TDG: Cody's Top Ten Introductory Wargames (December 2023)
Transcript
hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer say why do Twitter users make such bad soldiers they're always too quick to retweet ladies and gentlemen today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 introductory war games all right ladies and gentlemen so uh what we're going to do today in introductory war games these are games that I think are great games to get people into the hobby of War gaming to uh you know just very light games that they they can give them the flavor of wargaming they may want to graduate to something a little more meaty um but uh I I kind of debated did I want to do this list based on you know 10 to one what was the easiest games to get into which are the most accessible ultimately I decided no because that's a little more subjective so I just I did what I usually do based on fun how much fun do I have with these games that that is kind of my ultimate criteria here for this list now I should also point out this list contains multiplayer games and there are a few solitary games on this list as well but they're all fairly light fairly accessible war games so let's just go ahead and jump right into it my number 10 is Napoleon returns uh 1815 from Worthington games Napoleon returns 1815 is a pretty straightforward game in which uh you can play up three players uh two to three players um one side of
course is Wellington and Bluer the other side is Napoleon and essentially you're moving these armies along point to point during the waterl campaign now when you have your core you have various core that have health points and when your core comes to battle you then of course are going to draw a number of uh cards and so depending on your position the strength of your core y yada you're going to draw a number of cards and then you go back and forth you play the cards this is similar to like the We the People combat system where I play right flank then you have to match right flank and then we roll for initiative and then you know I play center attack you play center attack and then I play artillery then you have to play artillery and we keep going back and forth where the person with the initiative plays a card and the other person has to match that card as soon as somebody can't match the card then they lose the battle so ver I love that card combat system I think that is such a fun car uh card combat system and this is a great way to introduce people into kind of ideas of maneuver and combat um and and really enjoy it quite a bit so that is Napoleon returns 1815 that is my number 10 and that is from Worthington my number nine is a game uh a solitire game that I first played years ago when it was released by Victory point games and I've recently played it again since it was released by uh uh tabletop Tycoon they I think they've redone Victory point games but this is hapsburg eclipse and I could easily put ottoman sunset here which I had not played before until just recently but they're very similar games um but hapsburg eclipse of course you
are uh the rulers of Austria Hungary you're in Vienna during World War I and you have various uh tracks coming at you it's a stage of Siege game so you have various military fronts coming at you and every turn you're you're drawing a card the card is telling you which fronts are advancing um it's it's also telling you you you may have rebellions in certain parts of your country um you know like Hungary or or Czechoslovakia or or Slovakia Slovenia whatever there there's various tracks that are uh going into rebellion and so then you get certain action points so you can go ahead and you can spend those action points to push the armies back you can try to stabilize the rebellions in your country um and there's various other things you can do there's very other things you can do there's offmap battles like battles on the Western Front or at Sea that you can kind of contribute res sources too in order to make it more likely that your the access powers will win that you can get help from Germany that can help you on some of the die rolls so it's it's it's really a fun game of just kind of Holding On by your fingernails as all your enemies are advancing tremendously fun game I love it quite a bit this is number nine that's hapsburg Eclipse that is from Victory point games tabletop Tycoon my number eight is a game I played fairly recently and this is really cool because it's a game that combines a traditional war game with a more conventional uh hidden movement game and this is the hunt from Salt and Pepper games now in the hunt one of you takes on the role of
the royal Navy one of you takes on the role of the German cigs Marine with the Admiral graph spay and you are moving your ship offboard that is to say you're writing down where you're going You're trying to hunt down convoys and Destroy them meanwhile the British are trying to get their convoys home and they're trying to hunt down the the grass spray you're playing cards this is CDG essentially you're playing cards that you can either trigger the events on or you can trigger the or you can play it for the action points the action points give you a lot of abilities to move and to and to search for your enemies and what have you but there comes a point in the game where you may trigger a battle and if you trigger the battle then you two are actually playing cards to to to fight each other and again playing them for either the events or for the points but really really fun game it's a great like I say mashup of war game and hidden movement game really enjoy it quite a bit this is the Hun that is from Salt and Pepper games that's my number eight my number seven is a game I played fairly recently uh this latest iteration I played the earlier iteration before but this is bismar solitire Deluxe great great solitire game I think to get people into the hobby because again it's it's very simple it's you you you can move your ships youve got the bismar the prince Yen and a German uboat you're playing the German and you're moving them in the Atlantic and then you roll a die and you roll a couple of dice and the dice tell you where where they give you kind of a grid and it tells you where certain British ships are operating so you may find yourself in combat you may find yourself with with targets of opportunity like convoys and
