Libertalia: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for libertalia the original first edition by paolo mori um when did this game come out was it like 2012 tuesday tuesday uh about about 10 years ago i remember the day because i was uh i was having coffee and i saw the announcement and boy oh boy did i just anyway um so this was a game that's always been kind of brought up on a lot of top tens throughout the years um a lot i think a lot of people compared this to like citadels and those kinds of games uh where it's basically kind of like everyone starts out with the same hand it was 2012 i must be rain man just i i just know the year um but but yeah so i've never played citadels but i have played games where kind of people have the same hand and you're playing that hand um and it's just kind of the order of how you play it right and usually i'm i'm piss poor at that but i can definitely see the hype around this one i think this is a very fun game like it's it's simple but deep i think in the same time with the different card combos i like the fact that there are 30 cards in every game you play you're going to shuffle your deck and it's like oh it's now this order of six and that's gonna i mean after two or three games you're familiar with what each of them do right and you have to focus so much on reading them and thinking about it and trying to figure out synergies and then the next round you get six more
and you're just like oh god okay now how do these work you definitely become a little bit more familiar and try and maybe plan for future turns um so i do like that i think this is easily one of the better ones where of that hand management kind of game so uh but this is one that you tout it's one of your favorites um so yeah take it away um why why this one yeah i mean it's it's in its core it's a party game it's just a more complicated party game um yeah yeah it's one that i've played a thousand times um it's easy to teach overall i just yeah i don't know it's it's pretty straightforward there's not much to it i feel like but yeah uh what do you guys think for me kind of the opposite but i wasn't playing it with a party mindset yeah yeah as a strategy game and so it's like it's limiting and it's random and right so i wasn't i wasn't in that mindset where you've been enjoying it so if i shift i i can see it being a lot more enjoyable right because when you think part of the game you think like laugh out loud haha like crazy like craziness of like oh and then this doesn't have that it's more just and often they're groups team versus team or their groups yeah kind of thing and this one's definitely individual yeah right yeah but so i mean i definitely liked it um i probably kind of i'm halfway in between so i see this kind of strategy game but kind of a party game like that's where i'm at because like citadels to me it is a lot of strategy
and reading people because you're only taking it's nine cards and you take one of them yeah and they each do something different and someone is trying to kill one has to plan out who they're trying to kill but they're trying to target a specific person they don't know who it is yeah this you are doing similarly where i'm counting cards or at least tempting trying account cards for everybody but like by round three that's right it's like i yeah round three i was like everyone everyone's cards i knew you were playing the voodoo thing but basically you also said it but then like you both were like parrot and i'm like what happened because i died years ago how my parents are gonna get played this round but that's that's the cool thing is like i also like the fact that the treasures like depending on the number of players that's how many treasures there are right and none of them i mean they're obviously ones that are better than others there's the cursed relics but i like the fact that there's cards that will benefit you for taking because it's like if it was pure random it'd be annoying it'd be like oh great i'm going last again yes i'll take the curse relic but there's people in here that have ways of getting rid of them not taking them or not taking them or turning them yeah or even to the fact that you see that you're probably going to care cursed relic so you put out someone who's going to benefit you over a long period of time like the bar keep i was like okay i'm going to get something bad here yeah let's start getting that one to plume one turn earlier than i was originally planning for it yeah and turn that slightly negative that was going to basically be guaranteed to at least some
mitigated people yeah and it's not so party-esque that that it is just like right randomness like the the brute for example it's like you can hedge your bets and be like okay i think they all have a higher card than me they're probably going to play it right so i'll play it and you they have one play something lower so then he beats himself up right and there's so many times like i thought i was like oh the pair have been so useful here just right see what everyone else is going to play right um i will say there are some engines in the game but i feel like there's you can never really maximize them your voodoo witchdoctor was really good um but i think it was also at the time everyone kept killing your people prior so you didn't have to play the spanish officer to do it yourself right and i did so i'm like oh i could really maximize i can get rid of all of them now but i'm like no wait i i'm playing the cabin boy last therefore i have to play the voodoo witch doctor here therefore i have to play and so that's like i'm actually like a turn late so i'm not as efficient and that doesn't feel great right that's not that's just more of like man to play so it's like okay everybody's killing my stuff and the two cards i have out aren't benefiting me so let's just take there's a good treasure let's play number 30 the governor kills everything off and next turn maximize it yeah see what happens i think this game also has this is where the party s comes and if you come in thinking it's a full strategy game you're gonna get annoyed right if people keep killing your guys or you're trying to get the witch or not the witch it was the governor's daughter and you're like oh man i can't wait and then someone's like i'm gonna take the sword and kill her right and it's like
if you take that really personal it's like you're not gonna have a good time with it or even like right debating should you take the treasure or the sword because he thought well of course then i would take the circus why would i take the charisma i was like well because i have a card that's going to give me 60 balloons by doing it right right but yes sir has to remember if you played that right so stuff like that so somehow to me the strategy portion is i it's not really it could be lying but no i'm going to take the math yeah which influences decision do we have any negatives on the game the randomness is for me a little bit negative but it's not terrible the randomness of like start the starting instrument or the cards that you get that's interesting i like that actually because i think that's more variety and because it's zach mentioned it's kind of a party s game i don't take it this seriously so whenever i'm like getting the six i'm more excited like oh what six am i going to get it's kind of like it's kind of like it's it's it's like rolling dice like if you're if you're like i want to do this action and then you roll to see if it works that part pisses me off like war of the ring where you roll the dice and these are now your actions i like that more right because now it's like i wasn't anticipating something versus now here's what i got what can i make of that that's how i take the cards a little bit i think it's the mindset because i do feel like i want strategize i don't want to make engines work and then the cards don't pop up for it yeah and so i think that's where again it's probably just more me than anything else that's an actual game you guys got any any negatives
um i've just always viewed this game because i've been playing it this was like one of the first games i got i think i got scythe after this which was like my first big game but um i think i think i just see it as is what it is you know like i've never seen the negatives and it just because it is what it is if that makes any sense for sure sure um i think nostalgia helps a lot with like kind of overlooking things like you played with a very different mindset than i have true i come in as playing a lot of strategy games and i prefer them and we're each playing our own hands and we've got similar we can do the card counting we all know each other's powers yeah and i should say that it's the more people you play with the more of a party game it is the less you play with the more strategy is involved especially with three or four or four is kind of the in-between point i think four is like a good like yeah i i wouldn't play with less than four yeah i would agree i would play three would be very weird i played i never played with two um does it even play two i guess you wanted the new one play solo too but yeah this one does i don't know actually yes two to six yeah i don't know that that would be great but three works yeah pretty well six is fun as a party game i can see that yeah this is one of those that you we've mentioned it with the gaming group it's like everyone tries to play max players and i'm the one that's like no like max player sucks for most games and this one i would actually be like oh six players yeah i'll jump in on that yeah i kind of agree let's [ __ ] see what happens i kind of think again it would go more party-esque i think i would
enjoy this more and the four players is like oh it actually kind of requires some strategy here with six players i feel like three would be more cutthroat because in the swords it's like you and i aren't affecting each other and neither are they but three it's like everyone's dying all the time right so you trying to get your den to work it's just like you're getting they're getting killed all over the place it's like can you guys stop why are swords keep coming out right i don't think i played this at less than four yeah four is a good buffer yeah my negative is not really a fault of the game it but you know 10 years later it is dated the the wording on the cards it can be very frustrating i remember the first time playing this there were multiple times i'd play a card being like oh that's how that reads and it's like nah that's not how that works and it's like and because i've seen all of yours it's like well [ __ ] okay uh it's not really fair for me to take it back um like even with me when i was playing i mean you have a total of what 18 cards no there's more than that nine six six twelve so i don't know that you play that you'll play but you'll have you start out with six and you get one of nine nine right yeah um i didn't even remember some of the cards that i had gotten right and i could play like three games and not get certain cards like some of those cards right yeah yeah i hadn't played with in a really long time so yeah yeah and it's it's and it's just so stupid with the mistakes that it's like the the biggest one that happened in the run through was the preacher where it's like discard all booty titles but one it's like
okay that makes it think like oh haha because he's going last but he's really screwing everyone else over you know now that i think about it we've played it both ways before not not this group but my group and and various other groups so we've always played it worse i never really second guessed it i'm like okay that's the way we're playing it but yeah yeah i i guess i just never really think about it right and the biggest thing was the fact of they they have this token that's supposed to be like hey you're out of the game thing but they still say discard pile so the entire time we were thinking the parrot was like super like amazing or the surgeon right because you're like oh my god i get to go way back and then on top of that the pair with the surgeon is even better right um but that makes that makes sense because it's like discard pile but then it's like what the hell is this thing it's like no those are your out of game cards your egg and you said exiled i'm like yes just say exiled or something this book needs like a card by card explanation that would be nice right i we're we're comparing this to the other game i'm sure that remedy because their rule books are usually pretty adequate but right this one's only like six pages eight pages ten pages which for the game portion of it is plenty yeah um it's not like so detrimental once again if you're going into this as a strategy game then those miss words like the uh the ambiguity would be more frustrating right but if you're like at a lighthearted game it's like oh okay yeah whatever um i'll still take it and then i'll get rid of this whatever or what we did the first time oh you okay just you know take the card back and then shuffle up and randomize right if you have knowledge right that's really my only negative like
i i think this is a very fun game um good theme good theme like i wouldn't necessarily say the pirate theme shoots out like it's not like oh wow i really feel like but it's not i don't think it's really asking for that yeah like if you want a pirate game play merchants and marauders if you really want that whole shebang but but yeah um the art is is good i really like the the box cover um and i love how these are humans uh real life people there are a few animals but it makes sense to the real world there's a monkey it has a sexy feet for some reason i'm not naming any other games but but i mean you also have a parrot that already has you know heavy balls the parrot's a bubble is showing the whole time oh weird yeah if you look carefully they are can tell its own story but you have no idea what it is but yeah i i think this is a really good game um but in the obviously go check out the the run through for the the next one because we'll be able to actually compare them uh and we'll see we'll see how that works but you guys got anything else no no cool on a scale of one to ten uh what would you guys give libertalia i'll start with you because yours is gonna be probably the highest this is a nine for
nine yeah solid seven and a half like solid seven and a half and a half so now we're just getting 20 uh seven seven i'm actually at an eight like i surprisingly like whenever we first play this i'm like i i suck at these hand cards trying to be like i don't [ __ ] know let's try this but this one has has a variety so i'm gonna be at an eight right all right so that's our thoughts on libertalia less than we think of the game in the comments below other than another couple they do hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you