Yokohama Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at yokohama which is a two to four player board game designed by hizashi hayashi this one takes around 90 minutes to play i would call this a medium weight euro strategy game that looks like this when it's on the table so this is quite a sprawling table hog style of game we have multiple different boards here such as these area majority star boards you've got um this this board here where you can draft technology from you've got contract balls down here where you could take new objectives to try and fulfill you've got the big scoreboard here and these public objectives that you can work towards and you also have the main part of the game made up of these action boards which are going to vary from time to time because you can see they are all modular so the layout is going to change and this is going to be how you're going to gather resources and trade resources in to get different rewards and each player is also going to have their own personal player board which is kind of their warehouse where they can store all their different upgrades and things that they can purchase throughout the game to increase the influence on the main action boards there's also a couple of decks of cards here for these technologies and contracts and a bunch of different resources such as these fish the rope the metal the coins and much more so let's talk about how you win a game of yokohama so as you'd probably expect with most euro games you're trying to get as many victory points as you can in this game and the end game is going to be triggered through a number of different means um the first of which is a number of spots being taken up on the church management board one of which is the same but on the customs management board if there's not enough cars to replenish
the order board here or until a player has placed all of their shops or trade houses onto the board so how does yokohama work so you can actually see on your individual player boards here how the game is broken down into three phases two of which are exactly the same and you've got the main action phase in between that so the additional action phases let you do little things such as complete contracts that you've completed like this one here which means if i had four fish and metal i could trade those in to get eight points you could also try claim these public objectives the sooner the better because you're going to get more points such as having a certain number of resources or technology or even getting onto certain or presence on these certain boards here like with these hammers on like the silk mill here but the main action phase is where most of the gameplay is going to take place and the first thing you're going to do in that main action phase is the placement phase and that is where you're going to take a number of cubes from your personal supply bearing in mind you cannot have access to your warehouse until you actually spend time or money to unlock them so you're going to either take two or three of these cubes and then you're going to scatter them out on the board as you want with the idea of which actions you want to actually take so let's just say one option would be to place three cubes on the board like so in different regions or if i wanted to let's say i didn't make that move i could place two cubes onto a single location let's just say i did this like so now if i ever put one of these cubes on a location where a an opponent's pawn is like this then i
have to spend one yen in order to do so so it's going to be quite costly if we want to put those cubes on a spot with other players on now the second thing you do is the movement phase which is where you move to which action you want to take but you can ever only ever move through regions where you have presence on ie these cubes so i can go as far as i want to any region that doesn't have that i have a cube on so let's say i go to this fishing ground here now once i've done that i'm going to take the action on that board depending on the strength i have there so each of my player pieces is going to count towards one strength so one h for each of these cubes and then i've got my pawn itself which is going to be another strength now you can also potentially get further strength by placing these houses all those big trade um trade shops on there as well um to again to get further further presence on that board but let's say i took the three here i'm gonna have a look at the strength three so this one here i'm going to get three fish into my personal supply now if i ever get up to four or five i'm gonna have the option to construct a building um so either the shops or the um all the trade houses like such and i'm going to put them onto one of these available spots here bearing in mind this spot can only ever store these trade houses so let's just say i took this one here and i wanted to cover up this spot here i'll take the reward beneath it i.e two of those leafs into my personal supply and i can only ever do that once per location so now i've got a shop on this location i
cannot build another one but it does mean that in the future i'm always going to have at least one presence there in terms of the strength value now if i ever got to strength five and i'm the first player to do that i can take this token as well which will give me a little one-off bonus such as getting bonus resources and things and once you've resolved the action potentially built on there you're going to take those cues back into your personal supply and start again from scratch basically you know starting off from where you've just left so let's take a look at what all the different boards do so we've already spoken about the fish one the copper one works pretty much the same way except you need to have at least strength three before you start gaining the metal so the metal is quite a rare resource to get hold of you've got the silk mill here which works just the same but with the rope also with the uh with the silk resource you've got the lavatory which lets you take these technology cards so depending on the strength there you're going to get a certain amount of points to spend on technology class you can boost that by spending additional resources which will let you go to this board here again spending the cost and potentially giving you ongoing bonuses such as like this mining technology here which will say whenever i gain a copper i can gain the next one or once per turn i could trade in the silk for two coins or like the um the stock market here where if i ever have less than two yen in my hand i can increase it to two yen so these are all quite nice bonuses to have additionally all these cards have a different nation tied to them like this where if you ever have a pair you could end up getting more kind of end game victory points the ports down here means that you can take new contracts to work towards so that if you need to have at
least a strength two to start taking them but once you do you can start taking them from this board here you know starting from the low the medium or even the high contracts and then you're going to start trying to work towards those go by trading in those resources getting virtual points and potentially getting these imports as well which correlates to another board here this cost customs board where you can trade in a number of those import crates and depending on how many you do you're going to put one of your influence markers on the customs management board up here getting the reward i.e points or other different bonuses and also the most coverage at the end of the game is going to get further victory points based on majorities and we've got the we've got the employment agency here which lets you take things off your warehouse so again let's say i had a strength three on there i could take two things from my warehouse and put it into my personal supply so maybe i'd spend two money to get a new house or a new shop or spend four and get one of these um trade houses down or even take a number of my cubes just to give me more flexibility and that is free to do so now you you've got the tea plantation which is simply take that tea resource you've got the bank which lets you take money and finally you've got the church which lets you get these faith points equal to how many well how many strengths you've got plus trading and other resources to boost that in order to try and claim one of these spots here by let's say i raised six faith points i can put my cube on there which will get me the bonus and additional points and again further area majority bonuses at
the end of the game and that is essentially how the game plays out you're going to keep gathering resources you're buying technologies um fulfilling contracts placing placing down shops and trade houses on these spots here to get points and of course working towards the public objectives the faith points here and of course the um the trade goods as well and again at the end of the game and once it's triggered you're going to calculate all your points and the player with the most victory points is going to be the winner okay so let's start off from a mechanical standpoint so very often you'll hear this game compared to another game called istanbul in fact it's very hard to discuss one game without mentioning the other and you know after playing yokohama i can clearly see why that comparison has made i think it's a very just comparison and there's a lot of similarities between the two so this one much like istanbul you are root building and then trying to kind of move your main piece around i suppose in order to get those resources trade them in for victory reports and things and it's almost like this race as well to claim the best spots to get your shops down and also of course to get your warehouses down because there's only one opportunity to get that big chunky amount of points but at the same time you almost want to do everything at once because yes you want to get onto that faith track yeah you want to get the impulse down because you've got the best returns um you want to get your power influence down quicker because then you can get you can be the best spots here and stuff and you can mean that you've got a bit of a presence there even though you're not relying on the cubes themselves so i do really like the way that works you're kind of constantly manipulating things around the board creating new pathways and things determining which route you're going to go next and i like the way that works so
again very smooth approach there and you know from a somewhat formulaic um system they actually do resolve pretty quickly because you know before you even um if you don't reach four or five construction points then you know you can pretty much disregard half of these anyway so you're just going to move there take the action which is very snappy and then take all your cubes off and pretty much start again so it does have a nice dynamic flow to things and you do have to bear in mind where your opponent is on the different tiles as well because you might have to kind of create a route around them because you don't want to be giving up that extra coin or two and when you can avoid doing so i do really enjoy this efficiency puzzle of how to use and manage these cubes because you do have quite a limited capacity of them yes you can unlock more which is another really interesting part of the game but that idea of building up these routes and leaving things just stacked in there so that when the time comes you can go back there and you can plan accordingly bearing in mind that your opponent might be in the way and you might have to kind of zigzag when you need to get to stop you spending that extra coin or two and of course you can't even share a spot with your president anyway so again people are going to be somewhat in your way whether they mean to or not so i do like the way that you can prioritize things and map things out and you know plan ahead of time and i do tend to enjoy games where you have the at least the option to do that and yoga hammond certainly does you know you can very carefully think that i'm going to go here and get this resource and by then i'll get my maybe my contract cashed in that'll get me import good i've already got some cubes ready on the import stand and then i can get down there i've already got some cubes there and if you've got building there so get a stronger action as well to get the better spots so again you've got
that constant synergy of the way all these dog boards work together and the different routes you're going to build and plan so yeah it has a nice thread of strategy there as well as the tactical kind of scope in order to move things as people get in your way another part of the game i really enjoyed was the technology cards i really enjoy it when games manage and utilize kind of upgrade cards and special powers to their maximum benefit without being broken and this game manages to do that you know all the different powers are interesting there's a whole stack of them and they're all worth having so i like the way that works and again it feels like you know if somebody has a card that you really want you're like i wish i had that card i wish i got there sooner but again if you're focusing on doing that then you're probably neglecting something else so it does have that constant tension of wanting to do everything at once which those games tend to keep me excited and to keep me engaged the resource management itself is also a strong part of the game because it's it's nice that when you can go to a region and you've already had invested in it somewhat already then you can get a whole chunk of resources at once it doesn't feel like you need to keep kind of monotonously going back to the same spot to kind of top up on your tea for example if you go if you have a strength five there you're gonna get a massive five strength all at once and something i didn't mention as well is that when you do build these um trade houses on these spots and another player goes there and uses that building then you actually get a coin from the bank so you've got that kind of steady income and that gentle engine of making sure you've got enough money in your kitty to keep you going forward in the game i did mention at the start of the video that the game takes around 19 minutes to play on average and i would say that's
probably right for your first game or two but i do think that if you've got a bunch of players who are very familiar with this game it actually does work at an incredibly quick pace and you can probably get it done in 60 to 75 minutes at that two or three player account if you really want to so it's definitely one that doesn't push the wrong side of 90 minutes it definitely stays nice and tight within that 90 minute timeframe which is again it's normally the sweet spot for me and additionally the turns are quick so there's not too much skate for analysis paralysis you're pretty much just going spot to spot getting a whole bunch of resources and you know what you're going to work towards so it's not incredibly brain burnery but it still does have enough to think about to keep it interesting the replayability for yokohama is also strong because all these different cars that go on these action boards are modular so the incentives and the bonuses are going to change from game to game there's also a ton of these technology cards so they do feel different as well and of course you're going to see different contracts and things pop up but i suppose they're not going to change the feel of the game tremendously now i did mention that all these boards are modular and yes that is the case that is gonna slightly kind of change the routes and things you build but something i would say this game does lack in comparison in comparison to something like istanbul is how different the game feels from game to game depending on the layout of the board like for istanbul i think that you can get drastically different feeling games depending on that layout you know where certain buildings are close to others this one i don't feel like it affects the game massively if i'm honest now i do think the game scales quite well too because the more players means you're going to have more action balls to play with and sometimes they're duplicates and things um whereas you
know the fewer players is going to get tighter and tighter meaning that you still have a layer of interaction where you're going to stand on each other's toes and things and um of course different action boards and things are used where certain sports are blocked off depending on the player account to keep things nice and tight the version of the game you see here is just the standard retail version of the game i know there was a deluxe version which i've not personally seen or played with so i can only talk about the components relation to this one i think all the components are generally fine you know the action boards are very good quality iconography is generally very good i didn't really have to refer to the rule book at all um even all the technology cards are very clearly kind of written out what they do and how they work so again no confusion there with how they worked i think once you've got the rules in your head in this game there's not really much scope to losing those rules because there's no fiddliness there's not very much exceptions and things um i suppose my only disappointment with this version is the actual buildings themselves like you've got the shops and the trade houses here they are just really thin bits of cardboard and they're small and i don't think they have much of a presence when they actually claimed on these certain action boards so it feels like they could have been better maybe even like you know like 3d pieces little wooden pieces or something but that's probably why they wanted you to go for the deluxe version but despite that i think the game is well produced and it's um you know it looks good despite having such a table hog so you probably will need a big table to play this one okay so let's get into my final thoughts on yokohama so straight up this game is excellent it's so well designed there's a lot to be enjoyed here if you like this style of game now something that i can't ignore and i need to kind of stress is how close it is and how
similar it is to istanbul so istanbul has been one of my favorite games this has had a very strong position in my top 50 for probably four or five years if not longer i adore that game and this game i think the base game to istanbul and yokohama are comparable i think i like them equally and i'd have a tough time choosing between the two now if you started adding in expansion material to istanbul i think istanbul slightly gets the edge on this one and i'd probably choose to play that one nine times out of ten over yokohama which is kind of my passing judgment on this game man you know i'm as i'm playing more and more games i'm looking for more and more reasons not to keep them because against storage being a being a factor and i can't keep every single game i play so i think that's probably going to be the reason why i don't keep hold of yokohama now i also want to be fair and judge this game in its own right and its own merits and i think the game is fantastic even if i played this game um before istanbul i might even say like i'll keep this one over istanbul because it's what i'm more familiar with it's um more kind of sentimental to me and i have more of an attachment with it but because i can't get that nagging thing on my head that i'd probably always rather play island ball it's going to be a reason why this one isn't going to stick around but that being said this is still a strong recommendation it does everything exceptionally well um so much things that synergize with each other and you want to get everything done and there's a real tension to get things done before the game ends because it does end quite abruptly and it's a nice rapid game i love the the warehouse mechanism here where you have to bring things from your kind of storage into your personal supplies ready to spend it and use it um
the actual investment in the boards is great as you get stronger and stronger actions as the game goes on and building that thread of that sort of strategy to decide which boards you're going to go to next and build those pathways and things there's really nothing here i can complain about again the only reason why it's not going to stick around is because i have a game that is so similar to it in my collection and i like that game slightly more but still a fantastic game well it definitely is well deserved of a shield of quality and i can see why this one is so respected i think this one is just outside the book you know the bgg top 100 rankings which goes to show that a lot of people like this game and i think that is very just so that is my final thoughts on yokohama enjoyed it really enjoyed it in fact but sadly it's been trumped by istanbul