Codenames: Critical Role Adventures Review: I'd Like a Word With You
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.
I'm Wendy Yee.
And I'm Chris Yee.
Today we're taking a look at the newest addition to the Codenames series of which I believe there are six now, but I just made that number up. Um this is Codenames Critical Role Adventures, which also is based on the very popular Critical Role uh YouTube show of Dungeons and Dragons and
lots of role playing game systems.
Yeah, probably the most famous of these shows. Obviously, they've been in other games even. Um but this one here, I got to be honest before we start, I have not I know who the show is, I know who the the Dungeon Master is, uh Matt Matt Mercer, and I know a little bit about it, but I've not watched it.
I don't know the characters. Yeah, they're like, "Oh yeah, this is Vox or Nix." And I'm like, "Oh, okay." Oh, look, it's like a little goblin creature. That one has a gun. He's got a gun.
Yeah, I know pretty much nothing about
But I don't think you need to know that information to play the game. Well, I know you don't need to cuz I didn't know it and I played it. So, don't worry about that. So, let's take a look at how the game plays.
When you're playing this game, you're playing through a short campaign and you're going to pick three characters. Doesn't matter how many players are playing the game. You'll three characters. And so, the game comes with six characters and you can choose any of these characters that you want. These special abilities that the characters have will be folded underneath at the beginning of the game. You rip them apart so you can unfold them as time goes by. And as they gain experience over the course of the game, they will get more abilities. They also have a role. This is their modifier for skill checks and a certain amount of hit points with extra abilities. So, for example, this is minus four, but it's plus two for each health that he has. So, at the beginning of the game, it's actually a plus two. But, it could get up to two plus six. This could be a plus eight. And, he also has at the beginning of a mission, he heals one. And, if you'll notice, there's a lot of special abilities for each of these. But, they these do not correspond to a player. They are controlled by the party as a whole.
Parties will also be picking one of the campaigns to play. You'll have a map and a campaign book. The campaign has the three campaigns here, and each one has a prologue and epilogue. It will tell you what you need to do to win, the reward that you get, and it sometimes you'll have splits, and depending on whether you win or lose, or things will change. You'll jump through till you get to the end. So, each mission, you're going to set up some random cards. The game comes with a ton of cards with different words on them, and you're going to put them out in this display as it is shown here, like this grid. One person is going to be selected to be the GM, the dungeon master, the game master. And, they're going to take a key card, which they'll keep behind a little shield here. And, this key card can be put in four different orientations. So, that with this and all the different key cards in this game, there's tons of different things that are happening here. But, there are some There's going to be the same number of symbols on these at a time. You'll see there's dice numbers 1 2 3 4 5. There's gold things.
There's an X and an O, and then there's this deadly black one here. And, each of these will have something happen. Each of the players is going to take their sheets of these characters, put them out. They're going to put their health on to show how much health they have. So, this fresh guy grabs only has one hit point. While Dorian also has Dorian has two, although they could get a third later on. And, players are also going to have standees for their characters that go on top of those character cards. There might also be some special rules for the scenario. Almost always is. But, we're going to just talk basic game play. The GM each round is going to give a word and a number. So, for example, they might say gray two. They're saying there's two cards that have to do with gray. So, players are going to go around. They might say, "Hmm, all right. We They're going to take They're going to agree and they're going to put one of the characters on a card.
Werewolves are gray." The GM's going to look here at the cards. Yes, that is correct. So, that hero specifically is going to get an experience point. And you're also going to put whatever color is on it on top of it. Now, the gold ones are always good. You're trying to get those. The blue ones are going to change from round to round. So, for example, in the very first scenario, they're bigger, badder bandits cuz you're trying to fight bandits. And so, every hero would get an experience point. You need to get rid of all five of the yellows to win this mission. So, you're going to have to find five yellows on this card. Now, after players do a correct guess, they can guess again uh with a different character. So, maybe they'll put someone on Boulder because Boulders are also also gray. Fantastic.