whatnot but if you get into combat then you have a roll off against them and it's a pretty simple usually a 5050 on a d D6 roll but you can engage in tactics you can close in where your where your where your Firepower counts for more but you're more vulnerable where you can pull back where you're less likely to get a hit but you're less likely to be hit so you you have some options there and there's a lot of different missions that you can play so there's some variety there but I really like bismar solitar deluxe that is a fun engaging game and it's easy to learn easy to play and I think it's a great solitire game to get into uh the hobby with so this is number seven that's Bismark soliter Deluxe and that is from Worthington number six is a game that I another game that I just played this year for the first time and this is a game of aerial combat this is fighters of the Pacific uh fighters of the Pacific is is a great game where you have these groups of Fighters on hex's and you are attacking your enemy but there's also ships that you can go after and and and Targets on land and whatnot but how it works is you have altitude if you're on one side um your fighters on one side they belong to one altitude but you can switch their altitude you can flip them over so they're different they're lower altitude or higher altitude but whenever there are groups that are together they're flying inform formation that gives you higher initiative and then as soon as they break up you H have more individual groups then You' get lower initiative and so it it really pays to have groups flying inform formation but as soon as you make contact with the Enemy that's
harder and harder to maintain so it's a really really fun and interesting game now the only issue here is and it's not an issue for me because it totally works for me here normally I'm not a fan of it but it works for me here and that is deterministic comat meaning if you've got an enemy in your firing uh Arc in your line of sight in the range they automatically take a hit um unless they haven't been activated they can they can they can activate to get out of the way but other than that they're going to take a hit so there is some deterministic combat for those of you who love Dice and I do love Dice and normally I don't like deterministic combat but it just works here it's actually super fun fighters of the Pacific is a fantastic aerial war game that is again super easy to play super easy to learn and easy to teach great introductory war game that is number six that is fighters of the Pacific that is from Aries games my number five um gosh this is another one I played this year no was it this year or last I think it was earlier this year either earlier this year or last year I can't remember not too long ago but this is another solitire game and it's another game maybe a hair more complex than some of the other um soliter games I've said but still I think this is a good introductory game because it's not that complex and this is Stalingrad Advanced of the vulga 1942 this was a game that I played that just blew me away way first of all with just how much fun it is but also too it's it's relative Simplicity essentially you are the Germans you're moving into Stalingrad and you are you have your
units um you're you're when you attack you're assigning a lead unit but you have other units coming in but when you move into a space with a with a Russian unit you just you flip it over you don't know what it is you know the terrain but you don't know what it is and these different events trigger and you have to fight based on these events and it's so good and you're trying to bring in support you're trying to bring in artillery and aircraft and other things that are going to support your attack to give you the numbers you're going to need and the problem is for all the attacks you got to do because you only got so much time to do it all the attacks you got to do there isn't enough support and you got to make the best best out of what you can it's a great game it is a fantastic game and I know the designer is working on kind of more games in this series and I'm super excited about that I think there's a Philippines one I thought I heard there's going to be a Berlin one but anyway great system really a lot of fun and a great introduction soliter war game so this is number five Stalingrad Advan of the vulga 1942 now my number four is a game that is I'm G to say it's kind of Representative of a genre of game of a family of games and this one is probably the most accessible and this is Memoir 44 by days of Wonder Memoir 44 is a commands and colors game so if you're not familiar with that which you should be by this point um this is a you can you have your Center and you have your right and your Left Flank and you have your units on the board and as you play these cards you activate units in the different flanks or the center of the of the board here
and they go ahead they attack they um you know deal damage they move etc etc but this is such a light and engaging game this is it's from Days of wonder which is doesn't do war games right they usually do some pretty interesting uh you know regular board games and so what interesting that they would they would they would do this as this really super accessible war game in fact I know people that are not war Gamers that don't like war games that play this game that still love it but I think this is a way to get people that are not interested in war games that are or maybe would like to learn more about war games but they want to learn basic things again like maneuvering and combat and stuff like that I think this is a great way to go so that is Memoir 44 that is from uh days of Wonder my number three is one of the great alltime light war games it's one of the games first of all and i' I've mentioned this hundreds of times on the channel this is the game that really got me interested in World War II and it's the reason why today I have a PhD in World War II history this is axis and allies uh that and and it could be any axis and allies here um it was originally by Milton Bradley Avalon Hill had it a while access anal is currently being published by uh um Renegade game studios got the license in fact they've sent me a couple of uh Europe and Pacific I got to get those played because they're access and allies right I actually played not too long ago I played um access and Allies World War
I with Kim and she has never played access analy before and I was wondering and she's she's played a few lighter War Games before she played fighters of the Pacific with me um but she's not and she's played Memoir 44 too but games are not her thing but she played access and allies and I was wondering if she'd really dig it and she did she loved it she really got in to access and allies the World War I access an allies um they're just a great series of games super easy to learn to teach the only downside is they do take a while you can be play a game of access anal for several hours um but if that's not a factor these are great games to teach people how to play war games what war games are um committing of resources and again you know tax and learning learning basic die rolls and and and probability on die rolls and what you want to commit where great game I freaking love access analy 2 this day um I do like war room better which Larry Harris is the next evolution of access an allies but I find I still do enjoy access analy quite a bit I know before I had said war room kind of killed access an allies for me in fact I ended up selling a bunch of my access analy stuff and I kind of regret that now because I had so much fun the other day playing access anal World War I with Kim I'm really looking forward to playing the Europe in the specific uh probably with her at least one of them with her in the future great games and I also heard they're doing a g Joe access and allies game and I love GI Joe when I was a kid I collected GI Joe and then I played access and allies that's gonna be freaking awesome so that is number three
that's access and allies and that is from Renegade game studios all right number two this is a game that Joel Eddie of drive-through review he called this the Ticket to Ride of War games and I totally see where he's coming from and I totally think that's the case this is a game that when you're playing it it it's very much about area control and so it feels a lot of times more like a conventional war game but there's dice rolling there's random initiative that comes up so it's it's really a fantastic game there's card play too you play cards for events or or for what have you this is 1775 Rebellion this has traditionally been a top 10 game of all time for me uh you know maybe I need to do a my top 100 next year it's been a while since I've done a top 100 I think it was 2020 when I did top 100 maybe next year I'll do another top 100 list but 1775 is is almost always been in my top 10 games of all time it's a great game in the American Revolution there are four factions you've got the British regulars and the Loyalists you've got the American Continental Army and the militias and so these four factions have to work together one of the things I love about this game is between those uh the two sides now each faction there's right they're on the British are on a side the Americans are on a side but you've got two factions on each side and they're working together and I love that kind of team game and the negotiation between team members I love that so much it's it's just fantastic um played this game several times pretty much everybody I played it with has loved it I played a
game when I was in Wyoming with some of my friends there and it ended early and and it wasn't the best and I felt bad because I wanted to play it with him again because I really wanted to see what this game could do and we never got around to it but 1775 Rebellion is just fantastic I love this game so much there are other games in this series like 1754 1812 878 Vikings they're all good they're all awesome but 1775 is the best in my opinion I absolutely love this game so that is number two that is 1775 Rebellion that is from Academy games and finally my number one now this game I would say is probably a great Gateway game for people that want to get into wargaming that do have a pretty solid footing on in regular gaming right in more conventional board games specifically those who understand the basics of a deck builder because this is of course undaunted Normandy undaunted Normandy is fantastic it is a tactical war game but it is also a deck building game and how you and the cards you draw when you play them that allows you to move your units on the board Riflemen Scouts machine Gunners snipers mortar companies etc etc uh tanks and some of the later iterations of the game there's all sorts of things uh all sorts of units that you use with these cards and then the cards let you draw other cards or or let other units move a second time so there's a lot of fun stuff you can do with this game in terms of both deck building and tactical wargaming now some people have
crit some War Gamers have criticized this game because there's no real line of sight issues and there's no um you know nothing like that which is of course a very important thing in in a lot of a lot of War games um but this is why this makes it such a great introductory war game is because people can play it and they don't have to get bogged down with a lot of those other rules this gives them the flavor of a tactical war game and then it it can maybe lead them further on but it's just a heck of a game in its own right I love undaunted Normandy because of the deck building and because of the um uh War gaming tactical wargaming aspect of it so that is my favorite and then of course there's games in this series North Africa uh the Stalingrad which is the campaign game it's got the reinforcements pack which is um gives it the tanks and you can play A 2v2 Team game with that which is my favorite way to play it and then of course there's also the um Battle of Britain which is um you know kind of the airplanes fighting in in World War II over over Britain love all these games undaunted Normandy is such a great intro war game that is why it is my number one and it's so much fun if I may say so so my number one is undaunted Normandy and that is from Osprey games well ladies and gentlemen thank you once again for joining us today on the discriminating gamer again what do you think what do you think are some great intro War Games what do you think of my list are there some that should not be on there do you really like some of them let me know I'm always eager to hear I just ask please keep it civil uh so uh please leave a comment on YouTube
on Bor Game Geek on our Facebook page on the discriminating gamer.com please like us on Facebook subscribe to us on YouTube and follow us on Twitter I'd also ask you ladies and gentlemen to please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about military history and books on history fun things like that please check that out and please subscribe to that channel it would mean a lot to me please leave a thumb to this video on Board Game Geek as well and if you really do like the content we provide here on this channel I would humbly ask you to go ahead and click on the super thanks button here on the YouTube page and uh leave a tip again we really appreciate that you know I had this Soldier friend and I kept asking him what rank he was he just said it's private help me on my again and I don't know where I'm going and I don't know where I've been please somebody help me on the solid ground it's a long time and I've been dying I up in the fight but I don't it's in well allc we've had some laughs one or two tears I tell you what it's been fun and and you want anything else you want to say something amusing I'll try I'll try let me you didn't like that one
all right uh well Salton I tell you uh I've been to many a board game convention but none has enlivened my spirits as much as this one this is the only one I've been to but it's been very good thank you Sal