Skip to main content
Loading video...

Descent: Legends of the Dark - Discussion 2.0

Transcript 31:54

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games and like and today I'm doing the final discussion for descent Legends of the dark act one uh so this was a campaign that I uh me and my friend Josh were doing for the channel and I I can't remember exactly how many scenarios we had done uh overall but uh as you can clearly tell we did not finish the series for the channel and this is one of those instances whenever I do a series or a campaign uh on on the channel I usually do a few uh you know episodes a few whatever quests or whatever they're called then I do like a preliminary discussion kind of what we're thinking how we're feeling uh about the game at that point in time and then I either do a completely end of campaign discussion or I do another discussion where if we don't finish it out you can pretty much guess why so because we didn't finish it for the channel you can tell that we probably started to not really care for it or want to do it uh we had done about I think we we did we recently did two more chapters and we were extremely close to officially finishing out the the overall story like the I think there were like two overall things we had left to do before we just kind of ultimately called

it we weren't really vibing with the the the game as a whole as the the campaign went on and it just kind of felt that we would rather dedicate our time to doing something else for the channel so uh with act two now out I believe is officially released um I was like okay well now here's the time for me to talk about act one I still think that this descent is better than the previous descents I know I'm in the minority there I never really liked descent I never played first edition but I did not like second edition I very much enjoyed almost every aspect of this better than those uh and it's not to say that this game was bad there were just elements of the campaign that we just got completely tired of especially for a recording State like the recording purposes like the 3D terrain is really cool until you have to actually start fiddling with it and it becomes kind of uh a hindrance whenever you're moving and I feel that there's not a whole lot of strategy or depth with the monsters or the 3D terrain combat as there could be it's more of like a o that looks really cool versus oh that's you you know we can utilize terrain and you know the the uh stackable elements of the scenario and what I mean by that is like in combat

like your movement is not just orthogonal and I feel like that's a huge uh distinction for a lot of these type of combat driven games uh because if you're able to move diagonally which you can in this there's no reason to have pieces near you there's no reason to have uh you know lava or water or anything like that like if you have an area that's water but you can just go from Stone to Cornerstone I don't really find that it's like okay why even have the water it's never going to be a factor unless it's like a story element the lava never going to be a factor unless there's a story element but whenever you have to move orthogonally it allows for a lot more tactile decision- making how you want to spend your movement points uh how the enemies are going to get to you how you're going to flank the enemies that all is done in other games that I feel like make the combat more tense like Madara allows you to care about how you're moving because while line of sight and stuff can be you know uh drawn diagonally your movement cannot so you have to be like do I want to spend extra stamina to run there I can't get there in my base movement do I want to spend extra stamina to increase my movement but then I'm not going to be able to attack as much as I wanted to stuff like that versus just like I can get anywhere at any uh given point so I'm able to do whatever I want so whenever you're messing with the 3D terrain and it's like yeah this looks really neat but none of it's ever in my way I can and like if you have a

tree in one spot you'd have to go one two three four spaces to get around the tree versus just diagonal diagonal for two which might some people might like they might like the fact that they're not hindered by all that they can just you know kind of hopscotch around all the pieces but I kind of find it to be like well we're almost always within sight of anything so yeah the enemies are always going to get to us um and uh so that was kind of getting annoying the 3D terrain was really neat at at first but then it started to get kind of cumbersome to deal with uh and one of the biggest reasons that made me decide to just kind of call this as a campaign uh well I also did speak to Josh and he's like yeah I'm not feeling it anymore and there's a there's actually a big distinction that I'll talk about in a sec but is I I saw how act two was going to be and I was like oh it's more of the same I'm not interested because whenever you're talking about The Narrative of descent Legends of the dark I can't really tell you what is happening not because I have trouble retaining it it's because it's just so generic that it's just like oh okay evil evil force take over World good guys stop them and that's that's pretty much it uh I don't find any of the characters compelling and a lot of this is done I

feel like this would have done really well years ago but because of audio narration being put into these Campaign games those just Elevate that stuff so much more like if you have pre-written characters like this would make sense if we made our character if we made our characters and we like didn't they obviously couldn't write for that okay well then we have to role playay and act all that out that's perfectly fine but if you have pre-written characters that are supposed to have motives and backstories and opinions and feelings uh whenever your game especially a game like this where you have so much that's done on a laptop or an app don't ever use the app just use the laptop when all of there's so much into that and you don't integrate voice acting into your heav narrated game it a lot of it is lost especially if you're not playing with a Max group of people or even if you are one person has the laptop like you can't share screens like so it's like one person has it and you're not going to be passing that around to have everyone read their lines whenever not every character is going to be there I guess they would be for the story purposes but it's like okay so one person's doing it it becomes incredibly taxing on uh on the player reading it and if one person's reading it eventually it just sounds like droning on and on so people check out and it's like whatever let's just get to the scenario that's going to be a generic oh it's an alchemist

lab okay that's we're here now I guess um so the The Narrative element of this being compared to so many other games especially for the channel I do so many Campaign games there's osor there's uh kfire Chronicles now there's uh Madara and then at some point there was Al trespass ASI familiar Tales um sleeping Gods like all six of those have audio narration like hell I can even probably go through foreteller isofarian guard seven all campaign narrative driven campaigns that this would fall into that all have audio narration that takes that away and so all players can be integrated into the story and all of those just feel way more unique than this one does like because the game was new when we did the discussion and we had jumped into it the 3D terrain element you don't really see anywhere that was cool the all the stuff in the computer that's never been done before um so that was cool but as you kept going on and on that stuff lost its luster so then you eventually just kind of realize that the game is just an allright game uh and you don't ever really feel like you've progressed or gotten any better like the leveling up for the characters is so whatever it's not really exciting uh

in fact it's it's slightly hidden in the story like whenever you're setting up you're kind of like you just kind of stick with what you got and then you look and you're like oh I actually have XP that I can have oh that means these cards are available eh I'll just kind of stick with what I what's currently working cuz it's not like the cards that you get at a later level are that much better they're more situational um so it's was like oh that's cool well we still have that fatigue thing that's kind of That's So that's there and I mean I still have to roll dice and hope I get what I want to use this new card I'll just stick with whatever I have like I like the fact that they have six individual characters that do play differently like I'm not saying that these are all just kind of all the same they do have like their weapons are different the hilts and all the stuff that the laptop manages all that is done extremely well and I'm glad that the laptop exists to micromanage all of that but all that just kind of gets lost you you craft stuff you're you're overwhelmed with resources that's not managed in any way like you just kind of have it you look through all your stuff and then you craft items and then you're like well I don't I since this isn't tangible I can't organize it in such a way uh that allows me to compare and contrast like you know whenever you go to a video game and you're like okay I have this sword and here's a new sword and usually it pops up and you can compare both and if the game's really good it'll be like red or green showing you what goes up and what goes down this

game doesn't have that so you have a bunch of handles or or items or upgraded weapons and you're like I can't really tell if this is better than what I currently have so you just kind of have stuff and you have resources and you're like okay I have bombs that are around we can choose those now so those cards are tangible uh but like the hilt and like the grip and on your weapons isn't there it's more of just percentile or like like stuff that's like hey you have a 20% to make an enemy exposed now it just it loses it loses all of its like coolness and uniqueness whenever you're you know 20 hours in which some people might say well you got 20 hours in that must mean the game's really good it's like well no that just that just means that some scenarios took way too long like the game itself if you just stick with the main story is I think it's like 14 14 uh main things few side quests here and there uh I don't know the the overall story just never gripped me like all those other games I mentioned I didn't care about any of the characters uh even though they did have specific character side quests that you could go and like it's supposed to put some depth to them but because there was no voice acting you got no inflection you didn't care uh and it was just I mean overall it's just