Now, you don't want to mess up. If you pick one of these gray tiles here, you'll put a gray on top of that and whoever the hero is that you put on that is going to take a wound. And the same thing, if you get a red tile, but not only that, that's going to shorten the mission. And if you ever foolishly to the black tile here, you instantly lose the mission. After guessing, you advance the mission. The GM's going to take the top red tile from the red tiles, look at the number, and that one is a four. So, they're going to place that on this one. Now, the four here happens to be already covered up. And so, they're going to be placing another one. So, they'll draw another tile. When you run out of red tiles, that also will end the mission with a failure. So, we need to get the yellow tiles beforehand. In this case, we need five yellow tiles, not particularly hard. Win or lose a mission, players are going to get to keep the experience and level up the characters. Losing means you'll play through the thing again, you're trying to beat it and go through the campaign.
Of course, you can take some long-term repercussions. You'll keep You're going to increase your experience here, and sometimes it will give you one of your special abilities, sometimes it will give you more hit points or more of these tokens here. And these matter. Let's take a look at some of these abilities here. So, Dorian says he can use his special ability when his song is active. His abilities are called songs. When he guesses, he can roll 20-sided die and then choose unlock songs according to the result. Remembering he gets to add this number to that roll. So, 6 to 18, choose one. 19 to 22, choose two. 23, you can do all three songs and he gets a coin. So, this one here, it says anyone standing on the same diagonal as Dorian make prevent a health they would take while guessing. Anyone standing in the same row gets an extra experience when they guess. So, he is somebody who will help other characters while Vexia here, they roll a 20-sided die when they're doing trap tracking and they also come with a bear that they can put out and take a damage for them, an extra token.
But, the the GM will tell you if you roll a 20, they'll tell you the size of the same color cluster they're standing on. Also, whether that one that kills you is around them. And with a 19, it does tell you if you're next to the tile that's deadly. And so, that gives characters some information. And all these abilities, there are so many different special abilities that I think you could just go through video. You can go online and look at them, too, but they all do cool things giving you special abilities to help you beat these missions. And so, you're going to go through the campaign trying to get to the end like I mentioned, but But a basic overview.
Okay, so the Before we get into the the weeds on here, this is this is Codenames. Um it is based on this universe, the Critical Role universe. And I said you don't need to know it, and you really don't.
I think it's just general fantasy. If you have general fantasy knowledge, you're pretty good.
It's obviously a little silly fantasy. And I think though that you can still get attached to these characters not knowing who they are. Like, "Oh, I really like this character. He has a pet bear."
yeah.
Yeah, no, absolutely. And they have health and whatnot. And so you're like, "I don't I don't want Grog to keep getting getting beat up here."
But also it's nice that he's a punching bag.
Yes, that's true. The stupid bear. You're like, "Throw the bear out one. We don't care."
Aw.
So it's an interesting concept. And it I think this is the most different any Codenames has been. Codenames has kind of gone through an evolution. It was a straight basic party game, very popular, millions sold.
Mhm.
Then they did Codenames Pictures, and then various Codenames Disney, Simpsons, and even a hard-to-find Blizzard version. Then they did Codenames Harry Potter last year, or Hogwarts Academy. Which was had had its special abilities. And I thought that was really cool.
Mhm.
Well, this ups the ante on those special abilities. I mean by a factor of six.
Wait, is this the first one that's fully cooperative? It's not team versus team, by the way.
Codenames Duet.
Duet was, yeah.
Duet was fully cooperative.
This feels like a gamer's Codenames, for sure. Like there's a lot more rules, so it's not going to be something that I'm just going to like pull out to anybody that I'd bring Codenames to.
100% on that. I'll play Codenames with tons of people. I would not bring this out if you didn't A, almost already know how to play Codenames, maybe. And B, you know something about role-playing. Because if you don't know about leveling up and all that, I I would not play this with a good chunk of people I play Codenames with.
Sure.
Agreed. Codenames is core strength as a party game is that people can literally say, "I don't really like playing games." and they'll just watch. And then, you know, a few turns in, they're kind of leaning over and they're like, "What about that card?" You know what I mean? That's one of the great things about it. This one's far more involved and it's far more of like a gamer's game, which is great because it is so different and all the other Codenames still exist. And so, this is nice you know, break from form, but still feels like the essence of Codenames. Give clue and number and then people have to discuss and guess.
