Luthier ►►► What did we think?
Transcript
hey everybody final thoughts time for luier the art of the instrument before I get to that please remember folks this was a sponsored preview and without way folks I have been really really Keen to check this game out for a while because it is from the Publishers designers developers of a monster hit that came out recently called distilled and man people love distilled I mean we covered it on the channel when it was crowdfunding several years ago Shay did a great run through of it and uh I was impressed by it at the time although I never particularly sought out playing it myself because you know full disclosure I come from a family of functioning alcoholics and I just don't like making spirits and beer in games it's just a theme that turns me off so while I always thought the uh the gameplay of it looked really really brilliant a nice midweight with so many interesting um you know things to keep track of and and all that but it was just never for me so I've always wanted to try to still with a different theme and that's why I thought luier was going to be you know you know transplanting from modern-day you know distilleries to uh you know 19th century classical music instrument making which is a theme that I absolutely love and it's certainly got presentation that I absolutely love with it's just Gob sming beautiful with art from Vincent Dupre of course and uh I was super excited what I didn't realize though folks is where distilled is a nice midweight uh Euro mostly is about card drafting you know you know taking turns grabbing cards from the market um you know putting them into play uh you
know uh distilling things aging things selling things all you know using special powers um this game this uh is like what if um designer VTO larta really liked distilled and said you know what I'm gonna make my own version of that turn it into a big super crunchy thing add a whole new gameplay mechanism because uh whereas the original game was just C Drafting and then using them here it's a very tricky and very deep worker placement game where we are sending out workers in Disguise uh because at the beginning game you've got your One your three and your five and over the course of the game you'll eventually get your two and your four as well plus you can buff them up with apprentices if you can afford them um and you send out to your workers and nobody knows what worker did you send where and then they've got to go man okay I want to perform too and you're already there and you went there with an apprentice does that mean was that your weak uh your worker with impr so you're only going there with a two or did you go with your strongest your five with impr so that's really a six are you going to try to do if you put on a performance are you going for the same one I am oh my gosh yes you are because I can see that your um uh Patron will respond just as positively as mine will you probably want to go there as well but what if you only went there with your four + one so I could beat you with my five plus one what if you went there with your 3+ one and you're noten even doing doing a performance you're
just trying to get some more building materials then I could beat you with my five and save my apprentices for other things that's the Crux of this game every but then that's only the first half because the first half of every round the game takes place over six rounds is we're deploying our workers in secret trying to anticipate right if I'm going to the same place as you are you're there first so ties break in your favor do I have to put more in invest more so the tie can break in my favor even if it means I'm going to be weaker someplace else that's also important to me cuz it's really important I get that Patron or that violin or you know that repair job or whatever it might be um you know but that's just the first half because then the second half once everybody's put their workers out uh players take turns deciding what areas to resolve and that can be just as filled with tension and Dread because you and I both went to that area I went there to do a performance um but I mean or no I went there not to do performance I just went there because I need to get those building materials I need those building materials before I go to the repair spot because I need those materials to do the repair that I want to do so I can finish off my Patron and get the huge payday so for me it must be perform and then repair that's how it has to play out and if I were in charge that would be the case but I'm sharing repair with somebody else and if they choose to to activate repair before I get a chance to
activate perform then all my plans go up and smoke and I've got to start pivoting which is a good thing then that every one of these areas has the main thing you can do but they have it a very strong alternative that okay crap you activated the repair I'm going to have to do this now hey you didn't even take the thing I want I could repair it but I did not get a chance to go to the market to buy the stuff I did not get a chance to perform to get the stuff so now I can't repair it anyway all right well well I'll get two wood and you know what that just saved me eight bucks so I can't complain too much I'm going to need that wood to work on my um pipe organ that I've yet to build anyway so uh that's a fallback and now maybe I should go ahead and grab that pipe or I was even thinking I was going to grab it but maybe now I should or the flute now that I've got some extra wood that I didn't think I was going to have because you made me Resolve my stuff in an order that was not optimal for me so this game pivots on these two really tension filled and incredibly interactive moments when you're deploying your workers and then when you're activating your workers and the key to success is knowing that okay I'm sharing that repair work replacement spot with Bob does he want to repair no there's none of the things he even cares about repairing so he's probably going there to get the wood or heck maybe he doesn't even care about either of those things because another thing you can do is you can go to an area not do either of the actions and instead just get a couple of bucks because you need money somewhere else but he might just be going there only to upgrade on the track so that he can get his upgraded super worker what
do I think he's doing because if I can figure out what you Bob want to do in repair I can make an informed guess of whether you're going to make that happen sooner or later and then I can make informed decisions about what I'm going to activate on my turn and that is freaking awesome this worker placement slash I mean it's a worker placement game and then separately to that it is a worker activation game there're like two different games um you know I mean gosh you know kind of Shades back to the old classic kis we put all our workers out and then we activate them that is something you very rarely see in modern design it's always put the worker out do what you want whereas this one you have all the tension of the setup and then unlike kis well kis had a little bit of un prly too because players could royally screw you over and destroy you and ruin your plans but this game isn't mean this one's just that oh you have to do repair first because you need to get that wood before you could do the thing you wanted to do and that meant I had to change my PL but it wasn't out of malice it was just the way it worked and if I can anticipate what you're going to do I can make the best moves possible for me navigating this space and that's freaking awesome and then on top of that this game then also has all the really cool stuff that people loved about distilled very done very differently I mean there's no aging of wines instead you um you know making you know the main thing we're here to do being luers which are traditionally um you know influential families that Focus you know Artisan crafts people who made beautiful uh instruments as work works of art it's a two-step process now you have to do the first step you have to do the Second Step are you going to spend two-thirds
of your workers just to do both of them on the same turn thereby giving up everything else on the board no um are you going to upgrade so that one worker can do two steps instead of one or get you discounts maybe it depends on what you focus on trying to do performances trying to focus on repairs trying to build stuff and that depends on what patrons you're able to grab but also what secret objectives you have for yourself and what public objectives everybody's ring for again very distilled like in that regard so there's some similarity but at the end of the day this game is really really different and really unique from most other worker placement games out there because of this two-stage process that gives you double the tension as what you would normally see in a really designed worker placement game um now uh you know I'm I'm really really impressed by it I have a couple of minor complaints uh one is why why does it come with this this game is already so huge it's such a huge table hog and then have to put this to keep track of players scores it's just ridiculous there could just be a single track on this main all you need is like an extra half an inch and then we could put our Victory Point trackers there we don't need I don't have enough table space to play this game fingers crossed the um developers decide before this goes to print because of course everything you're seeing today is prototype a lot of the cars have prototype art on it hopefully they see the air of their ways and just put a victory Point track on the main board because there's plenty of room for it plenty of room we don't need an extra board um and there's I know there's a
couple of things I know they're redesigning the layout of the cards and the boards and stuff like that so hopefully that's another thing they might think about uh but you know overall I got to say like distilled before it this is a very easy game to grock the iconography is super clear I mean there's uh you know I mean you've got this as a quick reference and I mean very rarely do I even need to look at it it's all so straightforward but because of that tension because of that angst I was talking about it is a very deep game too and it is a game that heavily rewards long-term strategizing okay I know I'm trying to go for that thing because that eight points on offer um but the only romance based Patron I can get needs three things done so it's going to take me a while to finish that um do I rush it oh nobody else has any romance um uh you know uh patrons I can afford to take it slow I'll get that done by round three and I know that's going to require this this this and this right so how am I going to deploy my workers to make sure I get that done by round three and what am I going to do with my remaining workers also bearing in mind that as the game goes on your Workforce gets bigger um when you go to round once you're round three after the first third of the game your Workforce increases by 25% and then it happens again for the final third of the game so that's an interesting thing too um everything I just talked about all that turn a in tension it's not quite there at the beginning of the game even when I mean as I was I mean maybe in a four-player game I haven't played a four-player game but I have played this as a two-player
game without the dummy player and with the dummy player and by the way I got to say I I know it's different designers I I I do want to give them a shout out let me look up who are the I I know Dave Digby was one of them because I recognized his name from something but I got to give a shout out to the other because this is one of the best AI opponents I've ever seen um you know I mean you know Dave DD and oh where are you d d oh come on did I open the wrong thing uh yes I did I opened up the main rule book not the solo rule book oh my goodness this is driving me nuts hold on and Richard Wood Richard Wood David Di and Richard Wood you guys should go get hired by autona Factory I mean this is really interesting uh these days and I'm sorry this is only for the solo players or for the two-player games who want a rich or more robust game it seems like often amaas are one of two types super simplified super streamlined don't really function like a regular player at all just have some very simple cards that let them I'm getting a little froggy here hold on right the uh nope I'm so froggy nothing to doing about that I guess they they don't rep replicate the functionality of a third player they just uh very simply replicate the output of a third player but then you've got the other end um you know typified by designer Dave churchy and others who go with the uh thing of Let's Make incredibly complex otoma characters that do everything a human player would do that somehow have procedural methods to make all the same decisions players would do so you really feel like you're playing against a human player but it requires a lot of overhead to maintain
this beautifully you know rides the line wi between them it's F it's simple it's fast it's elegant but it's not just about um you know replicating output it actually replicates players taking up spots grabbing activating things that I did not want to see activated yet and there you go and do it but me being able in the same way that I could look over at your board and anticipate what your priorities are I can see their priorities so smartly done Richard and David well done uh solo fans check it out you are really looking into it and two-player fans like I said as a two-player game without using it it worked really well but even when both players get up to where they have five workers it's a pretty wide open space and we didn't really find that tension happen very often but then when I brought the automa player in things got so exciting and and so terrifying in the best possible way so I mean the rules literally recommend after you've played a couple times to player to try bringing it in and if you do I think you won't regret it because it really elevates the experience and of course it's going to be great at a higher player count anyway um because of all that stuff I was saying up front all that said I I had one complaint it is something I'm finding myself saying more and more in these wonderful heavy Heroes boy this is long and I think it's unfortunately a little bit too long for me and Jen I really do appreciate it feels almost like this game has an Express mode because as part of setup I get what is it two instruments two patrons two families with special powers each um four objectives and then I have to cut in half so I feel like I'm starting out
really big I feel like I'm skipping you know rounds seven and eight that the game must have had at one point and just jumping right into it but even still the game gets so much more exciting in the second half once there are that many more workers being put out there but at the same time that's when I'm starting to get fatigued because it's a long game and when we get to the fin rounds five and six now each of us has five workers and the AI has five workers it's the longest it's ever going to be when I'm getting I'm it feels like I I really want to be speeding up this is something that I recently came aware of and i' never occurred to me before because of course this is I mean this is so common for games going all the way back to Agricola that hey over the course of the game you get more workers as the game goes on turns get bigger and more powerful and longer I should say rounds get longer and longer I mean this is what made AG gria great um or at least once upon a time that's what I thought but then recently I compared wingspan which I'm sure most people are familiar with with its spin-off game worms span and worms span which I did not like anywhere much as wingspan made me appreciate something wingspan does so beautifully and so brilliantly and then I thought back to other games that I've been super impressed by over the years like Mires um the idea that as the game goes on as we get more powerful as we're building up for the big finale there are mechanisms that take stuff away from us in Mires it was oh I've got to give up workers to latch in you know victory
points and actually it's the same thing for wingspan I love that and it makes it harder for me to be as excited about a game that the longer I play the longer it gets I like the I I think more and more I'm appreciating hey you know what the the longer it goes the faster things go as we start you know when we get into that third act and things are just zipping by at a mile a minute and every decision is so crucial because I'm not going to get another turn with all of my workers I got to use them all now um you know and again I'm sure I mean this game could have been 10 Rounds long or something like that and to be fair I mean what is it uh three turns uh six turns and then plus eight for the next two so that's 14 uh so 24 turns you're going to take you're going to get 24 worker placement action over the course of this game and that's not at all unreasonable uh it's per you know but I guess it's really just a reflection of where Jen and I are I am so finding myself appreciating these days more and more uh you know games that patch a huge punch in an under an hour time frame so I mention all this only to say that if you are like me um and uh you know you're you're looking for the Epic feel without the Epic length well um there are other games out there but and ultimately I mean I love so much about this game I love it's really clever thing and I'm hoping I I just find myself saying this all the time now uh ever since I mean I hope the industry
can see how incredibly popular it was that terraforming Mars introduced the Prelude expansion I'd love to see something for this I would love to see a fourr round version of this game um you know just to just so I could get it done because you know I mean you a version of this game that gets down to the distilled length I guess that's what I'm looking for I mentioned Vita larda up front and I stand by it I think this game could have been designed by him and I say that as the highest possible praise I can give a big crunchy meaty epic Euro that is still driven by simple clean elegant mechanisms that has always been the main stay oh and it is also incredibly strongly thematically grounded you make choices because of the combination of cage and res resources you have but those cards and resources are all driven by the theme this is what this person wants this is what I have to do this person is this type of person in the world of course that's what they want to see of course that's what they can do for me because it's all really thematically strong just like a great larda luier delivers um and I mean I know there's a lot of people out there who love that and so if you want that but with beautiful Vincent D tray art a wonderful new theme and a really very fun in the most agonizing way possible and I mean that in the best way possible worker placement take I've seen in quite a while well it might be worth checking out luier and uh that was the preview
folks thanks for watching have a very nice day talk to you later so long oh bye-bye