Skip to main content
Loading video...

Die In The Dungeon: The Boardgame has Minis!?! - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip

Transcript 6:28

I want it. I do. I feel like the video was very well done. Like it showcased gameplay, it showcased components, it showcased artwork, it made it look fun. I didn't understand everything, but I had the basic gist, and it looked familiar but different but most likely it just looked like the video game. So, if I'm a fan of the video game, I felt like that video was very well done. If I'm a fan of board games, I felt like that video was very well done. That's off to a great start. Do I want it? Yes, I do. Rule booklet is there, gameplay videos are there, quotes are there, solo game is there. Everything you need to make an informed decision is there on the can you do it. And the bottom line is this is not a technically impressive game to make. Yeah, it's got a boatload of freaking dice, but dice aren't that hard to manufacture, especially if you're not doing inscribed dice. So, can you do it?

Just looking at this project, $165,000, absolutely. Also, kudos for them on a lot of little details. They really crossed their t's and dotted their i's and just There's a lot of little polish in sections that a lot of companies don't polish areas, and I notice those things, and that's why they were awarded not one, not two, but three third-of-a-point bump-ups. However, the can you do it cannot be understated when the fact that you have done three games. One of those games, in its current form, you need to put out a version 1.5 rule booklet that people are still actively waiting for, and you are still not actively giving them information about despite the fact your project is live right now, and they could very well come in here and start complaining. So, I don't know if they are. Let's go check out the comments. So, yeah, that does concern me. And then the other game is not out yet. So, can you do it is shaky there.

Uh and then this also concerning, double concerning with the fact that you seem to be open to like, "Hey, let's talk about maybe rules or ideas or abilities." And that's fantastic, but that's stuff that you need to play test and run by your current set of rules, and it's just it's it's concerning. Uh sorry, should have bring this on the Discord and not here. I don't know how to remove the comment. No, you're absolutely incorrect, and that's one thing I definitely imagine they're probably doing wrong. Uh I always say this, you should have a Discord blackout. I saw a company do it recently. I don't remember who it was where they were like they turned it into a challenge to bring their Discord and make it the most active and poppin' thing, and it was so good. And yeah, bring the Discord to here cuz Kickstarter wants you engaged.

Kickstarter wants you to be in the top 12 in popularity. You want to be in the top 12 in popularity, bring that Discord over here. This is where you should be chit-chatting about the game and the discussions and making it a living breathing environment because a, it makes you look good, the game is going to inevitably get better, and b, it buries any negativity that might potentially be coming through because, you know, you haven't shipped out a working game yet. So, yeah. Do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yes, but oh my gosh, I don't feel like there's a lot of baggage. And then, how much is it? Feels fine until I get to the shipping cuz now it's like, all right, it's a $90 game.

I guess it's got a bunch of dice, but the shipping sucks. Like, and that combined with the information that we learned earlier about how their first game was like 65 bucks, and somebody's like, yeah, I'm in the United States and I had to pay 40 bucks in shipping. Like, it's just everything that we saw in the can you do it aspect where we looked at their past two projects just feels like it drags down everything else to a certain certain degree for me. And so, final grade is mixed cuz at the end of the day, the question is how do I feel like they ran the Kickstarter project? And at the end of the day, after going through their entire Kickstarter page, I have no idea that they have a game that they haven't shipped out. I have no idea that they have a game that they shipped out that rule booklet sucks so much they have to do a version 1.5.

And I shouldn't if you're running your Kickstarter project well. So, I cannot just ignore that. Final grade is a B. You beat me down. I'd love to give you a C cuz I hate the cut of your jib and your track record and you ignoring people in the comments and people having to mention dates about rule booklets and just ignoring all that and I want everybody to know that that when you back this project, just throw this game completely out of your brain. Don't come back to Kickstarter because it's probably going to be a frustrating experience with their customer service after the fact, at least looking at other people's experiences. But, can you do it? Yeah, you'll get the game. So, I'm going to go with a C. I'm going to go with a B. But, really in my heart it's a C, but they have those three third of four grade bump ups, they got rock solid quotes, they got videos, they got quotes scattered throughout. Uh they got a they got an organized FAQ, they have pledges that clearly are showcasing what their fans want. I can't go B. I'm going to go B minus cuz I do think I do think the not spotlighting those big pieces of plastic is is a misplay cuz those, you know, probably cost a good amount to manufacture cuz those, once again, those are steps up from just your typical minis, at least it looks like. And the spotlighting of that really cool translucent D20 holder that's probably never going to lose our table. And now, it looks even cooler than this. Like, I have to go down all the way down to your to your stretch goal section to even see that this is even cooler than that. And I know it's only for the first 48 hours, but I'm sure there's a way to buy it after the fact, no less, right? Like,

it's just it's the basic knowledge that this cool thing that exists now is even cooler and I have to go down all the way to here to find it. I'm going to go with a B minus, but in my heart it's a C minus and you know it and there you go. Die in the Dungeon the board game. Let me know what your final thoughts on this and let me know what your grade is for this and when you do that let me know are you a fan of the video game or you just a board game enthusiast? I feel like if you're a fan of the video game that they then they did a really good job. Like honestly, I would I might even go like B plus A minus for just being a fan of the video game. They completely buried the fact that they have two games that are not out and playable right now and this is their third thing which is you know valuable shopping information you'd like to have and they hit it very well. Good for them.

B minus.

Progress saved