scoring goal card that'll be available each round and you're going to play three or four rounds depending on whether you're playing three or four players. And there's different bonuses you can chase after each round. And then these bonus cards which are up for grabs uh that players can earn throughout the course of the game. Now, the idea of this is a mustfollow trick-taking game.
And if you're not sure what that means, I'll explain it here. But uh at the start of the game, each player's dealt out an equal number of cards uh dealing out the whole deck. and they're going to choose five cards to remove from their hand and shuffle into a separate draw deck that they can personally draw from if they want to. So before any player leads by playing a card into the trick, all players have the option to draw a card or not to. The round will end as soon as a player is uh has no cards left to play. Uh, and that will be because some players might be trying to draw up new cards to kind of keep the round going or give themselves more choice of cards to play. So, I am going to lead here with the white 12. The cards rank from 1 through 12 of each of these four suits here. And so, every other player must follow with a white card if they have one. So, this player here is going to throw out the uh two. And I'm going to leave these cards face up just for demonstration purposes. And this person's going to throw out the one.
So, at this point, I would collect these cards into a trick. And to mark that I have won a trick by playing the highest number of the lead suit, I'm going to place this face down into a scoring area. And I'm going to offset tricks that I win in some way to be able to keep count of them, whether side by side or something to this effect here. So, I have won one trick, and I get to lead again because I was the winner of it. Now, a wrinkle of this game is that if I were to play this card here, the 12 blue, and once again, I'm not actually seeing other players hands. I'm just doing it for the overview. This person throws out uh this blue card here. And this player over here has no blue card. Maybe they had some in their opening hand and they put them all into the little five card draw deck. So, they would be short on a suit or not. But either way, this person has no blue.
They are shortsuited. So they can play any card that they want from here. That card will never win the trick because it is not of the lead color. So the player who played the highest number of the lead color will collect the cards as before and lay this out in front of them to show that they have won another trick. And the player who played the offsuit card, non-matching card, is going to keep this in front of themselves as what's called a false trick. They're going to be collecting these face up and any tricks that they win will be collected face down. The goal of the game is to try to match up an equal number of regular tricks one and false tricks that are won. And I'll talk about that at scoring. The other wrinkle is that these sevens have a little lightning bolt on them. So, if the if they are one as part of a normal trick or if they are one as a false trick, whoever wins the seven gets to grab one of these bonus cards, which count as a false trick of a the player's choice of color, or it can count as a an instant ability or end of round scoring, one point per regular trick they've won, some other sort of instant bonus they grab right away. Players are going to continue playing. And let me simulate an end of the round so you can see how scoring works. Let's say we reach the stage of the game. This player has two cards. This player has two cards. And this player has no cards in hand, but all five of the cards in their draw deck. Before the start of a trick, every player, as always, may draw a card into their hand. Or this player may choose not to. And if they choose not to, then
the round will not continue. The hand of of trick taking ends immediately, and all these cards will not be played. We move now to scoring. How scoring works is that every regular trick that a player has collected, these face down ones will be worth one point each. So five, three, three points in this example here. And every false trick or these face up cards that they've collected by playing off suit or by collecting bonuses is going to be worth either three or five points per matching pair. Uh so in this case, this player has four false tricks and five regular tricks. because they do not match. These pairs are going to be worth three points each. So, the player will get 12 points in addition to their five. This player over here has an exact matching number of pairs of false and regular tricks.
So, these will be worth five points a piece. So, these are these false tricks are 15 points in addition to their three. This player over here has more false tricks than regular tricks. So, only three of them will pair off at three points a piece. This player over here also grabbed this bonus scoring which says they get one point per every regular trick that they've scored. So they'll get another bonus five points. And then all players will evaluate this scoring card here in the middle of the table. You look at the suit of which you have the most false tricks and based on the number that you have, you'll earn a number of points. In this case over here, three false tricks of the same color get three points. This player gets one point and this player over here with five uh of the same color in their false tricks will get 10 points. So that'll be one round. You'll change out the scoring objective. Everyone will return these bonus cards, shuffle up and deal again.
And you play rounds equal to the number of players. And whoever has the most points at the end of those rounds is the winner of tricky twist. Reiner like the designer. Riner like the designer
locked in there.
Yeah, I got it now. I got it now.
