A Message from the Stars: Extinction Protocol Review
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal. And I'm Chris Yee. Today we're taking a look at an expansion for a deduction game from All Play, the original game A Message from the Stars, and this is Extinction Protocol. EXTINCTION PROTOCOL. BRUTAL. SO, UH A Message from the Stars is a cooperative deduction game where one person plays an alien. The humans don't know the language, and so you're giving words back and forth and using mathematical formulas to figure out what these I don't know what the theme is. Figure out letters. Figure out Yeah, what Yeah, exactly. How kind of deciphering what letters are key key characters, I guess, in the alien language. Yeah. It's really just letters and math. It is, but it's a great game. I originally gave the game a nine, and I still very much like A Message from the Stars.
This makes it harder. Is that good or bad? I don't know. We'll tell you in a second, but first Chris is going to show you how what it plays, how it plays, what it adds. Here's everything that comes in the Extinction Protocol expansion. You'll see that there are 12 more cards here with words. This is just more stuff, more variety, more little Mad Libs. But these are importantly the clue cards that you have to get the opposing team to guess or the opposite side, the humans and the aliens. This is just more stuff. This is the real module of the game that changes the gameplay. There are now three possibilities for trust, three for amplify, and three for suspicion conditions and the way that affects the value that you give as a clue, and these boards here are going to show the same conditions over here. The alien player at the start of the game can choose to randomly select one from each of these categories. You'll notice that the top one are going to be the base game terms.
So, in the basic game, a trust letter always added one, an amplified letter always multiplied the value by two, and if the suspicion letter was present, then you'd make the value negative. Instead, you might now have trust every instance of a trust letter is going to add a plus two instead of plus one or every time a if there is a trust letter present in the word, you start with a basis of two. That's going to really change things up. The amplify instead of multiplying by two, each amplify letter might add three. So, you might just have adding lots of values instead of multiplying or you can have an amplify that modulates it tight it multiplies it by negative two. So, if you have a two and one [snorts] amplify letter, it's negative four. But, if you have two amplify letters, it's positive eight, then negative 16, then positive 32.
Over here, the suspicion say that for each one present, you can subtract two or if a suspicion suspicion letter is present at all, then no matter everything else, the value is still zero. So, there's two ways to play with this. The first way is the more introductory starter way. The alien player is going to select three of these at random and let's say that it is in fact these ones here. They'll mark this and it'll be publicly known to the human players and it's just a more challenging basic game of a message from the stars. Or the alien can select these and keep them secret. The humans have to deduce what the rules are based on the numerical values given and received over the course of the play. So, on top of deducing what the letters are behind the alien shield and what the words are for each team, the human players also have to decide and figure out what are the conditions that are in play.
Now, instead of a perfect score being 12, the perfect score will be 15. One additional point given for each of these that is solved correctly and that is what comes in the extinction protocol expansion for a message from the stars.
Just as a heads up, as always, that's remind you, all play is a sponsor of our show, but I hate some of their games.
And we're not afraid to say that. But I do love a message from the stars. So I was going into playing this expansion um assuming I would probably like it, but I had no idea what it added. Um when I found out it added more cards, Yay, cool. Easy.
either way. Yeah, and they're not exclusively limited to anything mechanically with this game. They're just more cards you can always play with. Cool, that's a nice little add. I wouldn't buy it for more cards though. No, you definitely want to buy it for that other function, the extra three or the extra rules in all three categories. Uh and then there's the two game modes I went over in the overview, right? The where it's known or where it's hidden. And I think both of those I think either way it's going to add complexity or add a little bit of thinkiness to the way that you play the game. Cuz the rules are a little bit trickier, and especially in combination, they can be extremely tricky. And that's with them as known entities. Yeah, small negative here about this. It It's only it not necessarily negative, but you need to keep this in mind. It gives you these cards for the alien to know what the new rules are, but if you're used to reading across the top of the shield like I do with the letters, the original rules are written there and you don't cover those up. So I There's a free app that you can type the words in and put these new clues in.
