Skip to main content
Loading video...

Four Gardens Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:34

hey everybody today i'm talking about four gardens which is a board game designed by martin dolezal and published by arcane wonders this one accommodates two to four players and takes around 45 minutes to play now this is a medium light resource management and contract fulfillment style game that looks a bit different because you actually have this really impressive 3d pagoda which is one of the main focus points of this game you've got this score track here where you've got these four different gods that you're trying to climb the tracks of to get victory points at the end you're going to start with some of these dual sided cards here and you're going to have a supply which you're going to draft from and as well as some of these bonus tiles and of course you've got all your resources which you're trying to collect throughout the game so this is a relatively simple game where you are trying to paint these landscapes by fulfilling these different orders here so as you can see this card needs a stone two wood and a water and if i ever completed that i would paint this part of the painting and as you can see we've got all these different types here for different colors and they've got these different kind of symbols here to show which part of the painting that is so ultimately if i painted these two bits of the painting they will come together like this and that will kind of constitute towards some of this painting which needs five parts to complete some of them only need two parts like this one here and so they vary in their difficulty to achieve so let's talk about how we get these resources and all the different mechanisms that are involved in four gardens so while the idea of this game

is ultra simple the actual mechanisms are a little bit different and have some things that i haven't seen before so you're gonna have the option to take four actions or three of a potential four actions um on each of your turns and that's going to be constituted by these cards available to you so these are multiple use cards um depicted by these different signs here so you've got this wheelbarrow which is present on all the cards but as you can see some of the cards have these ones relating to the pagodas and some of them have other things as well such as being able to take wild resources um additionally you can always play them as the actual painting as well where you put them separately meaning that you want to kind of commit to this commit to this painting and therefore looking to achieve that by getting those resources so anyway let's go back to the actions here so the first action you can take is to actually acquire resources and when you do that you are looking at this part of the card here with this pagoda symbol and that relates obviously to the pagoda so as you can see from the pagoda here they are i have four different levels all depicting a different resource and different numbers on each of those levels as well so what's quite important about this game is that the actual physical orientation of this pagoda is um is really important so this side of the pagoda relates to me you know this side of the code would relate to another player this side would relate to another player and so on so i'm only looking at my face of the pagoda and again when i take this action i am going to have a look at which um which of these

symbols is highlighted so this one here says the bottom one it means i can rotate this uh in 90 degrees fashion so i go like this for example meaning that i would take every or every kind of um layer above the one i've moved is also going to move as well whereas if i just did this one here it would simply rotate the top part of the pagoda and this is really important because um you are very limited on how many resources you can hold at any time so you've got this little this little uh cardboard piece here which shows how many resources you can hold at any time so you start with a base value of four but you have got potential to upgrade that but looking back at this symbol here it will then show the order in which you collect those resources so yeah if i played this card i'd discard it out the way and it was saying that i've rotated the um retake of the dakota and then i'm going to collect resources from top to bottom where some of them go from bottom to top and then i'm going to have a look at the resources going down here so i would get two stone and again i'll put them on my little um my little tracker here and then i would get two wood now obviously that's important and the reason why you might want to manipulate this pagoda in different ways is because if i say i really wanted some of this um some of these plants here i might want to manipulate the pyramid or the pagoda so that i don't have anything here so when i take from top to bottom i'll go straight to the plants so that's how that mechanism works it's really different i haven't seen anything like

this before and it particularly works well because you have a strict capacity so now i have these locked in here i have no potential to hold any more resources another action is to simply play a card into your tableau of cards that you're kind of committing to committing to for filling and um you are always limited to three of those so once you've got your third one down that's not be completed yet you're pretty much locked in there so that's a very simple action another action is to discard a card in order to use this will bowery function to ship resources either from one card to another card or from your storage area to cards um and you can do that as many times as you want so i could say move the stone here i can move these two wood here like so and so that would be my action and i can always choose to move them back to my storage area and or as i said from one car to another to give you some flexibility and the final action relates to this symbol here where you simply take a wild resource and commit it to a card like so now as you notice that one now once i've got this um this card completes i'm gonna remove all the resources from it put it back into the supply and then i'm going to flip that card face up to constitute part of that landscape now as you can see here all the cards have a certain color color relating to it so you've got some wild ones like this one but you've got these ones here these ones here and uh like the yellow ones like this and they all correspond to the different cards all the different tracks you're going to climb when you fulfill

that card so this one is a wild so i can choose any of these tracks to climb up so let's just say i climb up this uh this one here and this is going to be your final score at the end of the game so the game's actually going to trigger or the game end is going to trigger uh depending on the play account and how many paintings or how many landscape cards have been completed so in a two-player game like i've got set up here it's going to be when one player makes 10 paintings that's going to trigger the final the final round but an interesting thing about the scoring is that when i when i complete the second part of the painting then i am going to not only score the uh the card i've just built so again climb up the red track i'm also going to trigger every single car that i've built so far in that landscape so again i'll trigger this wild card one more time which means i can climb another track and that's going to keep on going depending on the length of that landscape so if you do these big landscapes you've got a potential to uh get a lot of points by just compounding on one another and you might think why don't i always just build the large landscapes because i'm going to get a lot better scoring well the reason you might not want to constantly build the large ones is and build some of the small ones is because of these bonus tiles so whenever you completely complete a a kind of panoramic then you are going to take one of these bonuses you can either take one of these uh just pure points so and they're going to deplete as the game goes on so you'll be the first to get that big chunk of four points you can get these wild resources which are going to give you the ability to complete other landscapes really quickly or you can increase your storage capacity meaning that now you've

got more flexibility when taking resources from the pagoda and once you've taken any combination of those four actions three times then you are going to replenish your hand up to five cards either drawing these face up ones or taking from the face down deck like so and adding them back to your hand and that's going to be pretty much how the game plays it's really simple however something i do want to mention is that once people start climbing to right to the top of these tracks and still achieve more points then instead of going any further you're actually going to push your opponents down the track and that's important because if you do it one more time and your opponent is right at the bottom here then they're actually going to fall off the board and have no ability to get back onto that scoring track meaning that they can no dog compete for those points so let's talk about how i feel about four gardens so let's talk about some of the mechanisms here so first off i really like the compounding scoring here i think it's great and you can really try and uh compete in all the different fields being careful that your opponents don't push you off a certain one of these tracks so if you really find yourself falling behind on a certain color you're gonna want to get one of those cards down again to make sure that you're not falling too far behind and that's another mechanism i really like i love this scoring system where you've got these four different fields which you're competing on and you've got to be kind of competing in all of them ready or at least not falling too far behind on all of them and i like these subtle differences when games introduce um scoring systems

and just that extra tension of you know you can potentially push them so far to the point where they can no longer compete at all which can be pretty devastating and i will say that's not unlikely to happen so it's actually happens quite frequently and um you know you really do have to be on the ball because these you know you actually start on three on these tracks and um once you get to 10 you're going to start pushing them down so that's actually one of my favorite things about this game is this um this tension of not wanting to fall off this track i think that's really interesting um additionally of course the pagoda system is quite fascinating uh you know you initially you might think you know why don't i just try and line up all these um all these symbols to try and get the absolute most resources i can it's because you have such a strict capacity here and i think this works really well and you have to manipulate that board as best as possible and puzzle it out and it all stems back to the multi-use cards here so generally as a rule of thumb i do like and enjoy these multiple use cards now do you want to commit to them to build these certain paintings or these landscapes because you know i might have both of the cards here like this and that's quite a good opportunity to get them down and get them played to get those bonuses but at the same time i might really want a specific movement here in order to obtain the resources i want for other cards or maybe cards that i've already committed to to achieving and i i do also like the way that you know sometimes you have a very subtle move here like just moving one top one but i like the fact that when you move the lower levels then you're going to move all the ones

above it and not just the level it's on and that just passively is going to affect all the other players it's going to be frustrating for them at times because they might have lined something up perfectly and you've just completely screwed them over by trying to help yourself and that kind of passive player interaction is quite nice in full gardens i think it works quite well i will say that as the game goes on i think the interest and the uh you know how interesting these cards function does diminish because at the start you have such an open field here you know what what paintings do you want to do i want to commit to completing um but of course as the game goes on you kind of know which cards you you're going to go towards and you know which specific cards you need to build meaning that you have a more locked in strategy and know which cards you can dispose of so that tension and the difficulty of the decision of which card you're going to keep which cards you're going to lose um does diminish as the game goes on so i i i suppose that's unavoidable ray but it's just an observation that i i noticed when i played this one i enjoyed the decision of weighing up are you going to go for the smaller paintings or the bigger ones because as i said when you go the bigger ones you're going to keep on get that kind of domino effect scoring to climb up loads of tracks at once but the smaller paintings and smaller panoramics are equally as good because you get to kind of compensate for that by getting these other ones here these bonuses which are really useful you know just having that extra couple of spaces all that extra space to um to put a new

resource on is fantastic that's really adds a lot to your flexibility there and um you know while it's only one it does actually make a big difference in how uh how well you can manage your resources so there's kind of two different approaches there you know do you want to go for the big ones do you want to go for the small ones but they both have their advantages and disadvantages i think the uptime and general flow of the play is decent in this one you get three actions per turn um and to be honest they're mostly quick grabs you know if you just want to use it to shift resources around you can get that done in less than a second really so despite having three actions and you know not being overly involved in other people's turns it doesn't feel like you are disengaged from the game you not just sit there twiddling your thumbs while other people enjoy their turn you are kind of uh you know it does get back around to you pretty quickly and of course if they are manipulating the pyramid then you're going to have to adjust your plans sort of the pagoda you're going to have to adjust your plans on the fly because you could have lined up the resources that you wanted and then your opponent has just completely messed up meaning that you might have to now discard another card that you wasn't initially planning on doing so so yeah it's the down time and the general time of the game as well being 45 minutes feels about right for me it didn't outstay it's welcome the trigger of the game is pretty fair you know just getting being the first to uh build a certain amount of cards feels good and you know when the game goes on you're going to start to smash these cards out pretty quickly and find yourself getting a lot of points i think the arc the flow and the tempo of the game is is good from a production and aesthetics point of view i think this game looks

great it's simply done it's pretty elegant looking in terms of what the cards do are broken down into these very um digestible sections here you know what all these symbols do very clear very clean and uh yeah i definitely do like the uh the visuals and just symbology graphic design etc very clear to see which which each of these cars do i like the fact that he's got this kind of dot system to see which part of the panoramic it is i love the artwork of course this is a gorgeous looking game particularly when you build these big panoramics they look fantastic when they're put together and line up beautifully so it definitely has a nice bit of table presence and of course that is dominated by the pagoda this is a really good um i suppose you've got a gimmick but there's a functional gimmick and it's you know it's only got these kind of hollow cardboard houses but they're durable it's definitely going to stand up to repeated plays and uh yeah i've got no issues at all with the production here i think it does what it does very well for a very affordable game actually this isn't expensive i suppose my biggest concern with four gardens is the replayability i i'm concerned that down the line you know once you've played this a few times there's not really much else to explore you know you're going to be doing the same thing again and again and again and there is really isn't that many paths to victory or things to try and go for you know one game you might want to go for the small ones and get the bonuses the next game you might want to go for the bigger ones and i suppose you are always kind of tactically making choices depending which cards are available to you at any time so you're going to be somewhat tunnel visioned on

which cards are available to you but because you have five you are a bit more flexible than a lot of other games but yeah it is a very simple contract fulfillment game there are some different little novelty factors here some different gimmicks and some very small mechanisms which make the game feel different and fun but i think ultimately the crux of it is going to feel similar from game to game which does concern me again um i would love to see a maybe a an expansion or something to ramp up the complexity here to if people really enjoy these systems like i do you know like this i think this resource system is fantastic but i think the game around it is somewhat maybe a bit too simple uh for me you know it's very simple contract for film i just get the resources down flip the cards over whereas if you had some other things to consider then maybe that could make this even more interesting so i can see what it's going for i can see the market it's going for and i know there's going to be a lot of gateway plus level games which i suppose is the the most commercially uh kind of appealing uh weight of gaming out there who are gonna really enjoy this and find all these different things great as i do i think the game is is rock solid but again just that legs and is it gonna stand up to repeated plays again and again and again i'm just considering how simple the actual objective is so overall i think four gardens is a lovely game i think there's gonna be a lot of people out there who enjoyed this one there's a massive demographic for games like this and it's one of those games because of the the breeziness of it the quick time stamp i would play

this one pretty much any time without complaints um you know would i be saying that after i've played this you know five ten times maybe not it's pretty self-explanatory here and i think by the explanation you're going to see if this is going to be for your gaming group or not it does have a lot of things here that i find interesting again particularly the scoring and the resource management which i suppose is the usp of this game but that idea of just simple contract fulfillment is is somewhat limiting um i would i wouldn't hesitate to recommend this one i think it's fun i think it looks beautiful and um again there's gonna be a lot of people who enjoy it but am i gonna be wanting to play this one one two years down the line i'm not sure unless it does have that extra injection and extra layers of strategy and decisions um embedded in this one so i'm not sure if that's gonna be fixed by an expansion or two or whether they want to reuse this mechanism which i really love in a more complex involved game so yeah it's check it out if you uh if this is the kind of game for your group but you know if you're looking for a more meaty or a really involved game that's going to stretch you in different ways every time with loads different paths of victory i'm not sure i would recommend four gardens but again if you've got that gateway level gateway plus level game and there is that niche in your collection when you're wanting something a little bit different then i would certainly recommend checking out four gardens thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least

somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time

Progress saved