Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Porters | Zenobia Finalists 2024

Transcript 21:46

hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beond soliter and I'm very excited to have three special guests for this interview I have got Nico Cobrin Lucas Cobrin and Alex Goss game designers and Nob finalists who are about to be submitting the porters so how are y gentlemen doing todaying great great great yeah thanks for having us absolutely I'm super happy to have youall on so for people who have not been following zenobi award uh what is like the the summary of the porters well it's it's basically a game that's based on the experiences of Black Train Porters in Canada in the early to mid 1900s and their eventual success in unionizing um bit of context can Ian rail companies had adopted a luxury sleeping car service that was based on um what was being done in the United States at the time um under this model the companies would hire black Porters to serve the passengers who were predominantly white um and while it was one of the few jobs that black men could get at that time um it had pretty terrible working conditions um they were expected by the companies to be smiling subservient uh um wearing pristine uniforms all those sorts of uh stereotypes and then they had to rely on tips to supplement low wages um they faced racist policies racist attitudes um and long work hours which was uh a major part sort of of their story um in terms of working very long time

without uh the ability to sleep or rest um and they also faced arbitrary punishment from uh the companies or their bosses so with all this with little job security and despite all of this they were still able to come together and unionize so that's that's basically what our game's about oh that's awesome uh so what got y'all interested in this topic and what made y'all think that this was a good thing for the three of you to do uh together well we you know Nico and I have been playing we're brothers uh so so we've playing board games it feels like forever so uh we kind of jumped into the modern board gaming hobby uh maybe like a decade or so ago and Alex and I live in the same city and we were part of a gaming group and we play a lot of games together so the gaming part of things was sort of always sort of cooking in the background um and I had looked at Zenobia the first Zenobia award in 2021 and you know I think I did a concept proposal back then so I was aware of the of the Contex um and we thought when this contest came up we had I had an idea about uh train Porters uh being a a good subject for a game uh you know in Canada we don't hear a lot about the contributions of of black Canadians and black immigrants to sort of the fabric of society and so um over time I sort of felt that uh

bringing some of those stories to light with be really great and so it just so happened that there's this sort of vend diagram of you know board gaming and having these guys to to to play with and these thoughts of Designing and that overlap with wanting to bring some of those stories to a wider audience um and it seemed like a like a good fit there's been some popular media in Canada um around train train Porters um there's like a there's a TV series and there's a novel that came out that was quite popular and so it was kind of in in the Consciousness a little bit um and you know we sort of looked at some of those things and did a bit more reading I thought it was a great a great fit awesome and so uh if you're making game about uh Porters unionizing what kind of mechanisms and game structure uh did y'all choose to kind of Express something about this particular topic so it's a two-player um game game that we've got uh and it's Cooperative with limited communication um basically each player takes the role of a senior Porter managing a crew of Porters and the porters will serve passengers on the train and then in Canadian cities they'll work to undertake Union activities um and the sort of General end goal is to try to coordinate enough votes to uh form uh Union chapters so I

don't know if someone else want want more into the mechanics but that's uh that's sort of the overarching yeah I think there's within those stories and that history some really interesting tensions that kind of emerg that also work their way into the game around you know what the personal motivations are and trying to do your job and you know get tips and get through the day versus the more kind of community Brotherhood side of it of getting fair treatment getting faer wages job security um and trying to unionize behind the scenes while not losing your job as a result of it and so there's some really interesting tensions that come into play in the game as well and with the with the unionization part of it um the mechanisms in this there's sort of two phases of the game I think ni mentioned this the train phase where you're actively serving passengers and then the city phase is where you engage in some of these Union activities and so we chose to sort of model the union activities as um sort of almost a hi hidden information type of mechanic where there's a voting pool that you each have access to but you only know your kind of site of the pool because communication is sort of limited and and in fact uh you have to be very very careful about um engaging in any of these activities in the open and so what we've done is um when you are in the

city phase uh there's limited communication of the votes that you know and there are ways to manipulate the votes that you have and um ultimately As you move around the city you're basically trying to drum up support and generate yes votes but you will never really know uh the full voting tally until the end of the round oh that's super interesting uh and then I guess I would be interested in knowing how much has the game changed over the course of the Zenobia competitions did you start the game with Zenobia or had you kind of already started before and then how um how did the game evolve over time like does it look like how it did it to start or has it Beena it's changed a lot I would say it's changed a lot like we we started we started with Zenobia so it's a fresh design with the start of the contest uh and that's one of the things that I I found most interesting was how much the game has evolved from the initial ideas and the concept proposal to sort of where it is now so um would you guys agree you think it's I think it's changed a lot yeah yeah I was looking back at the design diary and it's completely different yeah yeah I think some of the core elements are there you know this the concept of Porters on trains and us cards to represent that

interaction and then having the unionization I think those concepts are in place but yeah how that unfolded is very different now yeah than where we started yeah we tried a lot of different mechanisms and I feel like with every play test we did like it was just generate a billion ideas and we play test those and generate a billion more and yeah it was it was quite the process yeah so I I always like to ask this just because you know they say Kill Your Darlings so I want to know what people's Darlings are um was there anything that you really liked for the game and that you kind of wanted to get in there that you had to cut in order for the game to work better I can't really go ahead ni I was gonna say that I can't I I know that we we we killed a lot um as to whether like there were ideas that say like I feel I had that just never sort of got off the ground but um we did a lot of like definite like trimming and cutting and that was almost like a real major part of our process was trying to get the game streamlined as much as possible and because we wanted to try to make something that was like had some Elegance to it and whatnot so we were constantly cutting and cutting I can't think off the top of my head about anything major that I can think of but uh yeah initially I I con seeed my my conception of the game was it was going to be like a semi Coop game because I wanted to sort of have a bit of competition to highlight the sort of

agency of the porters and their own lives and the fact that they weren't just just workers on the train um but I I couldn't we couldn't really get that off the ground and so we ultimately went to a a co-op game uh so that that idea of a semi Co-op really had to have to be killed I guess yeah and I think the kind of collaborative nature of this the group of us working on this game as well was really exciting and I think that kind of helped you kill your your favorite ideas I remember one time just showing up with I I brought my notebook in and we were trying to figure out the city unionizing phase and I I think I had like six drawings of different concepts I was like I really think this one like number three is is gold and went in was like it's not going to work no wait wait wait but like what if we do it this way and but it was really that kind of back and forth and discussing the ideas um really kind of allowed you to work through it and come to an acceptance of okay yeah maybe that's interesting for me but maybe it's not really good fit for this game yeah so speaking of collaboration so Nico Lucas y'all live in different cities and Lucas and Alex y'all play together so you see each other in person a lot how did y'all manage to maintain like good communication with each other and look at prototypes and all of that across a distance did you do some of this in

person or were you designing partially online so most of it was well I guess we did a combination of it uh Alex and I did a lot of play testing in person you know just with note cards and um you know very very very rough prototypes and uh then we would Loop Nico in with all sorts of strange foam camera setups above the table and that kind of thing um so we would kind of all sort of play test together um and once once we developed it further and actually got like a an online sort of mod going then it was much easier to play test uh frequently and be able to sort of collaborate that way and then a lot of it was just you know brainstorming and we have a a group WhatsApp chat going that you know we just send ideas back and forth back and and forth back and forth so it seemed to work out okay makes sense so as the time of this conversation we've got it's what like 10 days until you got to submit this thing like the final so um how much change is happening for your game in this period what do you got to get done before deadline no one wants to fess up yeah so so we yeah we we got some really good feedback from like uh from the last stage uh and some of the feedback between the reviewers was a little bit conflicting and we're still trying to

sort of piece together how much we want to change uh in in the game sort of wholesale um we are going to make some changes with respect to Clarity like on the game board itself and little prompts to help people remember some of the slightly trickier aspects of the rules I think the core of the game is going to stay pretty much as is for now um you know from our experience designing making one change is going to could potentially cause a lot of knock on effects and you know potentially break the game in ways that we haven't been able to adequately test and so there's going to be there's going to be a few changes that are substantive and then the rest are going to be I think helpful for the player experience uh and so this kind of leads to the question of you know it sounds like you've got like a pretty cohesive core to your game you come a long way to get there um when people people play the porters what is the number one thing you want them to notice or Come Away with after after playing your work I mean I think for for me it's sort of um bringing to light the various elements of what the porters went through and sort of to Marvel at the fact that they were able to um organize under such uh pressure and with such high stakes and actually get enough people on board to um to to do that um I think some of the design choices we've

made um will serve to sort of drive that home I mentioned earlier sort of some of the um dehumanizing aspects of the job um we hadn't really mentioned um in this that um the the porters um the the whole system that was done in the United States was sort of led by um an entrepreneur named George pulman and the porters um ended up just being called George rather than being given their using their given names um while they were working on the trains so that's obviously very dehumanizing um one of the little mechanics we've we worked into the game um on the train basically was to have the cards tuck when you serve passengers and each card has the Porter's face on it and um when that's tucked under the passenger sort of you know you don't you no longer see the porter right um so little little things like that I think will hopefully sort of cause players to sort of pause and think like wow like this was this was pretty pretty harsh and we've tried to balance the game uh so that it is a difficult game uh to sort of model some of that the difficulty and we made we tried to bring some themes through through the mechanics that kind of echo those things that Nik was talking about so like fatigue was a major part of the story and so you're generating fatigue every time you're moving to serve passengers on the train and moving in the city to

se to to do the union activities uh and so what we're hoping is that people will have a bit of that that feeling of you know there's not enough time there's not enough energy to do everything that we need to get done um and that that creates a lot of tension there and and with that said I think I think we also really we really want to focus on making a game that we wanted to play and so we tried to make a game with relatively lighter rules overhead but a lot of um interesting decisions to make along the way and to make sort of collaboratively and so we we think that I mean I think that that the mechanics that we've Chosen and just the style of game that we have is actually is a pretty fun and interesting game to play you know like the subject matter can be can be a little heavy but But ultimately I think I think the game is quite an enjoyable game game to play yeah I would just add I would hope that people kind of come away from the experience of of playing the game with maybe a deeper understanding of some of the contributions Blackport has made to building Canada and Canada's history and maybe some empathy as well of what that kind of tension felt like with some of those challenges and struggles uh looked like it the time excellent and so you actually hit on something I think is super interesting so the game has some pretty heavy themes and you have to really confront a harsh reality uh when you're doing a game on a historical topic like

this but it's also clear that y'all took consideration for making the game a fun and enjoyable experience as a game how did you balance that and are there times where you decided to pull back or deliberately make the player more uncomfortable um either way to kind of get the point across like how do you how do you how do you balance it yeah it's a good question I think I think when we try to balance it I think we used the mechanics as sort of a nod like Nico's example of you know the porter essentially becoming faceless as they're serving the passenger as a reference to that that idea of just being called George or boy and not actually uh being seen as a human we are try to Echo that in in the mechanics of the game itself um without having it sort of like it's it's there and we've made mention of it in the rules so people can see how the mechanics tied to the theme but you know it's not right we're not trying to sort of hit you in the face with it you know I think it's it's there to be discovered and to sort of Peak Interest and understand a little bit um while still you know being able to to enjoy the mechanics of of the game itself and you know we we tried to uh there's little things in the game like uh when

you're doing the initial round setup you pull a domino from a bag to determine which births are empty on the train and so little nods like that to to Dominoes which are a big part of like Caribbean culture a lots of Caribbean black immigrants that came to to serve we tried to have a little a few of light touches like that to to bring the theme out and have it not feel I not feel so heavy and I think to the like the end goal of the game I think we felt would be enjoyable as well you know that sense of accomplishment overcoming a challenge of the Railway company forming the union together cooperatively that that that end goal should be enjoyable as well even if the kind of struggles along the way aren't are a bit uh you know they're not always enjoyable in the same way Perfect all right so this sounds like a great game I honestly can't wait to play this I'm very very curious about what this is going to look like in its final form uh but we are running out of time so I'll ask you the softy questions what uh games have youall been playing recently that you've really really enjoyed I've had feels of ARL out I've been playing a lot of that and uh my wife and I have been playing uh uh Guild of merchant Explorer that's our most recent game that we've gotten to the table I'm quite enjoying that yeah I've been I've been I've actually got uh paper tail sitting on the table in front of me I usually grab a grab a game and sort of play it for a

week and that was this week's game so that's what I've been playing I haven't I haven't played too much recently so excommunicated okay all right well what's a fave then uh I'm a fan of Dune uh which one Dune uh Uprising all right awesome uh and then if y'all want do y'all have social media where people can follow you and check out your work online I do not nor do I sorry now all right so everyone you're gonna have to know these men of mystery uh through the work um but I can be found everywhere as Beyond soliter uh gentlemen thank you thank you so much for coming on this is fascinating and I'm very very excited about the porters congrats so much on making to the finals and it sounds like this is a great entry thanks so much for having us yeah thanks a lot it's great all right everybody uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy G oh

Progress saved