I mean these new rules in, and that makes it easier so you don't mess up if you're someone like that reading across. And I don't even know what I'm not asking them to have stickers or anything. Yeah, yeah. On your player shield where you have to put the cards, it yeah, that can trip people up playing the alien. I do think that the So the app works with the basic game or the expansion stuff. And it One of the negatives I've had with the game, and this happens in a lot of deduction games, I've had player who is the alien say, "Yeah, here here your answer is uh six." And after a few seconds they go, "Hold on, that's actually -9." You know,
and that messes up the train of thought of the human players. So, the app does clean that up. And I think that with some of these rules the order of operations has to be clarified a little bit more. You do the trust times the amplifier or whatever. Then you evaluate the third category of suspicion after doing that first part. And that needs to be locked down so both sides are playing with the same assumptions. Now, lest I sound egotistical, let me be egotistical for a second. I think I love a message from the stars. But if it didn't have the word cards, I think it'd be incredibly easy. The word cards make it more difficult. Right? But I feel pretty confident with my message from the stars. These new rules make it harder. Doesn't matter which one if you play with any of the new rules, it's going to make it harder because it's different and it adds in different variations, especially the if the if the trust letter if any of the trust letters in the word the word is starts at level two, which is a very difficult rule. No matter how many there are.
Suspicion letter changes the score to zero is probably the hardest rule in the game. If you put both those in, have fun. Yes.
And if that's not enough, if you play where you have to figure the rules out, that's very difficult. But also for me rewardingly challenging. I love that. There's no way on God's green earth I would use this expansion with someone who's never played the game before. No. They would die. But I also at the same time don't think that it would take too many games before you could say, "Hey, what if you twisted one rule?" And it's this card here. Right?
Sure. And that's that's fantastic. Yeah, and I so I think that this has this nice little you can integrate it slowly or as quickly as your players are comfortable with it. And I think that playing with that extra challenging mode with the hidden rules is super fun. Cuz to sound egotistical, we've done it. We've gotten a perfect score before, and it was so exciting. But it was also so just like it's not mentally taxing as in at the end of it I went, "Oh, I got to go lay down." It was It was taxing because it was a lot of work, but but I was so excited and uplifted at the end of it. Uh and I was in the mood to do, you know, play more games and stuff. Yeah, I think it's if if if you think maybe you're like me and you're like, "The game isn't as hard as it could be." This will definitely up that. I And and it also makes you think twice cuz I think honestly the original three rules are pretty good for deduction purposes.
They let you use an odd number for sure. Um it the negative thing is kind of a cool twist on the whole thing. So it's an interesting thing. These take that those possibilities out. So you have to think double thinks. Cuz in the original game, I'd be like, "Oh, they might have two ones and that's a two times two times two." Or there's four times And there's not a whole lot of options, but here I'll be like, but it especially when you don't know what the rule is. Oh my god.
Figuring out the rules out and then also making sure the words match the cards is much trickier. But I like it. This is definitely play the game first, see if you enjoy it. Do you want a bigger challenge? 100% get this. I don't know where the ranking on this is for me though. I'll I'll I'll just give it a 8.5. I think it's an excellent expansion. It's It's good. It's not needed for everybody, but if you're like me and love that in I I would probably always play the game with this if people have played Message from the Stars before. Yeah, cuz it's a bigger challenge. But I wouldn't play with new folk, which who I often play this game with. I teach people. But if you've played it before, we're definitely playing the expansion. For me, I'm giving this an expansion a 10. Oh, wow. I think it is so good.
me, too. Yeah. I don't know why you laughed now. To sound egotistical, I like this more than time.
No, I think it's so good. It's so rewarding. It is a bit of a niche expansion, but also a Message from the Stars is a little bit of a niche game. And so, it's fine. I think that this is the right type of expansion for this game. Uh and that's why I rate it so highly. I will always want to play with this expansion. I will always enjoy changing up those rules, and I really love the hidden challenge in the right group of the the hidden uh of the hidden rules. I think that that is so satisfying, and that's the ideal way that I kind of want to always play now. But, I still really enjoy the basic game enough that I would play regular Message from the Stars, especially teaching new people. But, I would also say, "Hey, do you guys want to play one more time?" And I would pull out at least some of the cards and and mix it up. That's why I I I think this is a perfect expansion for this game. There you go, folks. A Message from the Stars Extension Protocol, where the person who's trying to tell everyone is the designer. I'm Tom. I'm Chris. See y'all.
Hey, everybody. Thanks for watching another video from The Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us? Communicate with us? We have a Facebook group. We have a Discord channel. Lots of different ways to get involved with The Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that, and it will take you, and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook group. So, there's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of The Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vasel.