Now, this also has it has a little mini campaigns in it, right? Did you guys find the story to be interesting at all? Cuz I was not connected to the stories.
You know, I'm in the middle on that. Like, I wasn't necessarily in on it, but it made sense. Like, let's take the very first one. There's five bandits that you need to find, you know, take out, but there's two bandits in there that are hard bandits and if you beat them, you get more. And there's also a ticking clock to do that. That worked for me theme-wise. It also I mean, the special abilities don't always line up. It's you're doing special abilities into a word game.
Yes.
But, I didn't mind them and the pictures and the little bear and the freshly cut grass, dude. I didn't hate that the theme at all and I think if you like the show, it will even do more for you.
And I wonder if that's a thing is there were I felt like there were so many names of things that I was like, I don't know what these mysterious people are. I don't know what this weird place is. Um so, for me it was just a lot of name reading. Um but I do wonder, yeah, if you were more into understanding Critical Role, if that would be much more interesting. Once again, story is not the main reason why I'm playing this game. So, um that's just like a little side note.
I think they do about the right amount of writing for each scenario. They kind of set it up. Okay, I don't know where Valen Draffnor is, but it's an ice it's an icy mountain, got it. Okay. Oh, there there's like a slipping rule or whatever little thematic tie-in to the bit of story in this one, and I like those. I like that some of those blue tiles, the little special ones you get, sometimes feel like absolutely crucial uh to succeeding at the scenario. So, it's fun. It's a fun change-up from scenario to scenario what you're aiming for, what you're targeting for. Most of the time, get yellow words as fast as you can, but sometimes uh you know, some of them I don't want to I don't know if there's any spoilers, but it's nice to like kind of stumble upon things where like, "Oh, there's Oh, the blue target words play with the grid nature of everything a little bit, and it kind of hones you in on things."
I was really pleasantly surprised some of the change-ups they did from scenario to scenario.
That that I really enjoyed, and I felt like it made this so unique. That made it feel like this was not just regular Codenames, because we had new objectives, we had things that triggered, we had all those special powers that you mentioned before, Tom. Um and that combined made some really interesting moments, and it made some really clever play for some different like difficult challenges that I didn't think were going to be possible.
Yeah, and that's I really like that about this. Like I said, the Harry Potter one there was a special ability per side, per faction, and you had two different ones possible. And I was like, "Oh, that's really neat." Here, there are three characters, each with at least two special No, at least two that they can upgrade to, but they also have other ones that they start with. The leveling up is very satisfying,
And you can get gear.
Yeah, and there's gear cards, which I didn't mention, other things you can get, and and the leveling up is satisfying, but also, I like that nobody has any one character. So, I'm like, "Oh, that's a really cool character. Wish I could use that." I can.
That's true. That's true.
That works really well.
Yeah. Now, one thing I am curious about cuz I played this with groups. I've not played it with two. How does it work with two?
It's fine. I I like it a lot. Yeah, it's it's fun to just kind of be the clue giver or or be the other person and and there's so many tools at your disposal dispose at your disposal. I think it helps make it feel a little bit more like a deduction puzzle at times cuz like there's plenty of word games when I play with two and we're like, "Ah, this is better with a group." But having all those powers and all this Ooh, I'm going to go here and use this equipment is you know, tell me on the eight spaces around me is there blah blah blah thing.
Yeah, you feel like you're having a real turn instead of being like my turn is that. I touched a card. So, I I I liked it at two. And I felt like switching between who was giving the clue giver. That was pretty seamless because you know the powers that are being used as it's being upgraded and you can still discuss the upgrading. And so, every couple games switching off, I thought that was fine.
And you're also on the same team. Now, the the campaigns aren't particularly long unless you lose a lot. Um, but are also easy to pause. Really easy to pause everything because the leveling up system it shows you where the characters are. You will run through sheets in this game and it's a weird one to laminate where we have issues with that in the Dice Tower library. But also there's enough sheets that you're going to be you'll get a lot of plays out of this. I wondered my first play that I thought, "I don't know if I like the fact that all the cards are fantasy related." Like why can't I just take regular Codenames cards and stick them in? You can.
You can. Yeah.
But then I realized that the people playing the game are going to know all those words anyway. I don't need to change the words to make it general audience cuz the general audience isn't going to want to play the rest of the game.
That's fair.
I think you should have a passing familiarity with role-playing games, right? To because What's a grim war?
Right. Yeah, yeah. Earth and Kiln are in the same thing. You know what I mean?
What's the difference between a dwarf and a gnome, you know? We were arguing about that a little bit the other day.
very obvious, Wendy. But uh but yeah, I think that's the thing is is those words are going to have a narrower audience, but this game it matches the the the audience that this game I think is going to draw anyway.
I've no idea what who likes this the most. What's your score?
Okay, my score is going to be an 8.5. I think that this was absolutely fabulous for what it came to be. It was exactly what I thought it was going to be. Um it is a gamer's game for Codenames, which for me is great because I definitely got so burned out from playing Codenames way too many times. Um that this is where I want to be. And yet at the same time we introduced Codenames to our daughter who loves fantasy stuff. She had a great um foundation for this, but we introduced this to her and, you know, after a couple plays being on the team, she was very happy to play um and put the little characters out and the leveling up and all that kind of stuff. So, it was fun to be able to introduce her. And um yeah, I just think that this fits this niche really well, and I like a lot of what they did. There's a couple scenarios that I think maybe are too tough or or just difficult or don't make sense.
Um but at the end of the day, like I still had fun playing them, experimenting with them, and I don't feel like I have to make that choice to do that scenario again cuz there's choices as to where you can go and what you do. And so, yeah, I'm very happy with this. 8.5.
I'm I I've been debating. Uh I'm going to give it an 8.5 as well. I do think it's really excellent. We've had a few like the There's three campaigns and the last scenario of some of them are really challenging, like questionably challenging. But you also level up so much along the way. And if you fail out of a mission a few times, it might kind of sour your taste a bit, but then you also level up a bunch. And I like that it has a little tension, a little bit of pressure if you can fail a campaign if you lose too many scenarios, but you get so many boons along the way. So, I think it has a nice little self-balancing thing to it. So, sometimes, like I said, a little sour taste on a scenario, like, I don't even know if we can do that. And we have not always won every campaign the way through. But then I think about the whole journey, like starting up again and going through it, picking three different characters. Well, this one functions way differently. He doesn't stand on the on the ward he's picking, he stands one next to it. Why?
And you start unlocking his powers and you go, this is amazing. And it combines with this equipment in a really cool way. Yeah, it's excellent, man. It's so fun and clever and creative. So, 8.5.
Yeah, I'm I'm there and I'm a nine. I love this. It does not replace Codenames. They're really two different groups of people. I would play them both. But I mean, I guess there's some people there's a Venn diagram where there's a crossover, for sure. We're all in it. I like Codenames fine, but I love this one. I just I think it's so fun because each power adds deduction rules to the game. And then even a bit where you throw a die in, which I don't mind. Leveling up is always satisfying. Another health, better die rolls, another ability. It just feels good to get experience and level up. I just have a lot of fun with this. And like you said, there's three different heroes each time and you're like, well, how are these three going to work together?
Mhm.
And I think that that's that's fascinating. I think this is the most complex version of Codenames by far, but it's very rewarding for me, anyway.
And it's it's
not so complex that you say, well, why are we even doing? I think Felix and Vlada did a great job of kind of giving it the flair of a role-playing, leveling up and all that stuff. It's really impressive.
they used a lot of the ideas and concepts they've been getting from their the app version.
Yeah.
There's a lot of cool things that the app version of Codenames does and I think that you're seeing the results of that in this game. But it's fantastic. So, there you go. Codenames Critical Role Ventures. Maybe I'll get around to watching the series someday. I'm Tom.
I'm Wendy.
I'm Chris. There can't be that many episodes, right?
2,000.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things we review, games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.