kind of generic so then we had about the last session that we did uh we we we did two two chapters one chapter because we've been doing this entire campaign with two on a standard difficulty and I was like you know what what if what like CU it's just like it's you're almost always going to be completely injured uh both characters just because it's like well no one has defense ever so we'll just like you're just going to get hurt all the time so then we're like okay what if for the next one we just tried four you know we both control two and we'll see how that goes it was night and day different like it was so much easier not the the enemies didn't change the scenario didn't change it's not like a lot of games where it's like it shows like a little person icon and it's like hey like Marvel Champions it's like hey this uh villain's health is 10 per person so if you're playing four people has 40 Health none of it was like that so I feel like this game also doesn't scale for the number of people like if you're gonna play this game if you have just two people playing run two people each it's not that much more difficult uh all the stuff is still organized there and you will get so much more done and feel way less uh overwhelmed by the scenario like there the one we did we

had to basically get gather a lot of information at this particular banded camp and the fact like when one person person went off to go do something and they like had to they were trapped with a bunch of enemies it was like oh well three more people are coming to the rescue they can all get there and then just completely wipe the floor with all the enemies there if we did that same scenario and it was just two it's like well here I am and one person is coming to help we're just completely hosed here so that really put a damper on us wanting to even continue even though I'm saying it's not that much overwhelming it was just the fact that it's like that's really annoying that we didn't uh that it doesn't really scale per the number of players so it's like we could have just been doing that this whole time we could have just had four people each scenario it also made the scenario way quicker because if you if you're needing people like to go okay we need to go check this bookshelf and gather information then we need to have someone go over here and check this door uh to use that information and then once that door's open we need to ring this Bell whatever ever it is you could send three people to go do that and one one person to fight enemies or something or but if it's just two people it's like you still have to do all those things but now it's split between just two people and it's it's just it's too much so then it's it's like okay well so so the scenarios aren't balanced for the number of

players and that's incredibly annoying so yeah we could have just finished it out with four but we just it just wasn't ever really worth it like we were just kind of doing it just for the sake of doing it to be like hey we're done but we ultimately have no interest in like even going into act two which is crazy because whenever act two was officially announced I was super excited I was like oh hell yeah U but yeah last time we played I was just so over reading everything and just so over I I quit crafting stuff and I quit like looking at what we had attached to our weapons cuz it didn't matter at the end of the day um you go through the motions every scenario you move and then you roll a die and you're like okay I'll do this for seven all right I did I did 14 damage yep it has 89 health so down to 75 that's cool and then then do it again and you're like okay that was my first action I'll do my second action to attack and then it's like 72 damage it's like okay and that's also kind of like I said how I like how the laptop manages a bunch of the stuff and I do like especially if you're doing dealing with percentiles and all that it's like I'd much rather have an app deal with all that than an actual player but whenever you're attacking in all these other

games like I I I'll keep using Madara as an example and you roll your Dice and then you're like okay I got my Max roll here so I'm five over it's it's defense so it's five damage then use my symbols and boom boom boom and that's 29 you feel good because you can actually look and see how you got to 29 damage and it's like that's [ __ ] insane but in descent you just kind of roll and you're like okay so I'll use that surge symbol to get a plus one and I got four and then you add four and then you just kind of hit apply and it it calculates all that and then it's like one damage and you're like I don't even know how it's one damage you do another for another time and then all your percentage stuff kicks off and then it's like Auto kill how' I go from one damage to like Auto and this is like I'm not necessarily exaggerating there are some attacks that just do nothing like you'll get the same result but then you'll like it it just like all your percentage of stuff doesn't kick off so then it's just like oh I guess I hit just his defense of of 15 so I guess I just did one damage or no damage but then you do the exact same thing and then all of a sudden it kicks off and then it's like oh big number but you're like you really just are just adding just hitting the plus uh button and then apply and you're like it is what it is on the results I don't feel excited the numbers don't mean anything um so while all the little like resources

like in other games like Kingdom Death monster for example like having a bunch of resources is just kind of annoying you just have them there but at the same time you can you can organize all that you everyone can see it it's not one person looking at a laptop telling everyone what we have uh and they just kind of have to go with it I feel like the laptop would be super beneficial if everyone like if there was like a shared code like the frost Haven app if everyone had a shared code and then you could all put that in and everyone can see the like there's one person running it like so not everyone can control it but everyone's running it but whenever they make changes or click on anything all the players can see it so then they can see the resources they can click on stuff and be like oh what does this do and then whenever it comes the story they can read it themselves and not hope for someone else to read it to them uh but whenever it's just one person doing it it just feels like everyone's just kind of there as a person is playing on their laptop or God forbid their phone for this game um the interactive elements during the scenarios also became kind of tired like you you can only search through books bobles and bottles on you know book bookshelves so many times before it's just it's just annoying until you have to do it the Riddles In

the scenarios are so dumb like they're so dumb and the other thing is whenever you do get riddles that just give you an overload of information on their worlds it's like oh Umbra and firea and and and Libra it's like I don't know what any of this is but you have no Quest log or you have no like hey I know we're trying to solve a riddle here but either like you have everything in your computer but I still have to Rite all this stuff down because you don't have a dedicated section for me to find that pertinent information like any big video game whenever you're doing stuff for a quest it's like hey here's all the information for the quest or you go to uh like yeah like a quest log and be like ah here's all the stuff for the Riddle That I need I just need to piece it all together there's none of that the best you can do is dig through the log history of separate rounds so it's like in round two if you read a note that tells you some information that you're going to need later and then 10 Rounds later you find another note it doesn't take those notes not and separate them so you have both of those pieces you have to remember in log in round two is when you found that info so you have to go all the way back for that it's awful it makes the riddle so frustrating that you just don't care about action points or anything so it's like you know what I'm just going to I'm gonna uh uh what do they call it uh it's not bull rush um I can't think of the word right now but you're just going to keep trying until you

eventually just break on through ruin so you can continue the scenario um these are all things that are reasons why we're not continuing the campaign and that's none of that's to say that this game is necessarily bad it's just in a flooded market like this it just doesn't hold up like the games that I've been playing that are story driven are Frost Haven Gloom Haven kfire Chronicles Madara sleeping Gods isofarian guard uh and hell even Aon trespass Odyssey is going to be coming with they're going to be going on I think for teller for their narration osor has their own app with narration familiar Tales Freel Lancers is not really a campaign but all those have websites with narration so this just doesn't hold up like for uh that whenever you're comparing it to all those uh because all the stuff I said in the original discussion still holds true like at that given point and maybe because we took quite some time off like cuz just life events were happening so we weren't playing it as often maybe if we were playing it weekly uh or you know more consistently than like you know a you know three or four sessions you know once a month and then it's like not for six months and then we come back maybe

that that would have uh kind of kept us interested until we finished it but as time went on it was kind of like oh yeah we have descent to finish you know why bother uh like everything about it is just kind of it's it's lost it it's lost its sex appeal um yeah I mean that's that's pretty much it like I I'm not going be getting act two uh I don't especially because it's like I've seen gameplay and I've talked to uh people that have done run throughs for it on their Channel and I was like hey uh did they like improve anything did they add narration so someone doesn't have to get their voice destroyed reading everything that movement still looks kind of the same that combat looks kind of the same it looks like they added a little bit more 3D terrain and they're like yep that's it it's the same game just with a little bit more 3D stuff and and nope there's no narration I uh the other thing is like whenever you're trying to record stuff like this you can only do so much and it gets extremely annoying whenever you run out of the room trying to place like you you hit like a a sight token and it just dumps all this 3D stuff and it's like h

okay let's break the action and the we're I know we're all into it but now let's set up let's put all this stuff here and let's okay yeah I need I need all those pieces I need to put them all here and then oh sorry you can't see anymore yeah that's just get up I guess get up and move around um it just kind of it just it just ultimately fell fell flat for us let's see yeah like again like I don't think this game is bad like I'm not sitting here going oh after all these scenarios this game is trash it's not it's very serviceable I can see people really liking it if you don't have a bunch of other games to compare it to but because I do it stands out the most and not in a necessarily good way this game would have done way better like I like the 3D terrain I think that is is neat cuz you don't see that in other games it's mainly tokens or art uh and there's not really any art in this game and if it is you most likely don't like it so the so the 3D terrain could be a lot more fun if you're not trying to keep it in camera frame okay I get that but the lack of tactile decisions uh the the movement uh the rolling dice to just put in an arbitrary number and hope it it gives you a higher result uh the enemies I do not find compelling like whenever you get a boss that's the thing is like

other games whenever you get presented with a boss it's actually a unique boss and it's like here's the boss token here's the boss standy the boss miniature whatever it is and the boss is going to play out completely different every boss you fight in this feels like it's just like a different color it's like in breath of the wild Legend is all the breath of the wild whenever it's like hey here's bobblin oh here's a silver bab it's like that's the same [ __ ] enemy it does the same exact thing it just has way more Health that's exactly how this is it's like hey here's a fairy oh but now we've given it a different title to match the scenario and more Health oh does it you do any unique stuff no it does what fairies do but it just is going to take you longer to kill it oh okay I think there's been one scenario where I actually thought the boss fight was cool and it was kind of like at the Midway point but then so enemies are not fun to fight they're there uh again because it's all done on the laptop one person is kind of involved in the combat everyone else is just rolling and telling them what the number is and then they do that uh and it's not even animated like I think the people kind of do this and then it goes 72 and you're like whoa that was a quarter of their health uh and then when they do it it's just like all right they're doing 15 damage have 10 health and no defense all right I guess I'm one

shot yeah it's like it's there if you have 150 bucks to spend I would recommend any of the other games I just mentioned over this like I'm trying to see if there's a game that I've mentioned that this is uh better than and uh no no no it's not all those games I mentioned mentioned all those like seven or eight games that are in the genre that I was like here's all of these this is worse than them uh maybe it's I was going to say maybe it's more interesting than kfire Chronicles but it's actually not like because those characters are written and it's again it's audio it's it's you know read to you uh it's just more compelling you're invested more there's music there's ziance there's soundtrack so it's like this is like playing a video game where you're really really into bookkeeping and story comes you know dead last for you and that's perfectly fine if that's what you like I I should I need to reiterate again that I don't think this game is bad I just don't want to play it anymore is which might it's like some people might say that I think it's bad if you don't want to play it that's a bad game well subjectively yes like if someone asked me to play this I'd probably say no but objectively it

it works like it's still cool to see uh and maybe it's really cool to some people who don't play these types of games but I do and that's a a majority of my channel is like Series so whenever I have such dedicated time or limited time that I dedicate to other games I can't be spending all that on games that I'm not compelled to even finish you know so that's um that's pretty much it that's the updated um discussion for descent Legends of the dark if you were really really into the series and you were waiting for us to do it well we're not the even the two latest sessions that I recorded I'm not uploading just because it's it wasn't exciting um so though so and we're not finished finishing it like we have other plans whenever him and I get together and with act two coming out I'm not I'm not picking that up either so yeah on a scale of 1 to 10 descent Legends of the dark let's take a look at what I gave it originally decent uh Legends of the dark yeah uh okay so taking into account what I gave it previous ly it's like a six is too

low because I I'm I'm going to drop to a seven I think the C legend of the dark is a seven it's a good game uh it's just what I personally want out of narrative driven Campaign games is oh tainted Grail there's another one uh it just wasn't on for teller but yeah narrative driven Campaign games this is just not you know standing up to the rest of them but overall I think it's still solid so I'm going to drop it to a seven I had given it a nine so that is a twoo drop uh so do with that what you will those numbers don't even matter anyway uh but that's my thoughts on descent Legends of the dark act one uh let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time ofd this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my cont content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved