Top 50 Board Games of All Time - 40-31
Transcript
welcome back to my top 50 board games of all time today it's part two I'm currently on paternity leave in the future so hopefully I finished filming and editing these videos before the baby came if you really like my videos then I would really like your support on patreon and as a thank you you'll get five exclusive videos covering the rest of my top 100 as well as my monthly newsletter where I review games that I don't talk about on the channel become a patron at patreon.com forward slash actual and to see the rest of this series it's time to get serious with yourself and subscribe to the channel you can't expect the algorithm to lead you back here every time it's got things to do it's busy disenfranchising our youth right let's get to the list and number 40 is scroll or telestrations which is basically the same game and I have like a 50 50 combination of both of them to create what I think is like the perfect version of it it's a party game a drawing game and it's one of the funniest party games that you'll play like it's definitely not one that you're playing for the competition and for the points you're just playing it to have a good time with a big group of friends because what happens is you're given a prompt say for example pickle and then you have to draw that on the first whiteboard and then you pass that to the next player who doesn't know what the word is but can see that and they have to guess what you've drawn so then they write what they think it is on the next
one then they pass that word or phrase to the next player who then has to draw that the fun bit of the game is when you go back through at the end and you see the journey that everyone's whiteboards went on that it started off something simple like pickles and just ended up somewhere completely different and some of the people's interpretations but also their drawings is just what makes the game so entertaining and that's why I prefer scroll in terms of the prompts because they get you to draw things that are way more difficult and creative but that means that you end up with way bigger misunderstandings and confusions and just hilarity I've tried my best to do karate chopping a frog but this is all I'm capable of and then of course the next person thinks it's stroking a frog and then it'll end up completely different by the end of it so you just get crazier Journeys you can still have fun with just basic telestrations but I really prefer the scroll prompts but what I like about telestrations is that it comes with these whiteboard flip books that just make the game so much easier to play tells you what you need to do on the next round they even have different colors for the Rings so you know which is your whiteboard so I used to have both versions and now I've managed to cram all the telestrations boards into scroll with their prompts and created like a bastardized version this used to be a lot higher up my top 50 is one of my favorite party games of all time but I just haven't had the
chance to play it as much lately because I can't get those big groups together it's best with like eight players or more because you get a much bigger Journey that the words and the drawings go on and so therefore it just you get more enjoyment out of it playing it with smaller groups it just doesn't have that same feel so I would always turn to other games instead but still a brilliant game and if you do have that kind of huge group or family then definitely check out scroll or telestrations and number 39 is carcasson hunters and gatherers this is my preferred version of Carcassonne because it's a bit meaner it's a bit more dramatic and it still retains the things that I love about Carcassonne so this is a tile laying game where you are taking a tile on your turn and adding it to the map you're expanding out this land of rivers and forests and Fields and animals and you have meeples that you are going to put down on spots to claim them to try and get points in the original game getting a Road tire was often disappointing because you only get one point for each of them but in this the rivers score not just for each tile of the river but there's fish in them so some tiles will have more fishing than others and they get you extra points you also have these Huts that you can place on an entire river system so we're talking about going Beyond The Lakes which are like the end points of the rivers you get to school for every single fish in that entire river system so that could be the
entire board by the end of the game and that encourages other players to try and piggyback off of it to try and build a Hut that's adjacent and then connect up to your river system later so that they score those points as well so it makes the game a lot more competitive in terms of trying to steal points from each other which you can do in the original carcasson and happens occasionally but in this it's there's a much bigger reward for it and so therefore you're much more likely to want to do it the forest tiles are more interesting because if you complete one with one of these standing stones in you get a special tile off of this stack and all these tiles are more powerful than the original ones so this is a lake with three fish in and you get to place that in addition to your tile so it's not about the person that controls the forest it's about the person that finishes the forest so there's actually an incentive to finish other people's Forest which will give them points just so you can get one of these special tiles and I like the hunting more than the farming in Carcassonne firstly because it's just more straightforward forward if you place in a field you're connected to all the animals that are there and you're going to score points from them but also the animals scored different amounts of points so if you're buying a woolly mammoth that's worth three points whereas the deer are only worth one point and I find there's less frustrating turns in this game in carcasson you can so often get a tile that just useless to what you're currently working on whereas in this you almost always get an animal come up on every tile so you can add that to your hunting even if it doesn't improve your
forest or your River so there's there's never nothing to do and the final rule that I really like is that you don't get any points for forests and rivers that aren't completed by the end of the game so there's a real incentive to get them done and you can really get stressed out by the tiles running out and knowing that you're not gonna have enough time to do it whereas in the original Carcassonne you get like half points it's sort of it's making the game softer more welcoming to newbies but I like that threat I like the possibility T that no I didn't get it done in time well then I'm punished for it for me this really feels like a carcasson 2.0 the magic of Carcassonne is still there with the simple taker tile Placer tile and knowing when to use your meeples and not but there's just a few extra twists that elevate it above and I'd always rather play this version that's carcasson hunters and gatherers and number 38 is high society this is one of my favorite small box card games from my favorite designer Reina kanitzia it's an auction game with an amazing twist which is that if you've spent the most money by the end of the game you're out you can't win the reason for that is you are playing as the high society You are bidding on luxury objects but if you've spent the most money by the end of the game then you're not rich anymore you're not part of the high society and therefore you don't count every round a card will get flipped and you'll be bidding on it until everyone passes except one and then that person pays the money and wins that card and it's worth
points you're trying to get the most points to win but you're bidding with a fixed hand of cards everyone has the same amounts of money so you've got like a one a two a three a 10 or 15. once these cards are spent you won't get them back again so you can get into situations where you're having to bid more than you'd want to simply because you just don't have the right change to be able to bid what you want another great thing about the game are the disgrace cards and when they come out you're bidding to not take them because they're going to punish you they're going to get you half the points that you currently have or lose one of the cards that you've already bought so you're bidding to not accept that until one person takes it for free and everyone else has to put in the money that they've bid so you're making everyone else poorer which is great because then they're gonna have less money later to be able to bid on the cards that you want it's a game that really swings around with every turn you really feel like this person's winning then this person's winning and then it's over to them and you're just trying to time it right to have just the right amount of points but not spend too much when the game ends and the game always ends in a hurry it's such a strong Punchy idea you can't get such a quick brilliant game in such a tiny box as high society and number 37 is spicy this is my favorite bluffing card game you each have a hand of cards that have got three types of hot things you got pepper wasabi and chili numbers one to ten
and one person is going to start you off they're gonna pick a suit they're gonna play a card too chilly then you have to follow that you have to go higher than it and play the same suit you're playing it face down if you don't have it you can declare whatever you want but if they challenge you they're going to reveal the card and if you're wrong they're gonna win that stack as points but when they challenge you they have to decide are you lying about the number or about the suit so they think it's not a chili but it turns out it is it's just the number was wrong that means you win the stackers points you're trying to get rid of your hand and if you do you get a 10 point bonus but the game allows you to decide when to lie because sometimes you'll play cards and they're fine other times you don't have a card that fits the suit you can just draw off the top of the deck add a card to your hand it means you're much less likely to get rid of your hand but if you get called out for cheating and they're right you have to add two cards to your deck anyway so if you know that you're about to cheat and someone's gonna catch you you don't think you can Bluff it this round because you've got like one card left then actually maybe it's better to just take one card off the top and stop them from going away with all those points I love that it has that pure immediate bluffing of I'm playing a card and I'm telling you what it is and I could be looking you in the eyes and lying to you and you have to decide if I am or not but that extra decision of am I lying about the suit or the number makes the
game that bit more interesting because they're playing a bit with deduction of what are they most likely to have is could be likely that they have a 10 but we've played so many chilies at this point are they really gonna have a chili left but there's also a really interesting sort of dramatic reveal to it which is that you know they're lying but you don't know which bit it's about and so there's kind of a 50 50 success of whether you're gonna catch them it evens out the game a bit because you could be not that good at bluffing but still get away with it a few times just because they keep challenging you on the wrong type of thing ultimately I'm comparing this to skull and Cockroach poker which are like the definitive simple bluffing games and spicy is just slightly above them for me I still love those two games I have them in my collection but skull is just a bit fiddly to introduce to new players like it takes quite a few rounds to understand the rhythm of it there's only one loser in cockroach poker whereas in spicy there's one winner that you collect the most points and you win on your own and I just find that a bit more satisfying bluffing is one of my favorite aspects of any game it's interactive and social I'm not brilliant at it I feel like I have good days and bad days but it's always fun for that challenge and I really enjoy the challenge of trying to read my friends faces and trying to grasp whether they're lying to me and this is the purest simplest form of that kind of game so if I want that feeling but I want it on a train or in a pub then I'm gonna take spicy with me
and number 36 is K2 a game about climbing the mountain of K2 you each have two climbers that you're sending up as high as possible and trying to keep them alive and that's what I love about this game is that your characters can die you have two of them and if you don't manage their acclimatization properly if you send them up too fast or if the weather hits really bad then you can just have a character die and that's it you're gonna get no points for them so you're trying to get the most points possible and ideally you'd get both your characters to the peak and that would get you 20 points but the chances of that are pretty slim because it's a busy Mountain it's very hard to survive and you've got other players getting in your way the system of how you move is really simple you have a hand of six cards and you choose three to play every round and some will be faster than others some will be good at getting you up fast some down fast and others are meant for acclimatization which is tracked on your board if you don't look after them that's when they're going to hit the bottom and that's how they can die as you get further up the conditions are so bad that it's knocking points off of them every turn and then you've got the weather to deal with I love this about the game is that you have a forecast for the next six days so you can see that today is sunny it's not going to affect you but tomorrow you're going to take one damage but only at certain altitudes higher up the mountain and then later in the week you're gonna get two damage so you have to plan for that make sure that
your acclimatization level is high enough so that you'll survive and you use this forecast to help you time when you're going to make your ascent and pick which path you're gonna take the other thing you have to massively factor in is where all the other climbers are because as you get closer to the peak the paths narrow and they can only take one two or three people at any one time so you can be in a position where you're at the top you made it and got all those points but the other players if they're not getting out of your way you can't come back down so it's really tight especially in a four or five player game and you can be in positions where players are basically trying to leave you to die at the top because they know that you need to come down to be able to survive and they're not going to let you do that and that's what I love about this game is you have to factor in what the other players are doing for example every round everyone reveals their cards and how many movement points they're gonna play and the player who plays the most has to take a risk token which ultimately is going to be removed from their movement or from their acclimatization level so they get punished for being the riskiest player that round I love the decision of when you're going to make your ascent and how far you're gonna ultimately go you could win the game and not get to the peak with either of your characters because the weather was just really bad and everyone else died there's a really fun balance of things affecting your decisions with the timing of the weather where the other players are and then the cards that you're getting every round
and the Jeopardy of your character actually dying and that really hampering your chances of winning the game makes every decision feel that much more important I wish I had more games like this that managed to capture their theme be interactive and competitive with interesting decisions and yet seem so easy to get into is 13 years old at this point but there's no beating it for this theme that's K2 and number 35 is Hollywood golden age and this is another auction game from my favorite designer Rhino canitzia this has come under many names over the years tram fabric Dream Factory nowadays in English it's called nightmare Productions about horror movies but my version is Hollywood Golden Age so you start the game with some empty screenplays to some famous movies so I've got here Casablanca and high noon and they have slots that need filling so Casablanca needs a director an actor a composer once you've filled up the necessary spots that's when you can release the movie and you're gonna score points for it and the points you'll get for it depends on the star quality of the actors and directors that you've hired for it and the way you get anyone is by winning auctions so this car will drive around the city of Hollywood and then it will get to a new location and you will bid on all of the items at that location the person who pays the most will win all of it and then distribute it amongst their movies as they wish so here we've got Henry Fonda Greta Garbo
Marlena Dietrich a composer that's three stars and an agent that's three stars the bidding is super simple you've got a bunch of cash and you take it in turns to make a bid but what happens with that cash when you spend it is that it goes to the other players that didn't win so you're splitting up the money the money always stays in the game so at some point you'll be really rich because you haven't bought anything in a while but if you've just spent big then you'll have nothing and you know that your opponents have quiet a lot so it's an interesting Dynamic it means you can't win too many auctions in a row and I like that you're bidding on these Lots so you have to decide the value of five tokens some of which you want some of which you don't you're not always going to get three stars of everything to fill up your movie but the game is incentivizing you to hold out and make that Perfect movie because there's an Oscar given at the end of every year to the best film made that year and then at the end of the game there's even more Oscars going to the best movie in each genre there's also extra points for making the worst movie of the entire game the B-movie award so you can swing in the other direction and that can be a fun challenge like racing to get to the bottom against another player I like that you can look ahead on the board and see what's going to be available later on so you know whether to spend all your money now because that's the best it's gonna get or save it for later when you really want to bid on Cary Grant because he's exactly what you need your movie
another nice touch is that you have two Hollywood parties on the board those tiles are face down you can't see what's in them when you get there you flip them over and the person that gets the first pick is the person that has the most actors and stars casted in their movies currently so it's like this Hollywood Connections thing if you're in touch with enough famous people you're gonna get into the party first and you're gonna get first dibs on the best offering there it's a really enjoyable theme to be a part of you've all heard of these movies and these actors and casting them in roles that don't suit them I love that they were able to go with real people and real movies because some versions of this game have just gone with like fake things because of copyright reasons and this one just brings it alive that bit more but it's not just about the theme I've played a lot of other movie games that just don't hold up Hollywood golden age is a great auction game that just happens to have a really Pleasant theme on top of it and number 34 is foundations of Rome this is one of the newer games in my top 50 and quite a surprise for me that I like this game this much because it's a huge over-produced Kickstarter game in a massive box but unlike most overproduced Kickstarter games this one has simple rules and really Punchy gameplay it's a city building game you are building Rome on a shared board and that in itself is a rarity because most city building games have you building your own City in
a personal area you're trying to buy lots that are adjacent to ones you already have so you can build bigger buildings there's three types of buildings commercial is going to get you more money when you do income so that's going to allow you to buy more stuff residential is going to improve the population and there's a population track that you're trying to stay ahead of to get more points than anyone else and then you've got Civic buildings and these are the most interesting in terms of placement because they're gonna score of what they're adjacent to on the board so you're watching as the city develops seeing where people put their residential buildings and thinking if I can get a spot next to that I can piggyback off of them they're getting points off of building a residential building but I can get points off of them for being next to their residential building and the bigger the more people that are in it the more points you'll get it's all about spotting opportunities and getting in there before everyone else you want to be buying the Deeds so that you can build but you also want to be building so that you've got better income so that you're staying ahead on that population track and of course you want to be taking income because then you're not going to have any money to be able to buy anything you might see the deed come up for a lot that you really need but when it comes into the market it's gonna cost you a fortune how long do you wait for that price to decrease before you buy it because someone else might jump in and get it instead of you because they know how important it is for you it's such a
great level of interaction because you can't destroy anyone's plans but you can buy Deeds that they need and there's this constant frustration and having to adapt based on what everyone else is doing that I really love in games it's my favorite city building game because it has those typical adjacency rules of where you want to build and making plans and trying to stick to them but it introduces other players building in the same city of you which is how it should be I don't love that it's this Mega overproduced thing I'll never be able to put it into a rucksack and take it to game night but it's such an interesting different experience that I'm glad to have in my collection and number 33 is Isle of Skye this is a tile Lane game crossed with a sort of auction game and it's a lot more interesting than this cover and this theme would have you believe you're each building your own personal area of the Isle of Skye so you've got mountains and locks and grassland and then you've got cattle in sheep and boats and whiskey barrels but the way you get your tiles is the most interesting thing about this game every round you each draw three tiles out the bag and put them in front of your Shield these tiles are now up for grabs and you're gonna set the price of them behind your Shield then everyone reveals so I've put this tile at five gold whereas this one at 10 and this one I've act that's going out of the game you have to do that with one of the three so other players now have the opportunity to buy one of my tiles or
from in front of another player but they have to pay my price and they pay that price to me so I'm setting a price hoping that they're gonna pay it to make me more money or I'm hoping to be able to get that tile myself if I set it high enough then no one else will be able to afford it or they'll think I'm charging too much so if nobody else buys this for 10 then I will pay the 10 to the bank and I get that tile and add it to my Island I love that dynamic because you really have to understand the value of everything and see how much money other players have going into it but also see the tiles that they're going to have available if you put all your money down here to set the price for this tile then you won't have any spare cash to be able to buy that really good tile over there the reason you want some tiles more than others is because of the four objectives these change every single game and they also change which rounds they score so in the first round you're scoring objective a then be then A and C then B and D so the timing of when you need stuff is really important a here wants completed mountains this one wants lots of cows this one wants a really big lake and this one is scoring points for sheep so in some games sheep and cows and mountains are really important in another game it's going to be locks and whiskey barrels and uh lakes with boats in every game is completely different whilst the tile laying puzzle is interesting it's really this price setting mechanism that is what I love about this game I would love to see it
in other games because it adding this element of interactivity of worrying about what everyone else is doing in a game where you're still very much building your own thing I played this one just the other week and I was reminded how solid and how different this game is and number 32 is Chronicles of crime which is a crime-solving Cooperative game where you play as detectives trying to solve a murder the way you explore the story in this game is by using a phone app you scan the QR codes that is on the character's cards to interrogate them and you can ask them about other people and things by scanning that QR code which is what I love about this game there's complete freedom to ask someone about anything that you've previously seen and the game doesn't hold your hand telling you what to ask them about you really have to realize for yourself and it makes you feel like a proper detective because you feel like actually if we ask them about the blood that we saw here that could open up this whole thing and sometimes it will and sometimes it won't and when it does it feels incredible like you really broke through in the case there's a little bit of text in that phone app to answer every possible question that you could ask of all of the 30 characters in that particular case and that's why it uses a phone app because that wouldn't be possible using an analog book the other great thing that the app is used for is to give a 3D image of the crime scene that you can look on your phone and move around the room to spot evidence so
you'll be shouting out to the other players I can see blood in the corner there's a broken bottle there's some papers and they're going through this deck of evidence cards trying to find the things that match so that when you're no longer looking at that VR scene you can scan the codes of those things and see which of those is relevant evidence then once you've got them if you find the right papers you can then go back to the characters that you previously talked to and ask them about them and see what they know so if you're not observant enough and you don't spot the right thing in the corner of that crime scene then that's a whole range of questions that you won't be open to I play this game exclusively with my wife it's a really good two-player game and I really love just discussing theories with her and you'll start the game where you've got an idea that it's this person and then you go on a journey just like a classic whodunit and it ends up being someone entirely different and it's not just the base game I love I've played all through the Noir expansion which is 1950s detectives in La the welcome to Red view expansion is like a stranger things type story and then you've got the Standalone expansions uh 1900 and 1400 that I've played and I would recommend all of that so that is a lot of content to get through and that's there's a real depth with this game and I would say that they all hold up with each other they're all over really good quality it's not my favorite crime solving game there are others further up this list I don't love having to play with the app it's a little bit clunky at times but what it
unlocks is that ability to ask any question of any character and that's sort of completely unrivaled in any other crime solving game so I really like that USP of Chronicles of crime and absolutely this one is going to stay in my collection so that I can just continue to play all the extra content that comes out for it and number 31 is deep blue this is a push your luck game about diving for Treasure you've each got two boats that you're sending out to diving spots when you go diving you're going to be drawing gems from the bag hoping to find gold silver and rubies and not find the hazards the sea creatures and the oxygen issues that I mean you're gonna have to resurface and stop getting any more treasure it's classic push your luck you keep twisting until you either stick and go home with what you've got or you go bust but the twist that I love about this game is that you're pushing your luck collectively you might go diving with three or four other players but one of you is the leader they have this diving bell and only they are drawing from the bag and deciding when you stop so they might push their luck too far and that means that none of you end up with anything except not every diver is equal you can always take one Hazard of either color and not go bust but the second one means you will unless you have a card to protect yourself and some divers will have these cards and others won't so the leader might end up being able to stay down longer than everyone else whereas the others will have to resurface there are also cards
that will score you more points for certain gems if you draw a purple card and you have this crew member that's going to get you Five Points because they're a specialist in that type of artifact but if someone else who doesn't have that card draws it it's useless to them they get nothing so it gives you an incentive to keep pushing your luck to get certain gems but that might not be the interest of the other people that are on the dive and if you get to the dive site early you can pick one of the scouting spots that's going to give you a massive Advantage so if you Scout for rubies if a red gem comes out you're gonna get 10 points for it if you Scout on that spot it means that everyone has different reasons to stick or twist at different times and everyone's watching the gems being drawn out having completely different reactions to what's happening some are begging the leader to stop so that they survive and at least get something whereas others are encouraging the leader to keep going because they know that they'll be safe but they want to screw over the other players who they want to get nothing out of this dive and that's what I love about this game there's such a communal atmosphere to the push or luck that everyone is invested in it I really like the card system in this game because when you play a crew member it then goes into your bunk you can't use it again until you do a rest action which is where you spend your whole turn to shuffle up the cards that you've used and get three of them back but when do you do it because if somebody's just about to go and dive far away you want to use a card to move there to get to that dive spot but if you don't have your good high scoring cards in your
hand when you go diving then you're barely going to make any points out of it so it's a waste of time anyway so you're really trying to balance getting new crew members that's going to get you lots of points making sure that you're at the dive spot so that people don't dive without you and resting so that you've got your good crew members back in your hand for when you're about to dive I'm amazed that this game didn't do better I think that people just hate giving over control of that push your luck to another player but for me there's a real excitement in it you don't have to go on a dive with someone else but it's usually going to benefit you and you can protect yourself by having the right crew members when you get the turn to be in charge it feels so much more powerful because you're not just controlling your own destiny but everyone else is as well it's the same team as heat pedal to the metal that absolutely blew up recently and for me they're very similar it's light rules Innovative mechanisms and really entertaining gameplay I played this one just the other week and was reminded how much I love it that's deep blue those are my favorite games of all time numbers 40 to 31. if you'd like to buy any of them there are links in the description below to see the rest of this series please subscribe to the channel I'm John perkis thanks for watching thank you