Skip to main content
Loading video...

GrimBrew - Alchemical efficiency & you - TCbH Review

Transcript 6:13

Alchemy. Basically the same thing that your weird aunt Tina is into with all the rocks and creams and whatnot, except while wearing a funny hat. Well, Grim Brew, a new upcoming game by Lucky Omen Studios, is all about alchemy, collecting ingredients, crafting potions, and well, you know, having the most points. One of the key features of this game that I both like and don't want to underell is how easy to pick up it is. Three potions and three ingredients sit up on a central display. And on your turn, you take one and only one action. Either snag an ingredient, rekindle two of your flames, the why that we'll come to, or brew one of the face up potions, exhausting a fire, told you, and completing its ingredient list from left to right with unique symbols, effectively properties of your ingredients. This is the killer feature of the game. The logistics to which all cool things in this game hang.

One ingredient may contribute two or even three different symbols needed for a card, but if the potion needs, say, two skulls or two green wavy lines or whatever, those have to come from separate symbols on that or other cards. And furthermore, you can partially complete a potion using fewer than the full five ingredients to get the desired outcome. However, you get more points the further you go to the right. And you can't skip any of the steps. You have to go in order from left to right or stop if you choose not to or just don't have the ingredient on that step. But you now have to think about, do you want to complete it early because you want all those points, but you also want the ability that's on the bottom and you want to take advantage of the potion being available on the display. And won't someone think of the action economy? In either case, the potion itself is moved to below your personal board and permanently gives you either a discount on one of the six components or some endgame scoring bonus. And more or less that's it. Well, that's not it it but big picture-wise that's it. You just continue playing until the pool of victory points set out based off of player counts is sucked dry. Then you finish out the round and the player with the most points wins. It's neat, tidy, and the drive for efficiency combined with action limitation makes for some easily understood but pretty satisfying

decisions to be made in the game. Now for a couple odds and ends. Okay, let's talk maulings. And to talk maulings, we got to talk about ingredient bonuses. Most ingredients have some little one-time effect, a snackable ability, snability if you will, that comes when you grab it from the market. Light fires, spend some fires for points, or in several cases, place or remove modelings. three of your colored little critters that are sent to other player boards who, if left unchecked, snag the first point gained by them brewing a potion and bringing it back to you. In a clinical sense, this is a clever, efficient way to balance out the game, and you can target the lead player. You can use them as a deterrent. They are flavorful. I like them, but they only go so far. for having a full page in the rule book just as much as the entire how to play section. I felt like their impact fell short of their potential, which goes on to some of my criticism of the game in general.

Grimbru is a good fun game with interesting if relatively light choices, but there's a real sense of equivalency to everything that stifles some of its identity. Every type of ingredient feels roughly the same. essentially different suits and symbols that don't amount to actual vibes. Leaning heavy into skulls doesn't make you feel any more necroantic than your average alchemist and all that. And this isn't too unusual for this type of game. From Splendor to propolis to many games in between, but the flavor as presented from the vibrant illustrations on the cards and the evocative magical theme to the subtitle itself and this kind of anime box art, a battle of flame and potion craft hints at what could be. Similarly, I would have loved for the Mlings to have just an extra hook or two to be exploited.

Committing them for other reasons or having some guaranteed way of putting them out as they are, they're fine, but the potential is there. The last little criticism I have is to do with the fact that Grimbru is a very narrow game. That's not the criticism itself. I more or less like that, but for its scope, it takes up a big amount of space with player boards and box size and whatnot. for as efficient as the design is. I would have loved the production to be the same. That's totally a preference and probably more a consideration for when you're some idiot reviewing games and constantly worrying about shelf space. But damn it, I'm nothing if not honest. It's by no means ostentatious, but it could have been trimmed down a bit. As is though, it's a game that I enjoyed. It's easy to teach. It's quick to play. And it does something unique with the potion crafting and ingredient order that really makes you think about action economy and how much you want to invest in these potions. You know, are you going to try to save out for a big payout later or do you want to get that sweet sweet efficiency of extra bonuses right now? If you dig lighter games that still have a degree of engine building and resource management that also have evocative fantastical themes, then I think that you're probably going to dig Grim Brew. And that's our review.

But let me know, what's your favorite game about potion craft or alchemy? Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing the things that help this channel grow. Even [snorts] just spreading the word about this channel, sharing these videos is a huge help. So, thank you for doing that. But above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for the cardboard Harold.

Progress saved