Halls of Hegra | Review
Transcript
hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond soliter and today I'm going to be reviewing Halls of hegra this is a sort of solo tower defense game uh designed by Peter shanka and published by Tom pet games and I did buy it with my own money so it is not a review copy all right so here we have a setup of Halls of hegra this is a solo kind of tower defense game that also has elements of bag draw and worker placement uh and push your luck so it's actually got a really neat mix of different elements of gameplay so I'm just going to walk you through like the very basic version of what's going on this is based on a true story of a bunch of rag tag people who had to go to a badly repaired Fort fix it up hunker down and try to survive some attacks from the Germans and there are a few just kind of basic patterns to make this game work uh one thing is the turn structure so the turn structure is always going to work uh the same way so the first three turns are going to be spent doing what's called mobilization and that's where there can be some patrols that appear out on the map but there are no German troops actually attacking you yet it's kind of like um Home Alone where you know that the robbers are coming and you're trying to fortify your house uh and so you have a very limited amount of time to do that after that you're going to weather the first attack which has kind of got a limited structure for the Germans to attack you and then you remove this board alt together and you have like a fullon assault on your position but for now we're just going to look at the options from the start of the game one
thing that's kind of nice is that you can kind of be walked through a lot of your turn which is very pleasant uh but what the game center is around really is these bags these draw bags that are over here so your main resource in this game um is the soldiers and volunteers and officer and there are also hunters and Medics who can be recruited um to your supply of people who can be placed out here to perform actions so in order to get more of them uh you're going to need to draw from the recruit bag but the other thing that's going to the recruit bag is doubt because people are really really nervous about what's going to happen so when you're drawing from the recruit bag if you draw a doubt token it cuts off your turn and limits who you're able to recruit so in the early phases of the game you're really trying to limit doubt and recruit as many people as possible in the meantime you're sending them to different spaces on the board to perform a number of different tasks you're going to want to do a whole bunch of different stuff and you just will not have the time and the resources and I think part of the fun of the game is kind of seeing what your game state looks like and figuring out what you should lean into this particular time but you can open supply routes which means that you're sending people up to get these supplies Supply also Al allows you to refresh your workers uh and you're really really going to want it so basically your different Defenders are going to get tired uh and only so many of them are going to renew on their own per turn so you have to spend Supply to get more of them back or I mean you can take a hit to morale but um I'm going to talk to you momentarily about why you maybe don't want to do that so much so you can work on supplies you can do
things like repairing your defenses repairing your gun and once you've done that you can start doing things like firing artillery uh and trying to prep yourself for other things that are coming up in the game so for example if you want to you can remove air tiles which you may ultimately want to do you're able to shovel snow and get special tiles out of the snow so there's like another gun in here there's all kinds of fun little surprises and you never know what you're going to draw you can promote Defenders so you can take your volunteers who are kind of eh and then make them into something a bit more advanced and Hearty uh and you can Inspire which means you can move your morale marker there are also Supply runs uh that are easier to do or not based on the we weather because that impacts your movement and you're also kind of keeping track of morale so your morale track is really important because it affects your turn in the sense that if you're drawing low morale cards bad things happen if you're drawing High morale cards you get really sweet rewards that also help you you know kind of get through this really really tough defense there are also surrender conditions down here that help you track um whether you're going to lose the game on a given turn and with what degree of Honor you'll do so so essentially you win the game if you survive this entire set of turns all the way up to the Last Stand but you're going to lose either if uh conditions drop so badly that you have a surrender or if it is The Siege stage and you have fewer healthy Defenders uh than the required number that's indicated here on the surrender track so you have to have a certain number of healthy people to carry on the defense in order to keep
going or for the game to be considered a win at the very end I will note there's also a brutally limited infirmary with a waiting area that can get overwhelmed pretty easily if you are not being super aggressive about it so after you've done your mobilization uh this is going to flip but let's just move it out of the way for now the other aspect of the game is this kind of brutal situation where you have Germans who come in and they fill up various sectors and as they fill up the sectors they're also rolling to hit and to move so they can hit your Defenders once you repair these positions they can damage these positions making you have to repair them again and they're also moving up injuring people and you are just starting to lose morale really terribly if there are Germans that are too close to you so trying to manage this area becomes crucial and it also becomes increasingly difficult as the game goes on meanwhile artillery can also come out here and put a real hurting on you and if you want to do something about it you're going to have to send your defend Enders out on like little Supply runs basically where they can go and destroy the artillery but there's going to be patrols coming out here that place them in extreme danger one other aspect of this game that's very fun however um well it's not fun to get hit but there is a hit bag so a lot of things in here are built on bag building your recruit bag your Patrol bag you kind of randomly draw patrols you know more or less who's left if you're trying to track who might come out you've also got a hit bag and
basically as things appear on the m appap you're going to add things to the hit bag that can be damaged you're going to add things to the hit bag that can do terrible things to you and you also sometimes have the opportunity to add misses to this bag which makes it statistically less likely that you're going to just get completely wrecked when you have to draw from here so these Airfield tiles do bad things to you and can get added here unless you are using your artillery to do something about that for example when you repair stuff at your base so for example if you do gun repairs these actually get added to the hit bag so you pull from the hit bag later to see if things have been red damaged that you repaired early in the game and it creates kind of an interesting cycle where you know uh that you can fix things but also they go at risk of getting hit again by going into the hitback which I thought was a very very cool mechanism so overall this is a really neat game of building pressure feeling like you have choices about things to do but also feeling like you're never ever ever going to be able to get enough done and I actually think that is a key element of a really good tower defense game uh this is game is going to make you want to play it again and again I've tried like several different strategies and really you know pushed different angles to try to see how the game will go but the thing is that it's really really hard uh and every time you're going to get a really really dramatic story arc as more people are tired you don't have as much supplies to help them the infirmary is getting full stuff is getting damaged and you're just going to have to
prioritize and it can be hard because there's lots of Juicy stuff that you could do and you're going to have to figure out what needs to be done first and what is just going to have to wait or never ever get done in your attempt to survive the game the other thing I want to note is that there are cards that you draw each round and they're just divided by stage uh so you can see what stage you're at in the game by looking at the turn stuff along the bottom and if you want to make these a little harder there are also Mission cards that give you a little bit of a custom condition to deal with and that is a basic overview of Halls of hegra so let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts the tldr of this is I think that Halls of hegra is great and if you enjoy Tower Defense games with some sort of prep elements you're really really going to love this game it's going to be a fantastic match for you it's absolutely worth your time but to kind of expand on that uh as those of you who watch the channel may know I really do love Tower Defense uh one of my favorite game series is David Thompson's Valiant Defense series and I thought that h of heger was very cool because it had some of that same Vibe of you know encroaching enemy soldiers it set during World War II but it added elements that really added spice to that formula and that I really liked so part of this is that I really love bag Poole so I thought it was really cool that you know you had bags where you're trying to maybe add Mist tokens in order to protect yourself from fire where you were pulling you know potential new troops out of the bag and you didn't know what you're going to get the doubt tokens added a lot of interest although I do have some quibbles about them that we'll get to but the bag building aspect
of the game in all three of the bags but the bag building aspect of the game in the hit bag and in the recruit bag I thought really added a lot it gave the game extra drama and excitement and variability uh and it was something that I really liked as an addition to a game that's about a Siege I also really enjoyed the variety of actions that were available uh I like that you could dig new ones out of the snow tiles but I also just liked the basic actions that were there because there's already too much to do you're going to want to do all of it and you're not generally going to have the resources to pull that off so do you want to worry about supplies do you want to repair what do you want to repair first what should you prioritize should you be putting your officer in a position where he's going to promote somebody so you get better units or do you need to bring morale up so you can get morale cards or at least not have to draw something bad the level of choice in this game was really really enjoyable and I got a huge kick out of playing different playthroughs and making different kinds of decisions and prioritizing different things each time um because I felt like the game was still hard basically no matter how I did it uh and you know I'm still kind of learning to be responsive to what's coming out of the bag in terms of choosing the actions that are available to me and so I thought that was really neat it adds variability to the game in a way that gets you to try to play a little bit differently depending on who is available to do what actions and so there's really a lot to be said for that also while the game does kind of have like a sey story arc each time for obvious reasons it's a historical game it's a tower defense game you know it is what it is I actually really enjoyed the way that it was broken up um actually I
kind of like like those first few rounds where you're doing all your prep and it really feels like you're digging in having that as an addition to the game I thought was really cool and I really valued it and you know kind of being in prep mode before the Germans start to show up uh actually added sort of like a home alone vibe to the game where I was like okay this my house I have to defend it you're trying to like make sure that everything goes the way that it's supposed to go at least to the best of your abilities it'll never go the way it's supposed to go but that feeling that I had a chance to prep and that it was my fault if I didn't prepare well enough actually made the game's brutality more enjoyable for me and made the prep phase more vital and fun and exciting for me so in other words I think this game is really really good it's a fantastic solo game I'm not at all surprised that it appeared on the top 200 People's Choice list this year and this would definitely be in my top historical games of the year like I have no hesitation in saying that that said there are imperfections in the game that if it's not your kind of game it just isn't going to be and you might not like it so one of those is in those initial prep rounds that are are so fun when you are putting more doubt tokens in the bag and you're trying to pull the troops that you're going to need you can really end up being screwed by bad draws during that phase of the game and it can be to the point where you really feel like it made or broke the whole rest of the game managing to get a whole lot of people in early on really really does make the course of the game a lot easier and I will say that I have absolutely just been like screw it restarting when I drew the doubt token too early too many times during that phase uh because I just already knew that I was doomed and
that I was a lost cause so the fact that that is so crucial and also so unpredictable there will be people who like that and want to just try it with a challenge there will be people that that really bothers they feel like they got hamstrung early on and they didn't have a chance for the entire rest of the game but that's really my main quibble with it gameplay wise uh I will say that it can feel a little bit fiddly there are a whole bunch of different things you have to do it's very very easy to miss stuff or to skip steps because there are a ton of little steps and like the game board is designed to to help you with that it's numbered if you just follow the numbers and you go kind of like it's a flowchart you know you're going to get everything done there's no one action that's particularly difficult it's just that this is one of those games where there's so much happening and so many small things are being simulated that it's very very easy to skip a step to miss something and then you might end up kicking yourself later it's not a huge deal and it didn't ruin gameplay for me when I was being careless or when I caught myself being careless uh but I can see that really bothering people um and it actually makes me afraid to do a play of it on YouTube because I just know I will mess something up and then I'll just never stop hearing about it in the comments so it's definitely that kind of game um and it's really fine I wouldn't say that the difficulty level is too high I wouldn't say that it's fiddly in a way that makes the game like harder or less Pleasant to play it's just one that you have to really be attentive while you're playing in order not to make a mistake and then the other thing that I can see people having an issue with potentially uh is that the game does have a really specific narrative Arc to it you know you dig in you have some early attacks you in with
a big Last Stand that's really tough to get through um so the game definitely has like a repetitive narrative to it and I can see that maybe being something that you don't like or maybe you don't want to play it too many times in a row but I personally felt that the variability between plays made it really really fun I was super addicted and played this a ton of times and you know basically what will probably happen is I've gotten really into it probably cool down for a little bit on it and then pull it back out but it's definitely not leaving my collection I'm keeping it so for me Halls of heer is a keeper I think it's fantastic uh they are reprinting it sometime soon I think and if it sounds even remotely interesting to you I actually recommend that you get it this is totally worth my money and my time and uh I'm very very pleased with my experience of this one so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming