Skip to main content
Loading video...

Root & The Riverfolk Expansion Review

Transcript 11:43

medieval force critter adventures or shall we say pot and claw fantasy is my jam like many I started with red wall but from there like sweet oatcakes and strawberry cordial I hungrily gobbled up every single story I could find from secret and NIM to Disney's Robin Hood to mouse guard MYSA mystics and moss I loved it all and now between the artwork asymmetry and setting I have never wanted to like a game more than root root is a hyper asymmetric area control game where each player's faction is vying for control of survival in these woods while every player's objective is to get to 30 points and there are some general rules that all factions obey in regard to movement and combat how each faction gets those points and even conducts their turn is wildly different the most straightforward of the factions is the dominant standing army of marquis de cat who is rapidly gaining points by building these structures throughout the forest furthermore she has by far the most units available and starts in all but one clearing on the board now she will protect her footholds fiercely but spread thin and only being able to take three actions per turn she's going to have the most to lose as the game goes on the Eyrie is an ancient avian Kingdom fearsome proud starting the game relegated to a corner but aggressively expanding outward though their pride makes them rigid in each turn you add to

their decree which dictates on mandatory actions per turn fail to perform any of those actions and your governance collapses losing points and starting again with a new leader and a fresh decree no the woodland Alliance is probably my favorite faction from the base game I think it's totally emblematic of roots particular flavor of mechanical and thematic integration see with no pieces actually starting on the board they use their supporters came from a variety of means in order to put out these sympathy tokens which create little woodland revolutions exploding the spot destroying enemy pieces putting out base tokens which then create soldiers on the board and officers that go on your tableau which dictate how many military actions that you can take per turn but as with everything in route you must strike a balance because the officers come from the same pool as your soldiers and you may find that yeah actions are great but you may not have enough soldiers on the board to do anything with lest is the Vagabond who is unique among the remaining factions the Vagabond is the hero or scoundrel or roaming wanderer taking a different role card per game they are one single unit who can occupy both clearings and neighboring forests accruing equipment which are used to perform various actions in complete quests throughout the game the Vagabond earns points by completing those quests assisting other factions even fighting alongside their warriors or better yet betraying them in making them hostile earning points for each poor hostile

critter they slay so as you can tell this is an incredibly thematic game one that was meticulously crafted to marry the mechanical functions of each of these different factions to match their seat of power in the story the world feels like it predates the individual session where the invading army of the Marquise drove back the Eyrie where the duplicitous vagabond is playing both sides and the woodland alliances meeting in secret tunnels plotting their eventual uprising and it's one thing to be a really the mattock game but it's another to be a totally solid mechanical game so let's talk about the meat and potatoes of route a players turn is broken up to three phases birdsong daylight and evening aside from factions specific abilities players can generally move units engage in combat put out tokens and craft cards one thing I really love about route is that the faction boards clearly spell out the order of operations what actions can be done when so once you get through your first turn or two it becomes really easy to make sure you don't miss a beat combat is refreshingly simple where the attacker rolls too unceremoniously white 12 sided dice with even distributions of zero one two and three and each number is representative of amount of hits that are done to the opposing army the defender gets the lesser of the two rolls unless it's the woodland Alliance who are dopes guerrilla fighters and they get the higher of the roles even while defending your hits are capped by

a number of units in your army or in the case of vagabond undamaged swords in their inventory speaking of which instead of losing units in battle they must damage items that need to be repaired similar to combat other standard actions like moving or crafting cards for one time and ongoing bonuses feel straightforward functional and immediately familiar okay so the thing with this game that everyone's going to be talking about is the asymmetry which is understandable but I really want to emphasize that once you get beyond the initial density of learning your faction there's a really tight easy to follow area control game that with some smart efficiencies in abstractions like the attacker rolling both attack dice and damage happening just like that the take that elements of the game feel more manageable than mean but of course what makes this game shine is that asymmetry the weirdness of it all in the four factions in the base game all have wildly different orders of operation different limitations on actions different strategies that develop curves ways of interacting with the board and seeing how all those systems overlap is some of the most fun I've had in gaming in recent memory but that really gets to what makes this game fun and maybe what doesn't Roots it's in a weird place it is more complex to learn than your typical area control game but it is not a complex strategy game by any means don't get me wrong root is a blast and better players will win but it's more like a wind-up toy

witnessing how different players what different factions are going to end up overlapping but the number of possible strategies that each faction has against the other is kind of limited yes you will be making choices and yes those choices will have meaning but in general the arc of each faction will begin feeling pretty familiar as you become more acquainted with the game now if you really want to get buck wild in the forests of root then I am a big fan of the river folk expansion it adds four things first off it adds the mechanical cats which allow you to play solo player or fill out a game with only two to three players it adds everything needed for another vagabond player so you can have to trash pandas running around the board with our freaky little raccoon hands it adds some card holders which are nice and structurally sound but don't really affect much and then most notably it adds to new factions the lizard folk and the otters who take the cake for most adorable meeples in anything ever the new factions both showcase the ambitious asymmetry of the game while still feeling at home in the basic structure though the general consensus is that the lizards who build intricate in specific garden tokens to gain points and get stronger by playing repeated cards of certain suits are weak compared to other factions which doesn't matter much because they're still really fun to play saddle these guys with the most experienced player looking for a challenge or useless designers proposed tournament rules found on vgg which balance these lizard boys a bit more

otters are arms dealers like Nicholas Cage and Laura de Boer which the lone conjures great imagery but their cards boats and even units can be bought and use fighting for top dollar on the board these water dogs really change up the game and present a lot of interesting options to everyone at the table combine it with the extra vagabond and you have so much more faction possibilities to play with then there is the mechanical Marquis who is an automated player that makes two and three player games whether on the regular side or snowy side of the board much more viable the great thing is is that it's fairly easy to manage and creates a density on the board that gives enough of an obstacle to keep factions in check but the downside is is that they are relatively unpredictable because their actions are dictated by card draw where they attack where they move and the number of units they can recruit which can range from a couple to a veritable army populating all over the board this isn't going to be so much of a problem in a multiplayer game because everybody is going to be beating on the Marquise but in a solo game it can be downright brutal don't get me wrong solo mode can be fun but it's more like a practice mode at training grounds if you will a way to figure out an experiment with your faction more than it is a satisfying distillation of the game also I wish that you didn't have to fully remove all the components from one of the factions in order to make these mechanical me hours work I mean some of us want to play one two and three player

games as the cats with a mechanical opponent to beat upon it just seems like in an otherwise really elegant and clever game this is a clunky call be a functional solution overall I adore root yes my affinity for this type of setting drew me in but the fairly well balanced extremely asymmetric gameplay mixed with incredibly imaginative and well-crafted presentation kept me coming back I've been burning nights away with solo play organizing big games and facing off with my wife one on one while it may get a little unstable as you change up parameters with factions and player accounts the variety of overlapping systems is a huge part of the charm and it always comes back to the relatively narrow and strategic bones underneath a big stompy war game with tons of strategic options this is not but it is a fantastic platform for experimentation thematic immersion meaningful choices and playful competition my biggest criticisms are that I wish the automated player were better than being merely serviceable and as a consequence of the extreme asymmetry the game often relies on the players to keep a not always obvious runaway leader in check I also wish there were one or two more static systems that weren't dependent on the factions giving more dynamic options as the game unfolds last thing I want to mention is that there is a fantastic tutorial system that handholds your first couple of turns in this game while my group was a little bit anxious about having to learn something that had so much information by the end of those first couple of turns and certainly by

the end of the first game we felt like we had a fold confident understanding of the basic rules and structure of the game as well as a working understanding of all the different factions even the ones that we didn't play this is not a perfect game it could be janky unpredictable and requires a certain dedication to even learn the game but through the designer skilful pairings of mechanics and theme and the incredible visuals and presentation of the masterful Kyle Ferren route and its inhabitants come to life in a game that is inviting imaginative resonant and fun even in spite of a board that took two days under 16 pounds to finally lay flat Ruth is without a doubt one of my favorite games of the year thanks for watching I've been jack for the cardboard Herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via brighting podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Herald calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Herald

Progress saved