So, um I don't want to compare too much because that first that short zoot suit uh original printing of it was pretty hard to find. Yes. Right. And I'm so I'm excited that the same gameplay is pretty much in in this package more widely available. Uh but there I I do want to talk about a few things with the production here. Okay. In general, right?
Sure.
What do you think of the production? It's a mixed bag, honestly. Uh, I think it's a mixed bag. I think it's a they they were going for a very particular aesthetic. I think it's kind of like a almost I don't know. I The word art deco comes to mind, but it's not really that. It's just kind of the stylized New York in the some era. It's just Yeah. It's I don't know. It's the the it's it's got what's going for a I think a classy and elegant appearance.
Yeah. And I think that that is interesting. I don't know how I feel about the card sizes itself. Uh I don't know how I feel about the actual usability and the iconography.
Those are some issues I have.
Uh yes, when when I set those bonus cards on the side, and you saw them in the overview,
it's just it's kind of an overwhelming amount of symbology, I think.
Uh how the bonus scoring cards work. Sometimes I get confused which one means collect a lot of the same symbol which means collect different symbols. Those types of things, right?
The card quality is phenomenal. It's great. Yeah, they're very thick, kind of slabby type of cards. Not everyone likes them when they're that thick, but I these will hold up to a good amount of play. Um, and I like the look.
At first I look at them, I go, "Oo, this is kind of hard to read." And I realize, no, they're actually very easy to read. They're just very decorative and kind of busy. So, it's a mixed bag because I don't love the I think they're tarot size cards. Uh or some somewhere kind of in
some variation of Yeah, I don't think they're strictly tarot, but yeah. Yeah, they're a unique size. I'll put it to you that way.
Uh card sleevers will be driven nuts. I think they're very good quality. They'll probably hold up to a lot of play without card sleeves.
I agree.
Uh so, mixed bag on the production side of things. is the the iconography is a little bit confusing having to look up things multiple times until you kind of get it down.
Right.
Core gameplay is the same as it was before, right? This there's there's I think two kind of main hooks to the game. Y
you have your personal draw deck that you make. So you get to vacate suit vacate cards from your hand. Uh, and then there's this idea of wanting to play off suit, collecting tricks and then collecting face up cards or false tricks as they're called here.
Um, let's talk about those two those two gimmicks that kind of make this game what it is. What, you know, do you enjoy them? Uh, how difficult are they? Are they great?
I think they're both really nice twists. Um, you know, the and I they I think they work well together
because as you mentioned, you know, you're going to get a hand of 12 cards at the beginning. Five of those cards you're going to be taking and removing from your initial hand, putting them into a draw deck. You'll shuffle them up. So, you won't know exactly what's coming out when, but you know exactly what's in that pile. Or if you're like me, you know about 40% of what's in that pile because you forget immediately as soon as you put it down and shuffle it. But generally speaking, if you have a decent memory, you know what's in there. Um, and so as you said, being able to to short suit yourself or get yourself very close to short suiting fits in exactly with the other hook of trying to win an exact amount of actual one tricks with lost tricks off suit. Um, they they're both unique. They work well in conjunction. And um I think this is not necessarily something that would be intuitive for new trick- taking players, but I don't think you need to be an expert tricktaking player either.
You know what I mean? It's kind of intermediate.
If you played hearts or spades even, I think that you could jump to this, right?
Sure.
Um it
Yeah, I like the two little wrinkles together. I think that they're very fun. I love when you can end a round and you have, you know, four tricks face down, four cards face up. That feels so good. Yeah.
The new thing in this particular printing are the seven cards. Seven cards is a little lightning bolt symbol. That's when you grab the bonus cards.
I for most people they're not going to know that that's not how the game originally was,
right?
For me, that feels like a a small little bit of overdevelopment. Um where the bonus cards are kind of nice. They're little bonuses that you know, once again, you have to explain what the icons mean multiple times before people kind of lock it down. They're useful. They're good abilities. They're good little powers and stuff, but it does feel for me just like a little bit more than maybe the game needed, but also I know that I'm biased because I played it before without those.
And I agree with you again having the knowledge of what it was before. I I I also feel like it's a bit of a step back now. And I and I think I understand why it was included in a in one that's intended for wider audiences in that I think the original game was less forgiving.
I think that what this does is it makes the game
it gives you more mitigation. It gives you more of a chance to bail yourself out of a hand that did not go the way you expected it to. It gives you some options to say, "Okay, well at least I can lose with a seven and I can fix some of what I've messed up over here." So it makes the game a little bit more approachable in a way. Um it makes it more forgiving, more mitigation, but that's at the expense in my opinion of as you said maybe a little well a little bit more you need to get on the front end. You need to understand how all those works. It definitely leads to a longer teach um and a little bit more complexity.
Yeah, it kind of reminds So uh another one of this designer game, Taylor Riner's games was picked up by by Bezier, right? uh of what's left became
Sears Catalog.
Sears Catalog. Thank you. And I felt like that game was a little bit overdeveloped from what it was into something that Yeah. It's more zany. It has a little bit more uh wider appeal, I think. Yeah.
So, I can understand kind of like you're saying, I think that what they did here is in a lot of ways positive. Once you get past that initial rules teach,
people do like what those little bonus cards offer on the side.
Yeah. Yeah.
I think they're an overall good addition to the game. I might have I I might when I I teach this to people house rule it where I I don't explain the sevens I leave the bonuses to the side for one hand right so that people get used to the fun flow of the game and then I say hey here's some bonuses right you want to earn extra points from winning tricks there's a bonus card for that you want a little more flexibility on getting a you know yellow or a blue face up card that's what these are for uh I think that that would make the onboarding a little bit easier for a game that is I think overall fairly elegant and brilliant with what a few little twists can do for a genre that feels, you know, very familiar game to game.
Yeah, that's actually a great suggestion. I hadn't really considered that, but I think yeah, if you're teaching the game and because, you know, a round is quick in the game and especially if you don't include those uh bonus cards, it goes even more quickly. And so, yeah, I think that would be a good way to just kind of, hey, here's the two little twists that you uh may, you know, from from games you might have played before. Once you understand that, okay, now this is what these sevens do and that's what these cards are about. That's probably the best way to go about it, unless you're teaching to just, you know, a bunch of, uh, diehard tricktaker nerds, uh, like me. Um, for example.
Yeah, for example. So, um, yeah, I think that would help. That would help.
So, I think overall, uh, I like what they did with this one. I'm glad that this is a game that, uh, that is more widely distributed.
How would you come down score-wise on this one? So, I agree with you that this was a really really good game uh that deserved a wider audience and I'm thrilled that it's getting it, you know, uh sit down as a wellestablished publisher. They, you know, they they know what they're doing and they'll get it into a wider distribution. And so, for that, I'm happy. I think it is a slight step back from from the original. Um could you play the original way? Absolutely. Just ignore the lightning bolts on the seven and don't use the power cards. But I think a lot of people will like that because it gives it is more forgiving. It is definitely a more forgiving game with those. Um, so I'm coming in at an eight. Um, really honestly I rated the original 8.5 and so I am backing it back a little bit because I do think it's a slight step backward with I feel a little bit of over uh development, but that's a taste thing. I think the game is great and I think that if you like trick- taking games, you absolutely should try it.
Yeah. Uh, for me, I'm I'm still giving this one an 8.5. For as much as sometimes I think there's a step back with one, particularly like the the iconography, there's also a step forward, right? And making this a little bit more approachable for people, I don't think that's a a bad thing necessarily. Uh, and so, and if you really are a diehard and you say, I want to play by the original rules,
you can find short zutsu rules online.
Basically, you take out the seven powers. That's it.
Uh, I still like the game a lot. And what I will say is that playing this with different groups of people, they caught on to that those sevens and those powers quicker than I was expecting. So I realize I think that what they did with this is still is still good. I like this one a lot. I think it's a tremendously good trick taking game that feels different because it's letting you make these fun decisions. Gives you fun moments where you you say, "Oh, you led white
blue seven. Looks like I'm collecting this for myself." You know, good really good clean stuff. So, that's Tricky Twist. A high score of an 8.5. Give this one a seal of excellence from us here. So, there you go. Thanks for coming out to this review. My name is Chris Ye.
I'm Mike Delisio.
And uh may all of your tricks be twisty.
May all of your May all of your twists be tricky.
Twist be tricky.
May all of your your cookies be crisp.
May all of your cookies be crisp.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, do you want to learn more about us? Communicate with us. We have a Facebook group. We have a Discord channel. Lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that. It will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel.