Skip to main content
Loading video...

Charterstone Review - Do You Want To Win? Or Just Unlock Stuff?

Transcript 8:30

Hey, I'm Alex Wackler from Board Gameco, and this is a spoiler-free review of Charter Stone, which is not a newer game by any means, but I did just finish playing through Charter Stone for the second time. This is a legacy game with a whole bunch of plays packed in. And I played it a while ago, maybe seven, eight years ago. I played it for the first time. That's a rough approximation. I don't know exactly when it was. And then I just finished playing through it a second time. And I figured a second full playthrough of this game deserves some brief thoughts and opinions. This is spoiler-free, which means, as usual with Legacy Games, it's slightly harder to give a like a real review of telling you what I liked and didn't like because I can't really tell you much about what I did. What I can tell you is Charter Stone is a worker placement game. It's a worker placement game where you're going to be building out your own little burrow and this board full of a bunch of burrows.

Depending on the player count, you can play all the way up to six players, which I can't imagine that being fun. I played it at three players and at four players were my two experiences. And I think it's a decent amount of of of experience for the people at the table. Although it does mean that to a certain extent you are filling in the other burrows to just with other players having buildings come out. There's a degree of cross-pollination in the experience that you will touch. But it will be different if you're playing a two-player game or if you're playing a six-player game. But that kind of concept aside, you are basically building out this board. You're placing various buildings stickers onto the board as you go and you're trying to get these cards. These cards are to unlock them and those will give you these crates and you're trying to figure out where to put your energy at any given point. Ultimately is worker placement to a degree. Pulling back your workers, trying to m be mindful of where everything goes, trying to manage your resources, but ultimately trying to get more cards into your system, more buildings on your board, and then slowly but surely expanding the universe you're creating or burrow. It's more of a it's more of like a a singular area that you are expanding past that. There is going to be a story element to it. The story element is going to have the whole king's mission that you're on and the things you're trying to do and how you're trying to build things out and all these magical ways and the quests you're being given, not magic. There's no magic in the game, at least not that I can recall. You're being given these these missions by the king effectively.

And you have to try to accomplish these things as you go through the sequence of missions. you are going to be marking off on a box uh getting progress along the way so you can start the game with more things, unlock more things, and you're trying to ultimately build up more points by the end of the game than other players. There is a scoring system in play. This is a competitive game where in theory there's a winner of every game, but how that feeds into the larger ecosystem of who won the overall story, that's going to be different. So, you can win a bunch of games and you can lose a bunch of games, but your overall progression in this game is going to be what determines the overall winner. So, it's cutesy art. It's worker placement. There's story. There there's mechanics. What do I think about this game? Well, I played it twice, which is already a good sign. Generally speaking, any legacy game that I dive into for the second time means that I enjoyed it enough the first time that I was like, "Yeah, sure.

I'm down to rewatch that season of TV." That's what it feels like. It feels like going back to a a season of TV you enjoyed once upon a time. When you dive back into a legacy game, you're like, "It's been six years since I watched The West Wing. It's time for another watch." The West Wing is fantastic, by the way. highly highly recommend it. Also, I don't know what that was. I I don't think I've ever done that in a video before. I don't I'm not going to be doing that again. But that said, it is it's fun. I I like playing through it. I think it's a cute, appealing game. I think it's uh very easy to actually learn. They do a good job of adding mechanics at a not too overwhelming pace and doing mostly so at the end in between scenarios, which I generally prefer. You do have this sense of progression as you build out your burrow, but you can also explore the overarching territory. So, it's not you're not overly confined to what you're doing. what you do is going to expand the world for everyone. The cards you unlock are going to slowly unlock in different ways for other people. And so you are going you are getting this general progression but also a degree of personal progression. There very much is that feeling of unlocking new stuff of just trying to get one more card, one more building before it possibly goes into the greater deck and then shows up in somebody else's hand next turn, next next game that you play. And so you are being mindful how you progress and you are being mindful about that general degree of the world slowly unlocking around you. Again, there's a degree of how the game will accommodate for not having a full player compliment, which means things will slowly be popping out here and there faster if you're playing with a higher player count. You'll have more unlocking at higher player counts, but it does do a good job at the overall progression. I don't think that there's any strong wow moments in the game for

me. There are lots of singular moments where new concepts are unlocked as you go through it. And I had I have enjoyed those concepts. But then there's also a degree of patterns to them. Meaning there's very often once you unlock something, you're going to see multiple instances of that thing unlocking across the next few games. And so there's a degree of like, oh, this is the new concept. Now, let's see how it expands outwards. There's all these other, again, this is a problem. I can't I can't go into specific details on these things. Uh, but there's degrees of progression and characters and things you'll unlock there that will give you missions you're trying to achieve. I'm trying to be vague how I approach this. you have missions you're trying to achieve based on the various characters and things in the game and you're trying to balance leaning into the things that work well versus making sure to spread out what you do so you can overall score better across the game. But the biggest thing for me is that this is each game is shortish coming in at 60 to 90 minutes per session I'd say. There's some towards the end they definitely can run a little bit longer but you're looking at 60 to 90 minutes a session.

The overall campaign is a manageable length, so you can play the whole thing across the course of a week or two, assuming your group is dedicated enough to sit down a few times a week and actually go through it. But you could play this across two weeks or it can take you a year. That kind of depends on your experience, your group, and your willingness to dive into it. Although with most leg with most legacy games, I highly encourage trying to get it done in 3 months or less. After that, it starts to just float into the uh your ability to hold on to what the experience is and where you are up to gets harder and harder the longer you pace things out. This is short. I recommend diving into it. Ideally, aim for a month or less for this one. I think it is manageable. Assuming you can get together like twice a week and play two games a session, you should be able to get it done. So, it's short. It's accessible. It's easy to learn. It's easy to teach. The rules come at a reasonable pace. The experience is there's no wow moments in this. This is not going to hit the the highs of my favorite legacy games. Things like Ticket to Ride Legacy, Pandemic Legacy.

This is not going to hit those highs. It never had that those absolute moments of what's going on here and what is happening. It's it just felt like a good worker placement game that evolves as you play through it and gives you more stuff to strive for. I've enjoyed it enough that I've played through it twice now. I played through the entire game twice now and I can see myself returning in the future. I'm not in a rush to. I have so many games to get to, but I can certainly see myself returning to it in the future. I think the cute artwork does pull it in. It makes it more accessible. It's a good first steps legacy game. It's not my first recommendation for a first step legacy game, but it is one that I I think it's a good second steps legacy game. Overall, my opinion of Charter Stone rating wise, I'm going to come in at a 3.5 out of five. I debated going to a four. If I play through this entire thing twice, it almost deserves a four, but ultimately there are no highs for me on this one. This is simply fun. I enjoy it. I have fun with it. I've done it twice. I can see myself doing it again.

I I didn't I I like it. I like the game, but there aren't those wow moments. That's the main thing for me. This game is held back by the fact that it is a legacy game that asks you to contribute a decent amount of time, and there's no wow moments. There's just like a slight desire to play one more game to unlock that card you just got and to try to get that into your system. They definitely has that aspect of of the one more game feeling, but that's kind of where it caps out. So, overall, an enjoyable experience that does a good job at being a good accessible legacy game that I've played twice now. So, a 3.5 out of five. As far as other legacy games to check out, the one most comparable to this that I did enjoy more is Rise of Queensdale. I think if you like Charter Stone, you should check out Rise of Queensdale and vice versa as well. I personally tilt towards Rise of Queensdale as being the slightly better experience. And then separately, if you wanted what I recommend as my go-to first recommendation for legacy game, check out My City. It doesn't have to be your first legacy game, but if you're looking for the most accessible legacy game that also delivers on a good experience, I think My City is a fantastic legacy game that I've played like nine times by now. It is simple, accessible, plays through very very quickly per session, and it's just it's just a good legacy game. So, definitely check that one out. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Game Co. Hope you found this review helpful, and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved