Tend Review | This Is NOT Your Typical X-and-Write
Transcript
The first time we played tend honestly we didn't particularly like it. We tried learning it quickly at a convention and there was a lot happening and by the end I mostly remember feeling overwhelmed. So when we finally brought it back to the table, I wondered was tend simply too much for us or had we tried to learn a fairly substantial strategy game like it was a quick little X and right? Because after actually spending time with the rules and giving it another proper play, our opinion changed quite a bit. Tend is big. It's tactile. There is a ton to optimize and this is definitely not your typical quick little X and write.
Hi, I'm Sarah and welcome to Let's Table It. Today we're looking at Tend, a fairly crunchy flip and right game from IV Studios who have provided a copy of the game for review. It plays 1 to six players in about 60 to 90 minutes and is firmly in the medium weight category. Let's take a look at how it plays. Despite everything happening on your player sheet, the basic turn structure is surprisingly straightforward. Each round, you'll choose two of the five available action cards. Those actions might let you tend your crops, fish, mine, or chop wood. And initially, those actions are fairly basic, but the resources you're gathering can be used to upgrade your tools and abilities. So maybe mining isn't that exciting on turn two. But by turn 10, you might be pulling significantly more value out of that action and even be able to take it twice if you've invested in the right upgrades. And that progression is really the backbone of Tend. You only play 12 rounds. That's 24 actions for the entire game, which sounds like plenty until you realize how much you want to accomplish because you're not only collecting resources, you're also storing goods in your cargo hold. Those goods can score substantial points at the end of the game, but completely filling in a row also rewards you with an extra action.
And those extra actions can be incredibly valuable when your entire game normally consists of only 24. You're working toward end of season goals. You're gifting specific goods to other players to progress on neighbor tracks. You're earning badges. And as the seasons progress, new action cards get added to the deck. Those later cards can provide increasingly powerful actions and bonuses, assuming you've done the work necessary to meet their requirements. So, Tend has this really satisfying arc. Your early turns are relatively small. You're planting a little, fishing a little, gathering some wood, but by the end of the game, you've specialized, upgraded your abilities, and you're trying to squeeze every possible resource out of those final few actions.
And squeeze really is the right word because tend does not want you to do everything. I think trying to do everything is probably one of the easiest ways to have a disappointing first game. There are four major action paths sitting in front of you. mining, fishing, tending, and chopping. And it's tempting to dabble in all four, but if you've only got 24 actions, at some point you're going to have to decide what am I actually going to be good at? Which upgrades support that? Which goods are going to score the best in my cargo hold? Which seasonal objective is actually realistic for me? And then the action market introduces another restriction. You don't always have access to every possible action every turn. You're choosing from only five cards. Maybe the perfect fishing action isn't available when you want it. Can you pivot? Is there another action that moves you toward two goals at once? Or do you take something less efficient and hope the card you need appears next round?
That's where the game started clicking for me on our later play. Instead of seeing a giant sheet full of things I was supposed to accomplish, I started seeing paths I could deliberately ignore. And then the puzzle became, how much can I squeeze out of the strategy I've chosen? The progression is probably my favorite part. I love upgrades in games. Give me an action that starts mediocre and let me spend an hour turning it into something ridiculous, and I'm probably going to be happy. 10 does that really well. By the final rounds, your turns feel dramatically more productive than they did at the beginning. And watching the cargo hold slowly fill is extremely satisfying. You're looking at these rows thinking, I just need that one good because filling it could mean points and another precious action. The production also deserves attention because this is IV Studios. The chunky dice feel great. The colored pencils and deluxe markers make the writing portion feel more substantial.
The metal scratcher is wonderfully excessive. And then there are those scratch off cards. Scratching away the coating to reveal your reward is completely unnecessary. and also incredibly satisfying. It's a gimmick, but it's a fun gimmick. And I appreciate that Tend scales up to six without turning into a game where you're sitting around waiting forever. Most of what you're doing happens simultaneously on your own sheet. And the neighbor system gives you just a little positive interaction without making the experience confrontational. That said, our rough first play wasn't entirely user error. There is a learning curve here. There are a lot of systems, symbols, upgrade paths, and scoring opportunities to understand. I would not recommend doing what we did and trying to quickly learn this at a convention table. Give Tend some time. Read the rules, have the components in front of you, maybe watch a playthrough. Once we did that, our next experience was dramatically better. There's also some luck. Only five action cards are available, so sometimes the action that you need simply isn't there. The scratch cards also introduce another random element into what reward you're going to reveal, and I can absolutely see analysis paralysis being an issue, especially early in the game when you haven't specialized yet and everything still looks potentially useful. There's also one production concern worth mentioning. Those scratchoff cards are consumable. You get a finite supply, unlike your player sheets, which you
could potentially laminate and reuse. Once you've scratched through all your cards, you'll need replacements if you want to continue. For some players, that's not going to matter, but for others, consumable components in a replayable board game are going to be a significant consideration. I think Tend makes the most sense for people who already enjoy X and Wright games and are ready to take a fairly substantial step up. If your favorite part of those games is optimizing a sheet and finding increasingly efficient combinations, there is a lot to chew on here. I'd also recommend it to groups that regularly play at higher player counts. Being able to support up to six players without dramatically increasing downtime is useful. And if production matters to you, if the chunky components, colored markers, scratch cards, and tactile little details genuinely add to your enjoyment, Tend absolutely delivers.
But if your games need to stay under an hour, I'd look elsewhere. Likewise, if traditional exin rates already don't appeal to you, adding more systems probably isn't going to solve that. And if you're prone to analysis paralysis, Tend gives you plenty of opportunities to stare at your sheet wondering which thing you should optimize next. I'd also think carefully about the consumable scratch cards if that bothers you. They're fun, but they are finite. Tend has probably had one of the more interesting journeys with us recently. Our first experience was genuinely not very good. Our second much much better. And I think part of that was simply understanding what tend actually is. This isn't a casual X and right you learn in 5 minutes and play while chatting. It's a full strategy game that happens to use writing as one of its primary mechanisms.
And once I approached it that way, I started appreciating the puzzle much more. I finished our last game feeling accomplished, but also immediately thinking about what I could have done better. Could I have specialized sooner? Could I have filled another cargo row? Could I have squeezed out one more upgrade? That's usually a pretty good sign that I want to play again. I'm especially curious to try the solo mode and see whether that optimization puzzle becomes even more satisfying when I can really take my time with it. So, tend to sticking around. And if your collection needs an X andRight with a lot more to chew on, I think this one is absolutely worth a look. When you reach for an X and game, do you want something quick and breezy, or are you happy turning it into the centerpiece of your game night?
Let me know in the comments. And if you enjoy reviews that help you figure out which games actually belong on your shelf, subscribe and join us for the next one. Thanks for watching and we'll see you at the table.